Constructing A Maakeh - A Practical Guide - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

sing [Music] like to welcome everyone to constructing practical guide sponsoring 718 851 8651 email.com Smith someone was Building G and obviously it's not a it's not a common Mitzvah and he didn't know the basics first of all when you put up a do you make is there said you say who makes the the balos or the contractor the worker and when do you make a because typically you make a before the mitah but here the mic could take a few hours it could even SP till the next day so in the past we spoke about the actual of and we said we'll get back to it and I would like to do that today I guess the Practical guide the dos and don'ts of the Mitzvah of making a Maka so if you notice we have different types of questions about the bra when to do it if have the worker versus the person himself I think we could reduce all our questions as we always try to do if we pose a very simple question what is the nature what is theah of the mitvah and I'll explain we have a Mitzvah most Mitzvah the Mitzvah is the action mil you have to do a Mitzvah a go can't M A Child even if he's the best doctor in the hospital because you have to have a bar so the Mitzvah is the Mitzvah if that would be the case then a go that builds a Mak you wouldn't have a Mitzvah now maybe the Mak works because it's protecting but if you give a guy to do the M you're not Mitzvah just like if a GU does you're mitzvah but maybe Mak is a different type of a mitvah and that is the you see the gave us a in the which is and as we explained it's independent even if you don't need a Mak you have to keep a safe environment but one thing we also see that it's one objective get your home safe don't keep a roof that's dangerous so maybe we could suggest that Mak is a different type of a Mitzvah the Mitzvah is not that you should put to get put on a h hat and build a Maka the Mitzvah is that your house has to have a Maka so if the end result you don't need you know what you need a good worker maybe if the B does it not so good because you won't do it a good job you get a professional he'll do a job and you're safe so maybe the Mitzvah is the end result of if that's the case then we could understand that maybe go works but then again we have to rethink so is there maybe there's no BR if you're getting rid of a problem maybe there's no BR so really it's a few shist with one you say that we have to clarify I you'll say but this doesn't make sense I mean where do we ever find a GU could do a so that's I could say first of all if you tell me that the mitvah is the end result to have a protective fence around your gate so why can't a guy do it it's not it's not but this is the end results why can gu do it but I could do better than that was delayed shabas and already it's after and she did not yet light shabas which is a Calamity and also very traumatic U experience she's going to have to light an extra call so no problem if it's not yet it'ses she could have a go come and light their shabas I lighting an air on how could you to have a so is not a problem but the main problem on this how does this work she has to do you want to say she's okay but not so how could the say that the light and the makes how can you make a there's no I'll just give you a is assuming we understand that the Mitzvah of shabis is not a regular Mitzvah the Mitzvah shabas not a PK it's based on three objectives to get Shalom is in a house there shouldn't be a dark home it's not domestic tranquility if the house is dark so you want to bring in there you want to bring in the shom into the house whenever you have a special occasion you like n byis by and that's and you don't enjoy the food if you don't see the food so explaining that shabas is a different type of a Mitzvah the Mitzvah is not the Mitzvah is the result they're having the Illumination in the house and the DAV goes so far to say that it's an ongoing Mitzvah as long as the shabas are burning they're providing shabab and shom the mitz is ongoing but and here's the punch line you don't need a you don't need a Mitzvah if the ISA looks and she sees that there's shab is burning she in fact could make a because you don't need is not the it's the now I want to make a point before I forget that the say once already it's after although the guy could do it but the is can't make a because if she can't light now because they have she can't make but we definitely see that this concept if an Isa is late a go could light and if it's before is still before but for some reason doesn't want to light she make a says he doesn't understand how could a so he would recommend getting a to light no said but all agree that when the lights the woman is and I saw that has no even though the guy L it after but it's a Val so what do we see we see a precedent so why can we say however it's far from convincing because as I told you sh it's three good reasons now logic dictates that even though you don't have a a lights you're ending up with the result that you want that's why it's good but by the by the mitah you have to do it it's a maybe we'll say it's like like you see also you could say is also a I want to turn the baby from a oral to a mo true maybe right but it's also a guy that does me on a child the child was not you have to have a so we see by even though it's but you have to so the the same thing applies by a Mak and you can't compare it to n shabas in other words N shabas is an exceptional Mitzvah that it's only the but wait I can find a different Mitzvah that maybe we could say a do and that is the building a we know the is if a built the he did and doesn't have to make and pick it up and put it down do me it's the way it is so what do we see once again a something is good so why but the truth is that's not correct in fact because there is no mitvah per se of building a Suka the MIT sitting in the Suka so that's why if a GU does it it's but here the Mitzvah of is a who says it works in other words for the can't sit in the Suka for you he could build the Suka but he can't sit in the Suka so maybe who then he can't so what comes to mind is another sh I heard the sh true story probably more than once the painter AA painter but he knows his Jewish customers before he painted takes off the mises and after he finish he puts back the misas now the E has a problem I go put up my mises is that a problem with the mza GU put up a mza so the EM some hold as long as he put in the right place it's on your door poost what's wrong but most po can feel that's not true it has to have a m and a go can is not a to attach a m so here we see a guy that puts up a even though you say what's wrong it's there in the right place and it's a there you need but I'll tell you maybe something else this is a true story I should say someone came to me and he was very upset and he said it's not lash usually when people say that it probably is lash but he said it's not L but I'm very upset a certain cater and our neighbor they told me to name I we trust them I the following he says I can say not he was standing in front of Goldberg's Grocery and they have a Mikvah Alto Mikvah and this truck pulled up with the name on the cater on both sides of the truck and two workers came out they took out a few hundred K and the I'm eating in a catering hle that what's going on here so I wanted to say if I didn't say I'll tell you why because it and no one disagrees that a sorry if a the only thing is but he's not to do it you'll send a guy to 200 dishes he'll do the first one and the last one and one in between and be that's it he's lazy but let's say is watching him now there is a big problem the Tas points that out if you send the GU to do it you lost the because can make a and you can make a so the should start make on some of the one of the and the GU does the rest which is exactly what happened in this story the yish worker who drove the truck got out made a and he watched the so what do we see something very significant is not just and a could do it so here we have to say that the MIT is a objective It's The End Result it's the water that makes the the K into a K into a toal k so there I understand let's say a person is all and makes and as he making he drops the into the was he to the Mitzvah is because he went into the water a is not worse so can we say who Mak as long as you have a Mak you're good but again it's hardly convincing cuz here the P stresses who told you it's only an end result maybe it's like also is an end result the animal should be but even if people watch him is no good so back to basically Square One what's what is the of the so what is helpful there's a we mentioned it the other week he was asked a general question when does help so his basic CL is there are certain that you have to do yourself you can't Delegate for example you can't have a shake you but many mitv he says works and listen so we definitely find's works by but we don't yet see if a Works maybe just like he has on that list and works works but you can't have a or so maybe we're get back to the conclusion that a worker that builds a will not be good oh but we did find something which is asked our question point blank is it good enough that he can make a because he has a Mitzvah or maybe not so he has an unbelievable and he says here we know an that's Mish indebted to you and he your worker more than work your EV is more than just he's like an extended hand of yours and we say the same concept he brings a by a PO when you have a who to work a whole day if you finish this job you got to do this job as opposed to a contractor that that's working for a job but a PO that's work that's working is like sort of a little your so he says a that works even for Mak so not only can you get a worker to do the Mak for you but the worker does the it's like your hand did it and therefore it's so much your action could even make a then he says which for us is music to is a second another reason that a GU could make a Mak for you and he says M they we're looking for when you need to make it good like kin so obviously can't do can't be a but let's say someone volunteers you're sleeping at night and he decides to be a nice guy he goes to your house that doesn't have does not have a Mara doesn't ask you questions you don't make a and he builds a great you have to you don't need you need the end result and if a go does it you have an end result what's his listen how beautiful it is his is good build it is good but then he says so what do we see is but we don't yet see a can make a cuz when a gos and he doesn't do anything a can't make a he says so therefore the of works but doesn't allow you to make a but the first of that's such a powerful SW it even allows the to make a on the that he does nothing of the mitvah and that's his conclusion that we have two that a is good the is so good it even allows to make a and this is M what we're looking for however that's not the final word he says near when it comes to Mak either the person has to do it but if a builds the just like a GU does even though it's a perfect job you're not the Mak that's done by a GU would not be and he adds I found later says that you don't need he says by me is B by getting a GU to do the now he also probably agrees that is is effective it's working but he says to have a go do it you lost a Mitzvah and he says it's not is just a has on the show what was he wrote notes just says he's taking it to an extreme can you can a go who your workers be made for the D of your wife can a [Music] go or get because you so also basically disputes the whole Assumption of so here we have our question our now what's so we're going to do a little bit of typically we first have and then we apply it here we're going to learn and then we'll look back and see so what is the first we learn you know and sort of after is ready that's the so maybe we'll do let's start with a simple let's say I built a home and I have a roof I have no Mar is there there an Indian that I should go be and build or's good enough question number two let's say let's say the is and he wants to do it himself he feels but is someone that's is not do work he's going to be standing on the roof banging and knocking it's also so this should be t and listen to this had to appear in front of for he came to and what's he doing he's working construction cuz what's going on here goes this is not a clinic I'm building a Mak so we found both questions in was and yet he built so what do we see that even to the extent that is allowed to do it now is this that Mak is a not necessarily and I could prove it he wants to follow and he wants to go out and build but he's he's a renowned the end of on that that's to build he says he quotes that even allowed to build in fact it's before the he says that the no it's obvious it's what he's doing is a and there's no what do we see that even build we also know this from today you know everything's with pictures there are many pictures of for the they Pi his father either or building the so it's a but say what do we also see that when it comes to mitvah or the Mitzvah of building even though you're you don't need a how do I know CU building a is not a tell me so in other words when it comes to and the even you don't need it to be a like as long as it's a I guess the is it's not a to do something to do aah even is so big even is big and the biggest is a different he says every person should do something to even he's not different than when was chop wood and would would make the fire and and he should say shouldn't say I'm I'm too above it I can't sweep the that's covered so we see from another that is and there's no I do know the says that really a little different because the is but definitely from we see that even though it's not a but it's enough to allow okay so let's move on we do see even if you're not a even if you're big so we te to now next question is there a said when you put up a so say why not it's the says a cloud it's an a to do a MIT without but here could be the following if the Mitzvah is maybe there's no Mitzvah on a but that is not convincing at all cuz I could prove it because is very good is and yet there also probably and but there's another there is a reason not to make a listen to this in that's the for bread very weird ra why don't make it's a in other words it's the same because the Mitzvah is to get rid of s when you do something to to remove a there's no and it gives an interesting analogy let's say someone's drinking water at night and or by day and there are leeches in the water there's bugs in the water it's not safe besides it's an so he's m in the water and now with the water is safe you make a on that don't make a when you remove a danger from your house so what do we see removing a there's no so maybe we'll say who putting there's no because you're moving a it sounds good but it's absolutely not true because the same RA in the same a few later and writes that on there is a has two if you put up a in your own house you make the if you put up as a if you're work in someone else's house but the ra himself says you make a on and Tak so is that a Ste removing and building you do not even a can't be a first of all is not in fact many people already records the qu it in that today they don't watch so if it's a you can't just change and no doubt about it it's not a so once it's only a it's only don't make but more than that when you take out the leeches from the water so there's not there's no remnant of the Mitzvah when you build a Mak so the Mak is and that's why it's there's no Ste but then I found he also asked this question and he has a very interesting ter he says the mitvah of is remove from myself that is no but I'm also doing it for the workers that are on my roof and the people that visit and I'm doing it that's more of but at the end the day we have to say that we have a very good case to say that on Mak we do make a one of the and he says a a that even a is to do there's no because you can't say do it also and believe it or not one of his is there's no because even a to make a was to make a I looked into the a little bit some say I thought maybe it's included in suicide can't commit suicide and having a dangerous roof maybe is of a suicide but I found a little different that leaving a roof without a is well some say that's the some say it's a guy has to keep a safe environment but at the end of the day like this there is no doubt about it is not set on however as I told you the most there is a you want to see a very conclusive list in the has a long list of says that so basically we're convinced and that's the said as well that on we do make a now so much so although hold not to it's considered and we don't say so definitely we're convinced that a is said on a again the would be if you're building your own for your own house you make a if you're working for someone else again don't forget even though but we don't do we don't do can't take a why not because truma of the of the fact that he can't make a the Taz as I told you earlier the Taz wonders says why you making it is good you know why the is good but if the it you lose a and you don't do a MIT without so that's why the T says the best aids would be you make a one dish and they go do the rest but we definitely see we don't do a mitvah without a so although there is a and other that hold is no but the is on we make a the only question I which is a the r says the to make a the makes no mention of a so that's discuss it but it's not enough of a reason to change the do you say when you make a Mak after all you don't do it every other day it's a Once in many years and question number two someone that never did a mar in his life and now he's doing it does he make a of as well so here the same ra he says on was also said however I must tell you there's a famous of is a few words but a big that the was only said on something that is seasonal comes once a year because the is it's not just oh I'm so happy but I'm alive to see another kanah another PM it has to be seasonal but ma is not every year every other year you buy your suit every other year but Mak is is once in a lifetime so therefore there's no on only plus even the first time in your life you do it where where says the first time you make you make but all say it's not true cuz the first time is very exciting but it's still not it's the first time so they even argue on and that's the first time you do a even though it's very exciting people say don't make because it's not so what the right thing and all the say this says regarding regarding that try before you make down for the first time in your life try to get a and make the and have a mind that well says regarding and says on so basically when someone knows he's being the Mitzvah of Mak either for the first time or even not the first time but he's doing it by and make on that and it goes on the they say a story someone said he was embarrassed where's the because he didn't see he went home looked it up looked it up and he couldn't be know he says I meant buy a and make so that's the here as well not the on a okay someone buil Mak and he was so excited about the mitzah he forgot to make the now he's looking at a ready made ready to use Mar and need to make a yet can make a after it was done so we know that until she we don't really make it we make it after we wash but since the hands are wet it's a little bit so if he didn't completely finish the so he can make a and he completed but talking about it was totally finished and that once you finish theah it's too late you can't make it and therefore he lost the now I had a little a here because let's say is 20 minutes for this m no problem with that that wasn't a problem but she forgot to make a br and started Mak saying can she make a 10 minutes after she that's my question so you might probably wonder what's the every makes a right that's the meaning of at least women men men make a like but women make a afterwards so what's the difference 2 minutes after or 10 minutes after so that's true but that's because the Mitzvah of is the end result so once you lit it you have the burning n what's the 5 minutes after 10 minutes after as long as it's before you can make a but if we hold that the that the mitah is the so the after the mitzah is done you can't make a it's too late and that's probably why it seems from this that the others say you can't make a after the the Mak was done that it's not it's not only which it is it's also and now it's too late what Al so you could to take it down but that's funny because it's a now we'll soon about taking it down now next question okay were making a before when is the preferred time so typically shaking lul eating mat no sh but here the especially if you have a big r or you have to make a railing it takes a few hours some they can even go into the next day so who said you're making IA of such a long more so a little of I want you have a thought of this I'm making a on something I have the mat in front of me I have the in front of me what going on nothing was done maybe it's like over to there's nothing there so Thea the it seems to be clear most say this says that is you make it before you start now here we have a it takes a long time maybe you can make a long time so I'll tell you a Mitzvah that we all make a on even though the real mitah take takes place 12 hours later and it's the next day which make that the real mitvah takes place probably 12 hours later which is the next day a night in between that's the mitvah of we make a before when do we burn it probably 12 hours later the i invol in the old print that it's we see that even though the Mitzvah takes a long time you stick with so that's why the is before we start making the even though there's nothing in front of us that it's now there is now here it's interesting you see the he was not asked about this sh per se but he's talking about making a on that's writing beautiful ch but he throws in when do you make the last Hammer blow very short but he's very emphatic what I think he means to say is if it's not yet a functional Mak so there's no Mak but the other and says this but but so here we have almost the many to make before you start a beautiful also says this but as we said this says but the is before you start you make a now what would be a Mila if you could if it's possible if the worker or the balos whoever is doing it make a br and not be until you finish the entire Like We Do by a true story someone was so excited that always happens by the that he says when I built the actual Mak I forgot to have he was so he just forgot so we we have a problem so first of all I mean this person had a little ner obviously he's so excited about the mitzah what he forgot the mitzah what do think he was doing he excise someone told and and came over to after after I have do it again said did you see someone walking towards you in a white gown you saw that okay that's enough another I know this person he wrote that he finally waited a number of years to have a child and he had a baby and he made P he forgot to have so ra told him that if you said the words what the father typically says that that's enough in other words if you're you don't have to have that actual second that's but it's more than that there's a famous which is very good for people that have ner nervous he says when is there of lack of kavana when you were doing for a different reason you were blowing you forgot that it's R he thought it's a regular Tuesday so he's practicing or he says krishma to practice on his dick on his K but if you did aah there's no reason why you're eating mat on a regular night obviously you know it's you're eating so that's enough if it's that's enough so here I would have thought that when a person's building a Mak what's he doing he's putting up a safety feat now did he have a mind the M of the maybe did but his but even if he did what else he doing it for but all the say that maybe he's doing it to look nice you know yeah you can't have a porch without a a gate around it so I'm not sure if that really is is the case but what I found beautiful he says a CL when a is the end result you don't need he so he has this very sh he says therefore if a person built a Mak and he didn't have he was cu the is there now in a beautiful has nothing to do with per he's talking about he says the following interesting a person built a and had no Cabana whatsoever in other words it wasn't n he had no kavana so although he lost the but he says there's no and if he goes on that roof with that he not because it's a functional you don't have a no reason to tear it down so there we see his assumption is maybe if you didn't have so maybe say but basically I think a person puts Mak he has a at least a basic next question which is most we could put up a that's easy but the typical person cannot put up a Mak so the question is if I get a a worker a contractor to build a Mak did I lose the mitvah do I make a does he make a and question number two would be if a person has a go should work so the the CL is that if I make any other mitvah and successfully does the Mitzvah who makes the BR in that case because the one that does the so if I delegate a to make the a so so what what what I end up with I don't I have the Mitzvah because but I'm missing which not might not be a bad idea because if you're going to make a Mak Mak you know you're doing so it's not safe it's like you know like one R told me he usually tells fathers of the of of the don't make the other mitz because they he said I've seen more than once that makes a and the child's an he doesn't know what he's doing he tries you have to be qualified so to build a Mak you have to be qualified now I don't I don't M that knows what he's doing fine but it has to be you know the P say that is for we want to write your own but it's be so better get a and pay then also but no doubt about it if you hire a worker he makes the the question is which I once clared let's say a builder the typical builder of course of course a builder that builds a house for himself he's not for himself but he doesn't have a b yet and he puts a Mak so the if he's not living in the house and not PL living in the house the only thing could be there's a there's a that so aold that's what the explains on the that Mak is on the bias or bias that's livable is even if no one's living in it not so right that's free maybe the Builder can make a br but typically if he has a buyer then the buyer should get involved and make the Builder a to make the now the question is if the balos wants to get a wants to make a so there is a simple and that is if before the Mak Begins the work in the Mak he should do something so then the he's making a on his but what seems qu saying this hisim and others they all say it's not enough to do a little you know bring the B of cement you got involved you have to do a of Mak to build at least a small ma that has t and but if you don't do anything of significance against you're not doing anything and is not which is problematic because the average person doesn't how to build a doesn't have to build a gate but I was thinking I think it makes sense what the best a would be if the wants to make a is Worth T at least right what he should do is call the P listen I'm going to start I'm going to do as much as I can but I'm not qualified I'm making a making and I want to be with my so then is works if you say it doesn't work for the because he did very little but he's working even that would be an or maybe if you're Min is like tell the fell to work in it do it and the last so that you could do if you know how to do that and then you have a full on the so we're going to say that if a person does have a of he should make he has the he does have maybe again if he could do it he could but typically he can't do it but that would be the best I want to make a point someone to me it's very much a person told me I'm not getting but his wife is very late from their she in the shower when when so a few times he ends up he lights the NYS because it's almost but just no problem don't I'll make the when I come when I come out I'm I'm ready so is that legitimate that he lit in there shabas before and she comes out whenever she comes out and makes the BR so there are two problems with that number one even if it's still before so a could be said but who makes the BR the one does the Mitzvah and that's him the only to be make would be that if shabas as we said earli the mitzah is so maybe anybody could do it but then again the is the and she not doing anything but what's more often the case he told me is she's she's ready to make the after and that no one holds us good because once it was P because you can't do it so getting back to our question what we said obvious about the it's get and the do it right what's more challenging is when you have a work now always I always like to mention this we have to buy Jewish and hire Jewish workers our brothers need p and their families need P it's always to get y workers when I say I mean when is not available but whatever the case is we're talking about a person that has to have a go to work whatever the reason is and now the question is what do you do about a Mitzvah and what you do about the so this is M our from that we began with this is not a the guy did it did a great job and it's a very good protective fence but it's not the and just like a can't do me even though he's a great surgeon and he can't take offis even though does a good job but if there's a MIT he can't do it and that's why it's by hiring a worker besides losing you're losing now but if you hold like the that said two one is even allows you to make a and the second is oh you have a good we have a h if you have to hire and even the could make however again it's very hard to be on regarding because most hold that it's a it's a mitvah and there's no on mitzvah and the truth is even agrees that the only to make is but the other that we said that he could do any mitah for you once that's the truth that even you'll be that you have a but you can't make a then you run into a different problem like I told you earlier [Applause] says why only he says because if you're going to end up having to do a mitzah without a that's no good so if you're GNA have a you cannot make a so if the makes the entire no could be said and that's a if a person has no other and there's no working but a work let him do something enough to make a then he has the and then he can on What's that the is enough to give it a but as I told you earlier and this is important to mention who stresses this clearly that this that we say Y is not every worker Y is when a PO is is indebted to you he's like a stickle of an evid he's to work a full day if you hire him to work a full day you could give him this job and that job as opposed to a c that has a job a job to do his own time his own rate his own progress he could do what he wants so that don't forget that this that the was making was only by a now to my knowledge workers by don't get paid by day a contractor is a c so if a go a contractor or handyman whatever it may be could be even doesn't apply so you have to be careful about that as well now laa as I told you the minic seems to be and that's I think seems MAV that you can't make a on a cavan work with with the Mak but here's the point that we we should understand if the GU did it it's a Mak it's still a protective vence and even if you hold is no Mitzvah or no but the is effective so the only question is did the have the Mitzvah so that's but now let us go back to our original we began with what is the what is the identity of the mitah so let's think we definitely know one thing is a building Su is not even a it's not aah but it's so it's a of preparing for the that's fine besides the that on your door post but we did see enough P that that is is is no good it would be a problem of take it off and put it back again and then you have a this also if fell off on chab so we don't put back because of so can a GU put a back so besides the fact if it's what's but besides that doing should not be done now gra I must tell you as long as it's put up it's good is another interesting is good you don't need you have to watch they does a good job you lose the in a certain sense are also but that's wrong what is the Mas regarding it seems most take the assumption that even though it is a but all the other that we said all lead to the direction that it's also let me tell you someone asked me at first it was scary he said he doesn't know why he did it but he was involved he's a stickle of a contractor his own house and he first built the gate on the roof and then he put the most of the floor of the roof actually his Shila was with a porch that he first put the railing and then he built the floor of the porch now how he did it I don't know but this is what he told me he built the Maka and then he built the gag or he built the Maka and then the porch what's the sh so he wanted to know is that M apostle because of so that's CL it was it was a dysfunctional there was no and don't forget the P says we know by and we and the say so maybe was very maybe it's not a functional so he's and the says about this a similar of he would have to take down the Mak and rebuild it he said you don't have take them the whole whole the whole the whole Mar down a part of it enough to make a on it and rebuild it and make a however we saw a number of times what we call a even if in the worst scenario but it's still a functional said it to the extent even if you have no Noah but you have a and the says this point and he says even if when you built your before the you here and say but the if it's protective keep it as it is so he lost a Mitzvah and like one told me he didn't really lose a mitah he never had a Mitzvah because when he put the gag then he had a roof so whatever the case is you don't have to tear it down I couldn't talk to you 718 851 8651 or email ist at.com [Music] spee right okay the share also needs like a he something around so we have to seek Him make right let's just learned today we did a a pretty broad subject no doubt about it there's a MIT of Mak and it's possible that the is but as we proved it also needs a so basically it's not like or that is but here you have to have a safe environment that's true but there has to be some type of building a or is fundamental different because it's more of a applies not only to aah but even to a we when the the is to make the owner makes the the owner of the house make the meaning is not once the person finished the entire Mak can no longer make a because it's no longer when do you say so most place can hold before you start rely on that if you forgot until the end even though it takes time to but it's not different than the a person did aah of usually is kavana that's what we're going to say if im is could to say he no kavana at all no so he lost the but the ma of course is still functional and it's k a Jewish worker who does the entire Mak makes the it's better that the balabas get involved do something of significance make the of and the I forgot to mention which I didn't find but let's say the Bal made the when the PO was not there po came a few hours later and starts to do the second half of the Mak is to make two BR the B makes one and the makes one so like there's only one so he should not make a if the B if the as we know the Bal makes the if he could he should make a if an Isa was late for sending shabas so she could get a greater light near shabas but the BR is not said the if the husband L for he should make the and Noah makes a if as we said the a worker is employed so there's surely no novah he loses a Mitzvah but at least the can be done if a wants to do part of it he can make a as well there is a of by Mak but it doesn't make a said the Mak is ker I mean it's not koser it's functional it's good enough to take away the lab and even take away the B yeah yeah