Part 03: Sounds Of The Teruah; Machlokes Rashi And Tosfos

[Music] go on base starts like this one tequila equals a true and one true equals before we even translate those words and explain the connection between the terms and your let's backtrack a second and find out what is it why is there a tequila and why is there a true the in precious mer and bahar describe the sound of the chauffeur as either avarto explained to mean a straight solid sound or true which the word true literally means a broken or shattered sound or might call it a undulating sound but it's not a solid sound there's another word which has all used which is the swarm which also means a broken sound but the third does not use the word swarm the question is what is the true what kind of sound was the terry talking about until it says to blow a true and the murder says there's two choices maybe it means a sobbing moaning groaning sound or maybe it means a crying whimpering sound just for the sake of clarity shot to have a discussion about it you have to give these name these sounds names so hazal called the moaning groaning sobbing sound ashwaram and they called the whimpering crying sound a true but the true and the shwarm are both synonyms and they mean the same thing so either one could have been what the terrorist was talking about he said it sure well that's a good question which one was the terror talking about sir murray says that because it's unclear which one the terror is talking about so we should blow all which will both so it comes out we have to blow it to kyo and the marble dash and struck him that key has to proceed and follow every true or so we blow to here and then a true and then it here or you should blow it kia and a shivarim and it here or possibly both the true and what we call the shwarim are both the truer of the terror and the official well both of them so we blow but for now we have to go back to that mishna so the mission says that tequila is is kashira takiyo it's a shared terror and the sheriff is the slicey harvest so for mathematically minded one to kia equals one truer and one truer equals three of obvious well let's start backwards what is the average rash explains that evolve is the shortest possible sound so he says it's a koshu it's the smallest possible thing this is a koshu like a double emphasis on that that it's really a small sound something like that b would be your vowel that would mean that three of those sounds would be three of ours working backwards that's one truer so according to rashi a true would sound like three really short staccato sounds so tequila so tequila is one solid sound as long as those three short sounds so rashi's tequila would sound like it wouldn't be longer than that it would make the belt decay's life a lot easier if he could just blow rashi's kias the whole day so if the trua is one very short sound times three and a takia is one long sound equal to three of the short sounds where is the swarm fit in so rash's form is very very short almost impossible to blow it's more than one and less than three so rash is four might sound like not much more than a true it's a tiny bit longer than the individual sound of a true and a drop shorter than the three sounds that would form together here what would happen if you blew the schwarm longer than two sounds you blew it three sounds so taisu says in shahana bring pascals like that that according to rashi that comes at here so if you blew a sound for your swarm something like that was it's here koi into rashi so if you had to blow and then schwarm then here and you blew sounds the guy just blew you ended up with five kias and no swarms so it's very difficult for the vatican to blow rashes forms the truth and key is our pleasure but the swarms are really impossible taisus has a different understanding of what the above is theresa says that one your voter is three small sounds so three of us would be nine small sounds that would be the nine sound true that we're familiar with let's try that that would be nine sounds it sounds a little bit short but nine sounds really are very short and shul typically about the cable is much longer than that because most people can't count as fast as about the character below so according to tysons a truer is 9 sounds so tequila is equal on length to nine sounds that's one sound sound equal length the nine sounds so tequila would be if you blew shorter than that it's not at here because it didn't do the full nine sounds people who longer than that shakharak says that you can vlog with kia as long as you want so according to this life is very simple a truer is nine very short sounds and it here is one long flat sound and the pleasure of tasters is the charm because the charm is longer than one sound shorter than nine and you're good let's try the charms we're going to taste this that's perfect it could be longer if you want or even longer because as long as i don't blow any of those individual sounds nine kaijus um is still in ishvar so how do we pass him into nationalists leaves it open-ended he doesn't come to a clear conclusion between rashi and taisis as long as you're consistent and blow your keys and schwarms and truist to match either like rashi or like this either way you could be right sir so you have to blow long kiss and you can blow medium-sized schwarms and long and a multi-nine staccato sound true according to tasis and you can do that you eat them and below short truths and very short swarms and reasonably short techies yo to cointerashi whichever you do is fine the contemporary minig is to do lactases probably because that's much easier for people to do there is a mimic popular many circles on clyde israel that's designed to combine rashi entasis to blow one sound one kind of schwarm that you create seration tasters in one fact and that is to blow what's called a broken swarm the many varieties of the broken swarm whichever one they do in your shoe and sometimes you wouldn't even know that they're trying to blow a block and swarm but that but they are i'll give you a few examples of what broken shore may sound like or try each one separately number one number two number three and or more each of these sounds if you take the whole unit of the sound with the change in note is long enough to be a shivarim according to tysus because it has more than two notes it has three notes in it and it the individual bit of one note is short enough to be a swarm of coin to rashi when it changes notes rashi would consider that a separate piece now i don't know that rashi would consider that a separate piece but there's definitely a lot of discussion that we're showing them that if you break this sound in middle and you change notes in the middle it might be considered a different sound we don't know for sure that that's a rashi held but whoever set up this minig to blow the broken swarm he certainly held that by breaking the sound in half and restarting the sound in the middle by changing the note is considered a new sound and according to russia you didn't blow it too long and according to those we're considering it one sound like the mash manufacturer if you change notes in the middle it's one sound so that would be included in rashi and tastevis according to rashi if you change notes it's a new sound and a contosis if you change oh it's not a new sound but at least we saw that they can blow up according to rashii taisus in one chat [Music]