Introduction To Derech Emunah (2) - Rav Chaim's Seforim Explored (Part 9)

[Music] and welcome back rabbi dr elias abrupt part two of the introduction to the save darakamuna introduction yes just the introduction the safer itself we're going to get to that could be endless hashem we'll get it done hashem so thank you very much for joining us again last episode we made it all the way until the 1840s discussing the history of the learning of mr zirayam did we shine him back right now we just finished discussing the pasta before we go on is there anything else you want to add to what you talked about in the last episode yeah just uh two short points is that there were people yukidum that did learn drum just to mention just some of them is one was the great revised the great look for chicago wrote a lot on your xiaomi so he has a nice amount on your xiaomi's rum a whole volume it's first printed in the 1860s and one other great literature gold is that there is his father rahul heber to be miyashev who dies in the 1830s wrote famous gilianis so um daddares his father this rabinyaman a great guy if one wants to read about him it's good to read in the unbelievable autobiography of daldarus or in the introduction to the people called mishnas and basically this wrote which was published is andromeda being miyashev mishnayas all the various rebecca vegas the union um so we so my claim the the point i'm trying to bring out is yes people were learning israel but it wasn't the same as national music in which there is endless amount of there's much more and the frat one wants to get that is one point i just wanted to clarify on the previous discussion okay so before we proceed i just want to mention that again if anybody wants the sponsor or hashem these are very popular many many people have been listening to these episodes and again we'll be getting great feedback we just got two emails from people who have listened to episodes from the one you did on your bummers was already a good few months back i actually this will do it again if you're learning about this now might be good to listen to it again now that you're deep into your promise someone just sent us an email asking for some of the pdf files that you offered um during that episode on the arenas iron which lists some of the resigned him they even asked for david safir's article in rebecca people asked for that so thank you for bringing that up to everybody and if you haven't listened to all the episodes they're all available on old af again you could email myself m oyu.org any questions comments suggestions criticisms we take it all fine so we're in the 1840s and we still haven't identified any real spartan when i say real sparring that are put out for the regular person to learn and get ideas on tumor semiciris so tell us where we go from here so if we go further on in the century it's interesting is that in let's say 1880 suddenly more you didn't start going towards israel cleveland movement becomes somewhat more popular a lot of this is documented in various different works out there but the 1880s is when the pulmonary and the various massive controversies about shemitah erupt so this there's an explosion of literature chuvists from if there's a hetero if one could not have had the hero if it's necessary not necessarily all over everyone's getting involved with this um but there's still yet no hebor of the rest of mrs toy's parts now shmita um uh it's a fat it's fascinating the unbelievable amount of literature about it on the history and the aspects the suggest [Music] is learning shivers coming to the conclusion soon and i just uh there's a i want to have some there's a today there's a big minig to plug oneself so i was involved i had a supposed to be involved putting out the work now it's available in english called studies in few years ago tragically with his life by arabs he was an unbelievable writer unbelievably talented person and he wrote numerous farm and books one of the things that he was an expert in amongst many others was the topic of shemitah controversy in all aspects the historical aspects the lockheed aspects and he wrote a lot about it and sadly he was going to write more but we lost that so some of these articles were translated now for the english islam um in a book which has many other essays all translated in english called studies in allah and rabbinicus iii i highly recommend it of course i am saying that i do have a bias because i'm involved with the publication the preparation of printing this book but i think it's worth it anyway so this is about shmita you mentioned that book didn't matthew weinstein on his farm chatter podcast just have a conversation with his mother was it about that book yes yes yes he did he had a very interesting conversation it's worth listening to also to hear the mother the mother of the rubber up and did he talk about her son and about the project in general and other stuff it's also very interesting yeah okay anyway um so we now so we're already in the 1880s it goes these controversies keep on going they're still actually going on every year there's books written on the various poems but we're looking for all mississippi's parts so i would like to point to as follows in early i'm going to show a few briefly some things of other people learning this run aspects and then we're going to try to get closer to us of learning mississippi's arts and arts israel number one is that we find let's say in uh 19 in the 1900 in 1900 a work comes out called pilcosartysro it's printed um it was found by a manuscript by uh by ramnasha grossberg who was famous for putting out many other works and um they had heroes from rebellion at the time and it's printed in 1900 with horace shortly afterwards another edition comes out the same keyboard with horizon meredith platsky and rivaskowitz now this is a what's significant is this is a hebrew about hillary's troll supposedly to the tour it turns out it might not be the tour but at least it's a region and it's again a hillcott israel so the people trying to you know look for kiburim and it's it's already more relevant already because there's much more you than out there in artsy strong interestingly enough as a side point remartra gifter um the great russian shiva of tells eventually puts out an addition of this in in one of the journals at the time much later on than the with unbelievable harass and later on an addition comes out based on more manuscripts from a frank kuffer who we have spoken about in a previous podcast anyway this is just one work where we have any discovery of a region it's for sure region and it comes to um it comes out in early 1900s and um and okay now we're moving forward is 1914 work begins to come out from invarish i believe it was printed called a moon is run which is basically um summer is malacca all the various hazals midrashim everything all the material that there is on drum let's say your xiaomi's missionaries trace afters and all different purusha man plain simple alikut um so it seems there was and it has khashovah's comments from many different at the time i think he finishes wolves rum this is in 1914 so you see that in hutzler there was an attempt at least somewhat to make available in order to learn drum one has to have the caleb to someone else he was also trying to do such a thing just to fast forward a drop before we go backwards in chutzlarts is right before the war the great rashashiva gain redover rappaport that has mater lots of material lambda material and wrong but okay now but let's go back to artistro we're getting to the nineteen hundreds forget about schmitto schmidt we said there is materials but what about everything else so we must mention briefly uh the greater above rum lums was it was a was a unbelievable figure who tragically is born i think the 1850s late 1850s or something anyway he's prolific writer but he becomes blind before he's even the age of 20. so you think his life is over i don't know how but he basically continues being beyond prolific putting out multiple works farm runs a journal successful um called you shall i and prints all different materials related to cisro he um incredible his daughter wrote a very interesting um a nice long article about him but he's blind and somehow he does this which which shows when there's a will is a way okay anyway he puts out significant for us one is in 1908 he puts out are you xiaomi because he held with any and he worked very hard for xiaomi's run specifically trying to track down whatever the best news face at the time um because he understood that in order to to be able to learn he'll start to surround everything one has to have the proper caleb so you have to have the best edition of xiaomi okay it's its own story how is received and and um for example um there's an article from malachi about this and others but another safe that he put out was the capital of eric that we spoke about last episode he also went and made it his business he put it out it was i think a small format it looks like this in a reprint um not a nice fat edition but because he held these fiburum help um for to stroll get in order to learn about this role you need to have the keyboard okay fine so this is 1908 um do you show me 1897 was early as a catholic fair and i put out other stuff but we're cutting it short okay now we fast forward to 1913 something that when i ever when i first heard about it um i was also i didn't believe it and anytime i mentioned it to people they also don't believe it basically is that um the various cadillac at the time living in earth israel decided to take a trip to travel all over all the different settlements that were going on to see what's going on with the different things the the and one of the focuses that in this trip was to see the smear samitzvas not everyone was from or even remotely from and just to see the maps of what's going on out there or in all the many different small little settlements that existed all over the country in arts israel now okay very sounds very interesting but the key thing is it's taking place in 1913 who were the cast of characters as they say for fancy term who are the people that went on this trip so um that is that that's what makes it interesting so um number one cook number two rabies of time zone fell number three rabbi nasim bin yam and horowitz number four another great god that went on this trip was religious clears another was urban sea and adler and and a few other people and they traveled and it was a nice trip they went to many places and they not only they go on a trip and they saw all different things what's going on they recorded everything about this trip and it was even published right away then and then over the years in the early 2000s a beautiful edition came out of it but then even more recently a much much more expanded edition came out approximately 10 years ago this is how it looks and obviously people are finding shocking that movie is on fell then rip cook were in the same wagon going touring the country now one of the points was to see the massive of with what needs to be corrected for the mixes of police bar okay anyway a lot of interesting things come out from this conversation um from this trip from this tour um okay now which this brings us now to ramaisha clears one of the people that were on the trip so he was a uh slanoma qasid dies in 1934 used the rav rashi of tsvarium which was a more qasidish place and one of the things he writes is about a book about the history of pharya but more significantly for us is he writes more probably one the first allahu de khisparam in the 1900's ons rum it's called tarasa aritz a few volumes come out in his lifetime um afterwards more material has come out in recent years i think even very recently a new edition came out but anyway this is the i would say in the 19th in 1925 is one of the first halachic works written by one of the a great god of the time of inaudible okay so here we see we're starting to um change okay now we go a little further there was another of his name was it is a fascinating person to discuss um just to mention briefly two things about him and then we'll get to what his connection with ram is is it's we alleviate we have someone that was like to know very well which was also for in america less known but a great goddamn living that lived in iraq who had was young that died a few years ago so in one of his farm he so he knew that and now first of all is that he was a very into the gra until he was a litvak and to the grumps um he was varying to be making mitsubishi of arts there's a big thing by him he learned by martial of the world and one and one of the things that he did which is most significant for us and this charlie the blitzky writes fourth so he he says he wrote 18th but many of them were specifically about his life projects says schweitzie mitzvos have please parts okay and he held um that people need to know what to do so he wrote on mr sotomay's bar it's just one of his first works which comes out in the 1930s is 700 pages a massive work on true muslims it's available it's called asser tahasser it's available on hebrew books after 1939 he comes out with a few more books related to mrs atlas parts each one of big works now just to show you a hush of his says um troy doblitsky he says that there was a certain child a very complicated question that has sent he didn't want to take a christmas and he recommended who should they go to to revise its vlad similarly um we find the stipler also would send people off with difficult questions to distribute okay his and haggis that he had in a shoe which is it's fake it's more famous today it's it's called the grashull in tel aviv which this this shoe was like its own book about um the gray aspect of the shul and this type of stuff but schroedinger he recorded the manhunt of this from yahushua okay anyway moving on so we have here after where maisha clears who publishes first in 1925 to 1928 he'll cause mrs coley's bards here we have the early 1935 the start of another another great cuddle reviews projects and safari on missus boys bards he continues publishing them through the late forties evan also reviews them and says that they're incredible okay now this farm what level are they are they level for a regular person to be able to open them up or they're suggest i would say they're intense they're intense but they're but the point also is that at least there's a halacha they're leaving so a rav at least has somewhere to go to because to what what i didn't clarify and explain is there's no shocking really on lewis borrowed so that makes it hard at least you have somewhere to start you open up your show honorary and then you look here you're you're stuck after the rambam and a few showing that we discussed already you're on your own so here now in the 1900s these various to the two of them that we mentioned so far at least now someone has what to start with rav and it's the pascan he has where to uh uh some literature to look at that's that's the significance okay but this is but here we're holding in the 1930s okay so i want to just um um i want to just mention over here in 1930s so who all of a sudden comes to we we find out that there's a someone's very significant wants to come territorial why not it's beyond the scope of of today's discussion but that is with the chasmish assassination is nervous he's commentary strong he's very well aware that there's mutual toys parts what's he going to do what and and um especially that hasn't issues we've already explained is a very halachic uh um um that's his that's his big thing so he's concerned what's halal so in all different areas and mitsubishi parts so he ready before he comes there to swell he starts writing letters to people that he knew he had a very close um i believe it's a sort of slash talmud um person that he was close with in um in europe maisha kaine anyway we have the correspondence now we have the whole correspondence printed in glasgow so over there we see that um he writes back to the hazard what to do in certain situations he writes them that the situation here in eurasia is terrible um he says um and basically he describes he says what about demai it was it's problems it used to be a little bit before it was okay but it's it's a problem and he starts going through all different types of issues related to his ram in this long letter and then he says um there's other this casherous problem with mccloud not only mr toys for his issues okay then he says but i'm then he then this this person writes i don't hold that i know even though this person was a hustler he says i don't really know enough damages at least parents who should you go to i recommend you should send your questions and um to find out from this from yosef that we just spoke about um um because he is the person he's the writer jesus he's the right address for indiana mavericks israel and um he throws in that he was he's also um he's a son-in-law by him nathalie hurts who totally hurts was very isolating um and also putting out raw materials he put out the siddha agra okay then he also throws in and you shall i am this raf cook who's also a bucky god though in in saturday's parts goes and writes letters also to um tour of cook and this is its own people have all different discussions what could you read is it a good letter not the letters and then the censorship this is all beyond the scope of what we're we're trying to discuss but the point is that here we have this is taking place in 1930s early 1930s the maths of verity it's it's it's a it's a problem that's what he's writing back to the nation we see is also what's going to be okay so now um um here is where i this is where i would like to so what happens how does mrs please get saved so to speak where does it become that all of a sudden on some level at least there there we now have um a solution that starts to be learned rom starts to be learned especially with aloha what happens over here so looking around what it seems is in in in 1935 around 1935 we have a year rebukes with rosenthal it was actually closer to frank he comes up with um with other people which we'll get to momentarily to create a kylo to learn the even with allah go okay now adjust mama's got right now today the documents about this about this um title when they were how when they the first first documents that they were trying to send out the goal was to to be mavar hill hillcrest plurius boris okay so they sent out like we have a lot of times um this is a how it looked or fancy called carrier they probably hung it up um all over to throw um and it and it had the goal the mission statement so to speak which is the learns run your xiaomi which we know we already discussed to learn all the various we shine him hi skin whatever there is and to learn true muslims are all these things to learn the messiah so to speak who's behind this whole thing so it says the the head of it is it's a rosenthal and who's the good islam so it says writes a very nice thing about it that is a very worthy project and retupes of frank and a few and rebel iran these are the good olympian artists all the time and they were endorsing it okay now then the next thing it seems they must have gotten some form of funding and then we have the protocol of what they did and how they learned from their goals and the points and which was to basically learn properly mitzvos israel to put out swarm publish swarm hiroshi urum and all the different varum of the the kylo whoever will be in the kailua will get a stipend they will hear shiyurim and and hopefully be productive and produce literature about these earrings who's the heads of the who becomes the actual active heads besides the tribute to rosenthal who ran it but he also was involved with the learning was there t-pacer frank or mrs al meltzer they give shiurim to the okay now but it goes further than this this is all taking place and starting from 1935. um they heard sheer cassay they're from um from recipes of frank it seems and they also would hear share very often from meltzer a few years ago a volume came out of her business almost as tyrus and run taken from his your xiaomi and rambam decides this was based on it seems from shiram and notes of people of this kind of that her the shirum back then the 1930s okay but would anything else happen from this kyla and the answer is yes they put out multiple multiple massive gigantic volumes in all of which which were reviewed by zeven very and and it seems each one some of them were massive they weren't just like a five-page article with the stick of terror they were goals and most significant just most famous but even though the list of kailua members at the time were we would say who's who but just to list the one of the most prominent people that we knew that we know of israel about his work on schweiz and untrue miss was printed under this machon and this coil and the work was done there so we see this is where if you want to pinpoint a time that he'll say straw seems to be getting much more um saved so to speak is that in this title which wasn't a big title um weren't big in those days which all these coyote members they were very conscious of the people they learned they used to hear sharon from the greater diamond or two pace of frank versus al meltzer and they put out massive work so you can see them i believe they're mostly up on hebrew books most of the volumes of this uh journal okay now at the same time this is we're going 19 but this is 1935. um so we have just to mention the um dessert of dinkles earlier in the previous episode we spoke about maraschirolov serloff was bendyroy of the base yosef and he does a massive work on your xiaomi's run what we said is that the only one volume on brackets comes out in 1875 by red by marcus lehmann what about the work on zero interestingly enough 1935 it starts coming out by a great literature uh going with dinkles living in usual at first eventually moves to nebraska he was from uttar seems to be a talmud from from its upon avenger but also besides for being a talmud of his he ends up having i think maybe even have to do to briskarro but he definitely has really a close relationship with the thousand-ish and he ends up he starts in 1935 putting out one volume and he puts out 11 volumes on xiaomi's rum with the running parish of his so here we see again another person in the late ninth in the mid 1930s starting the project took him well into the 50s till he completed it but in 1934 he puts out your xiaomi trumas um and we see here yet another guddle putting out a massive project in these years and artistrol now you think what what i found fascinating about this with dinkles is obviously a lot to say about him but we're not going to just is that he dies in 1976. so 1958 he finishes his project on drum 11 massive volumes it's not only uh that he puts out this manuscript he has a running parish on xiaomi of his own he goes ahead now to tyrus and puts out a massive a bunch of volumes on tyrus i have no idea how he found funding for it or time to do it he put out many many volumes on zeralam and tires okay anyway obviously must have been incredible now back to us we're trying to locate works in of mrsa of policeman so we have zundel grossberg who starts authoring works on more halacha dick more for the in the 19 i believe 1939 one of his works come out here tour of zev and also reviews a few of them very with very glowing um that they're very useful he ends up writing on hill shemitah which was more prominent again but also in troublesome mysterious arla meteor incline okay and these come out through the from starting from 1939 to through the 1960s he also wrote multiple articles it was a tremendous time of hope okay but this is how all this what's significant for us is this is all happening when in the 1930s it's starting in the 1930s after this coil could be it has to do with the kailua it could be just stan this is what this is what's happening okay the same time this is in another title opens up literally in the 1930s this kailu was opened up by a hush of a very sort of forgotten a lot in recent years his name was rabistrel zieseldwartz he was a great talmud of remission murder epstein shiva and moving heaven territorial he was very involved with all these different things he wrote a book on on his rabbi ramirez epstein and he was a very big bomb muslim and he ran journals with most most of the journals but he also amongst his many different so there's a so there's a massive book on him called cool it's um i would say how many pages is over 500 pages so he opens up a cuddle in peta where the goal of this title is again because there's a necessity to we don't know mitsubishi virus is not being learned and the title opens up has a journal also where they put in tyrus of different um um members of their kylo and besides are putting out stuff of their kailu um they get other materials related to artistrol and they're also into this and he and he this was his um he founded this now interesting thing is that he had a son-in-law his son-in-law was in the shiva world from aries in many places people don't quote him by his name they call him they make bracha or in some world the tyres run one of the great great talmudim of the brisker of the shiva chavel his torah is considered unbelievable could have a very very close relationship with the brescarot i think he learned to them over ten years and his torah is loved by many arayan what's less known about him is the following he dies at the age of 34. tragic and he puts out tyra's rum and this aft tires ram is two parts he wasn't able to afford it but um but he's the son-in-law of this robbie swell divorce that we just mentioned not only is he a brisker full-fledged risker you can't get better than this he's learned with the brisker of ten years he's a tom olympia is a beautiful article from a friend of mine rabbi elio reich of lakewood in the shoot one of the insurance excellent article available by vip pdf if you email me where he collects all the information about this young guy which i did not really use enough there 34 because he's crazy famous from even just doing so from doing so for from printing so few works and he's very famous but what's significant for us is he's writing on zero tyre's rum is two volumes of his answer interesting review can be found by zeven also okay so we see that now this is also again taking place in the late 1930s and early 1940s so he sees run is finally getting on the map a little bit between shalayan pataka samsavaram okay also again in the 1940s a manuscript comes out which i would say also was a shock to the to the entire world and this is 1930 now we everyone knew about arkhashohan and it was incredible that zakir shogun wrote not only on our kind but he wrote what was not known is that our khashogging had a work on zero and touch him and tyrus the same style all of a sudden 1938 which i which the way i'm describing drum is is a disaster they start putting out a volume of his and drama and another volume of the names wrong seven writes in his book review on the safari that everyone was just blown away it was incredible it's different first of all no one could believe not only was he able to do he did something which was unheard of he wrote on gans and no knew about it now here there's a little difference because he has less sources than called arakula so here in these areas he's much more reliant on you obviously rose evan points out one little that he does if he doesn't understand why he doesn't use the pastor shulker when he should have mentioned it a little okay but but be that as a may reps evan's review is his ex that's excellent the actual doesn't really need um even this who was very into the arkhashogan but um but zeven is very pro this and what's significant is again when is this happening in the early in 1938 and on now if you think about it what's happening is what's going on in europe at the same time the world is coming to the stand the entire world is being is about to be destroyed and run which wasn't on the map even all of a sudden now starting from 1935 until the 1940s late 1940s and even onwards we see a new area of torah is the a is being which was uncharted territories the fee what i documented up till now is now finally getting on the map on some level mamas at the same time there's no destruction in cloudy throw on unparalleled levels that never happened before obviously something going on but not for me to try to even begin to fathom just when you think about the years it's incredible okay wow amazing um before you continue you've been mentioning you've mentioned in many episodes and you've mentioned now a lot there are seven's book reviews maybe just tell the audience what you're referring to what the name of the safer is where they can find this content okay so it's correct i'm very i someone that i'm very i was very influenced for many years these were showing me ace of zev um he's famous for writing a safer called and also for being the head head editor of my of encyclopedia tamudis the first 17 18 volumes i believe it is he was involved with every aspect of it and he was involved in how it was created it was obviously changes after he died not for now but anyway he wrote many others foreign besides writing swarm um such as which is one of the most populous farm that i've printed in the past hundred years is he used to write book reviews about swarm in the various newspapers and these are these book reviews are unbelievable because they penetrate sometimes into the safer he's able to find the strengths of the safer and the weaknesses of the safer he usually tries to be positive he'll try to be spin a positive uh thing but he he was such a tremendous time he was able to pick up a safer and immediately because he knew cole tarakula on his fingertips in unparalleled levels he literally called hirokula um tarakula meaning to say shisha during you can see from the reviews of his on this farm you name it in in the various reviews so some of the some of these reviews was collected into a three volume set called site from this farm for some reason they were not reprinted people always ask me i do sell them once from one from time to time and i find a copy or two of them excellent excellent reviews because you get to learn a lot you get to learn about the specific safer um and some of them are famous people interesting um like today i was reading one about the stipeler but he doesn't say it's the sniper and the sniper at that time didn't write it on this say for that it's his and he says he's not gonna be megalos soy that's the stipeler but today we know it's a sniper but it's a very interesting review in general all the it's a fascinating read i highly recommend if one can find them to get them even if you don't know the particular sperm but some a lot of this farm people do know um so those farm it's even mortgage smack but in general everything he says is is unbelievable um again that's my opinion obviously some people will are completely entitled to argue um but that's what i refer to many times so in in these episodes let marshall first run in in two of his volumes of cyphermus foreign they have a nice amount of reviews about the various farm anzra and he was living in architrave so he knew um firsthand he knew very well the suggestions as you can see from the just looking at the reviews what he was holding in the chuvas the reshining the the unbelievable he also one of the significant things is unbelievable that he knew how to write he had unbelievable writing skills that basically trained the next generation of how to write of writers um and that's why he was the head of the israeli entitlement and other projects so this is a very short very brief about zeven you put me on the spot over here i feel terrible because it's not doing justice to the great revolutionaries who i would would obviously spend a lot of time to talk about them but maybe it's better that you put me on the spot about anyway um so that's from seven of these book reviews and that's what he says about asset and this discover what i'm trying to emphasize is this is all taking place in the forest now okay now we're coming closer to even though the hamuna is 1984 we're getting a much much closer to us and how is that we didn't mention the youth the great yin who just mentioned a few minutes ago that he's coming to swell the hazard what about the khasanesh and erzustrom this is the interesting so he said he comes 1933 he comes towards israel so right away he puts his full carcass into learning as we said was the most important thing by him the learning's run and he and right away cop starts coming out materials of his ons run kahana in his incredible book on the hazard so he says this the first he puts out all about shmita because obviously shemitah was a very hot topic this is the first work that has puts out in 1937 1938 in arts israel but then already he starts putting out about the mai um nistrus dealing with the missionaries thomas xiaomi this comes out in 1938 and and the rest the and the next few swarm of his are the third safer of his is client and arlo anyone who learned to climb recently missionary will know that climb is murder forget about to learn one looks at the khasanesh and you're just like holy how in the world did this person do this but yes this is the hazard talking about so this safer of his comes out intense intense of hill basically comes on the scene and he puts out his one after the other these are common kind of documents okay now but they're very intense as we say they're they're you mamas have to be holding into the sugiya as you asked earlier is this for a regular guy wants to know the locust answer is um it's not easy okay we're coming to the end is a small safer comes out from the famous rehearsal to kaczynski called safari to stroll in here he has a little bit uh a section halachala maison for the masses more i would say hilcazarts israel also of truman mysteries mrs claudius virus this comes out right after he dies in um 19 in 1955 called say ferris israel and this is i would say one of the first farm that deal with and one other safer which is also very important is foreign he starts putting out um he puts out also for the masses it's found in numerous numerous editions of the kids of shokanarak in the back midsize but for the masses who did this okay um to be messiah with one last the one last makuuda over here is that with trey the blitzky i earlier mentioned who was also tremendously in talaka so it seems that in in these years in the 1950s he also was working on a mishna bureau type safer on which was going to be all of his run um the first volume was supposed to be about arla it was called sure we have one page of it from the shower of the p and the shy of the page we also have and from this we see that it was supposed to be something which a mishna brewer collecting all the materials up he the style of the mishna brewer says this in in the shower of the safer and the one page that we have is in type stuff but we don't know why it never happened it never came out it doesn't it seems not to even exist in manuscripts okay so this is ad khan we have summed up um in brief the massive of halachala maisa getting us through the 50s you know it's israel that finally because of the various different islands and the coyotes that started to learn it it starts becoming what we would call a machia that they're starting to that's even in the it's even in the on the shogun of rabbanim to start talking about to start handling etc this is this is the background that with this we can now begin and start talking about what rakhine konievsky started doing this is the 50s is when he's a young person starting to learn and we'll continue to sham in the next episode explaining what he does with run american okay fascinating as always thank you so much for sharing again please send in your comments and suggestions your criticism to myself schwed m schwe orta eliezer brought at gmail.com okay looking forward to getting to the actual dara kamuna the next time we speak have a wonderful day [Music]