Daf Yomi Beitzah Daf 10 by R’ Eli Stefansky

and it happens to be that it's the first nice that the more he's ever learned was with this great grandfather of his so this is by ed clark and thanks to rebellionamy wife and mdy for enabling me and all the participants to learn and enjoy learning the daf with wishes for sibo for all by steve jakubowski a lawyer that i know you guys remember that story that i said over that um pesach night after the last seders one o'clock in the morning there's a knock on the door and there's a baby by the door that's thieves tell us well we'll talk about a different time when we learn soccer baseball as of today having started an earnest with you on february 8th this year i'm only 11 dapping behind fully energized from rosh hashanah and some guiding ready to plow forward with my index he does he is indexing indexing the entire shots sitting behind the controls i've set up in my office i'm not even five minutes into your shirt on sukadevan gimbal and i'm in a ditch on the side of the road with a flat tire and couldn't be clear message from hashem that before i do anything else i guess that's when i was talking about the seom in chicago that these guys in chicago weren't participating this year and he's one of them so he's writing to us i guess something like that he got you have to get into the car accident couldn't be clear message from hashem that before i do anything else i need to ask you for merciless so please be moist on me absolutely not never just watching you share for three days early on my phone for sure not then instead of watching you live when you were last here in chicago but for everything from the time we first met in 2003 mustami is referring to that story of leaving his baby by my doorstep say their night steve if you come to the next uh few things every single day that i'm in chicago and you organizing you bring 20 people away then maybe we'll talk about until then zero you're going to um keep it with zero mekilo for me understand demarcus regards to your wife and brother avi he hired my brother avi i haven't worked for him for a while very close and much thanks to your team and then the kabura for making that i'm so precious everybody says the same thing we hear it all but it's true the team the team we share many more sim cards and see whom together good health steve steve uh what time is it that's not so late from akima sulk away does anybody know what what who are keva sulkowitz is f 2 whatever 202 or something spotted in new york why is that is not stam now happens to be that he's the president that says like this akiva sulkowitz president and ceo of diamond auto leasing now look at the look at the license plate all right reuben that's not a joke eight minute death the island's driving around eight minutes off cars so we're gonna here's another thing spotted one of the guys i don't want to mention his name so because the the put a hit on him or something he goes to cadassia besdon and he sees this in cadassi basin this is uh ad to join our shirt on the bottom here is robert schoenberg did you know you're an ad you're famous yeah so he's wondering why is this hanging up in cadassi vezden and then he looks real closely at the bottom it says the internet he wants to know if you let uh if it's if it's motor he brought it to kadashi basin to know if it's muted to learn toy around the internet or not that's why i was like no it wasn't hanging as an advertisement but here it is here's the lotion right down here beautiful it was in the garbage i don't know if they took it off i don't know um being that i can't afford to miss a single day of the deaf i'm now classified as a dedicated listener rebellious most amazing thing that i've shared in the world you mentioned three times during l that you do you have difficulties keeping your down medium like you're a rabbis and says you're fresh so your force is changing daily well here's the solution to your problem that many have in energy stroke if you can make time to visit the arab medium center located in malachi 17 second floor in google islam coincidentally is located in our home we'll be able to provide you with top quality arbor meaning and some easy tips that can help the eyebrow medium last right through circus right meanwhile none of the hints are here in this email so i'd have to go to malachi 17 second floor coincidentally it's located in my home uh coincidentally his phone number is also here 054-841-7272 i don't know but if you want to if you want to if you oh if you want to email him it's hesed gmail.com the guy just has him he tells people how to keep their minim he with three s's by the way maybe that's how they spell it in england c-h-e-s-s-s-e-d because i guess hessed with two s's was already taken you may realize however you want to learn new techniques understanding meaning from the entire youngster you can bring the cover along he allows that also tremendous you're guaranteed a free handshake and a smile the american way of doing business to make you feel at home may holly suggest that once you're here ready drop into your father and kill two birds with one stone so where is this again i forgot malachi 17. second floor coincidentally it's located in his home all right rabbi sai we have a very very easy daft today bar hashem heir of shabbos cheers at 9 30 months of shabbos so all the way if you look at the mishnah here all the way to the mishnah it's what we already learned yesterday it's repetitive word for word we're going to learn the same thing five times in a row we are today da fiod very very important now igor works made it even simpler than the simple repetition why not the first mission of our massachusetts talks has four problems you're plowing your coitus you're grinding there's also problem and the problem of making the whole so the gemara takes care of that problem and we're talking about knots that care as the mr says there's already a shovel in the ground so it's not muktsa it's not plowing it's not quite it's already in the ground it's already done so the zero is so the only problem may be that it looks a little bit like the sort of we got rid of everything who says that's okay beijing and they still say it's not okay so that's in the first mission so mar brings a list of mishnays that we're going to be learning today tomorrow that seem to contradict this idea that bishamai are the mako and basil case number one we had yesterday with the latter bishop he said it's also to move a ladder to get grab births for yanta for the magenta meal it's all simple but still says okay gomar says it's not a riot and it's all the same answer it's not a raya because over here the zero isser he already put he put it in the ground and he got rid of all the surim a ladder is different people might confuse it fine then we spoke about sipar yesterday which is our mission today but we learned yesterday which do you have to designate with your mouth or you have to lift up the birds according to besham they're more mahmur you have to lift up a bird designated by literally saying this is the bird i want to eat on yanta they still have more mako how does it jive with this basil say when it comes to they're the ones that are making and all of a sudden this whole list they're the ones that are mature and today we're going to be learning about an ailey ali is just a a stone that you grind wheat on is it or not or hyde and the tris is a shutter these are all in the mishnahs we're going to learn it today and it'll be a beautiful hazard for tomorrow and some of it even today but it's the same question over and over five times in a row same answer five times in a row besides the last one that we say this just means that we're flipping bishop because it doesn't it doesn't go with this with our first mishna of the musef okay by the way garrison if you're wondering so microphone number three is is blinking red before it's not working at all it might die yeah we have 40 minutes we gotta we gotta rush it a little bit last few minutes this year won't be on all right so here we go eloi casio casio let me ask you a question from somewhere else again visham and the first mission are the ones that are making they say you could use dirt to cover the blood chamois the cats have a love buster ali this is the best i can come up with i might be completely wrong obviously this is huge and people are not moving but it's some sort of surface like a pestle that you grind something on and here's the surface and i want to use this as a cutting board for my meat for simclasiantiff obviously i don't want to grind wheat now because grinding is not so permitted right the but i want to i want to use it for my meat so a smaller version of this or maybe a jacob aveeno you could just lift it up with one hand and bring it home whatever it is it's a collection of lister now it's on a chair and i need to sit down so you can move it or if i need the actual hammer to pop open a coconut so over here i need the actual ailee for my meat that's the sir goofy nevertheless basham i say no can do all of a sudden so here comes the question why in this case are basilo the ones that are mako and bishamai are the ones that are it's the opposite of the first mission of the muse where bishop are the maikel what do i do with the first mission of myself so that bishop may say that you can do kisi and them and for some preciative there's no problem over here you have to say that the shama are the ones that are making and they say that you're allowed to move an ailee allowed to use move this cutting book asking my why does rebecca have to say mukhlav sashita so again i pointed out yesterday that there was some sort of tradition rabbi akhon had mukhlav he got it from his rabbi that this some one of these mishnays you have to flip bishop so he's trying to figure out which one it is now we bring the contradiction so if this is a sort of a contradiction between the first mission and now we'll go that that according to rashi that's the one that's right basham are the are the maiko they still are the mahmeer and then we're just going to have to flip mishnah ali says same question we had yesterday twice we're going to have it another three times today perhaps the first mission of themselves is because there's zero issue there's no harish no no but nothing because it's already in the ground the shovel avalanche of the like a deck or no it's light but in our case of ailee this cutting board you know you're not getting rid of the surum the israel's here it's a cliche maybe in that case even bashar may agree that it's also inaudible maybe over here by the ali it it's a cl it's a cli clinically olaf and you're allowed to move a cleave that's cliche okay so let's go to the next mishna also on the next yeah the next half now you shifted an animal you have to hide you cannot put it down on the ground that people should step on it that's called mahabid you're tanning the you're you're working out the height of because i so i got a picture this morning from our in-house from vice fish and here beautiful picture of a hide here's the the skin and on it a kazias buzzer so if it has a tiny piece of bus or so now you're you're moving it agave bossa that's a separate allah not important for today but it's a great picture nevertheless if it has a little bit of meat you're allowed to move this on yantev otherwise it's smoked we sell my theorem we still say it's muted to put out the hide because if i cannot put out the hide i'm going to lose my height why would i check my cow today let's sorry for sim casiante if i if i'm going to lose 100 worth of the hide i can't have people step on it so now i'm going to it's going to prevent me from from enjoying yantefsa work out the hype almo oh contradiction first minister says the opposite bishop are making a lot of sellers over here it's flipped basically are the ones that say you cannot work out the hide and be shy we say you could who told you maybe there's no connection the first mission of this afternoon because the shovels on the ground already you could sit down the way they used to sit down says rashi they used to put a little carpet on the floor and they used to sit down indian style what is it called you know something like that oh you can't say it's not the public correct it's not pc jewish style avalosa ellie castro cash i have another question from another missionary ain't miss alchemist in now i got a decent i couldn't find what i was looking for but if you look closely maybe this picture first of all is great as candy and has a jewish kid you're just a kid looking at the candy but you see over here this is green so over here there's a shutter if you look closely here it is it's right over here here's the shutter so basically rashi says they take the shutters and use them as shelves to put out their stuff so i thought it was pretty pretty close a little bit you can see the green over here and it fits right in over here fine at any rate the point is that this shutter he puts out when on chavez and yanta he's selling his goods others are you allowed to sell are you let open up your store and chop is in yonder let's see rashi says rashi what all guys he's not selling no not him not him but could you so look at rashi they were masculine uh threesome so rashi says you see treeson like a third down these are the shutters that you close the store up i'm talking nice and big nice and nice on the flame you put the shutters right in from the store besides them tablets around you put out your spices says rash you beyonce you're allowed to buy from a store keeper that you are familiar with eventually you're allowed to purchase sometimes you'll not even say that the amount of money if it's a known item everybody knows that this costs two dollars the guy says okay you owe me four dollars a lot of buy stuff on yantev if you're not gonna pay him now and you're not gonna discuss the money so i guess literally on it for first on effort so that people should have a geshmachi yantif keeps the store open what are you saying remy schoenberger so you're about to say something you're going to tell me in england when you're a kid that used to do that in the circle next to ponovich there's a kiosk they used to open on and they used to sell the guy cigarette i mean you can get a sword on chavez but you have to it's based on trust okay after showers that's something else but this is you're going you shout you go with the cart you start loading up your stuff and you walk out and have the shop as you come yesterday the first time i went to sheridan a long time i wanted to went to covet shop you just you scan your own stuff you put in the car and you walk out it knows how much you this or in the airport in america now there's no people you walk in and there's a hundred cameras in the ceiling it's an amazon store you walk in you grab as you grab the stuff it scans it knows what you're pulling it out and it charges your credit card okay fine how do i get to the i don't know hey but could you buy that on chavez could you go into amazon store in chavez says the gemara so what okay we're gonna have to go through all this again it's the mission coming up they still say that sorry i'm making and you're allowed to affleck there you're allowed to put the shutters back so that's already this levy this is your favorite if i don't allow you to put it back then nobody's going to open up a store because people are going to come and steal all the stuff so okay you're right the putting back of the shutter it's a mukta item it's building sorry it's building it's buying a slicer taking off the shutter size or putting it back as baina i like to do binion on yantev because otherwise you wouldn't be slicing you wouldn't open up your store to begin with or prevent it is a little different but at the end of the day the first mishna the zero issue he already put the shovel on the ground that's why we're shopping i'm out there but over here by the triss you're slicer you're buying them that's why they say it's awesome they cannot elevate still having silica so at the end of the day this is where we stay this is where rabindran got his thing and he sticks to it over here and then says that kind of camera base caleb it's theory but at the end of the day you could slug it up and say that they still just hold you didn't do a issue by taking out a shutter because the shutter is a cleave that belongs it comes in comes out and there's no binion and steer when it comes to caleb you're not building the official mission is sponsored by official for for slamo for briana bass yentadvara if you also if you could get the other name ready i forgot to put the other name so we went through this yesterday you have these birds this is a slightly different picture i added something i'll show you soon in a second see how these birds which ones did i add very good how do you know because it's double the size it doesn't really look like they're sitting on the ledge okay um but i got two different ones i didn't use the same bird bishop i may hold you have to lift up the bird and say this is the bird i'm going to be shucking tomorrow you can't just walk in here and pick from the hundreds of birds that you have pick anyone you want and that we said yesterday was a casho it was one of the five questions you see the machmer okay not true you could just point and say this is the one i want so these birds by the way a little bit of background on these birds these birds that we're talking about we're talking about the babies the chicks call them whatever you want they can't fly it because if they can fly you cannot go in there and trap the magnante say though so they can't fly how many eggs on yontav i asked how many eggs does a bat lay how many eggs does a pigeon lay a year i couldn't believe it my biggest nightmare i read this rash i was going crazy i thought they they lay two eggs a year and if you're able to break them so you got them and finished they're not gonna they lay eggs two eggs a month for nine months a year i looked it up on google it's pretty similar to what they say today they and three months out of the year they don't lay eggs but basically they lay eggs two every month they're they're constantly laying eggs okay so in this dove coat they have a pair of pigeons and they have a lot of offspring the first eggs and they have the second the third etc interestingly raji says that typically when they have two eggs a dad i didn't look up one is a male one as a female okay says we're talking about the first eggs that hatched the shamisavre interesting i just uh those of you who care how do you and this is the first wave in the second wave i'm just i'm reading here that's what he says covet balaz okay and with niku this is literally kovid fine and this is the first the first wave of kovid is the macholicus you might not wanna shake them why what happens is in order to get these birds i'm just akiva he started with his kova joke in the in the scene he said his brother's speech okay so you think i forgot if you get rid of these birds the way it's very interesting i'm learning a lot about the pigeons now this is open to the whole world any pigeon can come in here and roost and do whatever they want to do but the way you get them to stay is you keep their offspring there at least the first pair if you can get the first pair to stay there then the that first pair is going to stay with their offspring if you get rid of the second and third they don't care that much but the first the part they need to stay with so the concern is that you might check if we're talking you you say you're gonna check the first pair and then you're going to have hiroto because then you realize that you lost your birds they're going to go elsewhere what keeps them here in your dove coat is the first pier so that's where the machine is you can just point it and say this is what i'm taking we're just concerned the concern there we'll see it's about mukta you tell you take it you look at it as if hey i'm not going to check this beautiful pair of birds if i shut them i lost a bunch of producing pigeons i can't do that and then therefore you're over on muktza for no reason but babrikshani and nobody has kharat says agamar now another thing um why does he have to say before yontev i want this pair right over there leimo before jantiff he should just say by the way i'm going to walk in here on young tiff and take whatever i want and why does that work because of the concept of the breirro brero retroactive clarification according to the art school rare i could decide on yantef that what i meant to take two birds is these two birds whatever comes to my hand that's what i decided before you hunted retroactively now let's say they still don't agree with that concept is okay so it goes like this if there's a dead person in the house and he leaves through a certain door so the whatever is underneath that door so let we're talking about a door a doorway that has like a ceiling to it it has like this door right over here it has indentation a lentil okay if there's a pot a cleat underneath the lentil then it becomes stomach if the doors are closed what happens then so this is where the shiloh is when they decide which door the mace is coming out of and now we have to this when are they deciding this exactly if they decide that a certain door let's say they specifically say we are always going to use the front door so then whatever is by the front door becomes tummy from the tomb of the maze otherwise says say it says like this but it's not amazing there's many doors you go out different ways cool onto me everything is coming because we don't know yet where the mace is coming out of nifty but they opened up one who thought maybe called them tire whatever is underneath that door that they opened is tame and the rest of the kayla matar when how where we'll see in a second if he thought in his mind he's going to take the dead person out of one of the doors out of a window that's large enough mat cells they call up then all the doors all the doorways all the caleb there are ah you have to think about this before the guy died so we still over here saying you do retroactive clarification go ready go reverse after the guy dies i decide that he's going out of the side door of the house so now anything by the side door is tommy and now i'm gonna undo all the tumor even the front door this was sitting by the front door now it went from tommy tatar because i retroactively undid the toma from it so you see that we still hold of breira i could go retroactive now i just want to point out a bomb question which i don't have to say now but i might forget it later if it's true that i could retroactively go back i could decide tomorrow after the guy dies i can decide what door i want to take him out of and only then so then as tyson's every single dead person that comes out of a house i retroactively decided because i took him out of the door eventually i'm going to take him out of one of the doors so that is the door i decided to take him out so everything else should become tar according to this havamino or even later on we'll see that's not the shout out and touches his dunk he says yeah you're right maybe the dead person never came out of the door like my dead guy in my apartment building who died and never came out he became reduced to ashes or what no yeah he didn't come out but they brought him out other people bring him out yeah bishop who's that avi what is that for oh it's the new year you're right once a year no but that was last year that was two days that was before hashanah no it was on rosh hashanah i don't know if that counts you get but that's it avi you're done for the year he he's the one you weren't here sean he said it's uh that's one he ahmadi said i only make i ask one question a year and i remember this first first question about a tuna fish a flying tuna something about a flying tuna that was back in hulu and all of a sudden speaking again two days later like crap that he meant that it's that was different it's a different year okay it wasn't a question it was a joke okay he saved himself an email now says absolutely and it's not true there's no retroactive over here it's all forward from here on out now what if question do you have to do physically open it can you think about it but it's from here on out okay nobody the reason why retroactive doesn't work by us by birds why can't he just decide what birdie wants a yantef and then that's what he meant on erev jantiv because we're concerned he's gonna start feeling every bird to see if it's fat enough for him because and it comes out that he's going to be moving much objects for no reason that's the kimura of amrez is if he stands there and he says we said you just stand and say i want this one right over here before you he points to it what's the difference if he points it before yantif he could also have harata now when yandev comes along he pointed those two great he says uh you see these two guys over here they look nice and fat he gets up on the ladder it's like my dog mando he's like he's this big but really he's this i mean literally he looks like a rat with a right you never gave him haircuts you don't know he's his total size but for all the casinos that are upset at me that i have a dog he's not really a dog i don't know what it is he's a rat that looks like a dog he's he's literally this i want a cat once i'm not joking he's barking imam and she's barking around we once went out and by mistake he looked at a baby cat at a kitten and the mother took him and came out ate him there's nothing you can do about it and from then on when he sees a cat a two i lost the mic which one i'm talking about mando so this one okay but now we're back i have the other one i have two more the other one is oh no somebody turn this off oh now it's on i don't nobody ever turned this one on okay how about now huh it doesn't matter oh this one hold on there's another mic here okay this one could go right okay now not so cool i only have two mics [Laughter] sometimes too many is not yeah lower he's competing just compare me to hamas if anybody didn't hear he just said i'm like the hamas they have 25 mics and they're all fake they're not connected to anything nobody's recording anything all we need is that guy from africa to stand over here and like do the whole share in sign language and my five mics in sign language okay we're ready garrison get valdick okay says gomorrah okay so fine says [Music] have a because what's going to happen is you'll find the heavier ones the gishmaka ones are really skinny and at the end of the day it comes out that you carried something that's not rowi names you'll find them all shwaka mysis the shovel glue you won't even take any of them you'll just wait until they fatten up a little bit however says rashi if you point it out before yanto if you're not going to take it back you already decided you're ready put your mind to it so even if you find out that they're not the fattest you are going to use them anyways we just turned to the eurodomain base sponsored by the md whitetail group for all those who need to do fools please join film.com and by lazarian from los angeles in honor of my wife who is mr nevesh for torah now oh yeah but before we get to the mishnah i want to point something out because it's almost yantif and over here we're talking about sim cristian birds it seems like that there's a big mitzvah to have birds for yante so the tour when he brings down this he brings this down he says how how do you and we're simple the the the time that the torah talks about the summative success coming up so how do you do sinclair tour says with wine avi and that's why i brought you down the other day and meet but the sugar of the besides have argues with the tourists is this not true there's no there's no indian of meat and he only brings wine so you're good with wine but there's a lot of others that are the shakasari brings a lot of rice that meat is or brings a right that meat is the way to go in fact a brisk mila rasmilla there's a lot of paisley that say that the way to do this mitzvah is with meat or at least chicken which is don't do bagels and locks one of my kids i don't remember which one it was i had a major fight not a fight my father was paying for the bris it was like my first kid or a second boy and i said i insist i said i want to go low-key i don't want any of your stick he's big into throwing huge parties i said no no bagels and locks that's what we do that's why i'm from new york bagels and locks and oranges so no no no no here this uh that's not how we're doing it so it's my kid and he's not he's not attacking like that but he like in in his adoles kind of way no we're going to do it okay fine at the end he did it like it was pirate cream cheese or but he had these eggs benedict with with pastrami and zach and don't ask but kobe was right at the end of the day i mean he i don't know if he did it for the halacha for the because he's the big foodies these guys but at the end of the day it seems like you're supposed to do meat even though it's early in the morning it's a proud but bottom line is that we should uh try to eat meat i think that's what it came out from all the prices of this there's so much about that yes there is oh that's what it is in our americas beautiful robbie schoenberg schoenberg uh has a big stickletory bed okay so i'm not gonna beat my i'll stop right here then what spoiler but rabbi said wine is is is definitely uh yayatsu with wine so basil one of the things i got really really excited about is i finalized with the guy yesterday to double my sukkah i have uh like probably 800 900 square foot sokka i could have that's how so it was half the size now we're going to do double so all the shira mazer hashem and the azer hashem i i want to let the islam know every morning but you have to be part of this year like from now every morning is going to be a massive breakfast pancakes waffles eggs there's going to be chefs making stuff and wine on the table and no and please don't tell her oh we have four minutes left so let's go no only only milkings unfortunately i mean based on this fine you're invited even though it's your first day here you see he snuck in just in time says the mishna sponsored by official four slam of four abram siemens you designated black pigeons and you found white ones here that's why i did the white ones you said these two and all of a sudden you find these two you there's no jokes here the you you designated the white ones and you found the black ones schneiderman if you designated two and you found three it's awesome why you must designate and you always designated two and i have three so one of your three is not designated it's mukta why don't we say bhattabharav no we assume that the order is not even that you don't even have to go that far you don't have to go that far why go over that you don't have to say what he's saying that all three left and two even even if one more came from outside it messes everything up and i'm asking why i'm talking about there's a question that you're shining it should be about to arrive and the answer is based on what we learned the obviously material that's one answer another answer very good the other one's holding up the other answer is because it's not possible what if you started with three and now you're down to two so perhaps that's what you said they all flew away and two new ones came in not a problem if i think it's something like this according to rashi there's a little you see that each one is beautiful each one has a ledge and you can actually see they sell these bricks with the circle there's a there's a there's a thing that's that happens i guess the ledge ratchet says on top but there's a ledge for these birds to sit on outside you designated them they're inside the hole and you found them on the outside assume that's not what you designated it's different birds remains from elohim let's say you designated two pigeons and you look around the whole dove coat and there's only those two pigeons so hareelumatar those those are probably the two that you designated is just in a different spot says if i designated whites and you find blacks of course you can't use them they were not designated from so he says very simple it's not two cases in the mishnah oh he designated blacks he found whites or he doesn't know why he found blacks no it's one case he designated blacks and in the place of the blacks he found the whites and plays in the whites he found black he designated both a pair of whites and a pair of blacks and they just flip a root the whites are on the bottom and the blacks are on the top now what do i do now this one guy says it says the gemara they just switched spots the ones from the second floor went to the first floor one from the first one in the second one all four of them left and now you're dealing with four new ones you cannot use them on yount of the moksa says the gemara oh let me say it [Music] by the way i'm serious very very simple sugy so you have the rove because all the birds in the world could come into this place it's not closed up it's open to the world these pigeons come they roam around the the skies they go fetch food and they come back in so you have the river of all the birds of the world vicarife but you also so you have you have a conflict between two you say this in in shas in the torah river the tire says you go right and you also have kharav like we learned in shkalam that if you find money next to the one of the puskas the 13 pushes in the basement it's based it's going to go to that pushka so what do you do over here are these the birds from within from that you designate or not if you always go when you have the two things conflicting raven and closeness you go by the road omar says the gemara is not a riot we're talking about there's a ledge on the outside it gives them room to sit there now who comes there says actually very interesting the birds from the world come sit there they won't go inside the dove coat you know why because the the the guys inside are very territorial and they'll chase you out so the birds from the world are scared what do they do they wait around like pigeons do and they wait for the the knockers to leave when those cannot pigeons leave these guys come in so what he's saying is at the end of the day they're really close but the very far so close yet so far these guys that are close to really from from from a distance you found them inside they're not inside what are you telling me that these birds from over here they're from within no they're not from within they're from somewhere else they're at the end they just were hanging out there on the ledge schneider was a swim explains that if you designated two and found three you're good why man you know like you were saying you start out you designated two and now you have three so mother shock it's no good if the two ran away and three new ones came that's the worst case scenario they're all bad none of them were designated but if you just added one it's also a problem because now you have one in there that's mukta and you cannot be bottle but if you started with three and you found two then it's okay it's the same two that you started when i was in the safari with three lions uh and i did a share with the lions one of them got up and ran away what chances after these birds no shaykhs one got up and ran so over here also one got up and ran but the two remained behind mamelia you're allowed to use those two living my season rabbihi beloi rabanon fine so here's a whole new sugya easy sookie by the way i guess we'll deal with it on mata chavez have a wonderful shabbos master shabbos 9 30. you