Peirushim And Seforim For Yoma With Nachi Weinstein Of The Seforim Chatter Podcast

nahi weinstein of the spartan shadow podcast interesting is that i think we live a couple miles apart from each other we've never met face to face so it's nice to see you on zoom this will also be oreo on this farm chatter podcast video on all that and we are here to share what's farmer out there and are available as we proceed to learn this how are you good hashem thank you elisha for for i guess allowing me to join you and for you to join me depending on which platform this is going to be people are hearing this on exactly so most people probably know who you are if you want to give a 30 second intro since we're keeping this brief and to the point of who you are and how you got into swarm and a little plug for the swarm chatter podcast sure so we'll try to do this as quick as possible listeners of the podcast and if anyone would like to check it out i actually just did was a one-year anniversary so on farm chatter which can be found on google podcast apple podcast whatever it it will say there um sorry there's an episode where you can listen a little bit about myself but just to give it quickly um i now i'm in law school but i'm starting to go work backwards um i was cuddled yeshivas and i was always wearing this farm and swarms was something that interests me i was gabe's farm when i was in shiva in philadelphia yeshiva and i was gabby's farm i'm in charge of a shul in lakewood actually in charge's farm and gradually a famous ux landmark on fifth street in lakewood however london my grandfather shul right that's correct and um in charge of that that answer where we have a pretty good answer i think if i'm allowed to say so in the game of dover and uh so it's always been interested in especially resharing him across him you know older all this far i'm interested in you know learnings farm the critical editions because the others etc so so that kind of thing definitely interested me and just a wide variety of safari i mean and i'll just recap for for for old uh people watching this that may not be familiar i started a twitter account where i posted all svarim and gradually evolved books etc and it i started this podcast interview program mainly with various guests across the spectrum types yeah from left to right um there's been a wide variety of gas so anyone interested we can check it out like i said it's called swarm chatter and okay so let's get straight to yuma we have swarm ranging from the roshanin tais is on the page we'll get straight down to the rates farm so why don't you begin with the bali taste this on the page okay sure now this is not just to be clear this is not meant to be critical i'm not one of my uh academic or historian guests so so this is just very quick um you know overview of the swarm and the massachusetts i believe olaf's going to be having rabbi dhakali as a rat a friend of uh of mine a friend of yours and and he will be talking about various different mushroom and more in depth and uh you know he knows this topic these topics better than i do i'm sure so you know i guess your main focus which is your expertise is what's farm are there which ones are used most which ones are available and more than i think most importantly where do you access them i think it's very important to point out also especially with that gaming learners the conversation and the point of this isn't that where you know we think that most staff learners are going to be sitting down and using all these sparring but whether somebody has the time to go through some cigarettes more be in but even if the person doesn't when they're learning them enemies after they learn when they have a connection they understand that they're just you know they're touching the tip of the iceberg but there's so much more there and who the sparrow are the mojave swarm are it gives it a gives a person a broader expanse of what they're getting involved in and a greater appreciation for the actual lumos right for sure i did this on on soccer and we figured we'll go this way so for listeners of my podcast here i figured let's try something different and absolutely not a villain definitely necessarily has the time or or or interest or whatever to pick up one of these foreign but i think it's important number one we're going to see the the the scientists against foreign speaks it out or in the art school in misifta or somewhere ever who is that who's being quoted here just so you should know basically who it is and if they're interested if someone's interested in picking up a safer just you know can you get it how much does it cost where is it available is there a new edition which edition is better i see a bunch what should i be on the lookout for that kind of thing so i think to start off um yuma is interesting for uh an interesting reason there actually aren't a lot of resharing and as i said i think uh eliezer brook's gonna be talking about that but there are a lot of bali texas um it seems like to me on the actual page anyone will open them yuma you have tysis and then you have right away um tyson shannon actually i'll try to pull out michael morrow see if it's come up on the video so on on any on any given page in the second yuma there's going to be i don't know if it's coming up there's tradition in the corner there's places so what's going on between those two right off the bat why why and that's on the homosexual why do we have two types on the page so and it's an important task it design which is quoted and used as part of a circuit very important right correct this is not just some like oh it's on the side whatever no no it's a real thing so um i got some information this is i want to give a credit where credit is due to rabbi uh doctor frank kanerfogel who i who listeners of this farm chatter podcast may be familiar and if you're not he's terrific and we did a podcast on rashi and isis um two different ones so he told me like this that the thais of the massachusetts seem to be edited from the mirami rokenberg uh romney ruthenberg obviously um lived and he was nifty at the end of the 13th century uh late 1200s so from the later ballet texas and he wrote a couple of riots that can just tweak them out quickly obviously this is like i said people you know i don't know if they know more than this or differently it says first of all that there's a very long piece on the nanda manolo on having drawing some animal figures in maximum which about faces didn't like and that's pretty much word for the truth of the murami ruthenberg said also that guys miami who was the talmud of the murami rottenberg um uh decides to perish of him which is on we have on the planet zion and um he brings a couple of other of other uh riots that he quotes as the various teachers of his rebellion and so that's a couple of rights so that that's number one so basically it's apparently a later of all tysons because he shot him on the other hand is actually a shannon sometimes you get as you shun him it's not it is a little older um he caused marvel robbie as believe uh i'm trying to i think it'll be the sir leon i think so um and he says they are they're telling them according to his name by the smug so it seems to be it was earlier so i think again we're not talking hundreds of a few hundred years difference but it seems to be it is a little older um now i will point that just i'm just getting very quick sketch of them of the two now another thing is we're and we will return to the tennis hashanah shem in our discussion of in of the classic because it's important now there also is two more ties to sin there's ties in we're going to get to rabino yakim but there's also something called tyson's riha lavon uh the white and uh i think and and and unless i'm mispronouncing that and um he was a talmud of rabbinitam from central eastern europe so rabbi cannaforgo told me that his taste is a little different style because he wasn't french like the other ballet tysons were and um he doesn't mention the names of israel so he said that his places are based on his other rebbe says the the german uh rivami shapira mishapira i guess aspire and it was different about this we're not going to go in depth you want to hear more listen to that podcast there's french polytechnic german validates this but so this was a little different it does really love when we have a little bit and then lastly um i would i would if i can get one of my swarm over here on my desk um this place is a rush laser rush was first printed by rob izarkowski from new york um printed this famous the national scholars he has there yes i want to point that out it might be interesting to people so first he has this kind of release zero finger then he has has come uh from a baron cutler then he has this comment from maisha but not sam it's it's has comma it's one it's a number of pages from my shirt moisture basically says wow it's a great thing and you see you know you should help support learning and then he goes on and i have a hara on one thing that you wrote in one of your footnotes and he goes on a whole long thing over here he has come abandoned and also from nagasakis and he also has his own you know footnotes and raid etc this was reprinted as well from uh i think it's still around and then masada of cook also issued a taizer rush and i don't know if i mentioned taizer rush was a talmud of the rama rosenberg so that's a later balticis so right off the bat even 2311 is not homosexual you have four valley tices on them which is a little bit interesting we shine them wise the the main region that really sticks out is um beno yakim now the one that's been around it was originally published by mckinsey no dummies but the one that's been around is also by vag shall it was they came like this with the real love on the back um now i don't know if it's in print anymore um however there is somebody in the new yeshurin journal that just came out there's a little piece in there and there's somebody i think we're my learner and artistral that i believe is putting out a new one i i don't know okay so you sure and we know robin elizabeth is one of the arkham so we certainly could get his opinion on this one right so so sure so what's interesting about urban new york him just from what i understand um i learned i used a lot i really enjoyed it it's like a rashi kind of safer almost he lived at the time of rashi actually and evidently it seems like um from from the reshading that he wrote on every massachusetts or most masektoshas and apparently what happened was i mean i don't know if this is some conjecture on my part but i think are called this that when when they back in the day everything was handwritten in manuscript so what you did was you wrote it down you and you copied it over so when you had rashi no one had used for some other purist of another somebody else because even if it was russian you use rashi right everyone is rashi nowadays we're all looking father we shining but that was what was then so that's mainly barometer actually he uh it's been the consensus kind of is that he likely was involved in the pierce magenta of maine's which is um the listeners may know it as um rabbina gershom on the side of the gemara which is irvana garcia didn't write that that was a compiled pierced magensa so he was likely involved with that to be so that kind of style it's very smack if somebody's looking for another kind of region you kind of want to go along with it and now you have art school massiveness i don't know people but obviously has condition there's any other things in here but it's something like it's more like what i mean is it's more of a pirish kind of a safer like arashi than like a rajba so to speak right that's um that's mainly the rishainum on the message i'm sure i'm forgetting one or the other there are smalls not that many actually i think um rabbi brought we'll talk a little bit more um and we don't really have reshaina makation which is a discussion why not but yeah humor i have on the new map you know in i would say 15 years back in my days in europe and the brisk yeshiva but it's been a while so let's get i fear up to this point i think when i was learning yuma way back when we had dossier yitzhak i think i have it here for those who are watching this was what we had is the safer this is the go to safer at least it was then is this still is this still there go to safer i guess we have to qualify the question because i think messefta is the go to safer nowadays but but if someone wants to go to real safer and i don't mean to belittle myself but a real safer on the message he was um in levarno and um and his me i was forgetting exact years when he lived we'll see seventeen hundreds but someone will correct me that i was wrong on that 1700s around um it's undoubtedly not wise now i'm probably i might be pronouncing it wrong um i don't know if he was the rather he was the brother-in-law of rubismo um he was friends his son was the wrath of lavorno after him so he's famous for this both that he wrote on he is the work he is the region after an endpoint he's the everything and and and he goes through literally he came out every single right you know tyson's rashi gemara he's going through back and forth i mean it's it's dense it's lengthy it's got everything in here okay so before you talk about a little bit you know what a style is i see i pulled up nice hard covers yeah that one's not available i believe you have something there that you're holding which is available yeah so we can i was going to mention that we can mention that now already yeah so if the css unfortunately is not available i've heard that it's being redone and i'm sure someone sent an email or something i'm not confirmed i don't know um but right now this is a paperback if anybody will maybe people know what this is this is um hebrewbooks.org you can publish out of prince farham in association with him at publishersafer.com it's called and now a lot of them are available on amazon so it doesn't example on amazon is you can order it with prime i'm sure most people have prime or have access to prime so this is 7.99 with prime it's great it's under 10 bucks you get yourself a csg it's monday morning the day before yuma starts get on amazon and get yourself be there right anyone listening on my podcast i'll include the link in the notes if nothing else on this episode i hope i want to be my president that you could order it and it is available to get um again somebody's working on a new one so i've heard but this is available now i mean his style i mean i haven't used might use it really in a while but it's it's really that you know sardi's style going through shots marginalized going through everything you know and and the other thing that i wanted to point out about it is is that in the back of the safer in the second part he has um peerish so he essentially went through the asham and picks correcting many mistakes and explaining it so i've heard that this is an ice the hudder but uh that last piece or i'm sure they used it extensively so that's something else that's that related to those genres so this is the safer on the massachusetts still is but obviously like i said a little more heavy he's going through each right it's going to not eat but whatever each it's more of a back and forth now the other thing that he quotes many times is something called he calls it shitak saviat and he goes over 400 times so many many many times wow now who was this so this it seems like he found out only at the end because he called it at the beginning and the bloody knows it's moroccan he lived in 1660 to 1733 i believe of those of the years um and he is known he's famous for for those that know i guess famous uh they say it is he has a say from the center called a very classical very important safer it was published by ava shalom mecca michelle farmhouse this one the this was just published in uh i in tess um this was published by the magana vote actually the uh publisher robert morgan ledbar i did an interview with yes from los angeles right from los angeles correct he has a lot of safari he publishes so this was published there now again what he does interestingly is again it's similar to the same style he goes through a lot of you know shot himself the quotes a lot he also is very busy with griez the editor of this one explained that he used the printing that was the the addition of the shots that he used had a lot of mistakes so it's correcting that so how does it again you know that kind of thing is interesting um the thing that i want to point out that i came across of this is that um about shalom like i said ryan michelle's publishing house has a they have a like a sister company called hilo israel institute and they published a very interesting uh it's a um [Music] annotated almost bibliography of it was there was a list of the ms of gare the guy rebbe had a very big he was a big bibliophile a lot of swarm and there was one of the previous scary rebels yes for those that no no i should have emphasized that yes and he had a big library and they have the list of his farm there they were going to sell it i don't know during world war ii got lost exactly what happened there's there's a very exciting sense of introduction here and which i read when this came out and he does so one of this form of here number 90 is evidently the one that was published last year is from the bodleian library in oxford from the hyman michael collection some people know him but his name is hyman michael this one here is a different manuscript what's interesting about that is it's the actually now in the payment against family another and and there um is what they say here is that the two different manuscripts are missing different things and they're planning on taking the two and publishing an edition now this came out a few years ago that still has not come out but i just want to point that out so again this saviat is something that's interesting if you're looking for the same sign of shot you know kushmak i say for an earlier actor and something obviously the cs gets a closer all the time so if you see it would make sense to get a copy as well um so that would be um for those things now a couple of other before we get into like heineken farm a couple of other olds farm obviously just to stay with the stardom for a second um i can't forget that there's a hidden rabino mushroom imran also shalom they have a number of farm of his also very good schmack going through martial texas shot you know i believe you mentioned him in your podcast also right correct i did and the second one i mentioned as well he um it's very smart now the thing is what i mentioned there i'll mention again i i i completely forgot to say this also the sheet xavi is readily available as i said is available on amazon the mission membrane is probably not available it may be available um but it's probably not so that's something that i want to um just point out now if it would be these from all you know the 20 range a little bit less not expensive so that's another one now the other one that we can't forget um is obviously the guruseri yes yes so we can't forget that one now the grossery so here's the thing there's a nice addition a very nice edition by rabe weisman from from lakewood so i believe you were in touch with him rubbish sweet and that one is i don't know i didn't think it was around but he said it is around that it will be back in stock correct he sent me an email that will be in the stores next week um we could leave his email address i don't have it on me this second but you can leave it in the notes of your episode and i'll try to include it here somewhere as well he says you can be in touch with him to get it as well okay right so that so that's very nice with notes et cetera um the they're also so then there's one that just comes grocery and all them all through mistakes um i think yuma tennis and marcus right but but yeah now it also comes in a two volume but that's just plain print there's nothing to it there was a nice one with some notes but i don't that's not around anymore it was it was a different one like a red a purplish cover so that one's not around so that's really that and the last thing i would mention is uh that people know him but he also has an um a little bit and he has a numera on the final parrot okay that's another one that i would point out as well i guess we'll call those early till almost hand diggers i don't know you want to mention that there's also a safer i think has some some nice writings on yuma right yeah i mean yeah this farm that have standing on shots we'll have a little bit bits and pieces here and there i'm not going to list you know the classical you know the issue yeah yeah right so now okay so you want to get to the what we call the hindigus farm some of the heintek the raids farm yeah sure so so i mean it depends what everyone's looking for obviously everyone today wants to get the raid i don't know today what values are because everyone has misifto evidently and that everything has everything but i went through the massachusetts actually it's bound here rather of a copy of isaiah mohammed who has he has he has a large amount of farm and what's nice about him is is that he doesn't first of all if you want to do a little bit uh you know you don't want to just cheat and have it just handed you a little schmuck because first of all he goes through gemara and he has all his arrows in the gemara and then he has rashi rashi thaisis it's very nicely done separated yeah it's similar to what the the on shasta the one on broca's magilla roshana does with the old safer same thing it's split up which is very nice number one number two he does a lot of times i in so he'll be like he brings a rashi in or sometimes he'll say he'll ask you the question or he'll bring that but he's just giving you the basics and i say look here and look here he's not going to tell you oh by the way this is this is what i'm telling you she doesn't do that which is very nice um that's another you know classical raid safer now there's many others and i'll just run through just not to bore people with a list but we obvious there's obviously but there is i'm trying to see i'm just getting no particular order there's something called as two values beautiful safer very helpful very well written yes excellent right yeah so that's one also the previously mentioned rabbi weissman has a simple terrorist humour big fat thick safer only in the first three proc him with a lot of raid brisker raid is a very bad um then there are obviously um um there is michael feinstein two volumes until daf i think llamadale so that's if you want to see your perhaps we'll get to this but we can't forget he's fair grizz has a little bit i think as well but the problem i would point out is that's only sold in the set so if you have a set of the triggers great if not get out of the local shul all these other ones are sold there are michaels are around they were so they're sold in two individual each volume sold separately um these are not expenses from either by the way um has three volumes there's three volumes so those are also i think they're sold separately to be honest on island yuma there wasn't much of ram yet on on yuma they had on zlatan but fantastic fantastic storm i think if i'm not i'm not mistaken he's a talmud of roberto salvajic and you know he says over from him and he's working with that i guess the brisker derek mahalo somewhat you know today's classic right as i could be i'm not sure of that um and then there's also miraculous mordechai i would point out on on the uh i think it's the fourth paragraph for kelsey um remember we'll call elias i believe his name is very injured i don't i didn't see it around though so i'm not sure if it's available but uh just an interesting safer a couple's forum to run through there's just maybe of interest suffers panic from the rugged shover that they printed on mars printing a couple of stuff i don't know what's going on there his notes and their footnotes but you're just pointing out it's around um there's a pure sky with pictures um there's also a dipper's maisha from what you find seeing very small thin volume it was it was done by the family but before they started beefing them up with like liquid and all those other things i don't know it was like in between they did yuma i mentioned this robert zurkowski who did it as a rush he has a lot of huskamas he has his own say from a sector um called base small it was published um by it says it's alma actually at that point this was a while ago and published by his family so after they took his writings very thick seems like a lot of raid there's a harass of the asheville um there is uh from mr roskin there's also there's an interesting statement called reducing i don't exactly i still can't exactly understand what it is it's like taking from old sarah moose farm likutem it's like it's a nice safer i know people like it but it's interesting and for those two people i'm not sure i mentioned this to you the same for yada lady who's the yada lady for those many people know his father is ashamed who has his yeshiva but he when he was in brisk when i was there going back he used to sit there he was people lined up to talk to him so he has a lot of the classic you know you like to see whatever from yeshua say on some of this raid a lot of that is there he hasn't suffered some nice things certainly available i know on i can't tell you if it's local in the stores here in america right i'm not sure and then another thing i'm just pointing out again i'm sorry if i'm going a little longer than listing here this is if you're calling me bass operations it's actually a save as a current thick save for all i'm assassiuma so very interesting um and finally uh two well more than finally there was a three volume kivitz from avoid the brewer has they like they also make crevices i don't think it's around just pointing it out and finally i would mention i don't think i mentioned that there's the same for yamakipuram on paraquamic people about 900 pages literally the thing is like a tractor trailer it's a large size not your regular size it it it's like it's this size but it's like literally it's your trunk is but but it's it's on it's on just that pair of raid and everything it looks good i haven't used it um so i want to point that out as well so excellent yes there are other smart menu because some there are there are more foreign but lots of more people if i would just recap here i would say wrap it up i went through yuma uh most of them with it with it you know it's like that people haven't missed if they're what are they anything for true but is that this is gonna include the link i think it's very statistic and um no isaiah mccain that you mentioned before it's so to the point short you're looking for something to open up a certain circus i'm going to interests you is fantastic oh it's fantastic right okay yeah what yeah you're wrapping it up you wanted to add anything else yeah i would just add to the old off um uh let's watch let's say watch your yourself audience viewers audience yeah i'm not used to using an on visual amin learners around the globe yes all of those all of all of the above i would say that um first of all if anyone's interested in reaching out to me contacting me correcting me or any anything else um i can reach us foreign chatter gmail.com so s-e-f-o-r-i-m chatter c-h-a-t-t-e-r gmail.com they can check out my podcast and the twitter feed and to the us farm shadow listeners same thing they know they can always reach me the email um there if anyone has any um artists and i will include in the link the uh the link to the cia uh the others farm if people if people are interested and they can't find them send me an email like i said some of them are not available like the piercer middle yuck him not sure about the tizen rush out of cook one should be although the local store store i went to that's usually good had like nothing so i don't know they're only available yeah right true true so um yeah that's about it so i would say i guess we have to do like thank you for the opportunity and thank you for joining me it's like both ways thank you whichever way you're looking at this whether you're coming to hold off or swarm chatter thank you and it was a pleasure talking to you and i hope everybody has a successful sexist humor and just to mention i think it's important we're starting yuma it's like it's a great opportunity to jump in whether you are a roy medafiemi on a regular basis where you have these familiar messages so to speak quote unquote the easier ones and it's a great opportunity as the summer comes along i think suk is finishing right before rosh hashanah so again it's like your mission here has it all planned for those learners you need to just jump in it's a great time great opportunity and i think that's it okay thank you very much thank you you