0:00 / 0:00
KRIAS MEGILLAH AND ITS BROCHOS WHEN READING FOR LADIES - Shiur by Rabbi Nachum Scheiner
14 views
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
And tonight here
we're going to speak about
inilla
by night and by day
we ver
Sunday night for
butes
and I think there's a lot more still to
speak about
and even after I finished still what to
speak about but he still there's a lot
what They still speak about
are women in
what's the sh why should they not be why
not cuz it's a mitz
they're from eating m not matzah the
from sitting in the from lul it's
so you would say that ladies are from
kaill all the business or
>> so that's a good sh we're not going to
get to it in tonight it's a beautiful
question we're only going to focus on
after all we're learning now
afterwards I would like to show you some
about it interesting about the other
mitzvah it's a good sh there's a lot to
talk about connected to night share but
we're going to focus on
the
why are they?
They were also in the nim.
What does it They were in the nace
doesn't mean they were in the nace just
like the men. The of was for everybody
including the women they were also in
the nace and therefore their mill that
brings from the
bomb is actually in these two other
places. There are two other places in
where the Gmorra says that ladies
as well as also
but I'll come upon him one
can mean because they also had the nace
or actually
which means the purim happened through a
lady through Esther amala but alapon the
gammor says that
on a side note if we're speaking about
the
I mentioned it in last week's sh briefly
but I think it's to elaborate a little
bit more see it's the general
the briskov and stencil and clares what
is the
What is the of
is
its own? In other words,
of
what's about the
because they they were part of the N.
That's one way to understand.
Or
says, "Even though in general we say
when it comes to
we say that even but why are they
not because of a
with me what's the not today that ladies
and giller are
Because
that's the of course their
for
wait a minute we'll say it very good
very good this you didn't say in the so
thinking what's the difference for one
minute first let's understand the shel
is that's the but why are they are they
because
or are
for why everyone else is because the
migill says
that you should read the
why don't we why don't we look at other
places where it says nothing there
even though they're not
>> what do you mean why do we look at
different places I don't say in three
places
>> right
>> we said we mentioned other places yeah
>> so but it only applies doesn't apply by
meaning if you have this message apply
to all the asking good cautious why you
don't only say it other places but I'm
asking you something else where there is
you see over there that doesn't
it doesn't it's not it's not it's not a
it doesn't void the
so the original it shafts it own
>> why why you say that why can't you why
can't you say
>> it should apply to all the
>> so Okay, you're asking a good child.
We'll get to that soon. He's a about it.
Let's
[laughter]
is the
or is the what's or is the not
if the
were not in the was not in the
reason why is because
even though it's
So
that's
also
if
they were not in the
was for if the that they have is because
of the grant that we were able to get to
it
then there will be
>> what you
So, so we'll get to that if
makes it into we spoke about it in the
previous we'll get it in a minute
puts it back with the same
question
one second of is a very clear
you want to know even if what do they
Let's let's get to that in a minute.
Mama minute. That's the next step over
here. I'm happy that I set it up this
way. This is the next Indian
takes the original
doesn't have that. So back.
No, it's that
>> if you hold that reverse to the original
then it would apply also
>> says the brisk says that if
that's the reason
what are we saying over here that
you mentioned very well that
we spoke about this in last year.
The following question
that's the other way the speaks about
why are ladies not
to sit in the
They were also in the covenant the
midbar
you should say.
So what does answer says that
is not applicable. So that's other
mitzvah also which will
by mitzvah I say that
you don't say
I didn't find it now but I I remember
seeing it in the past
is that
the says
so it it doesn't pass to say that came
and came and were in a mitzvah
on when the were. Okay. So the were also
not only for women as well.
Why would they? Because
even if you have
by night. Some
by day.
Why do you say
ladies?
No. If [clears throat] you tell me
he asks.
So
ladies
and
says that the for [clears throat] ladies
of is only
we were very busy in last week's year
that the
why ladies. You don't say
it's only
that we have a very clear
if day is
and if it's
all the we said last week four or five
fall off because by night and by day
it's the same thing.
However, in the verb
says it can't be that it's because it's
The same shily.
What does
ask you
of ask that ladies should be
in matzah? The Tory says that ladies are
why do you have to have a
ladies in matzah? Because with Russia if
not
what do you mean?
So Tyus's first heritage is that
is only only accomplishes to make
a
only to make a
so right now
asked based off
says you don't say
how do you say by which
So he argues and he says it's only
on this you see
says that even by you would say
where do you see
by
says it's only
you wouldn't necessarily want to be
bothered
>> I'm just showing you a steer
>> no but that steer is not a steer in the
g
So once I have
>> that's why I'm bringing in really
I was looking I mean what am I saying?
What does that have to do with the I'm
speaking about ladies in the terret of
the second terret what's second terret
ladies even
the reason why you need a trump because
really you have a fak you need this tv
not going into the butus is second
terror in migilla's mv that the afain
hoy
would be
we have three different over here. We
have a mahal which we spoke last week.
Even if you're confused, this summary is
very neat. We have three ways to
understand
at least by day. Either you can learn by
day.
Let's say the which is the most simple
women are
that's one way to learn. There's another
way to learn like
that men and women are both only
and now we're showing the third
from says that you would say
what would come out. I'm just saying
overus
so for the first 15 minutes of if
there's one takeaway
how we got to it we could smoo and over
it again but I think it's clear the
takeaway these three ways how to learn
by day I don't want to get confused
we'll hopefully we'll get to it that by
night also these it's not but at least
It's very clear by day either men and
women are kabala or bothan or menabala
and women
um menal and women.
Now let's go to part two of this year.
Could a lady be moy a man creat?
I'm not talking about zoosa. Could a a
wife be moy a husband with ka sagilla.
So this is
finishes. It's kad to go back to see the
tes also aim that's very relevant if you
have time it's a now before going into
the
let's just make one quick which we spoke
last week already if men
and women
they can't be right that's they're a
different level just like we know a
cotton can't be a god can't
So that's even be that should really be
the answer on this shila that should be
the answer on the shila before anything
that if between of a man and a lady and
a lady's own
cannot be an
in could they be could no be an
isus
brings one sheet that they can they can
yes they could and it's like that
there's another
that they cannot the can which is
brought
explains because both are men [snorts]
both it could be what's it sad that they
cannot so we said before it's two types
of but let's say that it's both
or let's say that sad that it's both why
why not so over here that brings the
doesn't it's not so clear but in when
Tyus brings the he adds another two or
three words and Tus says
it's
that men have and that women have in
men are
sabag to read the migillah. I we all
don't read the mill. So we listen
the person the has a mind to be we have
a mind to be
and with that nothing
you have
the clock before have a mind and that's
how you
read the even though you didn't read the
but when you listen to the meill with
sha you read the migill
women what
>> I don't know I don't know but one thing
I could say clear what the bak says is
that
to read the meill I'm just saying even
if you don't read the meill you only
listen to the megela you're reading the
megela
we'll get to the one minute one minute
women their mitzvah
to listen to the to listen where we have
the meaning
what do you mean I'm saying over from
the that says where does he get that
idea from where he gets
>> so I'm going to say over to explain I
might answer your might answer your
shilah why is it like that it's a good
sh I'll say over the mares maybe these
But first before the let's first get the
facts very clear
and we're going to get to in three
minutes hopefully we're going to get to
so what's the changes we'll get to that
in a minute but first let's get it very
clear that the of ism by men it'sa
that because the for ladies is only
what I just mentioned Before you have to
be to listen
that's only for men by ladies they come
to they don't have to be to be
the bal doesn't have to have a mind to
be mighty they have to listen they come
into shul and they listen and they men
need more than just listening they need
ka and the only way you get with ka is
with shmea kina
the next two three minutes I want to
just say it's because I want to really
get to the
but just to point out you asked why are
is it that ladies only
and he says the following he's also
going on and he says that there are two
accomplishments with kaillah
to denim
number one is with kaillah
you accomplish the same thing that is
the same thing like
the second thing that's accomplished
with with ka sagilla is pum haness
for the samik
you accomplish it with ka
women are not
so there's no kera for
that you accomplish. You don't have to
be the one reading it. It's read
and therefore men have both and ladies
only have
I'm going to leave out these big
by night and by day
I'm leaving it out, but this is getting
into the part. I want to be able to
still cover the
the of the of the
so we're saying over here that are
that even though the to hear the mill
they could listen they could read the
migilla it doesn't mean forget about to
be mighty for themselves could a lady
read the mill was saying that her then
to listen to the megilla. Could she read
the mgilla?
Sh they could. Why? Because when they
read the mill, when a lady reads the
mgilla, she also hears the mill. So if
you can read it, you don't you don't
need to read it.
>> You're right. You're right. You're 100%
right. The says it's true, but she
doesn't need she doesn't have to hear it
from someone that's
what is. We'll get to the soon. We'll
get to it. I want to bring you cuz
you're pointing out
they have to listen to a from a proper
meaning to say they can't listen from a
tape because it has to be a from a good
we get to in a minute in the but they
could read it because when they read it
as well also they're enough of to read
it to be able to hear it
la it's not part at all it's not part at
all for a lady to read the migill the
moav brings from the zy the brings
medelum the medelum on r is the zoyer
and he brings that ladies shouldn't read
the miguela
it's a it's a it's also a shila how to
understand the z it's not part the says
the lady shouldn't thees is only saying
that you still have a but in
the says not to. It's a
says that
if there's no man to read it and she
could read it, she should read it. But
it's a sh it's a sha
if she could read the mill.
>> Can she be the other woman?
>> She could read it. A she could be mighty
other woman.
I I take back a nada because we'll get
you'll see at the end of the year that
it's a shab
maybe it's a shab decree also I take
back but here we're just saying if she
could read it but if she could read it
for herself what's what's a problem for
someone else to listen we'll get we'll
get to that in a minute we you'll tell
me if it's the same thing remember see
if it's not the same thing let's
conclude over here with
no reading the so first we started very
clear that
maybe by day and by night maybe
[snorts] there's a day and night but
could they be men it's a it's a
showing them and we'll soon see
that the says
that they could be mighty
So it's enough to say it's a
let's go now to the what do they make
the lotion that we make you take out ash
is
that's the
z
and it's quoting
the says
but the haram he says is to make
The brewer in one place brings this
to say that you make the lotion.
These are brewer that says in a
different place brings the lion
mrogill.
But it's it's either
says the reason why you say you should
say
is about not
but even the that it has to be from a
mikra it's not enough just to listen to
me not just to have a recording it has
to be a proper Mikra, but the mitzvah
there is.
So we have a we have a
if the if the ladies make are
why can't they say the just like men
just like any mitzvah?
A lady that takes she can make a so just
like she can make a for why can't she
make a bra over here also over there
it's al so she can make a braha here
also she should be able to make a bra
on the miko
>> she has her own
>> and here here woman here it's even
better because she has her own so she's
a even so the whole thing
>> has her
Oh. Oh, very good. So very good saying
that's what answers
that here worse worse in a sense when
she's not so she's not that
[clears throat] she can make a
taking on
these
may be on the but these two parts over
here these the she's and these the ka
that she wants to take on. What should
she make a bra on? On what she's or what
she's on what she's immediately she
makes the on the
>> Yes. Yes. Yes. Yeah.
Very good. We're going to get rid you
just brought up cuz now we're going to
go and we're going to come back. It's
not
but you're 100% right. This whole of
changing the is only like the mitzvah is
the
what's
the
says many others say
there's another reason says you know why
you should say
because we're busy like you just
mentioned before this is all the sabah
and what's like
that the ina so what are you saying? So
even though mikra migill we explain can
also work for but at least if it's you
also have mikra
however you do the similar
says
whether you make alikra even
why as we don't think he brings it but
the says
not like the bahag. So
just for the awareness whatever they're
gonna make
a you don't oh very good this is the
final thing I'm sorry to drop over time
but this is very good so really if they
make the bra what should they make do
they make the bra or does the b make for
them I'm not talking about in shul you
come the regular minions that the b is
making these these regular men's minion
and these ladies also but the later cre
over here we have a cre at 8:00 9:00 10
11 12 those creas are for ladies so who
makes the bra does the b make or the
ladies make
>> so before you tell me
>> ah so before you tell me let's open up
and then we'll talk what you're saying
the says like this by the is that the
ladies have to make it this is very nega
I blow and then I come home. I blow for
the ladies. The ladies that's very good.
words
that could make could make the I think
he even says
this about if they could or they can't
which the Misha says that they that the
makes the
it's a shila but the shil has nothing to
do with ladies
the
the could be make the for them and then
what we said whatever the isra I want to
tell you even if the is going to make
the bra
he has to figure out what he's going to
make it's nothing to do that only if the
ladies make the bra he's making the bra
for them and he could he could what you
mentioned that the is not do
And with this I conclude because it's a
big shila nothing to do with ladies.
He's a big shila. If you were y the
mitzvah already could you make the bra
for somebody else but mark them where
the other person could
the same thing you find also on kashabas
you made kdish already you could be
somebody else with kdish. However the
brings it's a big shim. If the other
person knows how to make kdes and you
made kdes already
but there's a sh and some say you should
not do it. It's a it's a
says that it's only
you could do it. So back to the with
ladies
can make the if you go to a place and if
he makes the for sure he could maybe
even less than
says
in a lot of places the not do that they
don't make the doesn't make the not
because ladies
and you could partial because even if
you lame already the first time and you
go lane by a later minion a second time
over here in the morning we have every
15 minutes with
and one he lain and he was and he goes
now to the next minion could he make a
so that's really the same sh it's this
could you make the for ladies as well so
to conclude
it's a if they could be mighty men and
we saw
Abra is a Shila.