Daf Yomi Succah Daf 24 by R’ Eli Stefansky

good morning rabbi oh no sorry sorry stop stop stop stop good boy i forgot my tie link sponsored by rosie jaffe in loving memory of her father mickey mouse radz ate the yard side moishiaco vendavid and bayakov malcolm slattis before schleim of our son by donnie fine would like to sponsor today's sharing this huss before shema for hannah ita gittle paris by michael in memory of his mother fago bass shmuel and father-in-law to make it to uman this year had some amazing emails today i think i'm going to save them for matsi shabbas and sunday and these are also very amazing and these are printed out a while ago hello rebellion i'm writing to you from cote saint luc i don't know how to pronounce it but i did i know but kotsing okay um lewis thank you my name is shmuel mayor kravetsky i really enjoy your showroom i've been listening to you for about a month now i've not missed a day by hashem enthusiasm is amazing i've never done that fiona before i'm awake early every morning as my kids don't like to sleep in so when i turn on your youtube channel and start learning my kids both say good morning rabbi thank you very much for the free gemara sukkah you should be blessed as well as your family or the best small mayor from quebec i would like to point out a few differences between your sheer and ndy and hutzlaritz well i could point out a big one there's four and a half people in this room now and if i was in arizona we would have 80. if i was in new york we would have a hundred if i was in miami would have 80. chicago iraqis chicago this everybody has 80 nursing homes but they're not into learning the death you seem to smile more here at mdy not so much there correct there's a reason you do not yell at anyone during this year when you are there i do i yell at arya and a few other people you do not make fun of anyone over there i do i make fun of arya and a few other people you do not call me the sheer lets i do oh this is adam gargire avigar gear ps someone is trying to get the shirt to diamonds fired please bring back the old rabbit stefanski daniel cerfati says i hope you are well i want to say thank you for giving this every day you're engaging in something bad inspiration has enabled me to be they eat them during being in london so you have quebec london and ramada chemist and here we are in iraqis chicago and i hope to carry on all the way to the end of nida i really appreciate all that you do many things daniel cerfati and from moisha marvette if that's how you pronounce it hi i really love people should start sending their names with nikudus i do better with the kudus i really love your daft shear and you really are amazing how much how is this stroll you have you hear this i got this guy also louis he thinks i have hamstrings wrong oh i do that being said there has been something that's stuck in my head that i have been trying to get out of my head for a long time now in your interview of meaningful people with nahi gordon you said you chose ramaphichemish because you saw a father playing catch with his son and you said they they were normal quote unquote now knowing how much i have a c stroll you have i was a little disappointed just because this is something normal to you doesn't make it normal i'm sorry now i got to tell you something about that story so the person playing cash was rabbi simcha sussman i mentioned his brother yesterday is a roshiva in arizona in our neighborhood and he has a hydrous bottom of shiva as the beard the whole thing the shirt the white sits is sticking out and he's playing catch with the sun in front the front of his house over there i thought wow normally i meant down to earth like here's a guy that looks like a khashoggi bentira he's playing cash he's spending time with his son i thought it was geval de gaza i don't know what this guy's titus i mean i don't mean normal like oh that is normal that's not no first of all normal everybody has their own gauge and whatever you think is normal that's fine it goes based on what you think not with other people okay today normal is not normal la mashem it but here's the crazy thing about the story when i told him that i moved to ramachamesh because i saw him playing catch with his son by him and travis once and i said you know and his wife started laughing she said that was the first and last time they ever played catch together i'm not kidding protest all right rabboissai it's i mean it's mutsy shop sorry guys and there's charlotte's arab it's mozzie chavez and i'm on the way to a shabbos weekend with the mishpochah so we're only going to do one omit today it's meet them considering it's every single day it's a full daf and basil hashem is going to be a sheer tomorrow night at 11 15 chicago time which is 12 15 a.m in new york to correspond with the 715 in new york's role last week we messed up a little bit i messed up i did this year a little earlier and i went into the israel and they all sit down in the basement to watch it on the screens and there's no share available so we're going to do truva today and on sunday i don't know what time sunday i still have to figure out but it's definitely going to be on the day of the hassan there's going to be a share whether it's in the morning over here at 10 a.m or maybe at the wedding place i don't know we'll have to figure it out so we are holding that of dalit and we are smack in the middle of one of the most amazing interesting sookies and chefs a person takes an animal and creates a wall for a sukkah out of an animal why would he do it so it probably never happened in history but it's a it's a question can you use a living thing as a wall maybe it has different ramifications for other things for other allah's and in the mix we spoke about a get could you write a get on a live animal can you use a live animal for dumb then for passive mirrors which we're going to go into says the gemara like this casio derived at the end of the day we have sort of a contradiction which we address slightly we're going to address it again remember says we are not concerned that if you were masters true muslims into a vessel here you have something made out of leather and you say that two percent is truma 10 percent is nicer you go through the whole thing but it's inside the leather noide for wine so according to remayer we're not concerned that this is going to bust open and you're going to lose all your tumors and maestros and it came out that retroactively you ate you drink wine without chromosomes i'm not concerned on the flip side remember says i'm concerned that your sickle wall made out of an animal is gonna die i thought about it for a second yeah there's a lot of concern if you take an animal don't let it move for seven days maybe it's a great possibility but that's not we're good we're not going into that are we concerned that human beings and animals are going to just drop dead suddenly ramirez says no and all of a sudden uh sorry he says we are remember says yes rebuke this is no so when it comes to human beings where mayor is concerned that somebody's going to just drop dead and die and but when it comes to a battle made out of leather we're not concerned it's going to pop open oh my locker may your american answer to the contradiction miso shrikha there's one thing that we know that's going to happen and that is death and it's very common doesn't always happen not every single leather pouch is going to explode why the more even explains after the muscle like destroying you can give it to somebody for safekeeping and i'll make sure it doesn't explode cassio the review that i reviewed now the reverse question is review the review that says that i'm concerned that the leather pouch is going to explode but i'm not concerned about human death and animal death why not answers you misunderstood it it's not the shot that would be hudo is concerned that the bottle of wine is going to explode elo monsoon de las librero beautiful what's breira i have a whole bottle of wine and i say that two percent within it i don't know which two percent is this ten percent is that some of it is true or something is meister it's all gonna be in this buyer it's gonna be figured out when i'm done drinking i become sicker and then i leave a little bit of wine in the battle ah very good that's the two percent they took off and that's the ten percent that's called breira and there's a question in shaas could you say breira that there's a retroactive understanding of what happened rebuttals no you cannot go backwards it's unbelievable to say yes breira i drink and drink and drink and everything that i drink has zero true mice are in it and it's only whatever is left over on the bottom of the bottle that it suddenly becomes that's a huge criticism doesn't subscribe he's not concerned for breaking of the battle he's just saying that you cannot take true muslim meisters if you have a problem you bought wine from acoussi right let's go back for a second you buy wine from acoussi and the kusi doesn't care about true semesters he cares for himself the gemara always says but not for other when you buy from him he'll sell it to you oh by the way crazy story happened to me i know i'm not the guy i bought a nice suit for my son's hassan now i didn't have time i was running around i was trying to prepare shiites today and i couldn't i couldn't take care of the shatnas and he swore to me that he took out the shatness he knows what chatnez is and he took it out now he's a jewish guy but he's not affiliated i i and i bought stuff from him in the past and he told me he took out the shot and i trusted him one day on a hunch i said i'm going to send all my stuff that i bought from him to shatness everything came back that was shatness so for years i was wearing shannon's great so i go to this guy again like uh destroyed i am and i we it's me my shiver we buy two suits one for me one for my shiver and he says i'm going to take out the shot and i said yeah but there's a little bit of an issue in the past but know that i'm taking it all out and i'm going to show you that i took it out and i'm going to put the shot that's in the pocket everything is good and you know you don't even have to check it so i told my shirt there's no way we're going to wear these suits for the wedding but without checking the shot so i didn't have time so today after chakras i go to the guy's house at eight o'clock i knock on the guy's door he's up david zurkin if you want to know great guy he's at the sheer actually comes he listens to this he says yeah i tell him i took out the shot and he said well i have to open it up i said you can't open it up because it needs to be tailored and i'm the wedding is on sunday he says well there's no i'll explain to you there's no and therefore you cannot wear it so i thought the guy is crazy because i took out from my pocket i showed him all the stuff he took out from the from the thing so he says i have to open it up so i said okay fine open it up so he opens it up and he calls me back he says in one suit in my father-in-law suit the guy he never took out anything the shot is all in there and he took out a fake piece he just put in a fake piece the other suit my suit he says he did take out the shatness but there's a lot of threads and a lot of stuff in there that he didn't take out and therefore according to some sheathers that's the real shotness and now he bar hashem he did me a big favor he is going to bring it to the tailor i told him i'm preparing share i can't do anything i won't have a suit so he's doing it for me a gracie's going to love so anyways you buy why uh lewis call him saying that the reason why i had to go to the midfield my jet skin i almost lost my bathing suits because that chat is in my bathing suit so how did i find it afterwards was the remis okay great so why am i saying this because when you buy stuff from people that are not a hundred percent choice it's just like the kusi so you can't buy wine from the cousin wow this color is terrible there's some big light coming in okay we'll have to deal with it and whoever was watching yesterday because we didn't have youtube because i had a new phone so everything was off of zoom and zoom was terrible the sound was okay but the video once in a while jumped in and there therefore the byron hirsch i'm asking you to write a nice review say it was one of the best shirum of all time just the the zoom is terrible okay anyway so when you buy wine from acoussi you cannot he tells you he they always say it's mice trump some issues cause they took jerusalem isis right when they buy fruit and vegetables and they show from every store yeah they took turmeric some ices but they don't so that's why you have to take turmeric some mysteries but he didn't have a cleat to put it in so he put the true semesters in the actual battle they said when it's left over that will be troublesome fine says marvel because but review himself is concerned about the breaking of a battle you just said he's not concerned he's only saying that there's no breira again brayer means that there's a retroactive understanding of where the maeser is valmiktani say for um all these tanayim including rabbi huda attack ruby mayor and they tell him i don't understand something remember how could you take the true muslim meisters and put it into the wine bottle what if the wine bottle breaks open and you won't have any troublesome meisters to give to the cayenne and then it comes out then you ate tavel which is a here of miso choice are you drinking tables and answers them like i'm not concerned when it explodes we'll deal with it in other words the chances are so slim doesn't it's not supposed to concern you mikhail says the gemara when ramirez says like and they asked him about breaking of the battle shalom i wasn't kidding when i told you chicago iraqis i wanted you to see it by yourself oh yeah come on come here come here yeah it's a little now you know why i was complaining we're not going to turn this thing around it's great for coming all the way for me to stroll no i'm the shotgun this is the shotgun the shotgun hey everybody thanks for coming all the way from roma became unbelievable you can't but i have to get you some food we're almost done we're almost done we're almost done yeah i just got an email about you today that when i said that you have a source as if as if everything uh as every time that you wanted to turn tire it has turned he had somebody brought it right it's great i'll read it one day says so you see and by the way yesterday when rib schmoe brazil walked in i had no clue but emma's had no idea and what's amazing is i was thinking to myself as i was learning oh we're talking about a tree house a sook in the house and i was thinking about the whole story should i say it darling already knows the story i was thinking so i wish brazil would be here and tell everybody look it's a true story he doesn't make up his mices okay hashem so at the end of the day when we review the ask for mayor review as for mayor but but the battle is going to explode so that means review the beliefs and explosion in exploding battles says the gemara he doesn't he doesn't believe in it how some of you do they call male 1 leslie i personally hope that there's no breira you cannot retroactively decide what was the truman meister ella but you you're the mayor the espero who says there's reroll yeah don't you agree that there's a problem that another problem okay you hold there is bray ray you can do retroactive room or some mices what about a simple problem what if the bottle breaks and the wine disappears and the wine is no longer available for chromosomes and on daddy answered i'll worry about it then it's not going to happen okay another question what about the fact that according to review though we're not concerned about death well we're not concerned somebody's going to die why not but none in my favorite miser you remember my favorite no that's my favorite act yeah yuma yuma the first daf and you must have base what does it say it says that acquaint godo must be married and if a god that loses his wife i am kipper his avoid is apostle so what do we do we get him a reserved wife that's why we get a reserved wife here come sit sit next to me what are you doing over there once it once you hear it come all the way into the face maybe you're awesome yeah there it is okay it's okay they say i'm an attention speaker okay says the amaro but you're still on the screen here confirmation strong makes me crazy he came all the way from israel all right says the gemara but we're distracting everybody they're trying to learn torah and it's like there's a lot of editing today so you hear the shy law why do i get a cayenne why do i get a cayenne a reserved wife i put her on what's the word stand by stand by wife very good why do i put a stand by wife because maybe the goddess wife is going to die you hear the shia latak you're up but you got to listen i have four guys here in chicago one of them is on his phone texting what is going on here hashem listen to this the coin goblin needs a wife why does he need a wife he's married because maybe she's going to die so what do we do we put a stand by wife you believe this the whole thing that's right that base very good you're paying attention so that means the review though is questions for me so he's concerned that maybe he's gonna someone's gonna die in an hour so he says i'm not concerned about this guy i'm not concerned that the wall of your sukkah is gonna die right you learned to study on the plane the the sookie with the the animal bingo you put a stand by wife story because maybe she will die so very simple question says we already explained oh my rav will be ready to be sure the reason is ma loss it's for all of clyde's soul to have a comparison we went crazy we went out of our way maybe maybe someone's gonna die in a typical case i'm not concerned that somebody sukkah that's made out of an animal the animal's going to die but in for caparra that kaiser if she's dead there's no capara it's a big problem for clydesdale not to have a capper that young kipper great bailey thomas what's the concern little amanda said yesterday that we're concerned that the wall is going to drop dead it's an animal it's going to die or another concern is it might run away what does that mean these are concerns of their abundant concerns a concern means it's only in the rabbana in other words midday raisa is a hundred percent good wall if so as the gomorrah tamale elemental mayor so if so i could understand a mother you want to put a a camel by a mother the whole mother is the rabbanan the problem of movie is the rabbana the the reason why i put up a lucky is there a button so the rabbit said don't use an animal you want to talk about asuka fine are going to make xero and say you should be mocked but not to use an animal but by saying that this doesn't work a goyle covering a grave with an animal and you're going to tell me the animal is not tummy that's a cooler hakam don't have the right to make it cool they have a right to make a homura even the rice if this works if the wall is a good wall just said don't use that circle fine they can be mahm on you but if the wall is a good wall and the ceiling is a good ceiling they can't say this doesn't work and this is not tommy it is tommy miraisa how could they take away the tumor says retirement that needs breath needs air to survive is not a majito so if an animal that breathes it's not a majitsa in other words it's only standing here because of some supernatural power that infused in its life then it's not a mojito something that you have control over it's a machine this is a little different that if it's a mojito that could be made by man no no no no no no obvious means foreign that's what we said yesterday and uh so an elephant because we were talking about it that's why i saw the picture of the elephant elephant is that that's not the problem but according to this it's a problem why it has to immediately it has to stand an animal is not going to fall over from the wind that's not what we're talking about animals very strong you ever saw an elephant blow over by a wind a horse so the point is it has to stand it if it needs air it needs to breathe it's not a mojito that's all it's saying here so made by a goyle also this needs air it's not a mojito over it's not standing over its covering it needs it needs breath ignoring but some say a little different and there's enough you know some say kosovo if it's not made through humans an animal obviously is not made by a human being it cannot be what about a wall made out of stone it could be made out of human it could a human could take it and create it whatever so that's why that's a good mojito might be now but what's the difference between the two shot them that it needs oxygen versus it it was not it was not made created by hashem over here you see me first what it means if you take a balloon you make them like we had uh in miami all those balloons the mdy shape of balloons so that is breath very interesting since it has it's full of oxygen it's not a good mojito you cannot make a mojito made out of hot air balloons sorry lima that's made out of balloons it's full of air it's not considered but if the problem is that it's not made by human beings this was blown the ear was blown into the balloon and everything through human intervention and therefore it's a wonderful mojito sponsored base by the md white hill group for all those who need shidduchim refusing yeshua's please join the hilum.8.com omar yeah you don't write on an animal you don't take a cow and write a get to a woman and give her the cow my time is there every second what's the reason safer in the elo safer how do i know that i could write a get on a microwave and give it to to the wife come on because of law because it says safer so i think it has to be like a safer tire like a parchment or something but that you cannot put it on anything on a plastic on a on on a glass whatever it is because of law you write it to her me call malcolm on any object what is the significance of the word safer so it cannot be food and it cannot be something that has life in it so therefore says review you cannot write a get on an animal and you cannot write a get on an apple vera it's not telling you on what to write to get it's telling you what is a get a get oh boy great see the source i have here i need you here here take a look at this phone meanwhile for some reason it's not downloading the the youtube app it's already a day okay so again be safer this is the law safety crisis is not telling you where it's written it would say it was written in a book but since it says safer it's just separate dvaram you have to write 12 lines and this is what it sells it says in the get the tire is telling you what it what it what what has to be written in the guest but not on what it's written has money can't buy everything some people that's happiness to them whatever you cannot buy a get or be guys your wife with money why why would i think you could sake i would think because of this possum that the get this the puzzle right before it talks about a get you give you the wife again and says she leaves welcome she can marry somebody else so there's a there's a a heck is between yeti leaving and and going into a new marriage and i think that that hekish tells me that you could divorce a woman with money now it's working how do you do that magic i needed you yesterday so there you have it that safer the turret tells us you could only divorce a woman with a get with a parchment with a paper whatever but it has to be written there is a completely ice foreign how do you know that you cannot divorce a woman with money mercedes crystals nafkalay safer carso vane dover agriculture okay it has to be a safer that that's queries that is curious means to sever the relation through a safer through a book through writing and that's it so this is the famous gemara that when you give a get it has to be a full severance it has to be a complete detachment there's no connection between the husband and wife anymore in any way i believe said once that the letters get gimmel tess are never found in the torah together is that him is it khan kanewski you'll never find those two first of all the word get is not in the torah it's safe for christos it's crisos but gimmel and tess are two letters that never ever go together i heard another shot another thing that i did here i hope you can understand this the word i don't know who says this but togetherness between the yud and the comes the letter tess and between the word being dal comes the letter gimel together it's get togetherness are separated by these two words of get i don't know says that one hey everyone naturally this yeah so if somebody says i'm giving you a divorce on the condition on condition that you never ever drink wine so what's gonna happen he's she's always connected to him by this wine not drinking every time she wants to drink a cup of wine she remembers her old husband or ex and that's not a crisis that's not a severance but actually wow what a that's a big one never go back to the schwarz house the shrieker's house he gets everybody there so it's not a good get a decreases however if he says coachella miyam if it's only if it has a limit to it it's only for 30 days high raise increases then it does work why even though right now there's no creases right now they are attached through the snipe but since eventually this now is going to go away so it's considered increases today as well now the idol we already he already used say for christos that you cannot get divorced with money so how does he know this halacha mikhail is christos nafco it says chrysos it could say just caress could shorten the word from the fact that the terror used a longer word i'm using it for two jurashas vidal cars creases like directions this we have many times in shas i don't it's not true the third couldn't have used the word cars it doesn't fit in well crisis is the proper way to say it and therefore i can't use it for two drushes says the official mishnah the halogen mishna the official mission is sponsored by official illinois if a person makes a sukkah between trees and the trees act as the walls now the bottom of the sukkah is not on a tree that was the other mishna this mission is telling us where the bottom of the sook is on the ground what is the sukkah now the walls are from trees it's a big difference because now we're not using the tree in the same way before if the tree was gone whatever you have to go climb the tree you have to get there you might rip a branch this is different not a tree house tree a wall that cannot stand in a common wind of the ground anyway it's not considered that we had yesterday how does that fit into our mission if you create a circle made out of trees it's kosher the cause of asia the trees move back and forth now if you look in the mushroom i don't have mr with me but on top rich lamin i think it was sifud if we learn the whole maserta and we can fix one issue i i think that one issue should be these flimsy sukkahs that people put up made out of tarps if we just learn one alaka from this homosexual maybe that should if the wall moves you know it happens to be maybe it can be something it says what it means is that it lifts it up and a goat could come underneath it and that's the prob okay but initial it doesn't say that says in the remembering if it just moves and i think i once saw more than a tefak or more than three two i don't remember it was more than i could not i remember seeing there was a certain amount yeah it's not like one finger breath but the issue there is definitely an issue of a tarp moving in the wind and that's not a mojito and the answer for that is either build a wall out of wood and those lighter suckers whatever they call the plant whatever or put straps in every less than three falcons so you have a lover that doesn't move where a boy said maybe this year should be the year that would get rid of these flimsy sukkas baka azim also has the gemara the the tree is moving so what if it's moving so what if your tarp is moving well it passes the sukkah it's not a good sugar if you have a tarp aka my skin on percussion we're talking about older trees the ones in california a thousand years old they don't budge so we don't have a problem but if it budges you know even even the world trade center budged right they build these skyscrapers they literally move a couple of feet but something really old and and tough doesn't move like a knife but what about all the leaves and all the branches that do move what if the suk is made out of that the labor hoods of the dafno and the the the shogunate of the macabre brings us also that if you have one of these tarpy kind of sukkahs he calls it a sheet whatever right you we make such a set of sheets you have to put in these hoods of adapter you have to add wood to it small pieces whatever it is but something sturdy that doesn't move y'all came in the memorial okay so you may just took out of a tree and the branches are are all tied down and they have all this tough stuff in it and nothing's moving so what's the why is it different than building a sucker in a house everything's tied down oh because we're talking about a tree and the tree is also to go on on chavez and another so i'm concerned that if my wall is a tree i'm going to use it on on yante is not a problem tashma when it comes to i don't know if you need to see this picture here's the picture of futsa daphna it's tied down with these poles or whatever it is but pizza's not moving going back to the allah of passability here pulled out this picture from shabbos you have a well smack in the middle of which you surround them the well is and everything around us was a rabbit so if i want to drink i want to give my my kid to drink i want to give my animal to drink how do i get them to drink how could i move water from or should say after the rabbit so the eights of their abundance said is i create these four walls called doom them each side is one ammo wide and we we vision it as if it's filled in we fill in the gaps halal quickly we go from here to here and becomes this entire area becomes we discussed it yesterday we discussed it many times in this and in chats so hayao elon what if instead of this l-shaped bracket you have a tree oh god or offense or another type of need it works you could you could use it as a human says so over here you see that you can use a treat i did it in a way that it's not moving it's sturdy and therefore i can use it here's the picture let's say i have a willow tree i don't like this picture so much because willow trees whatever fine different time we'll print it out a guy has a tree like a willow tree that comes down and creates a lot of i when we learned to sow you had a nice willow tree not today but you get the idea the idea is that i'm using the covering of a tree to create my its own resources if there's less than three it's welcome between the branches in the ground methadone i can use it as a inside am i but these are branches and branches move in the wind look at this he tied it down you can see tied it down here's an enlargement tied it down everything is not movable if so why is there a limitation to the amount of amis i could carry alola if if you have a resource that's a carmelus it's like it's not livable it's just a place for for a storage whatever it's called the carmelus and that has a limit of how much you're carrying it you can only carry two saw so time tucson why is there a limit why can't i view this as a rush says who uses this this is made for a watchman and what is the watchman using it for to watch something on the outside he doesn't want to live on the inside he needs it for the outside so anytime that this is as far we had already in ireland and that's why it's limited to tusa rabbus i have a wonderful shabbos and or sunday great i'm on you forgot to look over here how long is it on pause and visual at 11 15 chicago time for all four of the chicago's that comes to share and no monster shots there'll be more people let's see if shop is here yeah oh i'm gonna give it probably in the hotel yeah so two people there okay so no live share in chicago they don't appreciate it anyway so we'll give it yeah no sunday we have to figure it out we'll we'll discuss over chavez a good and travis everybody you