Rav Chaim's Seforim Explored (Part 3)

[Music] and welcome back rabbi doctor eliezer broth we've already done two episodes on kanyevsky's svarim or hashem the feedback's been tremendous and that's why we're doing some more not here to waste people's times um today we would like to focus on the safer nacha son which was written about the suge of eglar ruffa so before we begin as certain people have the minute is to read emails so one email that we got is from somebody in nurses role who writes the following just finished your second video on the story of amazing you are fun to watch and listen to and don't ever say you're vulnerable yes there thank you he mentions that he also says keep up the great work and he says if your wife ever wonders what you do all day just stand there to me so okay if your wife ever wonders we have someone who to send her to to make sure that you're uh behaving okay so how are you today what do you want to start off with well so mr let's start off right now with the nacho ison of ski um so as everyone by now it comes up in most conversations about rokhan kanyevsky he wrote a safer at some point about eglarufa and some people admire kabata for a minute others a little more and bottom line is that they do say that it's incredible safer and there's no question that it is one incredible safer okay now there's i today would like to speak a little bit about this safer some points about it one could technically speak about the safer forever as we'll see because han kanewski just goes on and on and on about eglarufa like nobody's business now but first before anything there's a earlier this year uh volume which i hope to discuss a little bit more later on between a car a series of correspondences that went over many years between dave landau bernie brock and his and rochan kenowski they were very close they also had letters in learning and they were printed one of the letters after the the nachos comes out where dove landau one of the great live today writes to him it's a you're safer as a safer niffler um he goes um i learned a lot of it and i have some artists and it goes on and now dave landale also writes in general very begitser similar similar to khan kanowski legendary writing buckets about in these letters it's a 33-page letter with harris and harris and arus he says these are only some of the artists i have on the safer and then frankiewski answers him at least some of the artists and the printeros over here so we have already at the time in 19 in the 1970s when the safer actually comes out a friend of his writing that it's an incredible incredible safer that's if the safer has been printed in a bunch of editions which usually means that um usually means that people are bought it um if people learn it or not i have no idea but everyone it's if it's a safer that everyone always heard of that there's a massive safer on the sugiya of el agua roofa from kankanivsky okay now when one the shuttle is when did rakhine kanewski write this safer so i mentioned already earlier that a lot of times your hand kanewski gives us dates um when he does things and he even in his abdomen to his farm and someone's at the conclusion of the sephiroth say something and he also a lot of times gives us insight in why he writes a particular safer um which is very useful because we don't have to guess he says it's straight out now so in this safer nationalism when we look at it so first of all he says again b aldusi he decided to be mavar the suggest as much as possible he realizes not so much literature on the subject and he decided he's going to go through this topic and he's and he lists out a few reasons which we'll discuss in a moment he says that when i the first edition that i wrote on this that i did not publish um it was in tough shin tests okay it's pretty far back toffshin tests um brings us to his early twenties when he's riding the safer okay now that time the khasanesh is alive and well and he shows it to the fazanish and he spoke to him a lot about many of the issues in the safer not only that throughout the safer he brings tons of material but not i'm not talking about material that has his writings conversations he has about topics relating to safer then he says i want to went through it again um and then he goes through the third time it seems and eventually prints it in the 70s i believe it was his father also went through the safer very carefully his father wrote harass also was published it's printed at least six seven editions i'm not sure but in many of the editions he adds a few different harass material people sent in um about the actual safer and and um his father also seemed to have been very very um impressed with the safer okay now last time um i've mentioned that um he was he that some of the people that had a tremendous influence on him was the khasanesh and was his father and you see here here we see um not in there that their materials are included in here and conversations with them are in here and he stresses this already in the safer like right away not gum says now y'all do see i don't know the exact age when y'all do see means when he decided to do this because even when when you when you have the date tough shin tests that he's um that he did the ikker siva this is a a crazy crazy amount of literature that he went through in order to produce this work as i will discuss shortly so he obviously started this earlier insane as teens he started now seems at some point in this safer there's discussion about brachas in brachas there's all types of con there's all types of conversations in brachas and reshine him which bro um which process do you make and when do you make brachas um certain amidst us if you do if you don't and also anus also comes up a lot when do you make let's say um you'll say you just say the mitzvah or other times you say you add in the word shell um let's say mechanical shell hanako or zalahar hanukkah and this plays out in many many myths okay so this is a known this is a known um conversation in halacha which a lot have a lot has been written about somehow in this safer khan kanyevsky has a contrast it was its own it seems it was its own countries that originally was going to be put elsewhere published elsewhere this countries is um it spans over i would say about 15 jam-packed pages of mar mccamus on this sugya where he breaks down approximately ten shitas risha unit ten main sheets rishing and then he handles in all the differences with them this is there's hundreds of narma kindness over here one could get complete khaleesha said that's when one reads this this was done without a computer um way before computers that were in the before barry lam programs it's hebrew books google books this is way before this the fact that someone was able to open up this amount of swarm is mind-boggling but it's not so much that he collected information he puts it in this cheeto is this he sets it up very very clearly it seems he was going to write it say from whatever however you want to pronounce it and he was going to put it there in the end i guess he decided to take that countries here now what age did he write that contrast so it seems that he wrote this countries at the eight he started writing this country so he finished writing his countries at the age of 14 which is rather remarkable um at least according to this book i've been quoting a few times already and it's it's unbelievably remarkable someone wants to get a glimpse of his machias and also ian at the same time because the so many things he just throws in parentheses not with footnotes later on he developed more clear way how to do this by creating some a form of a character but i guess in that reason he decided not to do it so it's more confusing but there's tons of information in each in these parentheses um small points going off on small little tangents and this is written at a very young age i'm sure that over the years he updated it until he printed in the late 70s but still it's it's beyond remarkable and one doesn't have to learn the complicated suggests of eglarufa you could just have a glimpse of more easier topics over here in this field this keyboard this topic has been written about as i mentioned already in the time zone but has pages on it in the recent edition of from rebellio greenswag there's tons of material in it on this topic and the river margolis an interesting small save for komakara bracha he also wrote about it we see rakhine kanewski in a side topic that he put into this safer already in full glory at a young age now but why does he write the safer why does he pick english what was it that that sparked his interest in neglect rufus i said we we just turned to that gumma and and and returned he spells it all out for us the first thing that kaikaneski he says that he brings he says is that is a safer hasidim that um he first he brings the kumaran saita which is also relevant but first he brings the safer hasidim as his reason and this safe hasidim we have spoken about actually in a uh recently this earlier this year by learning massachusetts basically safehasidim talks about that there's a certain massage that becomes sort of like a mace mitzvah and the great horse if someone goes ahead and learns them and we discuss that great length of what um different aspects of this safe have seen them but rokhan kanewski brings this safer hasidim and eglarufa as i'm gonna um i'm gonna list out shortly is one of these areas that's not so much uh spoken about um actually you could say right now or i don't have to have to wait to basically egla roofa so to begin roofer becomes in um we find it the is a few succumb at the end of parachute basically we find a dead body in a field so what happens with it and there's no we don't know who is the person who killed who who's killed over here and there's all different details in in literally nine sukkah about an un um i guess in english translate the unsolved murder and then the zecatum have to come down and they measure from the body and they figure out all different details now there's a suggestion two blood approximately maybe two and a half blood about it there's not even twice this over there it's just rashy pretty much and from there um um rakhine kanefc goes ahead and he and he writes a safe and easy now how many pages is it so you'll say 10 pages 20 pages no we're talking about without without getting into the auditions over 312 pages without all the editions and these pages are jam-packed late more recently the later editions are smaller but the original edition athleticism was a big tall volume packed with material so how's it structured what did he write it around is it on the rambam oh so so i'm gonna i'm gonna get to how he so right now let's a good good point let's discuss quickly what he did is he basically he created a top part of the halacha which he calls the savage i'm going to elaborate more of what he do how he breaks it down shortly and then at the bottom he he has a running commentary to remove irish all the halachus that he has on top he calls them um and nacho nevaeh these are okay now one could see as you look on top over here is this is the words and then over here and all this is is pages and pages material and i'm going to give some samples of things um shortly now but what's significant is is he took something uh oh there's a suggest it's not like there was no swinging chance but if one learns the singing of aguilar roofa well fine yes so today there are some on site it's not it's not a must have to learn so much in ishiroshima septus but learns it and there was farm written about it before very nice farm on on on itself and there are discussions in the hwanum and i'm going to show shortly what it is that rokhan kanyevsky was doing and what was a little bit more to try to give a theory what was behind what he was doing about this anyway but the first so the first nakuda there okay mentions and his reason is he is he's pointing to this safer hasidim which we already admired about before so um i have rahmanis and we don't have to hazard over now the second point which is a theme that rokhan kanyevsky mentions time and time again in various farm of his is in his in a small safer called neimer tyra r which i also spoke about in a different time about learning kachem in general was famous for making him to try to get the illum he was a kind and various other things to get him to learn kachin and in this hebrew um he discusses the great husum of learning um kachin and one of the aspects that he brings up is is that when one that there's a certain system now we don't have a base something dish we're not able to be mckay in these mitzvahs so there's a special indian to learn these mitzvahs because through learning these misses it's kind of time brings us down from various makaires kain kanievsky is very into this and this is a theme which is found in a few other swarm of as he brings this sky in peace for why he's going into said nissan perhaps we'll get to some of them eventually um maybe even today but in a safer architecture which is mostly a muslim safer which also needs its own discussion but he has a chapter called simkasha mitzvah and here too in the chapter he brings down the the the material about this with the skym again showing that it is early sources and he and he also adds an uh um a different prank over here which is that there's a there's a big indian in general there's certain myths that don't come they don't come too easily so he shows the face with agra his father other people that there were certain mitzvahs that if they come your way one should go out of the way one should make sure so to speak to try to do them one of them was he says his father was um was he was able to read my time racism there's a few videos on the internet of different goddamn doing it there was even a safer empidiopathic hammer of these unique mixes and when it comes that were able to do it to run and do it so he's he um so he's using this after he brings he says um um has an issue has such a point that one should culminate is such a concept there's many other sources for such a thing but he also was into this the kuda and in interestingly enough in in in his farm he has lists of they printed some of them in xavier of his some mitzvahs that he had like mama um like a small page where he had what to do for for these um for these mitzvahs um which is very which is very interesting you know that he didn't just like so he was learning everything trying to keep in mind when it will come up um magnus kuna ray sages peter kamar like a small handbook for himself i don't know if he ever planned on printing it of paschal how to do it hello mice and that um which tickle torah maybe it seems some of these myths to see actually he was going to write about them also small hidro but he never was he wasn't able to um for various reasons uh i guess lack of time or whatever but this you said that that i'm saying from what she brings over here for this safer was also since eglarufa is something that um it's not common to be ultimate time especially today for sure not so i was that also was another push for him to write about this mitzvah and as i said he it seems to be a theme of him of his and others farm also now there's another nakuda which is also an akuda of his in general and this nakuda is that kalatarakula is um has relation with each other he likes to use the uh a beautiful yerushalmi taira anime which is a key key point um that one which one sees it in by him especially how all of tyra could end up relating and becoming a a piece of information one thing that seems to not have anything to do with it um could play out in a completely different subure um here too again there's a famous uh nephew uh sorry rakhine veljner and his a famous piece where he talks about half of the kalispa he says specifically says when one is learning that somehow from the learning of the suggyo you could come up with a way how to be aguna so now when one learns this piece of this this um kind of legendary you could think and and maybe that it means is that yeah you you might take it to mean you know that you get the um understanding of learning and your mind gets sharper and stuff like that and and that's the justification sometimes people say to learn different things but it's not true at all it seems is and someone asked for khan kesley specifically what's shot in this piece of login that's specifically a case from there it will come out that you it would be it's learned from some a piece of a sugya in take again here we have a pranking of speech bacchus answering it but the point is that kagneski uses this to xiaomi in various form of his that all of tyra plays out for each for everything so it's not and and as i'm and i hope to elaborate about the shortly is it's not it's just it's not just about okay there's a suggester and that's it and that's all he's going to talk about it's 300 pages the gemara desert as a as i said already there's not even tysis over there so how does a man come up with and write a hebrew of 300 plus pages so so that's what i'm going to get to shortly a couple of these three reasons the kind of murky and konyewski rights are the reasons why he's putting out the safer okay okay beautiful so just before you continue can you just summarize the three reasons one two three okay so the first reason to summarize the reasons over here is one reason based on the secrecy that there's an indian to learn the sectors that or or nauseam even that are not learned and this seems to be a theme of other suggests as well the second thing is that mitzvos there's an indian based on ish and many other macaris there's an indian of mitzvos that one cannot do today either because the best amigdas such as carbanas or other mitres that don't come by house one behind the mitzvah by learning them the third is that all of tyra relates to each other and learning egg la roofa could help in adus and in all other sugars so it's not just that egg roof is just egg larufa it can help mama she called tarakula azra khan kanewski definitely demonstrates quite well in this state okay beautiful okay so this is this of what is writing why he writes the station okay so now you take center into the safer itself we're opening the pages right so so like this uh as i i when i began the first and the first one of the series i said like this that i um uh my hara is that rochan kenowski was influenced by different people such as hassanesh now as i said already he's here he's quoting you a concept from him which he quotes in many of his forum and he mentions already in the dumbo that he spoke a lot with his father the uh many and he says i also spoke louder has an ish and he brings you a lot of material from these people but looking deeper into this and also obviously there could be ties to the growth also with this usually which eventually may be elaborated on a different time but like this i'm looking at this safer and i see a safer i start learning through the situation and and as i said it barely has any has any material so someone says how do you create material so i i started thinking about this and all of a sudden it hit me that as i'm learning the safer i i see that there are influences i would say strong influences on the hebrew the the famous yeshiva classic work not only in the shiva world but in the world at large the minhas and so first i would like to give some background as i've done in the past a little bit about what was the strengths of the min um has many strengths and obviously we cannot discuss all aspects of it today but and that was weird a sort of a model the the rochan kenneth can use that safer for a model in creating this safer nakalisa with keeping in mind is his points in the introduction so the minh is born in the early 1800s he dies in 1874 and he's a rav in a hush of a city and from what we know about him he doesn't really he's not really so active as a rav what what that means is we don't have too many chuvas of his he doesn't answer so many shilas even though he's a big city he has a few tamid and he's sitting and learning okay and as i said not so much written in his lifetime printed of his uh he's not involved with us he doesn't really get involved with controversies and then um what happens in 1869 amish a few years before he dies a work comes out called and it doesn't even say his name on it which is fascinating because it ends up being that the safer which we could which creates i guess you could say in the yeshiva world and the world that when i'm in the yeshiva world over here i'm not specifically but it also includes the literature world but it means the world literally everywhere if this safer took the world whether it's inspired him everyone was just blown away by this work and he say prince is safer it's 1869. he doesn't even have it doesn't even have his name on it so he's not even getting any cover for it okay um who prints it of a talmud is also a great guy in a dying removing rappaport also a fascinating person but not the time and place to talk about him now why does he print to say for so interestingly enough we again without getting into barricas well some various interesting theories but it seems that he wasn't even so into this uber himself and it seems that his real material that he had another sim um was stolen at the time around and and it says he worked so it's not so this stuff also shouldn't get um it was recommended for him to print this he goes ahead princess safer i remember once seeing it could be it says it in in somewhere in dakota but i remember once he looked at it as a small little conscious that he has on the safer i think i heard once that these um he he's a brother-in-law and one of his marriages with rakhine sanzer and um i think i heard another or read somewhere at one point that they asked him um after his stuff was stolen and um so they said to him there's anything left he says yeah i have a small little the world at large at the time was mcqueen and that the safer became a bestseller but i don't know if it has anything to do with that particular thing it just took off because it was it was something beyond unique and everyone picked up on this um and what we have over here is it wasn't even a famous person no he was a rob of the city but he didn't even even though he was a rover of a city he didn't even write his name okay um interestingly for example the duke safran writes in his harassing um that he's talking about the safe he says from he says it's called the min so he saw it already in manuscript i guess at that time when he saw it or knew about it it was um it was um he knew that who the author was but it's not clear if people if everyone knew who the author was later on okay now daddaris in his incredible autobiography writes at one point right when it came out he got a copy of it and later on he he decided at one point he was sitting and he just had the save from he wrote a lot of which was a manuscript for years barak hashem in our generation about 10 years ago or some or so the safer came out incredible work on the generoso but he says interestingly enough it's a shame i could have also written a safer with even more bacchias but but he says and he was not saying to this he was saying about himself whereas where funny is didn't even look at the safer as being his main thing imagine what we really lost and what he stolen southern or whatever the reasons behind the stone some um um whatever happened but okay we were so he was like someone describes at that time when the safer came to valajian it was schmuckler um describes how everyone was running to see it everyone was talking about it it was it was a safer to see a safe to look at okay in recent years um one other point that the shiva belt they like to say was it was always constantly on rakhim's table and uh makayam was into it he quoted it i think he quotes it even in rokha mala rambam and he come out never quotes i once made a joke that i want i want to write an article about all the different swarms on our times table because it might have been a very big table but that's a cynical um comment about it because this safer was not this safer they definitely deserve to be on the table just to clarify now you mean brisker correct okay because it would be forever forever as we'll see even as we'll see we already i already mentioned a little bit but i mean yeah salvation yes correct sorry it's not being clear anyway so the the so get the milk is this safer that causes a mapeka in the world at large everyone's talking about it um it's updated a a shortly afterwards with different with different harassers okay anyway um so this safer has one cute thing about the safer is that it had a lot of russia tavis this russia tavis made it for some people very hard to decipher the words what are you saying the way they say it is because there's a limited funding in those days it's it's not only this safer but in others foreign to save money but i've heard of numerous times from different um old time uh rabbayum or or abunim from way way back i said the part of the goddess was not if you could understand manchester united that was maybe even easier it was if you could understand the russia tavis of the comes along in our generation and one of the most incredible works that they ever did that they got their crazy fame from it i would even say is they decided to open up all the russia tavis make a beautiful edition of completely user-friendly edition of minnesota and since then it sold thousands and thousands of copies all over the world when i was a bakker this was the famous bar mitzvah present i have no idea if people give it today even but everyone has it everyone learns it and for sure by the fact that even though the midfield was printed numerous times until muhammad came around and we have hundreds of different that wrote and they were collected in different environment there was even but but the point is that uh did something incredible with what they did it may sound ignorant with this question was the hat that had been written on the self because it seems like most of it is not even related oh so that is a it's actually not omron system question it's an excellent question i'm going to touch on it for a second in my any minute but but um but it's not amaranth is the good question at all now kind of steven also was very intimate um there's there's a there's an edition of it that was printed with his artist it seems he was planning on writing a whole safer on it even um but it never it never happened for whatever reasons um the kitser so there's many additions of the safer as i said and i i even though i would normally not do such a thing but just this happened literally less than 24 hours ago a good friend of mine um was who's a actually a descendant of the father for more than 10 years were learning the safer memphis and they had an idea which was up till now was available for the people that read hebrew well so to bring it to the english audience and they did a they they um a few years ago they put out a small work on miele this is the hudners i don't i don't have copies it's only available in america so i can't show copies but literally less than 24 hours copies arrived in america um this is rabbi maisha hubner and his father they worked on this work and it's in english um for pesach specifically they did some of the mitsubishi pesos a few hundred pages from some sample pages that i've seen it looks beautiful and what the significance is it's now available for english audience they didn't just and they didn't just translate they give you the whole background as i'm about to say well one will be able to understand a little bit what they're trying to do the point is the safer is something unique so now now that i said it's unique i've been giving i'm daring about what's unique but what's unique about it and what does it have to do with khan kane correct this is this is a very valid question so one last source about this and and is this follows salvation if you're sure about salvation from yeshiva university in a famous um essay slash book eventually called man he said he talks about various so he talks about the success of the halachic work published in 1869 and reprinted many times he says is in large measure owing to the fact that the author did not limit himself to discussing family and civil law the new national ezekiel issues but concerned himself with all the commandments of the torah on the contrary the author only touched briefly on matters of civil law but he discussed that when those laws that were operative only when the temple was still standing i mean to say what helped him was that he wasn't only working with national music and he took he took the um he wrote a hebrew which is a guy called taraku so he asked what it's called what does that have to do with anything so the answer is that there's an earlier work a reason called the which deserves its own series of conversations about but the finner was incredible work we don't know as much as the light of ink has been spilled to figure out who the author is we do there's no there's no agreement at the end of the day who wrote the work but it's an incredible incredible work he collects the six 613 mixes going with the rambam sometimes sometimes not bringing you many different things about him and so he breaks it down into shiroshim tamim um sometimes you can have a page about him and so sometimes you have a few pages in the mitzvah and a lot of times they'll throw you in the gamoras um and is sometimes they'll have a kiddush but not as well known um there's a lot of in here and it's an incredible incredible work and so he attached to this a safer where he had a safer that's on the safe arm that's on the tar yag mitzvahs and he wrote a hebrew on it now how much is he mapharish and is that his concern it seems again this requires a lot of eun it seems that it's not so much dependent and he's not calling it even that he's writing a perish on the but he he wanted to attach it to the and it could be there'll be a drop of explanation why it works out um shortly but bottom line is that he took this which is on the mitzvos and he wrote this massive work today in the mahony shallam edition because now as i said they opened up the architectures and they broke paragraphs and they made it much more user-friendly than original it's three massive volumes they're actually working on a set that has seven eight volumes already or something like that which is horus and harvest of all the different raid and horus of the delam on the minnesota now to get to the point over here sorry on a tangent on a tangent on a tangent what does it have to do with the answer is like this when you learn as i said there's virtually almost nothing there's two black without isis interesting who is one of the first people that sort of makes an asic from egg la roofa is he takes this mitzvah and he turns it and he has 25 different issues in his mini type style as rosalichik said he does this to many other myths but not not only he doesn't limit himself just to the taglibe he has 25 beautiful pieces relate i only know 25 because i could just easily open up my horizon can i see this and basically he's myrik and his protein even marshall fisher perla who's also legendary being isaac and mittvis and having a ricoh sniffle on different suggests by him is very small so you have the both the min official pearl also quoted and more interesting um these are the two i would say the two people that have some material like a roofer besides comes along with kankanyevsky and he goes and he literally learns everything he tracks down everything and he mamish he takes every single product of of the sugi of eglarou for that past week and he he breaks it down breaks it down more and more and more and this is something one of the first that does such a thing i said he did 25 um issues so congratulations he takes that and does this into hundreds and hundreds so the difference is did this for all tired mittens or hangings he only did it on one minute i as a matter of fact i've been trying to think of another example of someone who took such an obscure mitzvah and turned it into this you say there are especially today legendary on every topic under the sun there's there's not one safer there's already whole shelves of things but a lot of times at least it has a sugar to start with so here i agree egg roofa is a gemara but still when you tell someone you pull it off a safer on eglarufa it sounds like how does one even do that and yes what would be one of the first addresses has 25 pieces so here kind of so kind of goes i'll put it similar ideas with the with the manuka what makes what's what makes america so unique what what turned it into being this incredible safe so again i'm not attempting to touch on this and i'm sure so many different people have different valid points about it interestingly enough recently a full doctorate turned into a book was written on the moon by a lady from lady inaudible very very useful material and and um here just to show a picture sometimes people don't um like to see a picture how the book looks here and this book deals with a lot of the aspects of the alumnus of the moon and breaking it down she deals with about she talks about also we also have to mention russ leslinger is safe around the uh all right rep schlesinger i always i'm always upset i wish that they could finish it it's just one incredible incredible work on the few minutes that he did i i still remember my great simcha when i found it in some store i thought you couldn't even get it i found it a bunch of years ago and i always feel bad that it's not finished but and there's so much on manhattan that's not that that as i said you could speak about it for hours and i'm sure people um have a lot to say about it but one nakuda is and this really is that also he breaks down a mitzvah and takes a sugar and he's he's breaking it down into so many different aspects and asking so many different questions to to that sometimes questions that you might have and he will be one of the only addresses that talk about it because he took it as a mitzvah and then to mamish like legendary and in llama test malachis he has a huge contrast which is also a small little thing in his eyes but in the yeshiva world when you learn limited locus it's the starting point of many different kiras different shylus his way of breaking down these khakiras and he wasn't had this is pretty pretty he's nothing to do with rakai the alumnus in there people love it it's so enjoyable it's written very smack and he brings rice and kalachaya he'll bring away from a gemara different places and then what's also famous and i think this in order to illustrate a lot of times his his hakiras and his different questions he used the whole new literature he used andreanis and the other hats stream and all these different things and became even famous the milk creator scout which great god called it a whole new family of people that we talk about and it wasn't because he just was trying to fill a paper it was because the best way to illustrate alumnus is when you give an african menace and you show gamara but then you show what will be how to illustrate a certain enough community because someone's gonna be very fine the differences they don't understand it so if you use um examples then then it could bring out a lot of times the great machis that's really happening in front of your face and you don't see it between various we shining more or more so the miracle of did this on a very large scale comes over han kanievsky and he and he he basically took the idea of the milk skinner for call for tarjak mitsus and he said i'm going to do it for one minutes for eglar roofa and he's hot agave he handles with dozens of pieces start with minkasunos and he just runs with it and and when you start looking at it you you your mind could spin i'm just going to give one example because when i looked at this i first couldn't understand what was going on i'm like what's happening over here so at one point he has a conscious and this contrast it's he's talking about um um if who could be an aide somehow it comes and says he saw the person getting killed whatever it's okay so he begins he says and then and he has a few lines where he talks about various aspects of aids which is complicated areas in in chats and then he says like this so he goes and he and he has the next 20 um on a second or something like 30 pages where he has this broken down to in 81 scenarios of different ways of atheists that could be accepted kashar negakusha kasha negotiated base chair and he uh when you look at this and he has for each one of some is a paragraph something there's a page with the relevance you're you're looking at this how he basically put in areas of adas stopping it into here but thinking about it like breaking down like milk type thing but to an extent like no one ever imagined to be able to do okay anyway but when you go back to the um when you open up the shower of the safer after that so he breaks it down into 17 parts and when is the denying the dining how do you measure it lazy ear and every single one you look at this the taikon young is a very mephoretic attacking you're like holy cow how does someone take a topic and just break it down into more parts and more parts it's incredible i'm sure if it's not done yet on some store maybe you know someone's going to go through this forum and just like make some kind of mafta like they have under ghost moisture and like admission all the different types of subjects that are discussed in nachos and you have them talking about aedos and you haven't talked about brachas like you mentioned before right so so so first of all kaikanewski realized that it needs a mafia and someone went ahead in his lifetime and frankness was very appreciative and he made some type of mustang however i believe that especially um um today with rahan kanetsky from then until today probably someone's going to come up and make a more fancier um son and make it more use it needs to be even more user it's not user friendly enough um you really have to learn the the russia tavis are also issues sometimes but but he literally i mean he br he creates whole topics new areas and you see this from what i'm saying with the dhamma he he literally one of the coolest i brought down in akdama where he literally takes color he plugs it back in the outman and and that to me is is what's mind-boggling when you're learning it i didn't i did not learn the whole thing i went through uh various parts and you're just looking at it and you're like how does it get to you it's it's unbelievable now just doing messiah a few last parts over here if the time is late basically as i said he just brings down everyone so one person that i found interesting and a lot of times you when you go through a safer you could see um different things that people claim are not so it's not so positive or they're not so true now his general mahala in learning that comes out from this safer i hope to deal with more when i deal with hashem so i'm not trying to talk about everything right now uh regulators although i'm not trying to do called terracula into his nakholaesan but literally let's say uh looking around at one point so there's a dvaravaram that has a few surmonim on the suggested vaguely roofer brings down every single piece from it in the relevant places and he handles them la marshall interestingly enough so everyone is famous for writing also a word called which which he concerned himself with areas of halacha that are that today some of it actually relevant because iran but when he was writing israel wasn't so relevant but it is wrong what about so you live and learn it doesn't come up because not really but put into his butt egg many he has many samara at the end he talks about all the time dozens of times he's bringing down not america but that's beyond the point the point is that was important enough for him and as i said was also one of these people besides and besides um let's say the devil of ram a real official perla that they wrote um things about eglarufa but when you look at the safer mine okay anyway um i already mentioned today we got questions about it so his relationship with roosevelt margolis here it's not such a commonly found um thing but even looking at the furious there's millions of pictures of of a pinecasting being sent and posted in different places you could see in there in some of the pictures in his library his well used copies of our goals you can see them clearly in these these pictures anyway point is he takes every safer and he went through and i have no idea how how many sperm he opened up but it's clear he opened up hundreds and hundreds of swarms farm and somehow he put them in the right he it's organized it's in the right place and and part of it's not just like he collected material like an encyclopedia here's this and this he deals with everything he processes information he's making tons of hashbrowns now we last time already in the previous time in the previous time before that also he said that he has this incredible yada he's using that here also somehow and he's using um i said targum and sukkam and tanakh that you think have more relevance somehow to target them over here could come up and to be relevant you shall be over here at a sept over there everything becomes relevant also again back to that dhamma where he says she opened up everything whatever he was able to get access which is very interesting i don't know where he had access to all this farm i i was i'm i was always a very big fan the pride of joseph unbelievable but it's an encyclopedia he quotes it a bunch of times he sat and opened up everything and and when one um when one sees this safer you're you're exposed and it's it's available in hebrew books and i feel it's very kadai even if someone can't learn the secrets of like la roofa and everything what they should do is they should even learn the small keyboard of his umbraca spend a half hour an hour just to see because people are always like how do you put in words or crankiness just open up the safer you open up and i you know i'll make it even easier let me tell you what page numbers so you so you don't have less less one will have less of an excuse um hold on it starts if you open it up on page i and above and onward about 20 pages you open up the safer read it just even read a few pages and you could start seeing how he's taking organizing masses of amount of information and handling with them discussing with them this safer has is packed with london's conversations that as i said with the hasanesh and the stypler here we see um now you're saying about brachas so right before pesach now we're about to embark on the yanta with so many different breakfasts the little i say there how many broccoli i'm assuming i would take a look i'm sure a lot of your brokers are discussing yeah def no definitely definitely and it comes up every day broadcasters are very negative thing but it's just interesting to see because i missed this one could see one could see it um a lot of times you know you hear a husband and they say about a person oh he's a guy and he knows something okay let me read something to see it and when you see it your understanding this is written before the computer is that he had to pull off the shelf hundreds of farm processed information it's it's machining and and as i said why he chose this and what influenced him i believe it had something to do with him oh besides all the other influences on him okay that's a wrap about him that's all for that's working today a wrap a wrap for today okay thank you very much although we mentioned we want to do other smart and we're gonna have to get back to those thank you very much rabbi broth and uh we look forward to some more so this i think is excellent before pesach like you mentioned um there's so much there's so much to take out and process and what a beautiful digression into the so thank you very much