Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
The title of today's class is two words,
the sleepers
in Hebrew, Hayesim.
Today's class is dedicated
by Stanley Frerieded in memory of his
dear wife
Sarah Miriam Basav
in tribute to her first yard site on the
sixth day of Shvat coming up this
Shabas.
Even now a year after her passing the
whole family feels the void of the
warmth and love that she brought into
her home and community.
Her impact will forever be lasting,
impacting many people. Her legacy of
hospitality, generosity, non-judgmental
openness will always be a part of their
lives and the lives of all who knew her.
dedicated with immense love and
gratitude by Yehuda, Usher, Ley, Ben,
Alisa, Elena, Kaim, Freed, and their
families
and may indeed remain an eternal source
of blessing and inspiration and
empowerment. Thank you.
You want the children anyway?
Okay. I said that the title is the
sleepers. So, uh I did it to myself.
Nobody will be able to sleep.
I once heard a rabbi from South Africa
speak about an experience
he had.
If it actually happened or it was just a
joke,
I don't know. I never asked him, but
it's certainly uh pretty funny.
Basically, he would get up every Friday
night in South Africa and Johannesburg
and give his sermon to a very very large
crowd in South Africa. Everybody comes
to shul Friday night, even those who
don't come Shabas day.
Friday night you come to schul. It's
very traditional community in that
sense. And that's when the main sermon
is. So he would get up to give his
sermon and this fellow on the front row
sitting in the front row was older man
his name was Burkowitz the rabbi would
start talking and at some point he would
fall asleep but this was like a sacred
tradition midday shabas bishabat every
single shabas he wouldn't miss a week as
the rabbi was giving his sermon
burkowitz fell asleep and worse began to
snore okay
this went on for many many years
one Friday night the rabbi is walking up
to the pulpit to theender to give his
sermon and guess what he already hears
the snoring and he looks and he sees
Burkowitz is already sleeping and
snoring at this point even the rabbi's
patient sometimes plots he lost it after
years I guess of uh containment and he
says burkowitz I don't understand you
every week you fall asleep after I start
my sermon
You think I'm boring. I have nothing to
say. So, you sleep when I'm talking. But
this week, I didn't even open my mouth
yet. You can't even say it's boring. I'm
walking UP. WHY ARE YOU SLEEPING? Rawitz
looks up and he says, "Rabbi, I trust
you."
The tradition of Jews sleeping
sometimes with eyes closed and sometimes
with eyes open if you're really good at
it. Goes back a very very long time. In
fact, the medish rabbi says in McGill
and Esther that Rabbi no less a
personality of the stature of Rabbi
Ayaka was giving a Shir presentation and
his students snoozed off and fell asleep
to the point that Rabbi Akiva changed
the subject in order to bring them back
to consciousness and that's when he said
his famous teaching why did Esther merit
to govern 127 provinces of the Persian
Empire. during the time of the reign of
her husband and he connected it with
Sara who lived 127 years. You have to
know why Rabaka chose that teaching to
inspire and arouse his audience. But I
guess you see that people fell asleep.
But the point that we're going to
discuss today is a very fascinating and
somewhat enigmatic
that deals with people falling asleep
during the sedar. Now you would say it's
not a it's a reality. If you know how
hard I work for the preparations of PES,
it's very normal that sometimes the
people that work hardest at some point
take a Dremel. They take a snooze or
even a nap during the seder around the
table or somewhere else. And indeed
we'll see that our sages dealt with this
with this question of people falling.
Now you would say what's the question?
They fell asleep. They fell asleep.
Okay. hopefully they'll wake up and
they'll finish. But as it turns out that
the laws here can become very intricate
when it comes to the seder night.
So let's let's go back to the origin of
it. If you open your source sheets and
you go to the opening the first source
in your source sheets and we post the
source sheets on the yeshiva.net. So if
anybody wants to download them later or
print them out or open them on the
computer, they're always there on the
website the yeshiva.net. net, but you
have it printed out here.
And I guess somebody's doing
construction right the middle of my
class this morning, so
we won't fall asleep.
The PK says in this week's paras
peric yud mev
Exodus
verse 46.
The Tyra is talking about the Kban Pes.
Let's remember the background.
The first seder night that took place in
Jewish history was the night before the
Jewish people left Egypt.
They left Egypt on the 15th day of
Nissen in the year 2448 since creation.
2448 since creation. On the 15th day of
Nissen, the night before, the night the
eve of the 15th of Nissen, which means
the night after the 14th of Nissen, they
conducted the first sedar in history.
And the staple of that sedar would be
the sheep or the goat that everybody was
instructed to offer on that day on the
14th day of Nissen. And that goat or
sheep would later be roasted.
would be roasted on a fire be a barbecue
grill ales and they would partake of
this meal and this was called the
Passover offering the carbon pes and
this became the tradition every single
of pes the Jewish people were instructed
to bring this offering later of course
it was in the ba mikdash first bd the
second bikdish and this was the staple
of the seder night as we say in our
mik
actually made a sandwich and the
sandwich contained matzah which by the
way was more like a lafa. The Yemenes
still have matzah that is soft. It's
like lafa. So it's actually quite an
impressive sandwich. And in the sandwich
you had pesak, you had lamb chops or
goat meat and you had mr. So that was
like you know the barbecue uh spicy
sauce or lettuce or horseradish and you
and Hill ate them together. That was
what kuruk looked like. Today, of
course, our kur is much more
impoverished. We're left with hard
matzah since most of us are not Yemenes.
We're left with hard matzah and even
stale matzah. And we have some lettuce
inside
and m which is lettuce or horseradish.
But the original sandwich was pes matzah
m. It had the beef. It had the beef. So
at the seda table, you ate the carbon
pes. You say matzah and this was the
first seder.
Now
just got a I want to read a puss.
I'm sorry. What?
You mean what was their whole life?
No, they're marvelous like
four types of herbs. There's one of five
types of herbs. You could use romaine
lettuce or you could use what we used
the horseradish. There's another few
types of of mishn
when introduced this mitzvah to the
Jewish people when they were still in
Egypt. He told this to them in the
beginning of Nissen two weeks before and
he said that every family every home
needs to purchase a sheep or a goat sell
and together families would partake in
the carbon pes the father the mother the
children if there were grandchildren
what happens if there's a small family
it's a nuclear family it's a small
family and you don't have enough people
to be able to consume an entire entire
lamb or an entire goat. So what do you
do? They can join. This was called a
kabura. You joined. He says you join
with your neighbors. You can join with
friends. You can join with relatives.
And you would do the seder together and
eat the carbon together. And indeed this
is how it was done year in year out.
Asal say
the pes offering was not eaten alone.
you had to have a kabur a group of
people and usually it was a large group
I mean depends on how much a person
could eat but there was a family or a
few families together dependent on the
size of the family you know you can have
a family bar that's very large they
don't need other families or you could
join with families and friends and
everybody would subscribe so to speak to
this pes
and they would offer it one person would
offer it on their behalf and then they
ate it together wherever they ate it
they would barbecue it and they would
eat it whether it was indoors or
outdoors and have the seda together.
This was a group. So the pes was eaten
always with a group of people that was
pre-arranged earlier. That's how it was
purchased. That's how it was bought on
behalf of a family or behalf of a few
families, a few neighbors, a few
friends, a few relatives, as much as
they wanted. At least everybody can get
at least a little piece of the carbon
pesk, not big kazaya. So you can even
have a very large group eating it
together. But of course they had other
foods so that people cuz if you had so
if you had a huge family eating the
carbon pes it wouldn't be enough for
everybody to be satisfied. So sometimes
you would have a little bit of that and
you would have another carbon to be able
to satisfy everybody. comes to Pik and
says peric
meter
12 46
chapter 12 verse 46
it should be eaten in one house when
Mosher Rabenu is telling the laws to the
Jewish people about this offering he
says it should be eaten in one househab
do not take out any part of the meat
from the house outdoors.
In other words, it has to remain in the
location that was designated for eating
the pes. And then
you're also not allowed to break a bone.
Rashi says, "What does it mean?
It should be eaten in one house. You
shouldn't take it out." He says, "It
means
a it has to remain in the group that was
designated to eat it.
Don't, for example,
split the group into two and say, "Okay,
you guys will eat half of it somewhere
and we'll eat the other half of it."
Okay?
Don't do it.
So, that includes also that includes one
element.
You have to stick to your you have to
stick to your group. Now let's see the
next source.
This is the track they dedicated to PES.
Say our sages.
You might think that a person eating the
pes should eat it in two places. So for
example, I start my karum pes in my
house and then I want to go to your
house
and and and continue the meal there.
Maybe I'll even bring my meat to your
house and eat it in two places.
That's why the says no stay in your one
house
from here. They derived an interesting
what's the
if the shamish ate a kazayas kazayas is
the volume of an olive of the pes
offering
near the oven
if he's smart
he should fill his stomach from it
says
and if the group wants to help him they
could come and sit near him. What does
this mean? So Rashi says
you have the shamish the waiter or the
chef
he was in charge on the barbecue. So he
was roasting it.
He forgot.
He put in aaz into his mouth
and he was part of this group.
So if he's smart, he should make sure to
fill up his stomach with it
because if he gets up from there and he
goes into another place, he won't be
able to continue eating it because the
pes has to be eaten in one place. You
have to remember that in the olden days
many houses maybe most houses only had
one room. It's not like today a house
can have barak many bedrooms. Even if
you go to visit old houses in America
the way they were 150 200 years ago
you'll see if a house had more than two
rooms it was a big kadesh. A house had
one room. It's interesting how they
lived. You know you can have uh eight
people sleeping on one bed mattress if
you're familiar how it worked.
life was different. So when the TA says
it should be eaten in one house, Kazal
understood it also means in one room
because often a house had one room. So
they said you can't even take it from
one room to another room. You want to go
upstairs. You take the car, YOU WANT TO
GO UPSTAIRS, continue eating upstairs.
That was not allowed.
You could designate a room, but that's
where you have to eat. If you're eating
here, this is where you eat.
Even to go to another room in the same
house was forbidden because it says
so that's why this shamish who forgot
and he's starving. So he's by the
barbecue and he starts eating. He now
can go back in and eat over there cuz
that would be a different location. So
the whole group could come to him and
they could make this the place. That's
fine. They could eat outside by the
barbecue or he could just eat whatever
he's eating over there because in the
new place he won't be able to eat.
But since you can't take it outside the
house,
huh?
That's
if the place is in the house.
If the if the meal starts in the house,
right? If the carbon basic has eaten in
the dining room. Yeah. I can't say,
"Okay, let's go now continue on the
porch or let's go to our next door as a
neighbor or let's go outside or let's go
upstairs or let's go to the basement or
let's go to the living room." You get
it? You stay in one place.
But you didn't start at the
Yes. We could designate a room. You want
we want to sit uh we want to sit in what
in a room that's the fine but once if
this is the meal of the carbon basic you
can't take it outside and continue
outside or from outside inside
now this was night time so people ate in
the house especially this is the night
of Egypt mak so they had to stay in the
house usually pes was a different
situation but this carbon pes remember
was different because they had to stay
in the house this was unique you
understandly
you can eat it wherever whatever you
want in one place. But that year they
had to stay in the house because outside
was the plague of the makas of the death
of the firstborn and they quarantined
themselves in their house
and they put blood right on the muzus on
the two temples of the door and on the
roof of the door they put the blood of
the carbon pes but that was unique for
that year that didn't happen again.
Okay. Now
there was a special then Allah to leave
the house till the morning
that was that year.
Now what's the logic behind this? Is
there a logic? So the mafam explain that
this is all part of the idea of freedom.
When a king sits down for a meal or a
queen sits down for a meal or a prince
sits down for a meal, they don't run
around from the kitchen to the dining
room to the living room. Right. Royalty,
aristocracy. Yeah. I don't take a
sandwich and go upstairs and downstairs,
right? In a more
it's more of a what's the right word?
Royalty.
It's a less dignified way of eating
where I'm holding my sandwich or my
potato chips and I'm running from here.
Royalty. The way of eating aristocracy
is you sit down in one place and this is
your place
to be served.
Huh?
And you expect to be served bring the
food.
Yeah. That's why you have children.
So since
everyone is a we so to speak reenact the
experience of liberty and freedom and
emancipation. So the dictates that
everyone behaves like a king and a queen
in their own home. So therefore we
establish a place for the PES which
represents the freedom and the night of
freedom and we don't run. We're not
going upstairs. We're not going
downstairs in the middle. We're not
continuing the meal at a friend. We're
not going outside. We're not going to
another room.
This is how many commentators explain
the the rationale or at least one of the
reasons behind this
fine. It seems pretty straight
straightforward and clear.
But from here
from this biblical verse the sages
deduced another very interesting
and let's see how the Rambam phrases it
in his magnumopus of
your third source in the sources
the Rambam and the laws oftal
it and he's basically quoting a Mishna
from the end of
page 120 in Mishna and
I quote
me
if somebody here we go to sleeping if
somebody
who's doing the seder falls asleep in
the middle of eating the carbon pes
I fall asleep it's been a long day or I
should say a long months or a long two
months.
I fell asleep. I was in the middle of my
sandwich
or I was the middle of eating my meat,
my carbon basic and I fell asleep
and then I wake up. Maybe I wake up 5
minutes later, maybe I wake up 45
minutes later. Hopefully, if you're
already sleeping, you know,
do it well.
Fascinating.
I can't continue eating the carbon.
That's it. Stop.
Even though I want to eat more. There's
more on the plate. I didn't finish. The
is you can't eat more. Stop. Move on.
Move on with the sedar.
Why? What's the logic? I fell asleep.
Okay.
Like you left the room.
Huh?
It's like you left the room.
So this is very interesting. What the
sages understood is there is physical
relocation and there's mental
relocation.
When I fell asleep, it's like I left the
room. Not physically, I didn't leave the
room. I stayed in one place the whole
time. I have a very comfortable chair. I
didn't want to leave the room. But
mentally, I left the room. I wasn't
present. I wasn't conscious. When a
person is asleep, they're in the room
physically, but they're in their own
world. They're not in a relation with
the table, with the people, with the sed
with. So when I fell asleep in the
middle of the meal and then I awake and
I want to continue eating, it would be
considered as I'm eating it in a new
location
just like if I take the meat and I go to
your house and I want to continue eating
it, I'm not allowed to. It says
so if I go to sleep for half an hour or
an hour and I wake up and now I continue
eating it, it's like I'm eating the
carbon pes in a new location again. Not
a new physical location, but a new
mental location.
In other words, it's not a continuum of
the first meal. The first meal was
interrupted. And now I'm beginning a new
meal following my slumber. What's wrong
with beginning a new meal? Nothing wrong
with beginning a new meal. But the
problem is with a carbon pes, you could
begin a new meal because you can eat 10
meals. You could fall asleep 10 times.
But with the pes
the says you can't have two meals
[Music]
right it has to be one meal in one place
so even though this is the same place
but it's like a new suda it's like I
went to a new place and I'm continuing
and I'm not continuing I'm creating a
new suda so this is what the kazal
understood that just like when I go to a
different home I can't continue eating
the offering because this this is not
considered a continuation but it's a new
meal in a new phase. So even if I'm in
the same space but I fell asleep in the
middle of the meal, the first meal came
to an end and when I awake it's
disconnected from the previous one.
Hence I stop eating the Passover
offering. Now the question is does this
have any relevance today. Today we don't
do the carbon pes and the answer is it
has a lot of relevance today and that is
at a time when many people fall asleep.
It's called the Afi.
It's been a long night. Now, I know many
people have different types of sedars.
There are seders that go fast. There are
seders that don't go fast. There are
people who like to hear themselves
during the sedar and they want everybody
else to hear them. They prepare a lot a
lot of insights and lectures and
speeches. Some of you know about those
durim and by the time you hit the you
are done or somebody at the table is
done maybe not you you're the matriarch
but some people are done and they fall
asleep
voluntary or involuntary right
once Winston Churchill was sitting in
the British Parliament. He was a very
sharp man and he had he had a sharp
tongue and somebody was talking and the
person was so monoton you know Churchill
had away with words but this person
didn't have away with words and they
there was very very monotonous and they
were going on and on and on and on and
Winston Churchill fell asleep and he was
a big fellow and when he slept you can
hear it and see it
so this person got very offended and
said Mr. Churchill,
do you have to sleep in the middle of my
presentation? He says, I don't have to.
It's completely voluntary.
[Music]
So whether it's voluntary or whether
it's voluntary or involuntary,
the person fell asleep. So let's see the
next
So the way he phrases the
laws of PE
section
478 and this is based on the discussion
in the T and the
and the commentaries of the because
there are a few opinions about this but
this is the that most of the authorities
embrace. Take a look.
This is the addresses laws that didn't
apply in the time of the B mikdash only.
It addresses laws that apply timelessly
even in the time of exile. The Rambam
addresses all the even of Msiah and of
the Bik. But the only addresses that are
relevant in today's time. That's the
difference. The Rambam included all even
those that are not relevant today
because you don't have a B mik. Today we
have the why do we eat an we already ate
matzah. You remember the system of the
seder is after you wash a second times
you do matzah. We make we make a matzah
and we eat matzah and then you eat m and
then you eat and then you eat a sandwich
and then finally we come to the
delicious egg which tastes better than
ever and we begin
right and when we finish the meal you
have the fish you have the soup you have
the chicken whatever you're serving
dessert I'm not going to ask you what
you serve for dessert for pes because I
know that the standards of dessert go
from uh pizza to ice cream to cheesecake
to uh oranges or nothing.
But whatever your dessert is, now it's
time for the because after the we're not
going to eat anything,
right? The word comes from two words, a
combination of two words.
Bring out the dessert, bring out the
meal is is nutrition meal means bring
out.
We say in the the mission says
which means we do not continue eating
after we eat. Why? What do you care if
you continue eating? What if after the
seder you want to eat? I don't know why
but some people the answer is because
the was introduced for a particular
reason. It's a direct commemoration of
the carbon pes. The carbon pes used to
be eaten at the end of the meal because
he didn't want people starving when they
ate the carbon pes. Why? Because again
royalty
doesn't fess forgive me right
aristocrats they're not so starving that
they have to jump on the food so the
carbon pes was eaten after the meal so
people weren't
obsessed with the food they can eat it
calmly and nicely
they were already I'm not going to say
satiated in our terms American term
satiated means you can't breathe then
satiated meant you ate a little bit so
your stomach wasn't going crazy it's not
What today satiated? Satiated means
today after nine courses you can't
breathe anymore. You feel like you're
having a heart attack.
You shut down emotionally. That's called
satiated. If not I'm not satiated. I'm
starving. It's like I'm fasting for 3
days. But then before before a lot of
things happened sati mean my stomach is
not you know rumble. Yeah. It's not
rumbling from the pangs of of of
starvation. And then they ate the carbon
bas. After the carbon pes you didn't eat
another meal because they wanted the
taste of the carb should linger with the
person throughout the evening. Okay.
Today we don't have a carbon pes so we
eat a is a special matzah that of course
we put away in the beginning of the and
our children discover it
and we eat it. So that's why that has a
very special place in Jewish tradition
and Jewish law and Jewish ritual cuz
this is what we're eating as a
commemoration for the sheep and the the
lamb or the goat that was eaten. We
don't have the lamb or the goat. We're
not doing a carbon. So we eat.
So that's why when you eat
came the authorities and they said the
same laws that the terra says about the
carbon pes we apply also to the
and now we'll understand
fifth source if you fall asleep in the
middle of eating the
I FALL ASLEEP 20 MINUTES LATER an hour
later
I wake
I can't eat anymore.
Even if I didn't yet eat the volume of
an olive of my I understand if a person
already ate a big portion of the and
they fall asleep, you're done. Fine.
Move on. But I did. I just I just began.
I took a little piece. Not even a
kazayas. I fell asleep. I wake up. I
want to continue.
The is you don't continue. Why?
Because sleeping is considered an abrupt
interruption. An interruption between
one meal and between the first eating
and the second consumption.
So if I now continue eating after my
sleep,
it's like I went to another location
and I CONTINUED EATING NOT IN THE first
location
[Applause]
and it's forbidden to eat in two
locations. If I'm sitting in my dining
room and eating, I can't go to your
house to continue eating, either mine or
yours or go to another room in my house.
And sleeping again, as we learned, is
like going to a new place. The second
meal is like in a new place in a new
mental location. It's not a continuation
of the first one. And the says the pes
has to be eaten in one location.
And therefore we apply it also to the
afika.
Okay, straightforward. So if you're
going to sleep, do it before the
afikiman. Do it after the kimon or make
sure you ate enough of your afan to fall
asleep.
Now here comes a fascinating
disclaimer or qualification
and that is this only applies to corona.
This only applies to a corona seder.
What it what does it mean? What does it
mean? Let's see next source.
And let me say it before so you'll
understand the source. This law applies
only if you're holding your seder alone.
We know 2020
corona broke out. When was it a week
after purim? You remember March 2020 and
many people including some of our
parents or grandparents or relatives or
friends
held the seda literally alone. Literally
alone in the house. There was not one
other person at the seda table.
When did this happen?
How did they know about corona?
You think corona invented corona?
The black plague.
The black plague is the 1300s. This is
Yeah. Listen, there were there were
people alone. Yeah. Throughout history,
unfortunately.
So here's the if you're eating the
Passover offering or the in a group
setting as most of us do with
and remember the pes you had to eat.
Today technically you're allowed to have
the seder alone. It's not comfortable
but if you really want to you could
you're allowed to sit yourself at the
sedar.
Yeah. You'll ask yourself the manishama
which is fine. We talk to ourselves
anyway. However, in the when they had
the carbon pes, it was a mitzvah to have
more people. So, if it's with a group,
now the is that if he or she falls
asleep
after they awake, they could continue
eating as long as one member or few
members in the group stayed awake after
eating also.
No, stayed awake. Smoozing, singing,
eating, whatever they're doing. Even if
many members of the group fell asleep,
you have a group of 20 people,
15 of them FELL ASLEEP, MAYBE MOST of
them fell asleep. And it's not uncommon
if you say there is not ending. It's not
uncommon. As long as some members of the
group stayed awake, everybody can resume
the meal when they awake. Let's see it
inside.
This is a mission at the end of track.
on. If part of them fell asleep,
when they get up, they can eat. COOL ON.
IF everybody fell asleep,
if the whole group fell asleep,
now they're all sleeping. They can't
continue eating.
Adds one more point
means you snooze.
You snooze, you lose, you doze off.
Means
you there's two different postures
means you're not fully gone
you may not be you know fully coherent
but if somebody asks you a question you
can answer
means you're schluff I have to wake you
up so he says even if everybody is
snoozing but they didn't fall asleep
mish and they wake up they could
continue but if
now let's see how it's how it's
formulated in
If you fell asleep in the middle of the
carbon and you woke up, you're not
allowed to continue eating.
But if you had members of a group and
part of them fell asleep in the middle
of the meal,
even those who fell asleep when they
wake up, they could continue eating.
If everybody fell asleep, the whole
table and then they wake up then they
can
if they just snoozed off they could wake
up and continue to eat the carbon and
he's going to apply it to our days.
Let's see how he formulates it.
When was it set that if you fall asleep
in the middle of and you wake up you
can't continue eating it even if you
just ate a tiny piece in the beginning
if you're sitting alone
group sitting together
and some of them fall asleep in the
middle of and they wake up
they can all continue jump right back
into the meal
Even if they ALREADY ATE A KAZAYAS, WHY?
WHY? YOU JUST TOLD ME THAT if you fell
asleep, you interrupted the first meal
and the new meal is like in a new
location. The answer is
there. Sleeping is not considered
interruption of the first meal. Why? I
fell asleep
because part of their
part of their part of their word comes
from like a group remained awake.
But if everybody ta fell asleep then
indeed
they won't be able to continue eating.
The logic I think is very clear. If I'm
eating in your company even if I fell
asleep my meal has not been interrupted.
You know why? Because we're in this
together. We're in cahoots and you're
still part OF THE MEAL. I'M NOT. I left
to a different world. I checked out for
an hour but you didn't check out. She
didn't check out. He didn't check out.
Whoever is there as long as somebody
some of the people or somebody is awake.
So now when I resume consciousness I'm
not starting A NEW MEAL. SHALOM. Welcome
to America. I jump right back into THE
GAME BECAUSE YOU KEPT THE chair so to
speak warm. You kept the meal going even
though I wasn't there because I fell
asleep. So the fact that I took a nap
for an hour, maybe even more, doesn't
mean my meal has seized. Why? Because
I'm not alone. I'm part of a and this
meal was never interrupted by me falling
into the sleep in sleep because the is
there. Of course, if the entire group
eating the kimon if everybody fell
asleep, then indeed the meal got
interrupted because there's nobody
keeping the chairs. They're keeping the
cheers warm but they're not uh they're
not awake. So then they cannot continue
eating the
and then he makes the difference in the
next between
andu between taking a little snooze and
really falling into asleep and that's
the distinction. Now
at first glance when we read these
They seem extremely technical. They're
really dealing with a very technical
situation. Somebody who's eating, he's
tired, she's tired. You fall asleep. Can
you continue eating and not eating?
That's on on on one level.
Very very technical in a particular
situation. And the truth is in most
situations it wouldn't even apply
because as I said, we had it during
Corona. But how often does it happen
that a person is at a sedar alone
without anybody else without any ben the
time of the bikdash and today when
you're eating the
it happens but it's certainly not very
common.
Yeah, the B mikdash you wanted it
finished. You did not want to leave over
the carbon pes and after the next
morning it was called nicer and the meat
would have to be burnt. So you wanted it
should be eaten at least you try.
Sometimes things happen, you know, a
person gets sick or a person can't eat
whatever. But you tried whatever you can
to eat it up and that's why you had to
have more people for a person to eat the
whole lamb
is is is difficult and the says you
should try to eat it with other people.
It's a question of not but certainly
according to everybody we try to have
other people. The pes is eaten by it's
the one carbon where you want dafka
dka group. So that's why it wasn't a
very common but still the discusses this
because it can happen and discusses all
situations even if they're remote and in
our times we saw that it was actually
quite quite quite relevant and practical
but it seems like a very technical
situation very technical question what
is more
as I was once teaching this to my
students we were learning and somebody
said you know why does everything have
to be stretched so much The Tyra says
eat the pes in one house. Leave it by
that. Leave it by that. So one house
became one room. Okay, I can understand
most houses had one room. Okay, but now
it means even if I'm in the same room, I
can't fall asleep. So the kazal
stretched it from physical location to
mental location. Okay, because it's
considered a new meal. And now they have
all these qualifications. If it's with a
group and not a group, how much I'm
sleeping?
So yeah, it all makes sense. But the
kazal really need to stretch it AND THEN
THEY STRETCHED IT TO THE T IS NOT
TALKING about is talking about the
carbon
has an expression
it's a stringency some people say it
doesn't apply to the is only a
commemoration for the carbon do we have
to apply every last intricacy but
we say it does apply to
the vagon writes he has a amazing
commentary on safer mish
on the book of proverbs.
It's a beautiful beautiful commentary by
the vagon
was written by one of his students what
he heard from his teacher's
which means your source should be
blessed and the source here means
according to most commentators the
procreative power of a person to
generate to create a new generation
that's called the muk
and rejoice with the woman of your
youth. So he's really blessing him that
their their marriage and relationship
should be blessed and and full of joy
and powerful and the source the father
and the mother should be blessed should
be able to produce a generation of of
healthy and wholesome and happy
children.
The vagon says like every puss and mish
it's about wisdom and about learning.
There's also the words are metaphoric
for a for for another layer
and he says
and this is a very famous principle very
famous principle has generally two
layers
it's called and
in it's called
the body of tra and the soul of terra
What does it mean? The goof is concrete.
You could see my body. It's tangible.
It's physical. It's practical. It's
concrete. The body concretizes the soul.
A soul without a body
exists, but it's transcendent. It's
elusive. It's nebulous.
The body concretizes it, giving it a
physical vehicle.
When a person finishes their mission on
earth, the soul doesn't die. It's rather
unplugged.
Unplugged is a much more accurate
definition. When a refrigerator is
plugged into the wall, the electricity
flows through the refrigerator so that
it can cool the food. When somebody
unplugs the refrigerator, the
electricity doesn't die. Electricity
doesn't die. It returns back to its
source. The refrigerator now is not
processing the electricity, but
electricity doesn't die. When a person
is physically alive, the soul's
electricity is being processed through
the body.
Like a phone that's plugged in, like a
computer that's plugged in, like an air
conditioner that's plugged in.
When a person finishes their mission on
Earth, the soul doesn't die. It's just
the body is not manifesting the
electricity of the soul. When a person
is alive, the body concretizes. It
brings down the soul into a physical
vehicle. The soul has vision. But
pre-birth and after death, the soul
doesn't use the eye to have vision. And
therefore, its vision is infinite.
The soul could see from one end of the
world to the other end of the world. It
sees things on a different level because
it doesn't have the limits of the body.
In the body, it's concretized through
the body. So when the zer says
is compared to the organism of a person
there's the n of there's the of the body
of
is the way is concretized in law
tradition and ritual and just like the
body is made up of a very very complex
and intricate system comprised of 50 or
more trillion cells each cell has its
unique place and position and function
within a healthy organism to make it
work. And every body is comp every
single body is comprised of the building
blocks of matter that make up the body
all the way to the levels of limbs and
organs and senus and bones and arteries
and tissue etc.
The same is true with tira. The body of
TRA is comprised of very very detailed
and intricate nuances and laws and cells
that together make up the living
organism called
the expression.
But the has the soul of this is called
the reason it's called pimiuses because
the soul infuses the go with a deeper
energy and vitality and consciousness
and even though the body the body needs
the soul the soul needs the body. So the
viliggon says
in Mish
want to see the language.
That's Mishapter 5.
The villagon says like this
is the source. The Torah has two layers.
So every law and exists on two
dimensions. One is the body dimension.
The body dimension is understanding its
concrete physical practical
manifestation. For example, this if you
fall asleep in the middle of the carbon
p and you wake up, you can't CONTINUE
EATING IT. THAT'S VERY PRACTICAL. If you
have a group and they're awake, you
could continue. Got it? But you also
have the same law on a soul level.
Meaning the law is addressing something
spiritual and psychological and
emotional transcendent. And the soul and
the body come together. So he says
go back to the source of
because that will be a blessing because
it will give you a depth and a
psychological and emotional relevance by
understanding the inner inner dimension
of every law. Then
then you'll have a new a joy with the
woman of your youth. Meaning when we
start growing up and we learn tra, we
don't start with the soul of Tyra. You
start off with the practicalities. But
when you get into the details, there's a
lot of questions. Did it really is this
is this nuance really so important? Is
this a little too nuanced? Is this a
little too intricate? So he says, but
once you see the muker, once you
understand the spiritual dimension, then
you'll go back to the woman of your
youth. You'll go back to the of your
youth and you'll have a new sim because
suddenly you'll see how every detail is
really a reflection of a spiritual truth
that is concretized through that
particular and what seems like an
insignificant detail really represents a
profound cosmic truth just like every
cell in the body is so significant or
just like every uh every element in the
in the in the genes of a person
in the DNA of a person In every single
cell, you have a double copy of the
genum, which is essentially the genetic
code, which is the manual and the
blueprint of how your organism should
function. And the sequence of the DNA is
so meticulous and precise that if god
forbid there will be even a tiny
alteration in the sequence, it can
create tremendous consequences,
sometimes very catastrophic ones in the
bodies. What's the difference? If this
chemical is before this chemical, if
this letter is before this letter, but
when you when you understand what's
behind it, it's not just a letter. It's
really the letter is a code for an
entire structure, you see how
significant it is.
A simple example would be if you decide
to send me an email and for some reason
you don't have patience, so you take out
the dot from the email.
Rabbi Yway atthe yeshiva.net. You say,
you know what? Who cares about a dot?
Take out the dot. I'm never going to get
your email. So, you'll ask me why. And
the answer is it looks like a dot. For
us dummies who don't know backend
programming, it looks like a dot. But if
you know about back end programming, you
know that that dot captures very
complicated code language.
And in the back end that dot allows you
to connect to a CERTAIN CODE THAT SENDS
YOUR EMAIL THROUGH CYERSPACE. IF NOT,
I'M SORRY. You simply you can't send it.
So on one level it looks like a dot. On
another level if you're the programmer
you understand it's anything but a dot.
It was simplified through a dot.
says when you go back to the mocker to
the source to the backend program of
Judaism
suddenly you will learn that those
insignificant dots are not dots they
have very very profound spiritual cosmic
psychological and emotional meaning not
in an obsessive way but in a holistic
way
because the worst thing to think about a
body is that details don't matter every
detail is an indispensable component to
the healthy organism. Why am I giving
this introduction?
Because that's what we want to now
address
to be able to really appreciate these on
a practical level. Let's go back to
let's see what it means on a source
level because as I said before, it seems
like it's very technical and very
uncommon and ALSO A VERY FAR STRETCH
FROM the original law. It's like we have
to stretch and stretch and stretch.
That's as long as you don't appreciate
the penimius the soul of these
and that's what we want to address
in the remainder of the class.
I was 17 years old. I was a yeshiva ber.
I still remember the date. It was kavis
tshin nun.
That's January 20th of Tavis. January,
it was around January 7, that time of
the year. January 1990, the beginning of
1990. Couple of years ago, not so long
ago, but a couple of years ago.
I was younger than I am today.
That's profound. That's profound.
a little younger than I am still young
but I was a little younger than I am
today
and happens to be the yardet of the
Rambam the Rambam's yard
is
the instituted a raam every day to
finish the whole Mishna either in a year
or three years if you learn three
chapters a day you finish in a year you
learn one chapter you finish in three
years and it's very fascinating Because
is the only work we have that covers all
of is only of today is all of Jewish law
from the mdish from so it's really the
whole body of
that day they were learning
so after might of the spoke and he gave
a presentation of in this ram about the
about the sleeping in the middle of the
and he explained then the ponymous the
internal spiritual energetic etic
dimension of these laws. It was just a
few minutes, very brief and concise, but
I still remember how moving it was for
me. Number one, to be able to perceive
beyond the external layer, to be able to
perceive the inner dimension of the
hala.
Number two, it was a paradigm of how you
have to see. And number three, the
message itself was extremely uh
emotional. The message itself was
extremely moving.
And when we understand that layer then
suddenly we see how all the physical and
technical details are manifestations
of that inner truth.
The seder essentially
the seder of Pesak which is introduced
in paras
essentially represents the eternal story
of the Jewish people.
The journey of the Jewish people is a
journey from Mitim from the exodus of
Egypt all the way till Messiah.
And the seder is that journey of the
Jewish people as they left mitim and
they began their work as God's people to
transform themselves and to transform
the world. And as we say in the
we say
every generation one ought to
reexperience.
Remember all the days of your life. In
other words, the sedu is not a once a
year or once in history. It's a
continuous mitzvah and process of the
Jew to leave Egypt physically,
emotionally, psychologically,
spiritually on our journey from towards
redemptiveness individually and
collectively. Individually and globally,
physically and spiritually. In the
itself, we say
It wasn't in one generation that people
stood up like par to destroy this. But
in every generation there's another
attempt to annihilate the Jewish people.
In other words, the journey of gullis
and continues.
And this seder is when we celebrate the
birth of our people, the birth of our
identity.
in chapter 16 compares to pregnancy to
birth. Hashem says, "I came that night
and you looked like a new baby that
emerged from its mother's womb
without clothes
submerged in blood like a baby coming
out to the world.
You should live in your blood. Your
umbilical cord had to be cut so for that
you could become a nation because you
were almost in the womb of your masters
and you had to be extracted from the
womb and and been given liberty and
autonomy. In other words, pes is the
birth of the Jewish people. The other
holidays are development and indeed it's
fascinating to observe the place that
the seder holds in the lives of many
Jews who don't participate in other
Jewish rituals and tradition. If I'm not
mistaken, even more than Rashana and
Yamiper, the Sedar is the single most
observed Jewish tradition among the
Jewish people, even many millions who
unfortunately are more assimilated or
less affiliated. I believe I saw once I
researched that in Israel, they could
barely find a Jew who didn't participate
in some type of Sedar.
And even in other places outside of
Israel where many Jews even Yam Kipper
won't come to schul but a sed I'm not
going to say everybody has a seder but
the vast majority participate in some
some type of sedar and there's a reason
for it. The reason is because somehow it
touches on identity who you are. It's
not the details. You have, you have
sukus, you have kanak, you have purim,
you have even you have other great and
important days. But somehow the the the
seder is who I am. Who I am. I belong to
this family. I'm a Jew before what it
means to be a Jew. But I'm a Jew. And
that touches most Jews. I'm a Jew. I'm
part of this people. However I interpret
it, however I explain it. And that's
what the seder the seda represents. In
fact, one of the most powerful qualities
of Jewish history is that uninterrupted
story. The fact that we have that memory
and we tell that story every single day.
The same matzah, the same stale matzah
that we ate 3,300 years ago, we're still
eating today. It's not just you tell a
story, you enact a story. The same food,
the memories, we know which day we left,
we know how many people left, we know
what we ate when we left. And we eat
that food. we eat sometimes even taste
the same.
We got to you tell the story.
[Music]
Yet
at some point in the long journey,
in the long journey of Jewish history,
in the long journey represented by the
sedar,
at some point
many people fell asleep.
They fell asleep at the seda table. Why
do people fall asleep?
They find it boring. They find it
irrelevant. They find it monotonous.
They may even find it disturbing. They
may even find it painful. May cause them
pain.
So people fall asleep, which means they
check out emotionally. They check out
spiritually. Sometimes they check out
physically.
They do what Jews do during a boring
sermon. It's called schluff. Falling
asleep. said there was a rabbi who was
once giving a sermon and the president
of the shul started to sleep.
So the rabbi who didn't like the
president tells the guy go knock him
over his head and wake him up. So he
knocks him over his head. The president
looks up and he says do it again. I
could still hear him.
At some point of our history,
a major part or a significant part of
our people closed their eyes at the seda
table.
They closed their eyes at the carbon or
the what it represents. In other words,
it became meaningless for them, became
irrelevant for them. And therefore, they
zoned out. They zoned out of the Jewish
story. They zoned out of the story of
Mitzim, of the story of Jewish identity,
of the journey of the Jewish people from
to Hari all the way to Messiah.
Somebody once said, "I'm very good at
sleeping. I can do it with my eyes
closed."
So sometimes people become very very
apt, very comfortable in their sleep.
And when we think about this reality,
it could become very very sad and
depressing. First of all, the way people
look at themselves. I hear this all the
time.
Sometime a person looks at himself or
herself
and feels that I'm detached.
my father or my grandfather, my mother,
my grandmother, my great-grandfather at
some point closed their eyes in the
middle of the sedar. They went into a
schluff. They didn't only doze off for a
few seconds.
They fell asleep. And now a few
generations later, the grandchild,
grandson, the granddaughter, the
great-grandson, the great granddaughter
feels that they don't have a connection.
They don't really have a relationship. I
didn't grow up with it. I don't
understand it. I can barely read. I can
barely understand what's going on. I
never practiced in my own. They feel
they feel disconnected.
There are others who eulogize them very
swiftly and say, "Yeah, most of the
Jewish people are lost from Israel. We
have 15 million Jews." If you look at
the amount of Jews who are actively
mitzvah actively so to speak sitting at
the seda table with their eyes open
involved immersed alive
it's a very very small percentage
extremely small percentage that's the
fact
and there are those who ARE SITTING
AROUND THE TABLE physically but their
eyes ARE STILL CLOSED OR THEIR EYES ARE
open but they're sleeping with their
eyes open. You know, I may wear the
garb. I may be dressed apart. I may be
walking the walk. I may even be talking
the talk,
but internally
I'm not interested. I checked out.
I was once teaching in a yeshiva and I
would give classes in Gmorra and there
was a boy who sat right in front of me
and he would stare at me. They were
two-hour classes but he was checked out.
So I once went over to him and I said,
"You know, I have to say I'm very
impressed with you. I see that you're
not listening, which I understand. It's
long. It's hard. But you you look at me
the whole time. How do you do that?"
He looks at me. He says, "Rabbi
Jacobson, I have 10 years experience
with my father."
[Music]
So my father preached to me and screamed
and preached and preached and I learned
to look at him because I had to look at
him. But I checked out. So sometimes
people sleep with their open with their
with their with their eyes open
somebody once told the
he was a big he had a lot of ambitions
he says you're dreaming he says yeah
my dreams are not when I'm asleep my
dreams are when I'm awake so I'm happy
to dream when you're awake is a little
more difficult than to dream when you're
sleeping so sometimes people look at
this group THE MAJORITY AND WRITE THEM
OFF. They're lost. They're disconnected.
They're detached from the narrative.
They interrupted the journey. Whether it
was conscious, unconscious, voluntary,
involuntary, beazed, not be amazed,
because of apathy, because of ignorance,
because of maliciousness, because of
foolishness, because of justified
reasons, unjustified reasons. But they
detached themselves from the golden
chain that continues literally 3,330
years. They cut their umbilical cord
that connects them to their progenitors,
to their past. They decided to write
their last chapter on such a glorious,
beautiful story. Their chapter will be
the last chapter. How sad, how
difficult, how painful. And then there
are others who say, "How in the world do
you think the Jewish people are worthy
of redemptiveness, of gula, of finishing
the seder, of saying
when such big parts or major parts of
their nation maybe a MAJORITY OF IT MORE
than a majority went to sleep and
there's such a minority
that's awake AND SOMETIMES THE MINORITY
THAT'S awake also becomes very
judgmental
there's a holier than thou attitude
there's a dismissive attitude I'm from
the holy ones you're from the sleepers
and that night and I'll never forget it
I told you I was 17 years left such an
impact on me and it molded it molded the
way I teach. The Reb said this premise
is mistaken
and the reason this premise is mistaken
and I can still remember the emotions
that touched me when I heard these words
because you don't understand the nature
and the chemistry of the Jewish people
which is not based on isolation. It's
based on
it's based on Bava.
It's based on a group.
The first thing the terror says is not
good is what's the first insh.
It's not good for Adam to be alone.
Adam includes men and women.
[Music]
Huh?
Adam includes men and women. You can
look in birches. I didn't make this up.
I'm not saying this because it's a
woman's class. If you look in say for it
says
I didn't make that up
includes and yes you could be more
specific and say and but
clearly says about and together and when
it says
what does that mean that Adam needs a
soulmate and certainly needs a soulmate
right they both need each other it's not
a he needs needs her and she doesn't
need him. It wasn't the wisest woman who
It wasn't the wisest thing when the
woman said women need men like fish need
bicycles.
Huh?
Why is that the only carbon that we eat?
The answer is because the carbon pes is
the one carbon of Jewish identity. It's
the offering that commemorates the night
we became a people. We literally became
a nation. Till that point, we were
slaves. Slaves don't belong to
themselves. Slaves belong unfortunately
to their masters. Theo says the first
mitzvah Hashem gave the Jewish people
before any mitzvah is which
the mitzvah of counting time. How we
establish our calendar. The first day of
the month, the last day OF THE MONTH.
WHY IS THAT THE FIRST MITZVAH? You can't
find any other MITZVAH IN EGYPT. BEFORE
THEY LEFT, THEY had to hear one mitzvah.
Not Shabas, even before Pes. The first
mitzvah was
really the calendar is so important.
Like you're gathering a bunch of slaves.
YOU'RE ABOUT TO GO FREE. BUT GUYS,
BEFORE ANYTHING, let me tell you about
the calendar.
Even today, nobody understands the
calendar. There's two and a half people
who know how the calendar works. It's
very complicated. The calendar, Jewish
calendar is very complicated. Roman
calendar is solar. The Muslim calendar
is lunar. The Jewish calendar is lunatic
because it's solar and lunar together.
And putting the sun and the moon
together creates lunacy.
It's an impossible feat. And yet we do
it every month. Ramadan could be in the
spring, could be in the summer, could be
in the winter. The pes could only be in
the spring. So you need the sun. But our
months follow the moon. So that's a
problem.
Hence our holidays are never on time.
Right? EVERY JEW SAYS, "THIS YEAR RASHAN
IS LATE. THIS YEAR RASHAN IS EARLY." I
NEVER HEARD ANYBODY SAY, "THIS YEAR NEW
YEAR'S IS EARLY.
NEW YEAR'S IS LATE. THANKSGIVING IS
LATE." WHY IS THANKSGIVING never late
and pes and sukus are always early late?
I never heard anybody say this year is
on time. The answer is because it's
never on time
because the sun and the moon don't get
along. Why is that the first mitzvah? So
the writes,
slaves don't own their days. They don't
own time. The difference between freedom
and slavery is time.
A slave knows the time, but he doesn't
own the time.
Your whims, your desires define my time.
A free person, where does freedom first
and foremost express itself? Time. Your
relationship to time. YOU OWN YOUR TIME.
IT'S YOURS. THAT'S WHAT HE TOLD them in
Egypt. He was giving them the mentality
of freedom before actually going
physically free. You have to cultivate a
mentality of freedom because if not, I
could leave Egypt, but Egypt doesn't
leave me as we discussed last week.
Why does
individual freedom come before the
group? Why doesn't
Right. So that's what he was saying. In
order to be able to celebrate Pesak,
you're going to have to realize that the
beginning of the month, you define it.
This is our first day. The masters in
Egypt will not define the first day. We
will define it. That's why you can have
people who are technically free. But if
you don't own your time, if I don't own
my time, I'm a slave. I can be a slave
to my addictions, a slave to my
laziness, a slave to my depression, a
slave to my fears. And that's very deep.
Sometimes it's worse than any other form
of slavery because there's nobody
physically chaining me. But internally
I'm chaining myself.
But is that is that defined by or is it
an individual freedom or a soesh is also
established by the best? There's
witnesses, a whole process of witnesses.
But it's still not because you celebrate
on your own. You don't need 25 people to
celebrate.
Yeah. So once the Jewish people when the
Jewish people now become free,
how did I get into the calendar? I
forgot. Anybody remembers? You remember
always my sequence.
Oh, the first mitzvah.
But right before that, discussing the
Okay.
Huh.
Yeah. So, so, so let's go back. So, the
first night of PES, so Hashem says,
"Now, when the Jewish people emerge as
people say this carbon together,
families,
because our attachment is not luxury,
it's not comfort. It's not if I have
time, I'll find attachment. As we know
today in the world of psychology,
attachment is essential to the core of
identity. There's no identity without
attachment. They used to think
attachment is later in life you'll form
relationships. If my attachment in the
earliest days and weeks and months of my
life is wounded, the attachment with my
primary caregivers, something very deep
is wounded in a person's core.
And the rest of their life they're
trying to compensate for it. And very
often what happens later is trying to
replay and fix and repair that wounded
attachment that could be very profound.
And it's not just attachment. It's we
live in that relational
field of energy.
Our facial expressions
as our our our our gestures, our smiles,
the way we react to people, the way you
trigger me and I trigger you. in the
earliest earliest moments are essential.
So the PES is and it's not just true
emotionally psychology. It's also true
collectively as a people and I'm just
going to refer to this very briefly
because he once did a class on this paro
before pes what was the first mitzvah
with the carbon pes they had to take
audas ao they had to take a bundle of
hissip hissip plant did I pronounce that
correctly dip it in the blood of the pes
and dye the doors of their home and
remain in that house till the morning
and not leave and eat the current pes
there And God says, "I'll recognize the
blood and I'll leap over your home and
keep you safe." What is that all about?
What is that all about? And one of the
interpretations is, and it's quite
astounding, is you can't leave Egypt if
you don't go back to the moment where it
all began. And the moment it all began
was Yisf
was sold as a slave to an Egyptian
master. BUT THE BROTHERS HAD A problem
cuz how do they break the news of what
they did to Tati to Yak? So they took
his tunic, his passim, HIS MULTICOLORFUL
TUNIC AND DIPPED IT IN THE BLOOD OF A
GOAT. No other animal rashi says it's
the most similar to human blood. And
they sent it to Yakov and they said
recognize is this the tunic of your son
or not? And Yakov recognized it. And he
said, "I'm going to go down to my grave
and grieve, mourning for my son.
A wild beast has devoured my son Ysef."
Here is the proof. The tunic is bloody.
In other words, a wild undomemesticated
beast has mold.
investigate that.
No, they dipped it in blood of a goat so
that Yakov
should perceive it as Ysef's blood.
But the truth is,
you understand?
But the truth is,
I'll explain to you again. A goat's
blood is similar to a person. They
wanted Yakov should think that Yseph was
devoured by an animal. If an animal
devoured him and then left his tunic
around, his tunic would be with his
blood. You understand? It wasn't really
Y's blood. It was a goat's blood.
Yeah.
But this might be absurd because after
all,
okay, but that was the actual the actual
implementation and that's why they came
down to
Mitsay. 22 years later when Ysef reveals
himself, he says there's a hunger in
Israel. Come here. I'll take care of
you. The beginning of the exile of Egypt
is that the first family of the Jewish
people can't get along. There is
profound discord and contention.
the night before they go free, God says,
"We have to go back to that moment, but
we're going to do it differently."
And it's really incredible when you see
these connections in that you can
overlook superficially. So he says,
"Take audas." The word
means what?
Gathering a bundle. Egood,
right?
Audos. You've heard of the organization,
right?
to bomb bring together.
THAT'S THE POINT to bring together.
Bring together means
different personalities, different
souls. But you have to be able to be
here for each other.
You can't allow other CALCULATIONS TO
TAKE OUT A DIP IT IN THAT BLOOD OF THE
GOAT OR THE SHEEP. But this time, you
know what you're going to do with the
blood? You're not going to send it to
your father.
You're going to put it around your house
and you're going to say in this house
there's a family AND DON'T LEAVE THE
HOUSE TILL THE MORNING. WHAT DOES THAT
MEAN? WHAT THAT MEANS IS I DON'T CARE IF
YOU'RE ARGUING BUT YOU STAY IN THE
HOUSE. Argue around the same table.
Don't run out of the house. It's easy
FOR ME TO RUN OUT OF THE HOUSE. SLAM THE
DOOR. I'M NOT PART OF YOUR FAMILY. I'm
done with you. No, no, no. sit in that
house till the morning then I'll
recognize that you are a free people
because you will not be able to be free
if internally you cannot really respect
otherness you cannot really unite with
your brothers and sisters you can't
really make peace with them and you will
not survive if you're not going to have
each other so that's the pes that's
there was one of the the second
Alexander rebber
It was known as the Isis the he passed
away in 1910 was one of the greatest
rebas in Poland Alexander
last name was Danser of Dans
has a called beautiful
he writes a whole he says the Gmor says
if most of Clius is impure they're
allowed to bring all the carbon they're
allowed to bring carbon pes even when
they're impure Imagine
kayanim go into the bdas they're impure
usually it's a death penalty it's kuris
but if most of the kayanim or most of
the Jewish people are impure you're
allowed to do all the carbonas in fact
there were those who wanted to be and
still those who wanted to be of the
carbon pes in our times because they say
since most of is you're allowed to do it
and as long as you build a misbeh and
you know ra says you can be mak of a
carbon even without a bik as long as you
have a misbak
so there are those who called and call
for doing the carbon even today because
there's many sources that it's
permissible
wanted to do it
there was a there were a lot of great
people who wanted to do it
so says what does that really mean it
really means that when people are
together they can transcend the impurity
even though there's impurity but you can
transcend so when you understand the
identity of the Jewish people the is not
luxury it's essential as we say before
why will he gather us together you're in
Australia I'm in New Zealand he's in
Moscow she's in London he's in Paris in
Tel Aiv he's New York and this one is
even in Rockland County
the answer is
the word
comes from the
connection.
Whenever there's a connection, so then
people could be fully cognizant of who
they really are.
It's an explanation. If I'm God, I'm the
source of oneness. So oneness is
essential.
Huh?
One second.
This is So now we come back. Remember,
there's the Jew who feels disconnected
cuz my father fell asleep, my
grandfather fell asleep.
There's a Jew who feels disassociated.
There's the Jew who eulogizes everybody
who fell asleep even with a certain
sense of
uh dismissiveness or vindictiveness.
You see it in Israel all the time. The
religious, the secular, it's complicated
over there. And I'm not just talking
about practically even emotionally.
And there are those who say how will
this nation be worthy of redemption etc.
So the Reb saidal
is one
and never ever has there been a
situation that everybody fell asleep.
And as long as somebody is awake and
is always
those who are awake.
So then everybody else, they're still
part of exactly the same meal. And when
they emerge, WHEN THEY WAKE UP,
they're not starting something new. They
don't have to recreate a new identity.
THEY JUMP RIGHT BACK INTO THEIR MEAL.
because somebody in the kabura
never ever went to sleep.
Even if the whole group snoozes
still it's good. Certainly they don't
somebody didn't even snooze was always
awake.
So therefore
therefore
at some point everybody wakes up.
Everybody wakes up. You're not waking up
to a new seder, to a new story, to a new
meal, to a new relationship that never
existed. You're waking up to a reality
that is part of you, that was always
part of you, to a meal that was waiting
for you, to the chairs that were left
open for you, AND YOU'RE PART OF THE
SAME MEAL.
AND THEREFORE, IT'S NOT JUST THEIR meal
wasn't interrupted. Your story was never
interrupted
because
remained awake throughout history and in
every generation you'll never have a
situation that everybody's asleep.
Sometimes it becomes very personal
with parents. We live in a time
where there's children, many children
and many families who at some point in
their life choose a different path than
their parents.
And whatever the cause is, whatever the
factors behind it, that's not today's
analysis,
but they choose a different path.
The path of their parents, their
grandparents, their great-grandparents,
maybe for thousands of years, they say,
"I'm done.
This is not for me. It's too painful for
me. I don't believe in it. It's
confusing for me. It's boring. It's
irrelevant. It's not my table. It's not
my meal. It's not MY FAITH. IT'S NOT MY
DESTINY. IT'S NOT MY VOCATION.
I'M GONE.
Whether physically I'm gone, spiritually
I'm gone, emotionally I'm gone. Maybe
I'll show up at the table as out of
respect for Bubby.
I'll even put on my keep out of respect
for Zadi.
But
the moment I'll say goodbye, I'm on my
own.
And it's very very heart-wrenching
especially for parents,
siblings, grandparents, uncles, aunts to
see this.
And this is where this hala becomes not
just important but it becomes vital and
it's oxygen. WHAT IS YOUR JOB AT that
moment?
Your job at that moment is
fall asleep.
You don't fall asleep.
You don't
fall into a slumber. You don't fall into
a depression. You don't fall into anger
or cynicism.
And you believe that their meal has not
been interrupted. YOU HOLD THOSE CHAIRS
OPEN AND WARM AND WELCOME and vibrant
and alive.
YOU NEVER go down
that dangerous path of of of sleep, of
alienation, OF YOU'RE DETACHED FROM ME.
I'M DETACHED FROM YOU. OUR MEALS ARE
SEPARATE FOREVER. Have a good day.
If you're READY TO WAKE UP, COME BACK
AND I'LL think about it. No,
it's a kabura.
You stay at the table alive, alert,
awake
because there'll be moments that person
is going to peek in and see what's
happening.
And if there's WHO ARE THERE WELCOMING
HIM OR HER BACK, they'll jump right back
in cuz they never really left
because there was a kabura that was
always present. And we're all connected
in that group. We're all part of that
oneness. Nobody is ever outside of that
call.
Nobody was excluded from that. But the
ones who have the privilege and God gave
them the gift to stay up, they have to
realize the preciousness of their
mission.
And it's expressed even in very
practical ways emotionally,
psychologically, and behavior.
Sometimes a teenager or a young adult, a
young man, a young woman, they're going
through their phases. Some of those
phases are difficult. There's a lot of
attitude,
grouchiness, negativity,
sometimes what seems like to be very
rude and obnoxious, often a lot of
trauma and brokenness.
And your teenage daughter or someone
else comes into the kitchen 1:00 in the
morning, as I always say, opens the
refrigerator, says, "There's nothing to
eat in this house. You just went to
Costco
and you have food there to feed an army
for three and a half years.
The refrigerator is stuffed to the point
that people can be nourished here until
afterm.
But not for your family, not for your
daughter. There's nothing to eat.
There's a natural inclination.
You're detaching from me. I want to
detach from you.
You're giving me a negative attitude. I
want to give you a negative attitude. Go
to another house.
Don't be so ungrateful. I become
defensive. In other words, you lure me
in to that path where I also decompose.
I also disintegrate. What do you have to
do at that moment? Don't fall asleep.
What's the difference between people who
are awake, people who are asleep? When
I'm sleeping, my head, my heart, and my
legs are on the same level.
You understand? My prefrontal cortex, my
limbic brain, my amygdala, AND MY FEET
ARE ALL ON THE SAME LEVEL.
I can't function with my higher brain.
My executive functioning is asleep. I'm
asleep.
All I can do is survive. That's what we
do. WHICH IS IMPORTANT TO SLEEP. It's
important. The amygdala has to recharge.
The body has to recharge. But you can't
expect a person who's asleep
to process and bring into the
conversation their executive
functioning, their prefrontal loes,
long-term vision, deep connections, DEEP
VISION. I CAN'T. I function based on
impulse. Impulse.
And if I lose it, I blow up. Don't fall
asleep. You stay awake.
NOT just for your sake. For their sake
and for your sake.
for you that relationship remains
intact.
I'm not going to lose it. I may want to
lose it. I may have to take a deep
breath. I may need to do a little voing,
A LITTLE SEMATIC, WHATEVER. I NEED TO
CALM MY NERVOUS SYSTEM. I GOT TO WAKE UP
MYSELF.
But the worst thing I can do is I go
into that resentful angry place and cut
the cord and say, "You're not part of
this kabura."
What I want to I want to always bring my
best, my noblest, my deepest connected
identity into the relationship.
You may come down every night and tell
me a comment that is very, very unbeing
and I could scream about their but at
this point you're so broken it's become
meaningless. You'll just feel alienated
from me. But what I want to do is when
you walk into that kitchen,
I want to smile, look you in your eyes,
and tell you how happy I am that you're
here.
Yes, I know there's nothing to eat.
Come, let's go get sushi. I don't know
why you do that at 1:00 in the morning,
but maybe a little earlier. Maybe a
milkshake. Let's make something good.
Nachos. Nachos. Did I pronounce that
correctly?
Okay.
It's not what you make. The point is
you're present. You know what? The
person may not respond in kind. I'm not
happy to be here.
Smile. I'm here. I'm awake. I'm here.
Because you know what happens after a
few weeks? That smile, that love,
it takes root. Like a seed, it takes
root.
It takes root in the heart. attachment.
Everybody needs attachment. There's not
a person who was created that does not
need attachment. And there's a reason
for it because we are attached. I need
attachment because I that's who I am.
And those who say they don't need
attachment is only because they can't
trust their attachment because they've
been hurt. So I say I don't need it. I
don't need you. I don't want you. I hate
you. I wish you were dead. Which only
means I desperately need you. I
desperately need you. But if I'm asleep,
I can't hear that. If I'm asleep, I
become very judgmental because I'm
triggered because I'm not in my higher
space.
My vagus nerve is is blocked. It's it's
plugged. I can't access it. So instead
of connecting, I become defensive. I
need to protect myself. In other words,
I'm falling asleep together with you.
What's my job at that moment?
Stay awake.
To stay awake requires work, especially
if IT'S LATE AT NIGHT LIKE THE SEDER, it
requires work.
You need to learn how to honor your
emotions, all of your emotions. But then
say, "And now I'm going to choose to
stay awake." And stay awake means stay
connected, stay alert, stay loving, stay
focused. My job is to make sure THAT
WHEN YOU OPEN YOUR EYES, YOU'RE GOING TO
know that this was always your place.
This was always your meal. This was
ALWAYS YOUR HOME. THIS WAS ALWAYS YOUR
SEDER.
And you'll be able to jump right in and
you won't even remember. You're like,
"Really?" Sometimes what happens is you
start reminding people what they did 10
years ago. No, no, no. Not me.
Erase the video. It's fine.
certain videos you can erase because
when they did it they were asleep and
people don't remember what they do when
they're asleep and sometimes people
sleep for many many years we know that
right
Levvenstein was the mash of Panovich so
he used to you know he like to joke he
used to like sometimes give the bakim
you know some comment so he once tells
the boys
you have to know the lit yes he says he
says you guys stay up a
A whole night of you dive in. You dive
in at sunrise
and then you sleep TILL
sometimes they sleep till.
The point is sometimes people check out
at a certain age and they may sleep for
many years and when you sleep you don't
remember what you do. You're not you're
not you're not you're not fully there
and you may have not chosen to fall
asleep.
You may have been thrown into a slumber.
You know what?
Everyone is on their journey.
But the most important role of a Jew is
you stay awake.
YOU KEEP THAT TABLE
WARM, LOVING, ALIVE, VIBRANT,
ENTHUSIASTIC,
ELEVATED, INSPIRED, EMPOWERED.
So when
somebody emerges from the slumber,
they jump right back in to their own
seder that was never really interrupted.
And together we can then hold hands and
declare.
Have a wonderful week.
I remember you can go to the tape.
You can hear the whole
what I want to hear.
It's not only technically it represents
the the we're not just talking about a
technical. We're talking about the
that during the journey Jews fall asleep
and the pes has to be a continuum.
from the beginning of history
throughout. But they fell asleep. But
that's only if you see them. But since
it's
and
everybody's sleep is not that
significant
because when they wake up, they're right
back in it.
They're all continuing their own story,
not the new story.
So they're all part of it. They're all
ready for the end of the sedar.
because the are waiting are there for
them with open doors with open arms.
So his vintage
his whole approach on
instead of instead of seeing Jews as
alien and and indifferent and apathetic
keep the doors open keep the hearts open
and then they'll see
my not my type you're not my this
you keep the heart and the door open and
then you allow them to be able to find
their own their own they're part of it
it's I don't have to give it to them. I
just have to let them realize that their
carbon pes their sudas pes never never
was never really interrupted. It was
just a little heapsick but it's not a
real heapsically. It's not a real heaps.
It's not a real interruption because I'm
part of them and they're part of me and
part of us were always present. So
they're also always present.
When you have family that's always
waiting for you and awake so a part of
you is always present. That's the beauty
of it. Since I'm part of the kabura, so
even if I'm asleep, but you're part of
me, I'm part of you. We're part of each
other. So your presence is my presence
even though I don't know it because I'm
sleeping. But the part of me that's
always connected to you knows that it's
present.
So
yeah,
very good. that is part of the
was always a Jew who was awake. So
is not just Hashem the Jew was awake
or so as long as
so then
no will be lost.
living in my house.
You understand?
In many ways, it captures, you know, the
power of Jewish history that throughout
all the wars and and difficulties and
even in the worst moments, you know,
holocausts and the Bolev Bolevik
darkness and, you know, huge millions of
Jews were plunged into spiritual
darkness.
But
they kept they maintained the fire. They
didn't go away. They didn't leave the
seder.
They maintained it even when everything
seemed like it's falling apart. They
held on to it.
So what happens a generation later? A
whole trouva movement. Everybody has
where to come back to
understand there. So all it's the same
thing. That was the Reb's voice. Don't
stop looking at it as two separate
communities. There's the religious jury
and the secular jury. No, IT'S A
WE'RE AT ONE TABLE. But
yeah.
Yeah. So keep keep the door and heart
open. Keep the cheer warm. Tell them
it's your cheer.
And then everybody comes back at some
point but they have where to come back
too
cuz you feel the itself helps them come
back
1990.
30 years more than 30 years.
33 years.
33 years ago.
Okay.
I was 17 years old.
Okay. So, here it says
we're getting younger. It's fine. We
don't have to be embarrassed.
Amen. Amen. I'm