Rav Chaim's Seforim Explored with Rabbi Dr. Eliezer Brodt (Part 2)

[Music] welcome back rabbi dr elias abruat it has now been over a week since the battery of abraham and many of us have heard many has paid them we've redisplayed them we watched us pay them and there's been a tremendous historious people are learning and feeling that there is a tremendous aveda and they want to fill that void the hiserus the claudius role has had over the last week week and a half has been something that i certainly have never ever witnessed and i've heard this from people who are a lot older than me that they've never witnessed and felt this type of this type of the feeling of a gobble that has passed on and the clamoring for people to have a connection to learn about him and take on a little bit a little bit in his memory so last time we spoke about the safer kiryas melech we got some tremendous feedback from the listeners i'll just read a couple of the emails that we got the messages one person wrote that the jewish world needs a video in a series like this for each and every saver of that most people have no idea about his greatness and torah and presentations like this one shed some light upon him and his astounding knowledge of torah someone else wrote i listened to your segment i think this is the best tribute a meaningful review of asvarim and their importance so it's certainly an angle that many people don't know and hashem you're able to contribute in this way to enlighten people about the goddess of abraham through his farm well this time we want to speak about three swarm one is called ish of hadas one is called his pirus heim which is the third one is the countries he wrote called how are you hashem very good okay so you want to start with the yushi vadas or give some context of how you want to go about and why you picked maybe these three sparring yeah so let me so i'm going to begin as follows before i get to the threes farm that i would like to focus on today just a drop of um background to why i picked these spherum first in as in the past ever since the material of abraham there's been a crazy amount of uh the spade them both written orals [Music] video recordings all over the world in america arts israel everywhere from all types of people people that knew him people that just saw him from afar and people saying over stories and different things about them and anecdotes a thing that came up a few times i noticed in various has paid them or comments about him was was requiem a balkishrin from his from the early age now of course as i saw in an interview that someone published with her michael zilber he says we have no business to even talk about it it's not even a real not it's not even a real question and as i'm going to show the question is is is is really is really a it's not it's not a question to be asked because it's silly basically of course it's a smuggler and his tremendous learning and as we mentioned last time that he he was learning called tarakula being assigned every year contributed to who he became but already from the from the sum of this farm that i'm picking to discuss today which are which are written when he was very young will the answer will be obvious that he was already unique from a very young age as a matter of fact one of his grandchildren writes in in the safer headquarter last time called asvaram that even before his bar mitzvah he had tyra that he that he felt that it ended up being incorporated in his safer sikh asada volume in this in the volume 3. there's no dates which are those pieces of torah but basically he had notebooks already from material of stuff of his from before he was bar mitzvahed we'll throughout in a later presentation we'll talk about some other works that he might have that he wrote even that he wrote when he was let's say 14 but these works that we're going to be focusing on today are written it seems written as some of them are written you start working them as a baker in patarktika and then later on when he decided to print them he went over them again and then he and then he published them okay so the first so so last time i mentioned that one of this farm that i got attracted the originals farm that that i think i um when i was young i took a liking to was which the time i bought it it had two volumes and it includes basically eight different swarm it could be that they were printed individually i don't know at least some of them were printed individually but i do know that they were printed numerous times some of them printed over 10 times and each time he added in different um new corrections and additions now two in so i'm sure people are gonna call in and write in that it's pronunciated so whoever has those uh issues could send those in and also i would think i think also um it's worth mentioning that the shin yurkes were his initials right yes definitely now and i also like to say at this point to disclaimer i apologize in advance if i pronounce names of swarm word wrong do not be medic in anything um i say of this type i make mistakes some i try to make it i should i do try um to say right but sometimes it's hopeless anyway with that introduction so in this safer until there's a conscious um in the second volume it's called yishuv hadas and what is the ishvadas so in in one sentence it is he goes to shas to answer up every time the masha ends a piece saying the yeshlyashev and subhan went through shasta answer up all those times that marshall says it now i would like what i'd like to do is to discuss to give the background behind this significance of this and of the safer and it's the stories as follows last time i mentioned already that i would like to claim and it could be it's obvious it could be um many others claim it or will claim it that the requirements was impacted by a few different godzilla more i mean savings impacted by a lot of dylan but he was impacted by four particular good islam my claim was that he was impacted by his uncle hasanish who he grew up by he lived in the same house he learned with him his father the stipeler the missionary and the vilnigan i would like today to give some samples of of some of the influences of some of these people so in this first safer in the safer yeshvadas already one of the things that's very interesting with rokhan kanyeski is you don't have to come up with tyrus why he wrote certain farm most of his farm has an introduction where he says he give he pretty much says something he writes a very begetzer but he says some of the motives so to speak behind why he's writing the safer which in general is very useful information when you look at a safer you look at the introduction some sort of don't have early back sometimes some don't have introductions but wrote a lot of times why he chose this specific topic to write about it so in the safer vadas he brings down a famous letter of the fazanish about the importance of learning the martial so before we get to the kazonish's letter i would like to give some background of what's going what what what's behind this safer and what it meant so he the first we'll start with is the marshall because he's coming to answer the martial so back up a little bit with the martial with the acceptance of the martial and then through that we'll be able to understand what wrote and what and and what rakhine kanyevsky was doing in this effort so the martial was was in the in the world he's very famous for writing a parish both on under on the i guess called the regular parts of the gemara and also that guy to gemara the guy mars he he's born somewhere in the year 155 between 1555 to 1565 they're not sure the exact year and he dies in 1631. he's a rav in various places rashishiva many in many in a few different cities um he's imparted one of the was part of the vada by ratsay see gizaskamas to some safari in his lifetime and la marshall he was very involved with the famous siddharth shabsi safir his safer some of his tyros starts coming out already in his lifetime such as his comes in i believe it was 1611. material of his came out earlier but that's not important for today's context a lot has been written about him most famous is a small safer a very nice safer available on hebrew books called told this adam from river margolis a very very nice saver now in general when one wants to know about his particular goddamn a good stop to start with is the khida the hedon when he talks about he says it was a tremendous cuddle etcetera and he wrote and then he says it's on roy talmud and it's it sheds light on the gemara and thai swiss and then he says ashkenaz zazu that everyone was into it and he he then he talks about he mentions a sentence about the khadusha goddess which is not for um not to focus on today now the safer becomes accepted as the writes and and we find different um as time goes on because it gets more and more accepted now who lives much later one of the things famously he does he traveled he traveled all over europe fundraising fair to israel uh in the past few months um his travels that he published that he didn't publish that he wrote which were published a while ago two new additions came out of of these travels they're fascinating material and a lot of times he he transcribes different materials of people that he met or saw or things he heard so at one point he talks about he he met some good alum and and he refers to them that they were being very isic in tysos and the marshall and the marsha with great eun and okay he described such a such a such a conversation that he had um that he watched or or i think that he might have had with them okay then elsewhere in the in the muggle he describes something that he heard from someone an old ducking about the rebel rebel he's known as the rubber of paschal although he had nothing to do with fasidas as he predates khasidis but the rebel repression as he's fondly recalled and basically he brings down a very sharp story that um that they say about the rebel paschal someone he he saw marsha he got very angry and he threw the safer down he was very upset about the martial and then it turns out later on he he he realized he might have been mistaken and he talks he talks a little bit about it he has and he has a few lines about this story but he brings down but here we see that at least someone is great the reber epistle was a was a great russian shiva at that time had some type of um was some type of a snagged us so to speak against the martial okay a little before the khida there was a great going his name was ribeying the landslipper who who died very young but he wrote a lot he was prolific and he's in the world of allah in the areas that he wrote about he's very much quoted he wrote sava and in this he talks about the martial and he says something else he says that when he talks about giving it's us about what to learn and how to learn properly so he says you should be madayak rav on the perish of the marsha and he says it could help you understand the suggest it's written with great kitzer then he says it was written it had to have been written with because a human being could not have written this safer okay so we see that different people had different and there's more there's other quotes and and if one checks and i'm not i'm not here to speak by requests about all the problems about them our show although it's a worthwhile um topic but i'm trying just to give some to just to be able to appreciate what rohingyawski was doing a bit later we find let's say in volusion um it's recorded a story more than maybe even more than one story and sounds like from the story the vibe one gets is that um and civ wasn't so happy with his with with um with his nephew who was being he saw him being isak and marsha he said that's for a different time now what's what's strange is is that if one looks and then it saves writings let's say you'll see he quotes the martial many many times in all his writings not only that one safer that came out which which deals with the marshall then it's if you gave a beautiful ascama so so what's so what's the shot behind this um let's say if you even could read so much into it that there was some type of islamists but there are other places that it sounds like some people were were sort of upset about the natsif not about them it's about so many times when um when one's looking the there was a great um a very special person the previous generation his name was slimy ace of zeven he wrote multiple swarm and one of the swarm was called ishmashitas a lot of times he could say something a sentence and derek aga from that you could understand um you could learn a lot from it so he's talking about the marsha and he and it sounds like that it became sort of that people were focusing on it too much of course the martial is a safer niffler and its lushen is very medujak but sometimes chitsonit gets its extremism gets too extreme and what happened is that people were spending too much time on the marsha and they were losing focus from being focusing on on what marsha really wanted you to do which was to learn rashi and tyson's and the gemara and and it became a thing that people were mama's spending too much time at it so it's very possible that was more what the native was getting nervous not that of course that it's very important to learn marshall but everything has to have um be done in the proper amount of time and focus now and this could be found in various um and it's mark there's nothing to say such a thing okay but without we're not we're not going to go into about reference now the the there was a great there's a great safer from a rabbit his name was her brunshbon and this were greenspan um wrote a safer called malachism um he also has a rehearsal in his rehearsals he talks about marsha and he when he describes it he says the following russian beautiful s and a lot of times it could help us understand the signona classic and it's um s and it's and it's very focused on russian isis and he has yet he talks about this a lot in a state from chavez which was recently reprinted in a beautiful edition by you shalom and there's a lot more to say about it but the kids are many good alum we find on the other hand they were very into martial martial i just saw recently a quote from a bicho le discon how he was very into learning the the the the martial and others were also in very much into the martial okay now with this background that they were we the the first letter is about learning the marshall [Music] says that he has a taina on his generation that the generation stopped learning martial it was and he says and one should be mimik to learn it properly and it teaches one he also says it helps lizzie curran call sugi le patel he says the previous generations were did appreciate the marsha and then he throws out he says and then he says and then we'll get back to that problem second and he says from when the people left learning this safer they lost out in idea and it and helps learning improperly and one in a misha sartar yashna and mckitzer is very very um and this letter has been quoted by many people in today's generation that we've it's i've heard it many times in schmoozin that that it's a shame people have stopped learning the marsha and this was addressing something specific something that was going on anything you could track are you gonna get to that or you know i wish i knew the i don't recall if i have seen what the backstory of this letter of the khasanesh is and it's a good question a lot of times we don't know the backstory what was the who was this letter addressed to and what was it about i'm not sure i have to look if there's an answer for this one because some letters we do have and the story is actually much a lot of times could get more interesting but anyway but this is a known thing about the hazardous now as i said the cousins throws out about rebecca vega so so rebecca vegard in the told us of rebecca that i know that hazardous looked at which was the famous i could not find mention about the marshall but in the dhamma to the joshua the sons already right that my our father rebecca veger he didn't really have time to look at him on the suggest but what was happening for him he aimed and that was the main akron that he looked at um and he made sure to spend time using it in one of the recent works on ruby vega called the iron shell israel so they have uh i would say three four pages of different um places where talks about marshall with unbelievable titles we see that the martial was very very important for emberkey vega now but more than that not only was the importance of robert vega in for learning as it's clear i i was doing a search in a safer one of the earliest farmers that came out was and even in that safer which is he quotes it many times and those horrors are more a lot of times more relate to this is obviously getting relates to a different discussion which we're not going to go into now about the marshall being and we do find many daily uh paiskim do use it because it's it is crucial to understand a lot of times the suggest and the way of our show will help understand this it will will have effects but we're we we will leave that um for now now so what but what is being made and so to see and he sees it also in the one so much so that it bothered the that it became forgotten so to speak now the besides four um i uh when i was learning in um in yeshiva in the mirror so i heard shir one of the people i heard cheer from was ramayana levitz and we were learning at the time kadusan and he said an interesting remark a kadusan the first parrot a lot of it has to do with russia's and and um and khashoggis and russia's of how we learn out different denim from sukkam and he said a lot of times so he said there was a safer at the time and then and which was an earlier safer a famous acronym the atmosphere so remember schneider said then the islam yeshivas they took on to learn that since if they use it a lot for the long distance pieces but but most of the safer is handling in the bonus of the gemara it's an excellent safer to be isokin to understand that on some level there's parallels similar to what the martial is doing maybe there's there's also differences said that people think it's a godless we don't need to look at those pieces he says no because we can't even understand it we're not understanding that there's so much happening in the gemara that's and because we're focused more on different points just on the londons and the gemara and the the chakra tires of the marashitaisis is not as much stressed so the and anyone who looks at his farm knows that that was a very fundamental point of his the text of the gemara the learning of the shock of atari and the feshbaenus is beyond important now with this introduction we could we get closer to our story of with rokhan kanievsky i recall when i was in yeshiva um marisha shiva must have said something either asked a question or something about the martial and somebody went over to him afterwards and wanted to maybe answer a question that he had or something with the martial and if i recall correctly he said something along the lines of did you think about myself for more than an hour says you have to fast to understand this martial the significance that they held for understanding martial was it was great correct yes but but it seems even today i don't know for sure but it sounds like it's still lost on some level it sounds like the khazanish's complaint is still relevant now what now with the marsha he wrote very bakitzer and sometimes he he was just coming to be my ira points and he's felt that if one goes on the right track of learning they'll you'll get to the right point so he wrote vietnamese that if you if you understand the shock of the time you look at it carefully enough you'll be able to come up with the answer you say he wasn't trying to ask these um earth-shattering questions or stump people it was actually he was a he was a it's legendary about the martial is that this keyboard was written with his tamidim he learned to tell me them and not only that certain parts he he skipped because he didn't learn with tommy them because he was busy at the famous erid that he used to go to as being part of the vada bahraz but the the hebrew was a hebrew written with with tamidem and it was to get talmidhim to learn so he felt i don't need to answer i don't need to spell out everything and so he wrote very bakitzer and he even says this in his akdama that he wrote very bakitzer now fast forward after them our show we read we mentioned earlier the martial is already printed as early as the 1611 so we get to the 1700s and there was two people they were i think they might even be russian shiva one's name was he was in grits and he had a great so he had a friend and they in the 1760s they decided and it's very unique because it's not so common to find two people put out a safer together we have sam with such a thing but they're not not so common and they put out a safer called hierarchy and by russia one of the things one of the main focuses was to go through marshals that were that he left off of the ashish and they say in the dhamma we don't know too much about them but in the dhamma they already emphasized that today people they still understand the significance of taka learning the martial but they get stuck on it so what the martial and them done was a dover paschal it needs to be spelled out so they went in a chat oriented way so that people who don't have as much time to spend learning at the eun would be able to know what possibly he meant with his vhl ash so and they put it out to see it seems the safer was very popular it was printed numerous times maybe seven eight times in in the 1800s so that usually means it's very very popular okay now um so now we get to recline kenievsky or kaine keniewski writes in his akdama that when he was young he and his lashes okay he's about 20 years old at the time and he also he's learning shiva's path for the the repriance he says i made it my business to learn the martial he says and he says vietnam at the end and he doesn't explain why because and many people are miyagaya to understand it so he says there was a safer yakar called harash shah but it sounds like he didn't know about it at the first at first so he went and he sat and he went through all of shas and walter marshall and he answers them all we're not talking about okay he had a few go he did it for a few things he does it it's a it's almost 60 pages he goes through ganshas of the marshall when he went to print it later on he checked and he saw he was having a lot of times to the raj to the safeway russia so he took out those pieces unless he felt maybe had a better answer and then he begins why he and he says what's behind it the fir the first paragraph introduction is he brings the whole lotion of this amazing letter of the of the kazanish so here we see him taking on at a young age i don't know so many people today young bakram that could do the could go could go through all of shas and answer the yeshly ashev of of the martial crusader we're talking about all the from the sectors over here the marshall wrote on everything or most of shas come at all of shafts and to do this so it's a very unique feat now the part of the influence was is because he was doing what he learned and saw from his uncle that has an ish and it had a tremendous impact on him and he felt this is an important thing now of course it's not it didn't necessarily take off in the yeshiva world most people never even heard of the safer i would say in the 19 in the 19 um 1979 someone went ahead and printed a safer call kaiwitsumafar marsha and in the safer he printed five four svaram that were written previously on the martial and at the end he got permission from khan kanyevsky to include his safer they printed it and like it's interesting is your clan can you have ski rights in this edition that it wasn't written with proper eon it was just to be relieved okay this is the first safer that i would like to do that i would like to mention and here we see one of the points i'm also trying to bring out is that his somewhat of an aspect of his connection with the fazanish to conclude this pract just to mention a draft about this with the kazonish throughout looking through all his works we could see his impact and i hope to discuss that more in a different time but just in the in the um in the safety time the safer time the crown the back so there is a small contrast which he which he included things that he heard from his mother about hanhagus of the khasanesh it's approximately um 40 40 different and haggis that his mother told him and he recorded them this time that already way way back now interesting we i recently learned that that the hankness has a safer about hazard and haggis that he himself saw living in the house that has an ish that he that he recorded and his father had him write this down for some reason it wasn't printed it seems that he he he said that he's he's allowing his children to print it so hopefully we'll we'll decide to have it soon and one last thing is in recent years a lot of material has come out on the kaizen ish one of the famous works that came out was the mice multiple volumes it used to be it came out one volume and people said okay and another volume and another volume another volume and then and like then they even put out an index and they just put out another volume and another anyway at one point they it seems they brought to rank he and he gave also a bunch of pages of unhaggis that he saw by the khasanesh okay this is the first safer that i wanted to discuss and this aspect of his connection with well very fascinating you said you may not know too many bachram who could do it today it sounds like you may you know a couple no i i don't i'm being on just a figure speech okay what's the what's the next day if you want to discuss so the next day for i would like to discuss is the is heber on the arkhashreim which is majors to the rush listen before we get to this so this video is found how do you find it today it's on its own it's part of the hasadah it's part of this but also i think it's um it comes up as the asheville on hebrew books if you search where i can ask his name on hebrew books he'll get many of this farm for free he gave them permission to put up a lot of his farm already a while back okay that rings the bell isn't that what many of the yeshivas say during ello exactly yeah yeah so this is all so this also um before i get to talk america i just want to give a little bit what the safer is and then i will explain a little bit elaborate what rakhine did for this safer okay so first of all we have a client in this again in one of these one of the countries and that was eventually incorporated into the safer it calls it he writes that it's it's the rush and he wrote very bakitzer but it needs to be he says russian but he didn't bring his makaris and people don't know where they're from so he decided to go sit and track down all the makairis and he brings down the shyness of his albuquerque he also he it seems he really liked this heber he wrote he made himself ready at the time he published it with him and over the years he kept on adding um to it his first ta'ara already he stalls through the the the name is not necessarily the name given to the safer um by the rush but okay anyway now so and he prints the safer um i'm not sure when it was first printed but from the end of the safer he says when does he finish it he finishes it in yeshiva tough shinyu aleph and pataktikva so he's also he's pretty young he's in the low 20s when he puts out the safer now to give background behind the safer okay so first like this you mentioned that you heard and you recall that an l you used to learn in yeshivas so it seems the safer became very accepted as a monster safer but before how did it become accepted and what's the story behind it so in the 1620s there was a plague in europe and the taisis yantif after it seems i guess when the plague i guess stopped um pretty much he made he um he gave us russia in his city of prague and in the middle of russia he says he wants to make a takana and this takana is that to say daily the hebrew of ravamov um he called he calls it arkhaskayam it's a monster safer he says it's printed already in some of the sudurum he's going to split it into seven khalaktum so every day to say a few parts of the safer daily wall when to say it before barak shalma after everyone's wearing talos and filling now he realized that not everyone even could understand it so he he translated it into german or yiddish whatever it's called so that even the women should be able to understand it and they can listen and and even children will be able to um learn the safer and it was printed already then in the 1620s um this safer would take this young since then it was printed numerous numerous times there's even a scammer from the sharia at one point where he also says it's known already and changed much later than the thai sisyantif akopanim the safer becomes very accepted in cloudy strong but no parish was ever really written on this safer um which is very interesting and it's not really um you know i don't think it's really quoted in the in swarm at all it seems the i think there is a shock that quotes it once or something but not you don't see it as a source so much um now in the in the early 1990s there was a journal called which came out from benebrach which had a lot of different kasha where people used to send in articles so one person a great guy that we lost earlier this year rashema fischer wrote in that it might not be majes to the rush okay and it was a part of an article where he had some other very interesting comments the next issue uh khashoggi also was recently nifty during corona he wrote in that that also talking about it saying that that already early on people did it or miyake with rush okay but these are all different questions and bibliographical questions about the hebrew if it is the raj it isn't the rush now a little later um also in the same journal another issue someone went ahead and tracked down mama's early manuscripts of it and the question was when you learned this what's shot in the cedar and what's what's shot in it what was the kavana behind it some people said it's a tava but there's no indication that it was of the rush for his children anyway but whatever it is even though it was said by a lot of people but no one sat and learned it it's a reason who wrote it and to be my mick in what's going on behind the safe it seems the balian muslim took a liking to it marshall and kelm they were very into it and at one point at one point [Music] various of the balayamosa were very interested the admiral mckelm was very into it and it seems he spoke about it a lot it sounds like for them they did it all year round and others and became a very known muslim safer anyway sir um a while back in benebrach they put out an edition of it where they took all the pieces of of the of um they took all different pieces of muslim well the great muslim where they talk about the safer and they put it in in a safer um calling it rush okay very nice now they also have the original edition of the tais yantev and stuff like that and they also have the manuscript that i mentioned earlier that was printed and the union you know in a more muslic um but the safer is looked at as a very muslim and stack of very useful interesting safer easy to learn and and that was what they did now a little earlier than them there was a great guy in benebrach his name was ilber wrote a lotus farm he decided to put out this is in the in the um 1950s i believe it was to put out a beer on this apron he was very into re-shining him he did this to the mother's farm and he found it very strange and no one went to learn the safer as a reason then someone told them by the way someone beat you to it who beat you to it or crying can you ask a young reprint can you have ski wrote a safer on the thing in the end he gets permission from him and it's printed today many this rib and yemen silver edition was printed in many editions also with the two peru or hankanyeski and benjamin the the what's called the boring bibliographical information about the safe now let's first focus on replying kanevsky over here where is rokhan kanyevsky here we see early i was said that he had influence of different people such as his uncle which we spoke about and others here we see his tremendous aha for ishain and anyone who goes through all this farm will see a word of a region is beyond important him but not so much that just the word of a reason he went out of his way to track down all different types of vishnu even the newest ones printed and he quotes them all because either here he went and he took the it's the rush as he brings and he says and he was aimid on to be mega called tag every macar okay now what is the word every makara by iraq and konievsky means already last time we said we discussed how he has this javascript he's already been doing the javascript sounds like for a good few years i don't know if it had all incorporate everything but he ends up throwing in ko tayu shabalpe as makairus over here so it's sort of like a musser encyclopedia also so let's say you're looking for about you should have saver parameters so you look up where he talks about save pointing office and then you'll have like 10 marmot criminals in kazal and when this was coming out this is before computers before all search engines uh obviously it's kadai to mention a very cute um um fact at the lavaya they mentioned what what their client his son mentioned as a husband what did he do for his chil with his children on these friday long friday nights they they were making them they had no kashmir what did they do he had a bunch of children he had to amuse them so they would do is they would test him there's a safer put out by meister of cook called mcclellan all different kazaals and or things people say from khazal they would read him a memor and they'd say where is it from list off what it said there probably and then you list a bunch more so here he went it's like an encyclopedia for musser if someone needs to get up and give a dress on booster and you want to know cass so okay today you could type into google you get some things but here he was doing this way before he has a bunch of sources okay so that's number one what he does number two is it's a region so he sho ends the rush right so so he goes and says what about russia's other places does it work out with other pieces of rush not every piece is a relative but someone is and he shows uh something might be a stirrup sometimes he's handling a gemara he'll throw in her arrow that he saw a steerer somewhere but it's not just that he's bringing you bavli you shall me midrashi he's bringing their hearts tongue debaleos all different midrashim last time i spoke chemical to the rashmi somehow gets in here also then he brings even some muscle swarm you say vishairish avoid him many times he brings him a celsius sharim he brings in many times to say him sometimes he even argues he's throwing at you all different things different madrassian from a safer right so madrashim which hashem i hope to talk about and all this is to show so he's doing he's first of all he's being the farish the the the safer he's giving the sources from a multiple sometimes it could be three pages of of harris of ghazal's that talk about this thing okay bucketzer um you see here this murder viva study this is where i'm saying is this was it could be other dialum had it and people mr burrow was also into but he i think took it to a new level which i hope to elaborate on more but that was part of what was motive in this safer i just want to show that another thing one other point that he says besides for showing with the rush so in one of the auditions they say rebecca sarno was aimed on that there's a lot of similarities between here and rabbini himself assignment on this and he shows sometimes with the rabbini that this could be a macarthur now i just want to mention just one example for such a thing which okay says in a few short words he doesn't say all of it but just to understand why a lot of times when you learn these types of swarm it's very very interesting in a lotion it's a region and and looking at a region how he could word something a lot of times could be miyashev something or could help you understand something so there's a piece of this i just want to give one example this mama's very big surname there's a piece where he talks about this then he says over here is that there's a famous safer of the besif um which is the maggot spoke to the base yosef and a lot to talk about to safer the kitser some people said that it can't be it's the basis because there's a problem with the safer what's the problem with the safer the series of says he's going to be zaika in the safer the malek says something to the fact that he's going to be burnt i'll kill this hashem um and he doesn't die but kill the shashimura the best doesn't die i'll kill his hashem with this rafa okay whatever so people use it as a raya it's a problematic safer what's going on over here so the radal talking about this and it's safer he says what the kavanagh over here was of the of her basic kaya wasn't that he's going to be meister nephesh and he's going to die you just have to have cavanaugh you have to have kavanaugh to be moister yourself now the rabbina says when does one what every day one is able to do this when during krishna that even though you didn't it's good enough that's what abhinayana says and there's other macarius and different we're shining them for such a thing that's the kavana over here when reb the rush and darkest time over here also says um he says when you're saying when you say it over here also he brings down the piece and then he says um he stills too he brings down this um um he brings in the gimbal and barakas he brings down magician and then he brings down this concept is brought down weir in the void they also bring this down the the seaside so in a few short words and this is what the radar says is really the shot in the magazine so it's not a riot there's a problem with the magnificent this is just one tiny example of the many it's very small print so there's a lot a lot of material in here in this hebrew of we got to see him as a mepharish of a region using his incredible knowledge at a very young age that we're predating all computers and everything showing that he was something very very unique even at a young age wow so we have the yesha yash with the martial which is something unique may have been done somewhat in the past but i'm certainly took it to another level then you have verb like you said the sources the muslim safer well really eye-opening okay so that's number two and you still want to talk about a third one yeah the third one is very is not so long it will be oh it's like this i said one of the influences on on on rib uh kaneowski is the vilna gain so again i hope to elaborate more about this but in the next small hebrew i want to demonstrate this also he prints a hebrew which is also in this in this collection and it's called he calls her as follows it's called and then afterwards there's another work called conscious marijuana this is a small contracem um and what is it so he says like this writes first okay so what's going on over here so dear again i will make a very big sir i have to have recommenders already on um the listeners is this follows if you look in your shasta vilna in the back of your gemara where today everyone sees a lot of people use eyes so you have this uh one of the purusha and one of the swarm that was incorporated is the fey e9 what's the assay 9 so this is a work written by ariel bialyn he dies he's um he's born in the 1820s he dies in 1886. he learns in velajin arav bunchesvarim prominently trisha gado okay fine what was he unique one of his uniquenesses was that he wrote this so if you open up the introduction just found the gemara brachas basically when you learn gemara you learn beverly talmud a lot of times there could be a piece in your xiaomi that will be very relevant to you but it might not be right over there on that kamara maybe it's in maybe you're learning your vanish and there's a piece in your xiaomi in gitan that could help you understand it so he make sure to move aside but not only that he does it for a lot of other including midrashim and he writes this married the significance of it obviously when one thinks about this this is obviously coming from he learned the village and the villain influence on it is also obvious so just to give i'm just and to explain what i'm talking about i'm just going to use one example from him and then i'm going to conclude with what khan kanyevsky says in his um dhamma about what he was trying to do and that's it basically there's a hebrew about the famous calmer of the village so in there he brings a famous story um a famous thing very bakitzer it says it says impossible so the question that everyone asks what does after sheila have to do with this pasuk so the gears change was suggested that it said i and tough and the russia tavis is wrong and it really should be after human and it will be and then it will make sense because if truman and akev there might be some um connection okay but and and and there's endless amount of material about us so so rabbi husker fivel brings this down he says that the the that that um this mistake just to correct it that of the russia tabus was wrong already he brings the grab assignment on it then later on he brings that uh told him that in the chuvas uh you know rajma he found allah lived human and others okay this is rip zalman um and um and this was a suggestion it could be a zombie and also said it but this is a piece in the talusam now you say nayem in that sugya in yuma he has a whole piece about it and basically what does he do he brings you down the um the gemara he obviously talks about the mara and then he brings down um the magistrate of akaraba are you shall mean kadusan a magician boris rabba another madrish and uh majestuma a few places all weird that with the where the lotion is then he brings down this and you obviously see that he's holding that he has a lot of gear size that's not like this he has a godzilla beret a giratius and other things now so he's bringing down tons of sources and and he taught and then he talks about it so you could see a lot of times it's a lot of times it's not just a year so change a lot of times it could be upshot and he could say how does he do this by his incredible yada and bakis he was uh entire shabbat pair beverly you shall me etc etc now so comes along the young i don't know what age your kindness he wrote it but i'm pretty sure he wrote it when he's relatively young but i'm not i'm not saying it's the same time as that because i forgot the date it doesn't say a date a lot of times it says replying that it's very important we know and it's amazing what the what the fear nine did he was an italian all the places where gemara and midrashim but he wasn't there's certain places especially in alan's roman tyrus where it's very very important because there we don't even have talmud it's very useful and important to do this so um there's also russian that this girl says and he's going to collect them the ones that he's missing so he goes and he puts it out and here you see once again based on his yada incredible yadda and teresha up pages of showing you the midrashim the safra safri and when one uses this one sees this so first you're blown away by this type of unbelievable heck if and yet and part of what we're talking about he was doing it wasn't to show off about his islamic comments because he held this is unbelievable crucial in understanding this where is this coming from this is the vilnigan school that kul tereshwa everything is relative when you learn the bible you have to know what you shalom he says you have to know what the madrashim say not only for a girsa it's more it's a lot of times it could change the shot it could be a whole sentence to the story okay and the last thing that he does is the maramaktim is a similar thing it's union from a question texas he says that they bring a magish or xiaomi or to sefta and it doesn't say where it is so now if it's uh if it's a magician the plastics or cesar kangaski i'm not going to bother with but a lot of times it isn't so who's going to know it without banning eyelash just goes through and he lists you all the different places again through his crazy knowledge not only of bavaria xiaomi but of many mid-russian midrashim that i mentioned last time but even some obscure sources just to mention one say from isis or abandon islam which i hope to talk about where climbing we have is our sun has got on this whole safer from the garden anyway be that as a may from these three farm alone which are written when he's two of them for sure he's written when he's young we're we're seeing that rokhan kanyevsky did something beyond unique he took his incredible knowledge of which came through it wasn't he wasn't born with it it was incredible hasmada and khazari which he was always madness it's as it now become more and more famous this book about it and he took that and he used that information that he learned to be able to be magala and be my first areas of torah on unbelievable levels i hope to continue with more samples to elaborate to explain this even more in depth and more in depth because this is just the type of shabayan of the swarm that he printed thank you so so much what could we do learn extra minute two minutes three minutes five minutes a day i don't know for the next month at least we got it we got to take something from this okay so everybody will take what they could we're not here to make suggestions but it's really really fascinating thank you so much for sharing and we hope to have a few more episodes on this thank you you