Rabbi Dr. Brodt On The Mesechta: Shas Kotton- Kesuvos Throughout the Ages

[Music] shalom aleichem and welcome back rabbi dr eliezer broth so we completed one season on the swarm of rahayan ten episodes hashem season two will be coming back shortly but we are back to focusing on the lumisector we just began the numester in the daffodil cycle and rabbi dr liazer brought would like to share with us some of his incredible insights about the sparring on this massage however before we begin i would like to mention a sponsor who's sponsoring this episode he asked to remain an animus i would like to read the following message that he sent us he says he is donating this sheer sponsoring the shirt in honor of rabbi dr elizabeth he says rabbi dr brought all the sessions are fantastic it provides a great deal of coverage and enhances one's limu rather by providing insight and history about mahabraim and swarm his sessions on the safari member of konyaski zatzal in particular are one of the best ways to honor the memory of this great and unique guzzle i had the opportunity to correspond with rabbi dr brought in the past and i'm appreciative of that despite his busy schedule he's giving up his time and quick to respond please continue with these sessions so i want to mention actually probably has that people have reached out you know we didn't do for a couple of weeks didn't post anything they wanted to know what's going on where are they i did tell them that it takes you an enormous amount of time to prepare these shirim these lectures and if anybody wants to reach out and sponsor perhaps the opportunity to do some more of them do them more often so if you want to reach out to either myself swayedm ou.org or eliazerbrot gmail.com it's something we are certainly open to considering and just one more message that we just got and the person sent to us and says hi tim oldaf thank you for putting the series at the center of your app i watched the first episode and immediately follow with another three episodes it's like pringles once you pop you can't stop okay rabbi dr eliezer brought so what do you have in store for us today um one thing i know we discussed before we got on air is that there's a lot of advertising about myself as tubis about shots cotton we haven't learned shasta or the matapuni to complete shots learn cubase you have shas kotlin xubus so i asked you is that something which has any source anywhere it's just something cute that was made up right okay so begin like this i'll i'll say um as a joke sort of i'll say as a joke that messages when people learn it so it's learned in yeshiva all over as well as also and was always learned but even though it was learned many times the parts that people get up to has nothing to do with suva they don't even know what the word suva has to do with subs now why is that because is this is a it's literally shaskatan what does that mean it means is as you start learning daffy me is already in the beginning it goes all literally there's soogies that relate to kala tarakula or could be found in this massacre now so where does this thing come from shots caught on how early how far back can we trace it so it's not so clear how far back it goes i do not have to answer how far back it goes but i could show some earlier sources for it number one is that a lot of times it's always interesting to see is that of adam goddel that left behind it's printed very a lot of times it's fascinating information one such known israel horowitz and rafshaft horowitz he is the son of the shla so he wrote it it's printed it's called yesh naglan it's first printed in i think 1701 there he talks about is giving his he's listing out which massachusetts children should learn he says make sure to learn he says and therefore you should learn it he has a lot of other interesting things and and ideas of what one should learn it's good to look at this and the kid already brings this down in his beard and over there brings down another tava of her where he also has interesting things in his he does not talk about learning service as far as i recall however um this is an early source 1701. now what does one do when one wants to find out what the early sources are so one source one method is always use google but um if one doesn't want to go before the times of google there were different ideas safer that had incredible yada and they would write articles over the years of their information that they discovered one such yid was his name was a lot of his material has been recently he died a few years ago and his daughter has been working very hard to make his stuff available it's on a lot of materials on the internet and she has put out so far ever since he died six volumes called mamaritovia volume four of my marituvia they put out they printed two or three articles that he wrote about this topic and he traces different sources for the where does this thing come from so he shows um originally he had a few different swarm which will uh list them in a second that they that the shire when they're talking about this after this they emphasize that this is a chance the earliest store so far that he found was a letter printed in 1699 where someone writes tour of dublin oppenheim famous goggle who's we've mentioned them in the past he also was a tremendous farm collector so some yid the son of the shire frying was writing from eretz israel to dub it up and i'm sending you matana the rambans khadushim a manuscript of it which is shaskatan this letter was dated we have it it's printed in 1699 so this is probably the earliest so far it sounds like from this that it that it was already known that that's how it was called but this is the earliest instance that he found he shows and this was all done before i saw him before google before hebrew books he shows that this was found in say for uh written in 1714 on suvis the mahabharata writes such a lotion in the shah of the in kobetus when it was printed on suvis and there are on the ritua well this farm these are farm printed in the 1720s through the 1730s the shaaram the the printers emphasized this makuta so it seems there was a known thing to emphasize now the most before most famous i would say um source is that flaw because that flow is the basically the go-to safer on massachusetts and he writes in his dhamma when he talks about it he says he's learning and he says so therefore he decided to print his first hebrew that he was going to write publish i guess or write was on sufis and then he ends up going continuing with kadushi now he's when he says we shine him it doesn't necessarily mean we shine him in the timeless it could be it is i i don't know um it has not been located if it's in china yet but as i said already in the 100 um his safer is printed at the end of the 1700s the exact date of his safer will get to but i believe it was 17 oh sorry it was 1787. but already as i said 1699 we have a source and then we have in the tava where the sun with the son of the is stressing such a thing okay now just as ara and to conclude this when one learns you have to know shaas that's actually um a very important point when you learn when you learn the you insert the messages you could get away without having to have your dias and other masektos when one learns that and you don't have your dears in chat you're looking at these acronyms you don't understand them even so i would say uh um a cute nakuda in the shasta is that you have it's cut them amish and you have to be learning shots cut and you have to be aware of of shas et cetera okay but this is just this time um a platform find one last nakuda is that the elektsav um the hungarian rav who died in the holocaust the beautiful safer he writes a school of shidduchim is to learn okay people always like um so we have to throw that in okay okay one more time the ella faksav maybe you will share with us where that is and where we can find that because yeah people likes to google it's in volume one of the alex have i believe it's on page curfew especially coming from azad litvak like you who's a proud proud person but uh i guess you found that type of safer you can mention it um i know we've discussed in the past learning different mistakes i know was relevant for availables and things like that is there any discussion about the sectors being learned by younger boys and on youvamis it came up i'm sure this is a classic isla are there any sources that discuss this and it's relevant in subus as well so the answer is yes i found interestingly enough someone in a um i think he lives in flatbush his name is the sacha hoffman he put out a chuva safer called chuni this is how it looks and he has a whole beautiful simmon where he collects a lot of information simon you dollared about learning and yeshiva and he traces various sources about it and just to mention he points out that there there are some resources that they where it seems they were nervous to learn certain suggestions and certain therefore they didn't even learn certain massachusetts at the younger ages and also he brings smart democrats that also sware the issue with some smart issues did not learn um parts of vesuvius they would start from da first which is taurus and armored just to keep it away from the boys now one thing that will become obvious throughout this whole um presentation today is that suvis was learned from beginning to end in yeshivas from the times of the russian and through that we don't really see such a emphasis of not to learn it um just to mention for example in 1533 we have a description from sensino when he talks about the shasim that this farm that he printed he says he printed 23 massachusetts of gamaras that were learnt in yeshivas okay now in yeshivas in those days it usually was people not married oh um another safer that we're going to discuss briefly soon the printer writes why is he printing on suvis because it has all different things shafts cotton which we've already just mentioned the gam yada called loindim af milande tinucus of barbae raf everyone learns it so it doesn't and this is a safer print in the 1860s it doesn't sound like such there was such a fear of learning uh mr stevens even with young kids not another source could be found in a um in the um 1630s from a double leader he wanted to go princess safer and he wasn't able to print the safer because the printers were very occupied printing others farm what were they printing they were printing the contracim amazus what's the contrast in the sequel so without getting involved the contrast refers to in the olden days way way back in the 1630s at least they used to learn all over europe the same sector each all in all the different yeshivas and in the beginning of each man at the year rid there was a fear and the deadline would pick which and then the publishers based on that would publish um gomorrah's so it should be available for all the talmidhim so these are prince can trace them so like sort of like paperbacks so it would be less expensive it was pretty expensive in those days and so this is a fascinating topic which is elaborates matt so he talks about this double either one to go prince which is similar today sometimes people go prince farm want to go print the safer during the busy season so he went into busy season he couldn't it was held up why because it can trace him he says it was super so we see subus was being learned all over europe on a mass scale and there could be many other proofs this just to be assigned this nakuda i would mention that i quote in the past that there's a majority and the native basically says that if it's a torah we're supposed to learn it and we're supposed to discuss it with the tao medium we're not supposed to be he was talking specifically about inanimate ziva of the kerry even though these things trigger the makshava than it says you're supposed to learn it and that's why the terror goes out of its way to talk about it byrihos and he's supposed to give it over arrive to the talmud and there's nothing to worry about because we're talking about other sources that inaudible it's torah there's nothing to to not there's nothing to be scared about and one could learn it even if it's with bakram it's interesting is that i was looking about if we have the netsif on um on suvis and we we literally i don't have it's a mystery to me we have let's say three four pages but i know that he that learned but i found it very interesting that there's only a few pages um in his hebrew which is some of the shiram that they publish of this anyway i can't these are some of the uh more zeitgeist relating to the massachusetts okay let's get let us get down to the meat and potatoes okay so what do you want to begin okay so i'm going to just mention briefly when we talk about the nusselt of the gemara so i always mention so in in a lot in certain saddaram of shasta we have the safe room but he um maybe one day we'll talk about in more barricades but he nasham he he died before working on ashim nashum was a project that was worked on for many many years i believe it's completed now by mahontai israeli and in here you could buy two three volumes of all the of them of the septum supers which is based on all the manuscripts to show all the different manuscripts your studies of the massachusetts some people like it when you use your article gemara a lot of times when they're when they're referring to a shiny nusselt when they mention in harara or isbahada i think it also does their this is what they're using um they're not necessarily going back to check up all the different manuscripts today there are more um there are other methods but that's not for now just to mention in the um just out of some as i always like to point out just recently literally um i think it actually came out today available for purchase there's a great um expert on the world experience his name is professor ahmeel brodie known as robert brody he wrote he's the expert on gainer and he worked for many many years amazon a running parish of his just came out on the homosexual he has also written some other books about massachusetts which deals with a lot of different interesting questions that some people like to know about but i'm just to throw it out there okay but now moving on right away to the um to the meat and potatoes as you called it i think this professor robert brody actually was interviewed by mahi weinstein on his farm chatter podcast he was yes he was about even yeah okay so now um we all first we always talk about rashi so rashi umas as far as i know is no one ever questioned it's rashi but there's something interesting we have the shittune competitors and the shipping rats is always quotes rashi madura kama throughout this massacre so people want to know what is it is it now if the discussion about rashi and the various maduros is a big discussion we're not going to go into right now but um professor yakuza put out many years ago a whole study showing that the the uh proving based on manuscripts also that the the parish that what the um is called parish rashi madurakama is really the rivan who is that the son-in-law of whatever is great tell me them and he print he published it and not only that just to show that that this um i have seen some people say that if the ingredients cause they're rashing i'll do a camera how could this episode say this but anyway without getting into that a very from from privates that came out in the um i think was 1999 the first time and it came out ever since then many times called oyolavram i'll mention it more shortly so they printed and they give them credit um that that the rivan they got from this yacht of the epstein and one could access it easily this oil of ram is on um and it's very important to have already someone from the basement shirashi this is supposed to be a lot of production one could find and some of this material was never printed before and this epstein had discovered in a manuscript okay that is with rashi what about isis so tysons normally were able to go through very very br very quickly this tysus everyone knows certain sexist hepatitis rash certain symptoms from sexist even advertisers shine some success parrots okay so first of all it has numerous baliotis now what's that significant we already mentioned it's just cotton so everything every exercise every extra right like if you learn a tissue and you open up a tightest chance your head spins already because of the amount of material how many gamers are being thrown at you if one wants to entice this properly only our generation was they had to have with all these new discoveries to with all the different texts that there are it's mind-boggling there's a texas rush okay yeah there's a taxi 311 that was printed in 1954. there's a fellow on gabe which i'll talk about in a minute he put advertises garnish and there's more um about isis one he print this aaron gabba who's written a lot i've quote him in other uh such presentations and satisfies published numerous manuscripts relating to the ballet isis and he has a whole beautiful article which is available i could send it out free um in pdf if someone asks at least about gmail.com and you should say no volume 10 where it goes through literally all the tices that are available he discusses what the kiddish of each one is what's so significant even at the end of the piece it gives a sample what's the khashevas of having so many things just to make your head spin is not it's not a good enough reason which shows unbelievable in helping one understand isis well and just to be messiah in this prat is a reason until recently if someone wanted to know about any question that they had about isis they would pull out safer even from people would pull out some admitted it some didn't from ephraim or bach called biliotis printed in at least eight editions and this was the classic work for the past bunch of years on the ballet in recent years based on new materials that we're able to that we have so this fellow aaron gabay another fellow ariel arnov another person ari leibowitz have done incredible work in getting us further with understanding isis discovering new manuscripts and and in depth one receptor that one could see this if you wanna if you want your head to spin it's just not just to learn the tysons it's open up this as a garden piece take this piece from gabay track down some of the stuff is online and you can see what's going on out there with isis and you'll have a great time okay that's with tysus okay now we go on to reshaying them so we're showing them i'm going to break it down in two ways i'm going to talk about is first the development of the printing and we're shining we did not have um contrary to what people people don't realize we didn't i think i already emphasized this a few times the different presentations we showed them were not so accessible we didn't have it in the 1700s is the first time pretty much we showed him really become available on any level starting with in 1722 a raw comes available was in the library of shmuel oppenheim this was the um the rich uncle over david oppenheim who he's discussed in the past with a crazy farm library and he also it seemed to have some rare manuscripts and this is printed from his library the ritz was printed in 1729 um this is from the mashbach it seems the schla had this in manuscript and used it in a shirum even then you have the sheet from quebeces it's first printed in 1738 this alone was a monumental discovery and helped um for the from 1738 and onwards because the sheeting bets that anyone's familiar with is a collection of many of the reshinum and that's how people if you had a in combat this until recent years even and you learned super fishing that's you're pretty good because he had in there the ram the rambandar to the rajba and many other pieces of reshape okay the mice of the ramban is printed the first time in 1765. for some reason we're not sure how this happened but right away it gets reprinted under the name the rajba and different people realize that it's on the state it's not the rajba it's the it's the ramban such as the radal he writes a lotion anyone um when he quotes a certain piece anyone who's he says anyone's familiar with haraga the lesson around you'll understand right away this is the ramban he says if you look in the shinjuku message you'll see whatever he brings from the ramban is in this is in this work called the rajma so somehow right after it was printed in 1765 it was printed a few more times it got it got misattributed it's not the only time that something from the ram ramban roger gets mixed around okay anyway we'll return to the shortly okay ad khan these were the four we shine them but i um um that were out there but they only come to light in the 1700s pretty much okay now okay now we could go further um the next step which is is just this so much um i'm just going to list a few different things and when they were available and and then we'll move on number one there was the ranch i said in 1610 right when he dies and that's one of the early chronium that one could find on the massachusetts okay one another early saver delia rabba delhi rabbit dies in 1712 and he wrote a hebron souvenirs and some other masceftus but it's printed by his grandson in the seventh in 1768. now el yorava everyone knows everyone's familiar when you learn halacha he's extremely important and the list is endless i have a friend or tsviller he wrote a whole art a beautiful article all about dahlia rapper it's printed yeshua volume 35 and one could see how he was so um how the island was very max of him throughout the divers he was a russia shiva at the time he was a talmud mover grader of the magana vram he had a beautiful swarm library and is allowed to talk about him but enough now he has a hebrew on a nice amount of of service it's available on hebrew books another hebrew that comes out 1714 is it from a kivalaran it's called as i mentioned he also says he mentions that he's writing about chance cut them okay now obviously um there are other acharyan i can't trace every single safer that's out there but i'm just going to list a few but the i would say one the big turning point in the islam of of achrainen that had an impact till our generation is the play yeshua the players is the pane yeshua is 1739 and later on he puts out a surface of a conscious action so the previous few that you mentioned aren't ones that are probably familiar to many of the people who went through the yeshiva system what type of sparring are they and why you pick out those specifically so i even do i'm going to list even a few more i cannot never i i was in yeshiva i learned at least three times in yeshiva sewas and i'm going to to be honest i do not think any most of the criteria i'm about to list i don't think i ever heard them quoted i don't even know most of them i don't think they're around this is pre-hebrew books days or it's so they were they were never used um why is a good question it it actually would have to do with what the mahalo khalima as the changed and um and it seems that what we what we appreciate more which i'm not going to get into is a whole new mahalakali mood which shifted towards i guess in the 1880s and onwards and then until the yeshiva world before world war ii and then after world war ii and this was a shift from moving away from many of these types of so much so that today i think a lot of people from if you have if you shiva if you bring these in they would they wouldn't be able to understand it because they're not even familiar a lot with the terminology and the types of questions that they're asking um but it's actually uh um a question to nager for all these actors to see the progress of the chronium and what changed what caused it to change it's it's a it's a rehearsal but we will not we'll have mercy today maybe it could be its own episode or two sourcing and seeing how the limu has formed that were used in the yeshivas throughout the ages that'd be a very interesting topic correct it's definitely a very interesting topic i i yeah definitely interesting though anyway but but what i would say is and i'm going to return to this listing some more in the taco are not heard of but first i'm going a little chronologically is the play yeshua in 1739 that actually does have impact till today which it's his own schmooze also needs to be discussed about richos but the kitser one thing that we find out is that i mentioned earlier the ritz was printed from manuscript in 1729 the pressure is aware of the ritual and and he uses it a lot now this gets involved with the the kiddush of the issue why why actually relating to your question why it remain that he's the safer that's still on the table so to speak at least in some places this gets into um interesting material of israel tashma and recently a beautiful work which was printed in the kaitsukitsuge that comes out from lakewood um um on the play show from a fellow yushua mayerson he wrote it as a masters but it's printed in this private hitsuki byrom yes in lakewood there's obviously some report to the on a different episode there's a lot happening today that's not happening in um that hasn't happened that didn't use it would not have happened in previous years anyway so this safer does remain i would say um um accepted but if we go on there's a there's a say for khadushi rashbots and the reason why it's called it's not of the region it's printed in i think 1779 from simcha boone rap report in an additional recent reprint of it there's a there's a very useful article from witsa lambda about it i believe that's on hebrew books um okay now there's a safer that comes out in 1788 from rabinyam lieftenstadt so this safer i found the drop interesting i'll just talk about it for literally a minute so this safer what significant amount safer he's a talmud movement by none other than the ladybug first in the shower of the safer he thanks his shiver for making available to him a lot of for spending money and making available for him hard to get swarm i found that interesting he also thinks on the shower of the safer his wife fredel okay so this is a question i've been asked recently um a few times and i uh people asked when did when do much abram thank their wives publicly with the name and he now i did not trace it at all i just was asked about it to um but here is a source where the muhammad in the shah it's not only in the dhamma buried at the end you'll say no reason here he puts it in the shower okay and he just saw this recently now he has a beautiful ass cover from the be huddle he says that i know that he was zaika to learn and he knows this masaka very well and then he writes out his abdomen um that he it it sounds like he was a guns fighter before he got to knowing you that he learned by the other daughter in prague and anyway he he learned this he puts adam sexual suvis what's he using the marshal the marshal muram lublin and then he says but of course the safer playing yeshua this is we see already in a short period of time the 1788 how the pressure is already mamish one of the main sparrows okay moving on there's a safer printed in 1790 who's a talmud of verbenas and shits as he emphasizes in the shower of his safer it's also a lockheed and it comes out it's also available again today i never really came i it might have actually been reprinted in the past uh 40 years but i never really saw or heard it used another say for this the mahabharata actually was famous but again his safer i would say is not also too much use yellows i have him from her are you late tomorrow he died at the age of 104 in 1831 incredible um he wrote his true receiver yehuda to what if one wants to learn about this interesting person who was a rav of bride of tremendous talmud a friend of mine benio kane wrote an article in yeshun lamet tess all about him he does not deal with this hebrew of his but he deals with the guerrilla very interesting heber and other information about him okay now there's another safer it's hadas this is the mahabharata was active he dies in 1785 his grandkids printed in 1863 much later on and here also i mentioned earlier that they referred to a batch ask copter okay and these are some of the various achronim i would say that are out there okay now but we are besides the um yeshua are there any other acharyan that become like the go-to that they are looked at on some levels answer is there are two very very important and that is the flaw a flow dies in 1805 in 1787 writes a safer it's a flaw sometimes it's called the saferexuva i believe whenever frames are my goal is reversed at all time he calls it safe suva you could see right away the tremendous symphony i think of let's say river from zalman others when it came out it was a map it was one of the moments in that goofer like it because they call him which is its own discussion but um the kits are this safer is a safer that is incredible i think it's accepted in a lot of circles to use um it has an incredible long hadamard which is kadai to read not out anyway another aspect of this safer is this there's a whole section in the back of the safer house so this is one such safer that becomes a classic area he also mentions that i mentioned that chassis another safer that becomes a classic and remains a classic till today although it's not as intense on the maser as the flood aflam mamish's tons of pieces on every block but this safers also carries you through the massachusetts not only through the few uh suggests he dies in the in 1832 his savior was printed in 1822 and alayom is also one of the most accepted that people are willing to look at now even though it's we have a different uh jargon of learning ruby kevegar is a different type of safer that's not one of these two i'm about to get up to rookie vega you almost took the words out of my mind so i discuss if these farm mentioned the peninsula i believe mike vega certainly does right yeah yeah the la fla da fla i don't remember but what's interesting is when looking through all these swarms you could see there's an intensity into the marshal which we've discussed earlier in the episode of kaian kanyevsky throughout foldisvar martial's mama's shoes the afla the best yakov even but another nuclear with the basiaco before we get to ricky feiger is that the he's also concerned about allah there's a whole the ones that they their names are still known today in the in the basement of learning they also write allah dick parts to their booram in the back which is interesting to see that they were just what it was also there was nakuda of learning okay now of course at the same time as the nasivis his good friend was rebecca vega on and today it's just endless how much material there is on the suffix service i still remember when it first came out the fancy two volumes from robert really on saturday sewers it's endless it's it's it's a pella how much material there is there's a joke one of the good ones that have been writing from his gr their graves is some safer so and when one picks up thak suvis they're wikivega you're like where did this even come from anyway so those are um three uh i would say those are the river key vega basically and afla and earlier i mentioned the issue now there's one last achievement to mention and that is the yamcha why am i mentioning in 1574. so without getting into the whole story of the writings of the of the amsterdam and if he had an impact or not on the world of halacha although he's of course the the bandara of the rama and one of the daily haddarf through the diaries but shiloh as if a swarm had an impact one of the coolest says this farm did not necessarily have such impact and why not that's a question and if it really did or didn't but messages his first time printed from manuscript only in 1862 on the first four procum here again the the printer emphasizes he throws in the shaskatan aspect he throws in rabyakivendin who gave us kama to the yamcha shrine which was printed in 1740 which is also quite a long time after the yamcha islamic dies because they said he dies in 1574. but basically rabbiakavemden also says maybe we'll be zaika to have the one in service and we see it takes over 100 years to get the manuscript on subaru's act who gives it a beautiful scammer reviews on inspector and the sheila maisha the shiny washer says again it's murdered to have the hebrew of yamcha on alcopod these are some of the famous um that are out there um and and today we have hebrew books we have and one could get them very easily for free okay now i i would like to just now okay so that that's part um now i want to make an akudo over here which i don't always do i like to do it in a chronological way that's why i'm choosing this up till now i said that you see this is the wealth of aquarium and now russia shiva svaram there's a credible welfare i'm not even bothering to think about talking about them there's dozens out there barak hashem and other people just to mention i have quote already a few times this is printed in the 1999 i think is the first time it's printed four or five times already each time it has some shine in after it first this is a hebrew called cheetah ishana who is this again this aaron gabba that i discussed he talks he has a whole theory who it is and even though this clive it's printed on most of suvis he found the manuscript of some other prakim which again is um he publishes of the shitty ishana it seems to have to um helpful for tysis again now we mentioned that the ramban is printed and then sadly it gets misattributed to the rajba what is the ra is there a rajbank service interestingly enough there is it's first discovered i believe it's in tough shallama gimbal where rehearsal prints it and later on now he prints it without too many harass recently meister cook i think was in tough shane iron weiser cook released it with haris on the whole sector so therefore if someone has the herschler edition it's night to get the moisture cooked if you like our rs anyway this is based on manuscripts so finally now in our generation we have the rajba and the rumba now the ramban i mentioned earlier this incredible work done by ezra it's of his work on the ramban on subus is available on hebrew books okay now so so far we have i'm mentioning is that we have the ramban with which is which which they did not have to even though it was printed earlier on that i mentioned was first printed and was printed a few times it was not complete it was full of mistakes only our generation resulted the first time it's being printed is in the 1970s and then and based either better edition but basically 1970s the ritzva although it's printed early on it's full full of mistakes throughout the generations again here moisture cook puts it out another region put out is iran it's first printed in 1976 but later on it's done it's redone it's not it's not clear if it's iran or but if it's someone that has to do it around again another significant region just to mention another reason robina crescus it's first printed i believe in 1983. another region is a hebrew from a talmud of the rush put out by this azervat he he has made available his work and to conclude with two more reshinim is the ah which i also mentioned was printed way back but it was done again up he manuscripts with many more pieces and to conclude with the last is nuki is at the same time we've got to put out the raw he also put it in what am i trying to bring out over here is sometimes the generation of zaika people don't even realize this some of the rich items were available they weren't so much used but our generation literally now even stuff has been discovered in the past 10 years that one has available through different you go to this farm store for some of them or it's a hakama or different search engines or marilyn has some of these texts you can learn and learn to reshine with on the on this amazing massachusetts that has not been learned before now that's with um just to throw out it's not fear we have to mention some akron that's been discovered so yes uh just to mention one besides the oil of rum that i've been cancelling quoting that they printed different shiurim and materials of that wasn't available or or from manuscript is a heber from the baal major shmuel the magistral was a talmud of the arizona so again madison is very famous he's the go-to save from the sacraments but do we have anything else from him answer is again in recent years there's been a safer of his of his rashes his he is his tairan hummish and now um she a few years ago put out i think a 40 blood or so on massachusetts so this is someone that's a talmud of he's a real talmud of da rizal so much so just to quote it this was a very important thing he talks he gave an incredible hospital on that arizona was printed first for manuscript by mordechai factor more recently he was printed again and in this manuscript you see in this drasha where he talks about arizona he refers to him as someone who was isik and mishna talmud zafra visa frey which is an incredible thing people were asking questions and all different things and he knew how to answer kingdom what's significant is it's because i mentioned what's one of the go-to swarm of which they did have three generations already from the 1730s the sheet mucobats who a very close relationship with the sheet and governs us arizona but this is its own discussion to the uh vanap okay i can't these are just some of the riches out there i'm apologizing i'm not talking about she was now just to conclude with one just some um um i guess in hebrew it's i don't know how to translate it exact unique uh whatever into english some will definitely correct me is this false one is that um the sewers talks about the suva so yes there are of course like every other area a bunch of them there's been illustrate people see it today but when did this come there's something called illustrated service so this is also a fascinating discussion there's a fellow sabar who wrote a whole doctorate about it and in jts they have a massive collection of servers that are illustrated ready for hundreds of years so they're finally putting out too massive i don't have it but they're about to put out in literally in a month i think if you pre-order it it's cheaper um a bunch of the pictures and you can learn a lot of interesting things from these pictures in these servers the whole collection is two massive fancy volumes it's supposed to come out within a month now that's one interesting thing another interesting thing is that in the kyogre museum they discovered from the family to stroll service which shows we have we're learning bavli so there's also what what was so this this the the kiva freeman wrote two massive violence called jewish marriage in palestine this is based on the chironisa it's called the suva traditions here's one volume and there's another volume of it also interesting to know about and and um to conclude with one last thing again just also because of its uniqueness is is there's a chuva that was printed in 1859 it's called chuva binyan kriya this is how it looks it's i'm pretty sure it's available on hebrew books and it says the author was from veen anyway but the reason why you'll hear why i'm mentioning in a second obviously it's a personal angle i have a good have a good friend that he was sadly nifty um his name was dr so anyway the point was is that he came across this small little hebrew this chuva and the truth deals with why um the the laning of the what let's shout out the mini this minute of the kriya sexual it's a small chuva it's about um 15 pages he bought it original of it and he was very curious he couldn't find who's this it says he's done in the city and nicholls in bialystok strange we know about the al stuck in those years he couldn't find it anyway he spent time looking and he couldn't find and then he sent eventually he said that i should go ask he was told that this yid rafi he's going to be able to solve this mystery and hitacho came up with an idea based on his idea sprecher was able to write a whole figured out more behind this and who was the real author of this keyboard it goes it was on auction even a few weeks ago and they didn't realize what this is this is not a real chuba there never was a person on the hamirov of the alastair it's written by someone else mayor ishalay and one could read this whole story this was this was um this came out a bunch of years ago on this farm blog dr specha wrote it up while he was alive and it's interesting jakarta safer related to truva we're talking about suvis march and vegan severus as they say so i had to throw it in um just to mention some weird whacked out thing to conclude with okay i can um okay so we have homework whoever knows how to say the word your cabin english please let us know if you're still listening and again any questions comments suggestions eliezer brother gmail.com again sponsorships available perhaps opportunities to talk about other topics and we're looking forward to seeing you again soon have a wonderful day