Review the past week's Daf Yomi Maseches Sanhedrin Pages 68 to 75 with Rav Yehuda Spitz

good morning everybody we're going to pick up from the top of we're going to try to get all the way till the top of so we learned in the mishna on that says in the name of that two people could collect cucumbers one is one's not one gets one's one's person does real someone does illusion he's just faking it he's poter is going to question that we're not learning this from rather from someone else so is this really true we're going to see a long lengthy we're going to see learned it from someone else was sick they came to visit him he's sitting in his little room they're sitting in the in the Parlor the entrance over there walks in to put take away his because so scream at his son to leave the room tells the people all the people were there he's losing it a little because why else we not want to remove his overheard this and he says regarding his son he says if anyone's losing it it's them why he explains what's the pr we all know today we all prepare for chabas we make CH we make all this stuff we light in order not to be now what are you worried about only he says you're busy with busy with what do you want the whole thing is even if you walk around it's not a problem realiz realiz on we all know it that put so they had to stay away so they're sitting over there I'm late so asked why you guys show up today came to learn from you where were you till now so answer let's be real he gave himself a ter um just said we didn't have time right he gave himself an excuse really was because wow I wonder if you guys are going to have a natural death and got very worried he says what's with me what's going to happen to my death you're going to have actually a worst we all know what happened they combed him gave him a very cruel so picks up his arms puts them in his arms up and no one took it learned so much and as I taught was able to teach so much I learned so much from I feel I didn't take anything away just like a dog would go over to the ocean and start looking the ocean nothing's really going to happen anything drastic would then when I was learning from we all know this regarding but over here means literal regarding when a person takes for imagine a lipstick and you take it once in a big bottle and you take it out once and put on the lips it's nothing regarding the whole bottle same thing over there he wasn't losing so much he knows 300 different all the color is very extensive and now then no one asked me anything I want to say that's where we're going to bring this whole is because of the Miss regarding the of the Cucumbers except so what's walking along the way tells meach me teach me all these basically next thing you know the whole entire field turned into cucumbers very nice you PL now get rid of them this was the now they had a sh on his deathbed andash regarding what held regarding he says that if something if something has a base or not if a regarding when you close it up and there's a concept of leather now leather the is when he close it up permanently do we consider this leather as a base keable or not so that's says it's not because you can't say really it says unless it's a because he says but the point is that if something's permanently closed do we look it as a Bas or not doesn't make a difference if it's permanently closed it's still considered a Bas and therefore it is Tom that's one one sh another sh what even if it opens up do you need to take everything out to be when you it is or not so those with the they want to know now is dying maybe he's going to change his mind theoe form we all know regarding a shoe it's very easy once you go to a Shoemaker then we all know the Sho maker could completely prepare the shoe any person can come and just take it off the rack is it a pear pouch what you change your still so he asked and then the second regarding what opens up if he could be he still held he didn't change his ended up saying to show us that he was pure as anything however and then the continues especially they want to go to the we going to see in a moment so they took him out of when was the says very clearly top of the whole was shabas so he died they kept in the the whole over shabas right after chabas they buried him shabash says they brought his his me from there you have to know exactly what it was doing there was ripping a SC T right away brings a question what happened to she says of the is not such a problem he's not crying for himself he says follow I know so much but I need someone to explain it to me tochange but what's this whole lengthy is for one purpose to this question what do we see from here not like our he learned it from H learned it from not from Yeshua so how do you understand ourish this is is the whole of that answers learned it from didn't understand explained to him how do you understand the how did he teach him how could he do anwers to teach what does it say the it says you can't do that we all know especiallyin they need to understand and everything how else can they Etc next M very fascinating per of so let's jump right into it we're gonna see there's so many extensive so many rules and regulations in order to be a we're going to see the itself if it's really ever to happen or not so what the only one who comes which is 13 years old but there's a very short period amount of time that we're gonna see we all know it means by it's not facial beard we call it okay this is the now there's another sorry there's no such a concept us comes out in the mishna that it's a very short amount of time that person could become and how do you know so right away has a problem with this what's the question what's your question first of all he's a we never find out throughout the entire time need a to tell us why in the world would I think and then he says this is's question if you think about it this is one of the fascinating Concepts that a doesn't die doesn't get executed based on a VAR that he did rather is going to explain it's only because eventually we 100% confident that he's going to do many many Etc that's sm's question who cares when could be even a 10-year-old it says we're making if anything you could say read you know how you read the it means someone who's already 13 years old but such a person could be has to be that he has here by the exactly where the has to be Cyrus the long it goes around the a sounds like it comes at earlier time regarding the G and not by the now we're going to go through a fascinating concept of give birth can he father kit wants to say if a gives birth why not says to tell us however if a son has a son that son cannot be we just used it a minute ago a second ago we said to tell us 13 plus to tell us what are you changing now to tell us that Ben Ben Mar ansers why do say the other way around is not going to be just say okay maybe it's but not somebody to us to tell us both to tell us and to tell us that a Ben Ben cannot become see canot give Birch and says in the regarding someone who stole and he made a and he has to pay we all know what does he do regarding the that he did that he's so the says the says as follows if the person has no craving what do you do it says you give it to the we learned to stand up there's no such thing as a person doesn't have a the only case could be talking about he no says to tell us when it's a man to make sure he has any children however however he only you could 100% be confident that he has no children [Applause] so you know 100% that there's no so what do we see from there that Aon canot have children you saying that what ask you a question says in the is we do have a that's just very clearly even n years old what what are you talking about 13 there it's talking about when it says from nine years old and up however if the itself could be could it be that is going to tell you that it cannot however just like it cannot be to tell us the words do says that he cooked over there he CED what's the case do you ever have a scenario of what's the case cus after we saw the miss you have to have two Cyrus [Applause] and he had a period of time that he was able to have a even before the was full that's it's minimum we're going to see seven months eight months nine months there's no such thing as a pregnancy less than that it's only three months and it's not possible to have a baby in that time you're G to tell me that what what they had it before know what are you going to see from there if anything the only case is is a how else can you have it otherwise and then my answer is no he went went after two that's why you could have a this is why it's possible that this could be a [Applause] father and gave birth before you going to tell me you just said three months with says this follows to tell us which means when mu the second the people see her in the streets and they ready mu they ready call her even the world is quite common the father why because he's right to be a father they already see that his wife is ISA is Mu so let's see the BR itself that you see the three months says what very clearly you have it from two cus till the but that answer is no you're right the reason why we're throwing to tell us is telling us even if what even if there was no is full you cannot become and you're still going to become you still cannot become anymore you have a choice to make when Isa is having a having a baby within seven months what you could do is you could change it to two and a third right a typical is is nine months you'll tell us after 3 months you see that she's Baris however a 7mon pregnancy you have two options either third of the pregnancy she starts showing therefore it's two and a third or the other option has nothing to do with that rather takes three months happens to be she will have a baby four months later so it sounds like over here that cannot you don't realize you don't see the by two and a third rather why does it say three months that's what that has a months it's good enough in two and a third that's I'll tell you right this is she has a pregnancy she has a baby in seven months you recognize two and a third however let's be real the majority of the world only has a baby nine months later so says that makes sense so what this is this is we're gonna kill him what do you mean we learned this in the beginning of to tell us you don't just do that we have a not to do such a thing I'll prove it to you we have to have such a concept that even we're gonna go why we learned this earlier right a person made a mistake he says it happened in the second month the third month we said that he just didn't realize but he didn't realize that the was and says you hear for once you don't hear for twice therefore after to one month you'll make a mistake that's what we're saying why we said he knew they do know the Mak a steer shouldn't be a good so why don't we say that the answer is we make a simple assumption that most people when they have two they didn't one realize one didn't realize we're going we do do such a concept why we learned this Also regarding we learn this the whole concept is we see already it's considered a [Applause] full however you now she can't have children yet maybe say it's a mistake in the she's not that a person marries an islandness we say that it's so again know means talking about a carb he clearly says he get answer is no in such a case has nothing to do with has to do with not just the father means to say is the husband that what he says even if you're an island I want this to be a good marriage therefore has nothing to do with right also very famous we learned this many times in right is mother is playing with her with her child because Dad he caused her he caused them for him to have even by we're going see in a minute exactly when is but she becomes a however they say everyone agrees as follow there's no question n years old it's a good eight years old under eight there's no question it's not a good be so where's the8 years old we're going to see in a moment this is bring many you could have a child at eight years old right away the more questions where you know that it's possible to have at eight years old follow first we're going to bring to show us the generations but the point is we clearly see that elam's daughter was B now B had now who which is B's father was and we're going to see we learn this actually that regarding he was he was the General and they didn't listen with he end up doing suicide he hung himself we're going to see this later was the great-grandfather of that's what we're trying to bring out so from these two we see four generations let's go through this now so right over here is two years old and he and had cheer had people that cheer the Sheep runs away see over there he's ready five years he ran rash says he ran to he's there for three years so comes is five years old how many years he's there for two years we learned this that he head over there 40 years we learned over there that he realized that he's gonna get in trouble once they didn't give his eight I think the kill that he should go attack now right now he goes over there and he ended up doing suicide so how old was he when he did suicide so it's very clear when he C when hung himself was seven years old if you go through the how old was now we have to figure out how old was when he did Sude so we all know a typical person is what is 70 years old the talks about this many times so half of that is 35 years old was 34 if they say would lived another year but the concept is when he did suicide was 33 years old he's 33 now how old seven years old we just made that see what are you holding how old was he when how old was when was born he was 26 years old there's no way shape way form around it that rash's takes even an eight-month pregnancy you still need another month of what for another 30 days so it's minimum I'm sorry even a seventh month mu still needs another month so it's eight months in total for every Le does at least eight months so 3 time 8 is 24 so it's 24 months we're knocking down at least two years they have to take away to two years so he's 24 years old we all know 24 divided into three generations is 8 years old what's we we mentioned but had who so we're bringing a r from a girl also I'll tell you has nothing to do with a man cannot do it 8 years old years old like we learned earlier she's actually more she has more energy more to give birth says if we already had a kid earlier Rashi says so already had a child even so there's no to 8 years old're going to bring us another from where from and S Etc says in the we all know that AB married who's daughter at the time was AB was a year older well was a year AB was one year older than so comes out so comes out how old is he he's two years older than let's make it that complex he's two years he married his niece he's two years old than his brother who's a we all know went and he married she was very beautiful now we all know when the told he's going to have a child it says that what he was 100 years old and S is what 90 years old how could it be that someone had such an old age could have a child now he clearly was 10 years older we know we all know s was 90 he was 100 he's older than a how old two years older you make it has to to be and in order for him to give birth to his own daughter had to be that he was what 8 years old again where this is only an assumption that is older than was what younger then his brothers then and Etc why the reason why is first because he was more we have this throughout the says going to see how says this and he was older now we're assuming what comes out is two years same thing like we just did with how old was by 600 years old in the P how old was Shame Shame Shame was 100 years old two years after was 100 years old he should have been2 years old because those two years after if you make according to if you make the what whoever's in the is a year older it comes out that he was born he should be 102 why because you have two years extra and it says as he was actually what 100 years old he was the youngest brother Ella you have no choice but say B he was the youngest brother so why was he brought down in the P first it Wass bring from the of 100 years old says the clearly says what was the older one was clearly older so if so we still have to find car that a person could have at eight years old a baby right because the first POS regarding we said oh you bring could have a baby for 8 years old and regarding we said no it's not a RI that AB was really older than from built the B of we're going to see that he was 13 years old at the time he built he built takes what we're going to see was great grandfather had to be at least 13 years old says in the is now is we all know is not a 13 so they were clearly what 13 years old at least it says when B was 13 years old that's when did the M the next year how old is B now year later he's 14 years old so was sent out as part of was 14 years old now we got to figure out how old was at the time at the time was now I'm 85 years old but 40 years ago I sent 45 years ago I was 40 years old so again is how old k at the time is 40 years old Balo when he was sent at 40 Balo was 14 then means K was 40 his great grandson was 14 40 minus 14 is 26 we're going to have the same of 26 3 months of8 months seven months 8 * 3 is 24 24 months we're talking about someone who's 26 years old minus the two months for the ler 24 years old 24 years old divid to three ler shows us 8 years old okay so let's see theide he's 26 this is the at the time was 24 years old and he was able to have three generations again it's quite a Pell to understand that M Every Generation all had it when they were eight years old says if you think about it it makes no sense should be the if anything is more than that that needs money what's she going to lead to she's going to lead to she's GNA be so she's G to do stuff but without she would also say that she's a okay we're the on the top of there's another we're going to see moment that it's a half of it's a large amount of so three B worth of Italian wi now to understand this we have to understand we care about one thing is this very addictive that's really the issue could be very good not good but it's almost like drugs that's really the question is it a drug or not so let's see this inside he splits it he says you need double sorry need actually double now I'm going to say another regarding that you don't become a person does not become we're gonna see we're gonna see they made a the night before all those type of cases you don't become they put in parentheses I think it's a parenthesis because it's not it's really pay you don't become a regarding we're going to see what that means forness Etc you can eat any food as long as not meat we're going to see even drinks that are intoxicating get you high but it's not wine until when until you eat and drink wine it says in the says this now sounds like a person I think like a fresh a Glon maybe is a nicer word someone that that freshes a lot and so on that guzzles down wine don't be part of the people don't be part of those peoplea Rashi says it's you can't really say it's a I don't know dou split that's what he want to do has to be that it's cheap and if you make if you think about it what do we worried about we're worried that he's going to EAS lead to a drug lifestyle that's the problem like today a person who's a drug addict he has to get cheap money and if it's expensive it's not going to really happen it's coming from the playing with the words of it has to be not deluding we're GNA see it because it's addictive how you tell me you do become you know what is such a case is says when you add a lot of water what we do today that's how we drink with a lot of water that's not a you don't become person does not become like again what we call I think it's like a third cook two third Cooks the point is you eat like a g he's always on the run salted Meats straight out of the wine press and the reason is again we we're we're reasoning that a person is not going to become addictive to such stuff we're going to see you can't drink or eat certain stuff so the is are you going to comp maybe not we're going to see that one has to do with and one has to do again with addiction straight from the wine press and says what is consider as long what is says it's what it's two nights two days sorry and one night and it's that's the concept as long as it burns like bourbon as long as it burns your throat so the is do we have the same thing do we say is it two days in one night like by meat or three days by wine and that says no if you think about the whole has however hear the whole concept again regarding the we care about one thing is it addictive or not the second assaulted we don't say it's what it's addictive to for all these alcoholics they got drunk all these it's interesting we did mention regarding on the way to Misa that you drank wine and we said that was one of the reasons why we drink wine it leads you to the Misa like that a person is not going to fight his execution look at wine because it's red don't look at the wine today when people get drunk they become bloodshot their face becomes red however when they get they realize what they were doing down here the face turns white if you look inside the what does it say however if you look is missing in the but we read it with the to tell us the what you become R without the you become without the you become poor says the says in the p means also like destroyed reread it with the sin destroys you wi and perfumes and smells pi and makes you wise the people that fight people that pain wounds the people that have what they have red eyes this next B says the people that run after wine they basically inquiring oh want to see how they could get all these wines Etc so the way we're reading the we're reading the so this how we're reading the soone that does such a type of thing who's who drinks wine you know what's going to end up leading to him who is that person you know the more answers who has fights who has all these stuff these soone who runs after wine it's A's question's answering now we're going to see the other way around they said the way reading it around like it's a question and the answers someone who chases wine is right there's no problem to reading the other way around that it's more of a statement I do fights right you know what that means that someone that runs after wine it's not a more of aets rather someone who runs after wine is going to end up fighting Etc you can read it both where's we find the but we also find the before we find by we by what happened by we all know with the with the wine we're going to see his son was let's see inside now if you look inside the it says 13 going to go through this P quickly is the first V and he planted the car the second the third drink from the wi got drunk got uncovered and and he tells his two brothers they take the to go backwards not to look at the then it says the 12 ises knows what his son did is the 13th V what did he do says what did his son do he C at we all know what happened was he saw that want to have a four son he said let me be M what did do when he got up he cursed he couldn't curse him he cursed his four son which was says the saw his father's and regarding also over there with the we can understand can't have another four child he did both Not only was he was m and he was okay let's go back to the planted says what were you thinking we all know what and he got drunk so what are we going going that the eight was what was was grapes there's nothing brings what Misfortune we all know that what happened with brought on it was East gra we all know what happened they realized after the they realized they were uncovered they seed on themselves fig leaves who's we're going to see his mother was trying at him so what happened and was ready to Whack Him follows this is what the says we're can explain this what what is she tining what is she saying to my son my my womb and my NE so what is going on she was basically sh everyone knows that what once they they didn't go back no I push myself in like brings down that the last three right that the three months the first three months bad good and the last much it's good for the V it's what it's making all they cared about was and what are you doing and he don't turn to that drink wine what are you doing going after the king after they drink they say why do we need a what these rul the people the rulers they come over and ask you stuff you're going to get drunk the people the secet every comes to them so what happened was said you know what M you're right why how do we know this I was foolish what we're going to see we're playing on the words is of regarding the alcohol the wisdom of and I should have known better and learned from we said you don't become a means empty heads people that are that are worthless call them potheads or something he doesn't my answer is a lot of times even today you could go but there's not one year sitting at doesn't look like even if it's a very and there's no one there that's still you don't become a even by eating such bring up to the at we saw this it was a special attic that they where they hand can only bring beans and grain bread even though you don't bring but he snuck in he brought up to the still and therefore you don't become have people like we just said the evening prior like Friday night for you have to go up during the day you don't go up now what's going on told his kids as follows go up early early which means to say is during the day you all gather and there's an action going on everyone's looking what's going on they talk about it so you're going up to the attic during the day so everyone sees you but the S and everything has to happen by night and the same thing the so is going to be by night however the same thing also leave early that's again we don't say a person is going beone who eats what chicken meat the promis as long as would be we just learned the if you have to however you almost let's say let's make it 10 pound you had already nine pounds of meat and you finished your meat and you took the last pound for chicken that we could say it's and it's considered what a person will [Music] be's is a tinest all the tinest a person eats is and says why don't you come and if it says this is the parents talking not to eat on a it's a place it's fix that what even though gets you intoxic R get today I forgot what they call those stuff that get you high um these candies what's it called not they have today they have these stuff they get you high by KES whatever even us why because it says the point is even though it's intoxicating to a certain degree however doesn't have the addiction on the top of we mentioned this when now we're just quoting this a lot of wine and wine and eats a lot of meat and more than that it continues what's the PK say someone who drinks a lot of wine and eats a lot of meat he's going to come poor that sleep going to have torn clothing someone who sleeps in tired becomes like what like it says in the cry someone that sleeps is what has ripped clothing who is he's not going to remember everything again more more rules and regulations to become if a person steals his father's money and he eats in his father's house or he steals from someone else he has to steal from his father's office he has to eat it somewhere else very fascinating has to be his fathers and his mothers and's going to question this the reason is it's follows when you steal from your father very nice you could just walk in your father's office and take his money you can easily get caught you're scared so we don't think come very hard to find money you don't it's very hard to get's money your father's gonna catch you you take your father's money and you eat it somewhere else very easy to get the money not afraid how could it be that it belongs we're talking about that's prepared for the parents you tell me you took money you just didn't walk over to your parents plate and ate off their plate since the money is towards the we consider both your parents somebody else gave you the money tells the mother your husband cannot have I was then back to square one says then here you only have there's no okay part of the procedure part of the procedure is what we do is the parents make a statement and they say that what they want they they designate and they clear that their son is going to be mother says no we don't want to make him wayna see what that means in a moment they couldn't got married away what's mean going to tell me what they they married sisters it's your father and your mother who cares about the isues who cares about the parents so who cares they have to be what similar in appearance we're going to see in a moment it has to be similar have to look alike you have to know what the means the height the size Etc you have to know how could it be a call a male and a female had different call the height to tell us has to be and right way the is going to throw in that this is not practically possible for parents to look alike act alike Etc so it's not based on all these rules and regulations tell us come on who is this like what the parents have to look alike Etc very hard to understand the reason is we put so many rules and regulation to tell us again however argues and he says how can he sit in his they ask okay so now that we mention the concept it's not possible going to see also more than that we're going to see people holds never possible again you have a city even if has one which is not possible really because it says the we all know put into the yard and we burn everything you can't burn it however again argues and he says myself sat in such a place again you're G have to say the re holds that they didn't burn the they even without burning the the reason is is going to say so many complicated where has to be at house that it's not really prac all these types of measurements are not practical it's never going to happen where's has be the corners all these measurements how do you have a w only wool is by a corner again he says call it anything the place of the the ruins of those nice be careful over there why because rash says that you shouldn't make over there because those would be now we're going to discuss the parents if any of them are what they're they're lame they're mute they're death many other you don't become talking about the parents if he's what if he's a he's missing an armor like his amp lame if you go through the it says how else could you grab it if you don't have an arm us tell us that can be amputated and it says they walked him out if you're lame you can't do that they spoke can't be mute they about to point and say this is our child can't be blind can hear now that he's going to get he needs to have 23 what's fascinating is you don't get you have to have the original Three so you're really adding just another 20 that got malus earlier to the original Three you go through explains what is what ear this should be a bomb R that's the's question answer no extra because it have just it could have and should have just said okay we're on the top of the three the mar since when betr it's good enough to a them why do you have to get three this is what it's saying where does it say the get they learn it from the the making as follows says in the first so the learning from from taking him out regarding and the says so B from they pulled out us we learned this from we learned can't be blind to tell us to tell us that it has to be that they're not blind and these 23 three of them were the original for right before he got he knew he's about to get convicted he ran away is next thing next thing he knows he waited a few months he ready however it doesn't make a difference a person what we learn two things changes we all know he's gonna get sorry more than who know needs what you need to have a he need that that's regarding and get and here you're going to get let's bring right says are we gonna say the reason why the whole point is because change if you do it today he be you can't compare to a by but then a if you do it today he still get killed to get killed by this he has he would not get killed because he has let's try to bring it what do you see from there even though it's says no you can't bring it right from there you're already you're already set to death nothing's going to change no matter what [Applause] he hit his friend he went and with wife also came is however if he went and he killed is or he heard is he went on is's wife in different you need to have two things you need to have like we said and you need to have from to different the you're right that okay okay let's go through we all know regarding there's no such thing as going to say we're talking about say you [Applause] say his is not why because in the beginning he had and now he has since is more than is Li in the therefore his didn't change is more than so we can understand that led in the it's not answers that he held it's not it's rather therefore didn't change we can understand regarding didn't change because we all know ear as a and according to it's more we're in the stand of the is the for and therefore again like we said earlier whenever there's all the are licked in that regarding that she gets what does she get she would get have to read get even even though she's not still says right if you think about it why does Di rather regarding it's good for us and it's good for them now that it's quiet and it's they can't do more the other way around that they were making on us we saw this in the beginning of again they can't do a good for us they all separate from each other because they can't sit them together and be to each other how to do all the way [Applause] around okay how could that make sense you didn't do anything you didn't do anything what's gonna happen even today look at drug addicts they have no choice but to Rob and do murder then we saying very simil to the Miss we're just handing a little quoting word to Word of Our now we're going to learn a very fascinating Mish one of the most famous Mish in soone who's going through a tunnel because we're assuming someone that's ready to come at all cost right a guy's doing a jeel guy's coming to steal a heist a real jewelry heist they come with guns they'll kill whoever's in the way they going to learn means you cannot kill him he has blood and you can't take it away You're he's the reason is because he doesn't that means he's a person that anybody could come and execute him we all know what that means you cannot get two punishments at the same time person is not going to sit there and say oh no problem go steal this whole entire safe I'll shoot him down we all know enter at your own risk and therefore you're willing to die if that's what it's going to lead to what is the I want to say fascinating you took k out and it's sitting in your house you're poter my time you bought literally with your blood you could have got killed want to say that it's gone but if it's right here in front you you got to give back very nice it's right here it belongs to the owners you're no different than right no different than that if you took it it's still you have to give it back very nice you still have you broke it there's no could kill you we're g to see what that means make a you take it you would have to give it back be tell us even when you have why would you think otherwise doesn't make a difference say however as she says and you could change it yeah you want to know what's it's not such it's all know someone steals wall in so there's a way to be if he drags it out and he's by being at the same time that you the K you however if you picked it up in the but doesn't happen till a minute later however and what are we assuming over here for the we're assuming that this wallet is still in your hands when you got rid of the wallet you threw it into a river the child to Reay to pay back that we're going to say your Potter but if you have it you got to go back so there's no however very fascinating R himself the Rams were stolen and there was a time of killing they wanted to return since ra says that you could hold on it I'm going to let you guys hold on it but I don't think R himself would pass like ra if someone would ask him okay if you look in the it says the sun is shining in you the sun is shining you n of the how do you learn this if you know for 100% that he's what that he's not that he's going to kill you then you have to kill him which means to say is shoot first ask questions later what's going on is it you need 100% confident or not when it's a father and a son we could assume that what that he will not kill him and unless you know for 100% your father's a and he's a m and he's not going to kill you then you kill him it's only when 100% alive unless you assume your son's not going to kill you you would kill him if anybody comes up from the tunnel you can kill him the had a special relationship with him therefore he couldn't kill him tell us when you can't so when you can kill him doesn't make difference and when you can't kill him it doesn't make a difference him we don't execute come he's a right if you kill him if you can't kill him you don't kill during the week you don't kill him what happened was in your tunnel the tunnel collapsed the is can you save him maybe since he's not since he's not a he's not a he fell in the tunnel while he's coming to Ste to save says in the you slug him you knock him out and he dies any person no matter what you want to drown the tunnel pour concrete in the tunnel and he'll die in there it doesn't make a difference so we can understand none of your business we already know this what we learned what happens a guy's running out a b and he jumps on the ship only or today with a gun you able to shoot it you have a special let's learn out from why not answerers whenever we have because otherwise they want learn the rest when we say no don't learn it out from each other therefore you need a special P to tell us that regarding this right you can kill him in any way shape or form going through your attics through your roofs and your guards Etc your yards knows which means to say very makes a lot of sense you don't need when a guy's coming with fully armed and going through your tunnels however if you look at your security camera and you see a guy picking your gate the second the alarm goes off what's he going to do he's going to run away there's two types of robberies there's robberies at all cost and the someone's taking his chances so when it comes to the we could assume the give him warning if you continue will kill you most of them run away but sh they come through a tunnel picture more like an armed robbery fully loaded and now one is stopping them okay wow what can you now because if you need to give can't accept he doesn't have we all know regarding abortions right again regarding a baby now the is the doctors tell this mother either you're going to die or we going to have to kill the baby so as long as the baby's head is not out of the Goof we kill the baby the second his head is y we say he's a life and you're alive which so therefore we don't kill him this coton is killing them what that you don't kill a coton right the made natural phenomenon that what that that's how you die that's we don't look at this c as a we look it as a d we look it as part of the process therefore that's you don't need he tells him look and here there's no there's no answer whenever he gets has to be and he's not answering it let's bring not like so what do you see that he has he's basically your hands are tied you see the guys right him across the river the whole purpose what the only way you're going to do him is you're going to say in court we're GNA kill you so therefore you g that we learned therefore you don't need okay runs after his friend to kill him now we're going to learn fascinating it's not just what even someone is running mind your own business but you don't kill him someone is killing you can't you have to go kill is this really true he's drowning so what do you tell me learn from a different place what is he doing he's not killing her I got it she's Russ is the worst time to go and do something with the wife right he's not even the husband yet we know we not there's a very few minority opinion that holds since it's a we C learning out from each other it's more we don't do but we do person we already know that didn't do anything wrong do know I got it so know it says in the this is the when she's in the and it says she screaming there's no one helping her if anybody could have done it whatever way to kill the person even to kill him you would do it we said this earli is this really true Lear from learn from answers you yourself need to go and and go save it to go maybe rent the diver you can't swim the guy is drowned to go rent the DI you have to go and spend money to save now that we're not arguing against our even though it's not a we're not arguing another the second time around r a person ready dis with the lady or and he says if there's a sa if he's able to kill if you have without killing him don't kill him don't do anything let him do this is you don't kill that the person you kill such a person for not doing in order not to do if you look inside the it says but if you look in the there's no what it [Applause] says so when it says without comes to tell then it says why do you know all that just learn one and learn from the rest let's go through this why let's be real is not it's embarrassing but husband you're not taking away any therefore it says us my answer is that you're right what are you gonna do with it we don't kill him do kill him then what you [Applause] do and therefore you us would able to kill him why he makes ansers you're right to bring it says you don't kill so what is what are we worried about is it the word at and therefore no matter what it all cost you kill him or worried maybe that sin she might come and fight for her life she doesn't want to get to get violated as follows here she's saying I'm not going to fight back and therefore you don't have to worry about why is that different answer okay what the finals the first mission of the third what is so what do you see if you think about then you would think about it should have that's what says sorry not mishna says and therefore you you think about it what has and if it has then you automatically have as follows when did happen by the and the second you do the second you do a ra we learned about this earlier that the even the there's no happens only can understand they you split it they both happen the exact same moment we're going to see so we have five truths in first says they we're talking about a so now in the second we have five wants to say so is the therefore it's the but the the we all know it doesn't make a difference thirds like we just learned they said earlier it's not a problem we don't kill him there's no the fourth says and everyone agre you don't kill call and the final says you could K you could save can shoot him on the legs with a knife but you have a gun and you can shoot him on his knees do we see is fascinating concept that if you could save him by his feet for example it says in the regarding two people are fighting with each other and we're going to see in a moment he has kav to kill and if he what and he by mistake shot a woman there's three options either shot a woman she died the V died got injured says referring to what the case that they wanted to kill each other cuz how else would you understand if you had no intent to kill Ruben you kill a woman there's no you should be a right so I have a case for you you were trying to shoot Ru and anybody could have easily shot you on shot you on your knees therefore still don't have how could it be that you would got killed and that more answers you know what the case could be you can't compare the is when it's one person trying to Kim and this is a different says no not there's no why chasing chasing even when it belongs to you still you clearly see my the reason is regarding the that's getting chased see a second you could take his money why you you're trying to go sa right you have to know member he's getting blocked could he go smash someone's car to go save someone he might be poter not but from the why should I go try to save somebody the only way to do it is by damaging y's prop and he's going to M me for the money therefore you're pot so therefore we don't have a walking away that's the case of we said the you don't get killed think about we kill say you're make answer is yes he h like like the minority opin father he made so the sitting in this guy's house his name was un look and they voted they signed they voted the attic the we all know these are the but what do you clearly see privately guy says so go serve we do serve him so what are you telling me it's part of the answer I think what we hold we say this every tell us they tell us as follows which most people like that however if someone's money is the most important so we see says as follows comes on and we learned this regarding the earlier we make a says what should I do the mayor the governor says he was you better go kill we're gonna execute you says you got got got to let yourself get killed you can't kill him why very concept very similar B you to the side that your blood is redder than y's blood maybe his blood is more red you could kill to save yourself this whole concept besides the when it's not even small we're going to see how small it is they're going to force us to they're going to convince us to do more and more they're going to basically be able to manipulate us to do more and more VAR so what is even CH shoelaces something something Clin something that that was the way we did it they said we want you to what do like we know that the 10 people needs to however do we need all them to be you have to know why let it be whatever it is what happens if this invol can we count them what's [Music] says just like over there one of the most famous one of these longest Sy that's quite extensive Esther we all know if Esther was married it's even how everyone knew that she was doing wasn't but everyone knew how could she do it more answers she didn't do anything regarding the Tash therefore it's not considered why want nothing to do with he wants because the she was very [Music] beautiful it was heaters was cold heaters Rashi says that they need it for the churches so the priest would come and knocking doors and have to give the heaters how could you give the heaters the answer is has nothing to do with they needed to keep some warm we learned this like feed my animals and he takes a gun to his head he says like the answer is you cut this you you don't let yourself get killed however he say I want to be just to be get killed and don't cut this he's doing it to what to go against then we say one last point he keeps however they tell him if you're not going to do this we're going to kill you it says that we that there's no it say we learn ET literally mean spices but the point is anything that and ala told him go to the yard then go seven times take a dip and then he had a mest and and it went away he gave up all ofs he went back to however rash that he still went with the King and he bowed down together let's see the P it says as follows when he went to the this this B down with me underline this I also bowed down with him and what was the answer go in peace what do you see not Ser better off dying how can you say answer and there's no therefore it's not a problem you have to know what is doesn't walk away sounds like the end of he's P that the way he looks at it that a is not next week we're going to pick up on the top of