Erev Shabbos Chanukah: The Mishna Berura's Recommendation

this torah class is brought to you by torahanytime.com okay i want to share with you just uh one indian in halacha regarding minha on arab shabbas chanukah and then light so the question is why why should one first dive in minha and then light certainly we do that the rest of the week but that's because the rest of the week we want to light when it's dark so we would have to dab in first but arab shabbos we're lighting when it's light why would we have to uh what would the indian be to david minha first so basically there are two shot them found in the acharyanam the sharat seyon says that the reason to first dive in minha says if you don't dial menha first it looks a little bit like tarty the sansari why would it be atari disastery it says because um if you're lighting the menorah before shikiya which is in general one should not do so one has to light them in around the nighttime so how could you light luminara before shikiya so but the other one collide the menara from mi plague from but that means you're establishing and you're being kaiveya that plaga minha is already nighttime so establishing you can then go in in the night time therefore says the shadow and it is preferable to first dive in and then you're going to light the menorah the plague however the shaoxin says this is all when it's possible now why does the shark see and say that why is this humra only when it's absurd one should have no alternative meaning one should be muhoy of tadavan minha first well if it's tarty the safsri then even if it's iaf sure the answer is many say that one could make the case that on arab shabbos they were not kovaya to light the menorah and the night tongue they allowed one to light during the day because uh arab shabbos you don't have an alternative so it could be that arab shabs you don't have to light in the nighttime but there's another swara found in the ahraem and this sarah is um mentioned the shardshua in the shari cuba from the berkeley yosef in the name of rav shmuel abbouhav was one of the godly italian where he says another reason to be mocked the tidal minha before alakaz and that is because since the lighting of the menorah is the zekha to the minority and the mikdash and in the mikdash first they brought the talmud shobein harabayim which is and then they let the menorah so therefore in order for it to be azekah to the mikdash one should first light once your first minha and then light the banana so these are the two swaras in the acronym to the extent that the contemporary game rabble yahshua zaman discussed what's better is it better to dive and be a hideous after hadlock in other words it's better to decide this before the hadlock is or to dive in with the minion after and they say no it's uh it's still dabbing with the menu a minion supersedes the indian of uh davening minha before hadlock is but nevertheless the fact they discussed the shaila we see that the indian is something to consider as the missionary concludes before they light the menara you've just experienced another torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com