Doing Extra Melacha When melacha Is Permissible - Rabbi Yakov Zev Smith

[Music] My boy Mash Hashem. like to welcome everyone to doing extra when is permissible. There's the outside of my was a year like this year when sh was Monday and Tuesday. I'm going to use that muscle the whole time to keep it simple. So shu is Monday and Tuesday. You know typically people prepare for the second night the yumpt for Monday night s they prepare in advance because you only could start preparing on yumpt itself and it's late because the person had no time of yamt to prepare so it was it was the afternoon Monday afternoon and Monday night suda was not ready so they had a brainstorm they have some children or grandchildren even one is enough but well let's say the one child or grandchild that's not going to stay up for the Monday night suit is much too and they have to eat on Monday. So they'll prepare the whole suda, whatever you need it for the suda Monday night, Monday to feed it to the child and the leftovers, no, they'll use it Monday night. So they can prepare a whole suda on Monday for Monday night, but the is they're doing it for a child. So is that a legitimate to allow you to cook on one day Monday for Tuesday? You're using a little bit but the bulk is left over. Do we say since the is you're preparing it for some of the eating today or look at the result there's so much you're doing for tonight. I mean the same you need a little bit hot water Monday afternoon. So you could put three cups of water in the urn and say that's enough for you but you might as well be a sport. fill up there until the top you'll have ready for Monday night. So it's one misa but you're ending up cooking and having much more water. Well the old child you need a box of tissues and jeul but it's only for one day it's only it's today's Tuesday already second day. Can you bring the whole box? You're not going to use 175 tissues but you'll use a few. You need a box a pack of you need some diapers. You're going from the parents house to the in-laws house on Monday afternoon. So you need three diapers for the first day and the rest for the second day. Can you carry one pack of diapers? You're only going to use three of them, but it's one misa. So this is the sug today when there's a can you do more result or do we say what do you mean but you're doing so much extra that you don't need for today. So the we have to realize yam is not hea. I once counted 12 times in it spans when the speaks about no less than 12 times the say there's a that's true is not in fact says if someone cooks onesh for he gets because it's not you're cook but the truth is it's more than that because really we know we have but is only one day like in their world today and based on this although we're very not but tells based you know how to prepare you know how to cook on Monday for Tuesday I it's both but the truth is only Monday is the real yumptive we look at Tuesday I don't want to say it but we look at it like so cooking on yum It's more like a it's like one long day. We do say on on for the second you have to realize one thing. There's an which is an you miss the on Monday afternoon for the laning on Tuesday you miss the one day to the second now there's no missing but that's still an is of is today's sug is not just if I cook on Monday for Tuesday it's not just It's it could be. So we say the word it's really inaccurate. It's really that's that's really going to be us. And all of this is info or for shabas unless you have an afterin or y to the second day even rashan. Now this really highlights what I heard is quoted as saying that is really like but we could we could really not for the second they not for a second there was so they had to eat. So now let's deal with our question. I'm cooking a only using some of it. I'm carrying a big volume only using some of it. Do we look at the just it's one of I'm putting on the the big pot of food onto the fire. Or you look at the maybe we'll say but each piece is I'm doing cooking a pot of of food. every bit of is right. So I'm I'm doing a beta. So what do you care if I have extra leftover? So here we come to we could say it's a beautiful that's really ele but that's based on a and here's the case someone the said he must eat two gregorous now we look at gregorous as the kip for eating we're very tired gregorous is a fruit a fig he needs two figs to keep him alive so the person that's helping looks up. Oh, there's a fig tree right here. Wonderful. And he gets all nervous. Because there's one branch that has three figs on it. Good idea. But he's cutting one extra. You don't need three. You only need two. Then there's one branch that has one fig. A second branch that has one fig. What should he do? Should he cut down the branch that has three? It's one ma is one cutting. But then he has extra. Or should he take one branch, cut it, a second branch, cut it, and he has what he needs? But then he's doing two. Now, you have to realize one thing. When you cut a branch that has three figs, you're not making three, even though you're detaching three figs, but it's the he calls it the is detaching a growing item. So if you cut one branch that's one although you have three figs. So here's my here's the question. One and you have three or two my and you have what you need. So the says in no uncertain terms what kind of sh is that? You have two is much worse than one. Ah you have an extra fig. Okay. What can you do? But that's called and we'll soon see that's not as bad. But making two is definitely worse. That's two. Cut the one that has three and don't worry. But what do we see from the Gmorra's assumption? Let's say I have a branch of two figs and next to that I have a branch of three figs. Can I do what I want? Because one might so the rashim I mean the ran the rash and the raja all say from the implicit that that's awesome is the lesser of two evils it's better to do than two is but let's you haveim in itself for no reason that's and all of that is in the the quotes the case of three or one and one and push it take the three but if you have three or two don't say it's one let me do it that's and that's awesome before we apply this we have to learn a wonderful in regarding in theor says the following shocking first says what's first of all don't one day to the next. That's the given. Like we [Applause] said, adds an is cooking meat. She needs two pieces. Don't Don't worry. Take the whole bag of meat and cook it all is 15 pieces. Don't worry. A baker needs cooked water. He needs a little bit. Don't worry. Take a big paleo, put it on onto the fire and cook all the water even though you don't need all of it. Why is every But wait, it gets more [Music] confusing. You're allowed to add extra meat. You're allowed to cook extra water, but don't you dare make extra bread on man bread for meat or water. So Rashi explains putting meat on the fire is one. You take the bag of meat, put it into the pot. Filling up the water, you have a jug, you put it into the pot, one but as Rashi explains was a it wasn't easy to make bread. You put it in the oven on the walls and you have to, you know, move it around. So each bread needs its own. Once you have an an extra for each piece of food, that's awesome. Now we can add, you know why extra is awesome? Cuz extra really means extra. So you're not making one and I have extra food. I'm being with each piece of bread and that is extra. So here we see that is the only is when you have extra. Now here the obvious question is how does that with says awesome and says so all the ask this question and they both say the same that basically the difference is shabas versus y. Shabis has the of but that there's no is only the Rajba asks a question that's really a big says you're not going to invite a guest on Yam because really you shouldn't cook for a guy a guest on Yam cuz you really shouldn't cook for a guy on Y and if you invite the guy you should guest You might cook for him, but I thought so says no. What the means say is you're going to cook specially for the guy. Ah, an extra pot. So that's not that's the real thing. So what do we see from these on is not because it's same but is more in has a problem and he proves that even under and he says it can't be like like so what's So says a very even if you have it's you have to do it but there's a cooking on is in the it's almost so therefore there's no is because just like the food itself is not not it's so if the the cooking itself is also for the is saying really a big that on is and is perfectly if it conforms with it's one now adds another why it has to be because a person can't cook exact act. He might need more. He might He's nervous. You know, people get all worried. Said, "Just do it right. Make extra just in case." You know, they say if you have no leftovers, that means you don't have enough. You have to have a little extra. Says today and wonders you don't need so much food. Why is it? So says each bit of the food is mut. If you have a big volume of meat or water, each bit of it is mut. You don't need all of it. So maybe this is good, maybe this is good. The end of the day, you cannot point your finger say that's not because all the food is mut. How do we ask in this big is so says and he's right and he says that I wrote that is like this is almost Now I just want to make a point because really the the shab is a whole different sh hope to get to that but just to give you a little of a gishmak of what the is all about. There was a famous shila in the during world war ii when many bisha many eaten had to escape. So they had a plan house escape from Europe. So they were allowed to carry of course passport and money needed to to bribe bribe the way out of Europe. The question is can they also carry on shabas that fill the fill is a big mitzvah but it's not it's not so said since himself in one of different in wrote regarding a soldier that he could rely on the ones that so maybe you're allowed to carry but again these are not These are something that on Shabas on a daily b on a weekly basis. I'll give you another example. Someone has to be rushed to the hospital or a woman's going to have a baby and the husband accompanies her. So he could carry whatever the needs. Can he put in to learn there orn food to himself. So that's and that's the question is either we'll hope to get back to that. But now let's let's just over and we'll apply this the is really like shabas the is whatever you need for today even with is okay let's apply this in so first of all I think I should mention this when we're cooking for y remember the ra's clout why is mut not to be nervous cook extra just in case you might need it the le page 105 said you're allowed to cook bv off what you what you do need or you might need. What about our question that we began with to carry a box of tissues or a bag of diapers and you only need some of it. So this is and this is our that basically we is to carry to put in extra meat. Let's say you're making one roast, one piece of meat, and you say, "You know what? I'm making any Let me make another one, and I'll use that for tonight, Monday, for Monday night. Can I put in an extra roast into the the pan and put into the oven in one in one motion?" So, this is mishumari. Don't say why you're doing it, but this is the case of mala. You allow to put in the extra roast and both of them are roy each one a roy and it's mut. Now the only thing is let's say you put in one piece of roast and now you want to say oh let me do the second one take the second one and put it in. Is that considered a so it's emotion but not a in the beginning on the page he quotes when said an extra is also it means a it means that you're being involved like bread you have to constantly monitor it and work with it but just putting food from the refrigerator into the into the bea into the pan is not a so basically you're allowed to put it in we'll soon see before the pot is on fire. If you put the next piece of meat when the pot is ready cooking, it's not just that's okay. Now, I must mention that when you're talking about cooking extra meat, there's a much bigger theas and the raja when the more meat that you cook, the more flavor it has. In fact, the the raja writes, you're allowed to cook extra meat. Remember the what does that mean? A fatty piece of meat. So double fatty piece of meat. I mean forget about the cholesterol on but the taste is there. So extra meat is not just for tomorrow. It enhances for today. And that's why the pim say is right. You're allowed to make chicken soup on Y for today. Although you're not eating the chicken because chicken is chicken and Y is I why you cooking the meat chicken for no reason. Is not for no reason. I need the flavor for now. I'll eat the chicken on is but making the flavor of the meat or chicken is perfectly m you're allowed to put an extra meat into a in a dish to give it more flavor. Although you're not eating the meat and state in the which printed in the back of the so meat has a bigger now filling up the we'll soon see is also it's one now consider the next question someone needed water for Monday so he needs three cups so he put in three cups why I could have filled it up already. So now he takes a big picture and adds it to the fire to the kettle. So that's wrong. Why? If you make it in one motion, it's one of then it's but to add what you don't need for today and say it's wrong. You're making a new and that could theoretically be if you is the and this says very carefully you're allowed to cook more volume but you have to put it onto the fire in one motion adding afterwards on the fire cooking is notim it is an extra mish now the lion is because the Second pudding is a but if you look it up, he used the word to really denote because again putting water into a cooking kettle is not just a it's a so you have to be careful differentiate between but an extra is nothing less than an extra Now I'll ask you a beautiful sham. Let's say I'm cooking my roast and I put in one piece. After it's cooking nicely on the stove top or oven, I say, "Hey, let me make it I make another roast for tonight, but I'm not doing for tonight. I'm putting in extra meat cuz extra meat gives flavor." So I have a way of adding extra meat. Not for tonight. I'm doing it for today. So the first roast tastes better. So the MS is invar that's that sounds okay. I'm putting the extra rows for today. Now, the fact that I have it for tonight, so that's a a fringe benefit and the MS is that the are it makes a lot of sense. You're doing it for today. But the a little later regarding bread, but you'll soon you'll see when you look in there, it's the same like our case of meat because then the bread gave more flavor. seems to say even though there's a benefit for the existing food for the meat let's say but the fact cannot be sanctioned now the Zion has this very case and he's not there to add a big piece of meat into an existing roast on the fire is doing it for today but I must tell you the he brings this and he says is it depends on your kavan. If you're doing it really, you're adding in a big piece of meat to give flavor to the first beef, then it's fine. Even though you're ending up gaining for tonight, but if the sole intention is to cook it for tonight, he goes with the like now it's got because typically the the rav goes with the but here he felt that it's now when could it be I'll tell you a very good sh someone made chicken soup before yam and they felt it wasn't flavored enough so they want to warm it and add another piece of chicken to the to in the pot, but they're not going to eat the chicken on Yam. So, they're cooking raw chicken on Yam not eating it. But that's perfectly mut cuz that is the real TLS for them. Adding raw vegetables to a stew when it's on the fire. Same thing if you're doing it for now. So, who cares if there's other bishop? The problem is if you're putting in a roast today for tonight, that's when it becomes a new next someone was cooking two big pieces of roast. Someone asked, "It's only you and your husband and you have two children that are you such big eaters?" Says, "No, no, I'm not. No, no. I'm making the second roast for tonight." So this is a he writes you're allowed to fill up meat even though you don't need it. Don't say why you're doing it. Don't say I'm only doing it because I need it for tonight. What's wrong? So you look at the he quotes other Gmoras that har is sometimes okay but is a problem. Now the obviously understood means what you're doing is seems fishy. But if you say why you're doing it that's more than that's the real thing. So the is saying that by talking too much that's always the truth. Sometimes you get into trouble. You got to do it because you're cooking extra meat. But if you're saying why you're doing it that's worse than many cars. That's why it's awesome. Now the MS is I must tell you that even this is really a bigish because if we understand that it's mut because it's giving flavor so what's wrong why should that be and as early as the Torah doesn't understand why the cuz if you say it's a because you're adding extra flavor what could be the problem and both the B and the They seem to agree and they say it's but at the end of the day we did see that the ism even by adding meat don't say why you're doing it the regarding adding water which is one big volume of water he said but don't say why you're doing it by regarding adding meat meat also says but don't say why you're doing it. So obviously he learned that the isering even by adding meat. Now the tour as I told you is seem to go with the tour but even the at the end of the day says and of course we have to follow our that Mr. B says this that you're allowed to add we got to make extra whatever is but don't say why you're doing it. In other words when you cook a big stew when you put it down don't say don't eat that second row that's for tonight cuz then you actually made an ism. Now and I think this might be a stickler of an understanding because the truth is once it's so who cares why what's why is it worse we find something similar the quotes him you're allowed to sleep on day even though your is to stay up and do work or stay up for the like this year or or party you're allowed to sleep on shabas from Shabas but don't say why you're sleeping. Now the question is you're allowed to sleep on chabas because you're allowed to sleep on chabas. What's wrong if I talk you're taking a mitzvah and turning it into an so it could be that's also a you cook it for tonight because you're not doing it don't say why you're doing it but to say you're doing it you're taking a bishop and turning into is so the mis at the end of the day it seems even when you're cooking extra meat don't say why you're doing it but I should mention when you're cooking extra water let's say you have a big volume of water then even the Torah holders Awesome. Because there there's no other reason to think well why you doing it and when you say why you doing it that's not a problem. Now the again is he says if you have a double it's it's even if you say it is but again our is the good news is that and says even when you said some why you're doing it but the never so if you did make that mistake you shouldn't but if you made that mistake It's not awesome even not awesome question which brings out a beautiful part of this he wants a piece of fresh steak on so in our society go to the freezer take out a piece of steak I'm talking about times of the of the what does steak mean you got the cow so a cow is a pretty big animal a lot of steak on it are you allowed to the cow for your mish to have one piece of steak So the is and this is that is perfectly even though it's but it's and is definitely now I should mention the the writes that the in his times was that we don't quotes it but on if it's the question is why you let the whole cow for one piece of steak the is this a bonafide it's one although you have a lot of but and that's why the the quotes one of the since what can you do you can't check a little bit for for a piece of steak it's one. So therefore the whole is justifiable for one piece of meat. Now what to me was beautiful is you're allowed to cook extra meat and adds you're allowed to chef even for a small piece of meat. Now I understand why is why did add k is beautiful adding extra meat is avoidable you don't have to put in so much but you but the is that that's even though it's avoidable you could really just cook what you need but is unavoidable the only way to eat is so is a better than adding than having extra meat now I need your help for the next few shas let's say we have a who needs light. He needs a candle and you have in front of you two candles. One that burns 2 hours that he needs and one that burns hours. Are you on Shabas? Are you allowed to light the candle that burns 3 hours? So, he says if it's one candle with one wick and the wick is the same size, there's no difference 2 hours or 3 hours. But he says if a needs a candle to be lit, so of course you light it for him. When the is no longer needs the light, we don't say tell the to close it otherwise it's going to burn more hours. Burning long is not a problem. Now that's to me I understand it's not an if it burns longer but what's to light a candle for 3 hours if only 2 hours? He doesn't explain that. But his grace writes the if you have two candles and you need two hours burning time one burns two hours and one burns 3 hours don't burn the three-hour one that would be again it's one but don't forget shabis according to the would be that would be the and he calls it the next thing I hope I guess I don't I don't date anybody, but you're probably my age or you remember this. They used to have what's called carbon paper. Now, carbon paper is you wanted to write notes. So, you had one one notes. But let's you want to make a copy for your friend. So, you had a piece of carbon paper basically had ink on it and whatever you wrote on the paper went through and went on onto another paper under the comb. You had a sandwich paper carbon paper and paper. So, the young people that know what I'm talking about. So, make it more lifelike. You're writing on one page and it comes out on the bottom page through the carbon paper and the pel is all the all the of 30 40 50 years ago discussed this there was a student that went to college obviously and there were classes given on shabas and of course he couldn't attend the question is can he have his classmate write with carbon paper and have all the notes so and much more emphatically. He says that's not rebu that's two the wrote two different drafts of notes because we're writing once she wrote twice and that's not I mean was also us all say no no no this is one is so the of I'm not saying college notes is but had been you could rely on the [Music] and but it's beautiful everything has a let's say needs one apple and there are two apple in a tree a bigger one or a smaller one that is a regular now let's go back to A person needs water on Monday for Monday three cups. The question is can he fill it once he's filling it can he fill it to the top and have also for Monday night and Tuesday. So in our times we use an earn. There's my question. If it works out I'm not saying it always can but some people could move the urn put the n in the sink put on the faucet and fill up the water from the faucet right into the urn. Now I'm not getting into the sham if the heating element is off. You're allowed to do that because putting in cold water you're putting on the heating element. Let's say the heating element is on. So the heating element is on. You're not worrying about he moves the from the countertop into the sink and fills it up to the top. Why you put that up? Now let's say he cannot move the urn. Can he take a picture and put it in? Let's take a second picture and put it in and use some for today and the rest for tonight. So this is also is using a second picture. So that we said earlier a little extra doesn't make it awesome. But we see this very mafurish because the mish does say when you when you when you're roasting meat on a on that spit you're allowed to add extra pieces of meat even though you're not using all of them cuz that's bashim. But don't add meat to the spit when it's under fire ready. That's special. Add it before you put it in. So the pisk the piskim learned from this that putting extra meat even though you're putting an extra piece another piece and a third piece is more work but that's not a t is like the writes and see bays going to the well drawing the water slapping the water that's a another slle another slap in the bucket but adding a little bit is just not a enough gimmel also seems to say this but adding another picture if the sink is right there. Build up a picture. Put it in once. That's for today. Put a second time. That's for tonight. That's okay. That would be okay. Don't forget also said that a small putting more into the pot is okay. But what bothers me is something much more significant. When I typically fill up an a kettle, I go to the sink, fill up a kettle. So then I fill up the kettle and then I put it onto the fire. That is vad. That's But let's re-evaluate what we just said. I'm putting water into the urn, right? The N is on. Putting more water into the earn is putting more water. Why isn't the extra water considered an extra? This should be Let's say I keep the earn where it is and I put in one picture of water for today. Then I say, "Oh, why am I about to let me put more reashure?" I take another picture and pour it into the earn. That's vasa. I'm adding cold water into an urn that's right now cooking. I'm adding water to a fire a second. That's a second. It's not that's like putting water into a boiling pot. The b the urn is alabi. It is and that's the adding water to the earn that's on is not is an extra if you could figure out to put it on before the heating element goes on. But adding water when the is on is not it's another it's adding water to the fire. The question is when I'm adding when I'm putting water in one gush I put it on all the water goes into the urn is the same thing because the the fire is on but the terret is since the initial putting on the faucet is because that's what I need for today the fact that it's continued to go is so I think it's partial like that they have to be careful adding to an that's on is only mut in one motion if the water is going going, going, you have to fil to the top. That's one motion. But the adding a second picture is definitely a problem. Someone wants to cook a half a bag of frozen vegetables for for today. Can they just fill the whole bag, pour the whole bag into the pot and cook it all half for today, half for tomorrow? That's perfectly. That is mala is you're allowed to cook it more volume. Now, it's not as good as meat. One doesn't flavor the other. But then again, it's not worse than water. It's one motion. Let's say you want to make lotus for today and have leftover for tonight. Can you fry extra latkas or extra fried chicken etc on Monday for Monday night? So this is the third example. here this a case of each needs special attention. It's like the bread. In fact, it's logical a lot you have to pick up to flip the other side. So taking it out of the pot and then putting it back in the pot is and he says you're allowed to add water one volume of water. You're allowed to add meat but don't make or crepl because each one needs its own people and that would be so breading chicken or making is now the truth is making you have another problem because you have to peel extra potatoes peeling every extra potato is an extra don't get so that's why baking Making cooking volume is okay. If each one needs its own or you only let them make what you need. Someone asked he wants to make a double recipe of kougal. They only need one recipe. They want to make once they make a double have one for tonight. Can you make a doubly big kougle on Monday? Half will be for Monday night. So the right answer, believe it or not, is it depends what type of kougal you're making. If you make a luxin cougle, so a half a I'm not familiar, but a half a bag is for a smaller cougle. A full bag of luxin is for a big cougle. So open the bag and put the whole bag of luxion into the pot. It's one. Then the baking, putting the beel in the oven is one. So making a big cook to my knowledge did not involve any extra or but making a potato kle you have to peel more potatoes. So that would be the whatever whatever the is needed it's more than a so basically the fact you have to do more would be a versus of of of the now someone asked more of a sensitive question they have a small family and she the woman only has a regularized bea if you make a kul a pedacle just that they need it's not going to be a be more like a flat latka cuz it will will fill the bottom but not the top. It might burn, might not burn but it's still mud. You're giving a potato cook where's the rest of it. So when you have a full kgle, it tastes better. It looks better. That would be a good that's a oft for today. The the Mr. Bura discusses a interesting shila when someone made dough before yam and baked on yamt. Now what do you do about the so you allow to eat the and leave a piece of the of the loaf of the of the bread on the side and after you'll mish from that piece of the and burn it but the to bake that bread on yump in the first place some of it a small part of it is an is is the ter this bananified because each one at that time is perfectly Right. Our question that we began with needs attention. You want to make on Monday what you need for Monday night. But it's awesome. Can I make for my child or grandchild even for one? That's we have a few of them but even one you know deserves food. Can you make on Monday extra for the child and the leftovers you leave for Monday night? Ground of leftovers is 90%. So that's if you're talking about frying or etc. That's us. We're talking about a legitimate and you're not saying why you're doing it. You're making a big volume for your child today and the leftovers is for tonight. So this is our and eat a little bit of each. That's why I say you could, let's say you decided on Monday you're gonna have one side dish. Then you say, you know, Monday night is a very busy night. It's a short night. I'll make two side dishes on Monday morning and we'll have both of them on Monday. But a is really to have that second side dish on Monday night. But you're making it on Monday morning, having it Monday, the leftovers Monday night. That's also that's again you're not saying why and you're not frying extra. Now I'll ask you another question. Let's say they finished the food which typically much later and the mother says I need some volunteers. We're having a party and the daughter say what's that? Just watch. We're making a lot of food to taste it. What does that mean? Well, we're going to make the food now. Taste it now. We're going to make a braha. I'm going to enjoy it and if there's any leftovers party we'll have it for Monday night. What do you say to that? So this sounds fishy because no one makes a party especially after you finish a suda. Why are you doing that punk Monday afternoon late Monday afternoon? Obviously that's and that should be in other words when you're cooking for a child a child is also you know a human being say give them leftovers. Why give them leftovers? give him a nice meal. You're cooking before the suda for the child. You're cooking an extra dish before the before the suda for that suda. Fine. But to cook a whole suda on Monday late Monday after the suda for Monday night, that's too fishy. And that taka is a problem. And that's why the spells it out. But the whole is [Applause] Now what's beautiful there's a raja he describes a very bizarre story but that's what it was that late afternoon a few animals I what he do to his animals he from each and the rest they gave to the Gisha butcher. Now you have to realize I think this what the meant he doesn't say this but when you have let's say Yeshua's Wednesday and Thursday Friday is shabas where's all the meat for coming from so if she Thursday afternoon and eat a little bit and then give it to the person that takes care of the meat have ready for Friday and I got to saw the has this very sh the Thursday afternoon they have meat for shabas but the raj says it still doesn't work because it's it's just too much of an and then the Raj is even funnier story someone made and I don't exactly but he coated the kala the bread with cheese I guess on they ate pizza but they had a bread dish and they made many of them for the next night what was the cuz they gave one to a child said that's really wrong you're allowed to make a big piece piece of meat to give to a piece to the child. You add a she maybe an animal for one piece, but you can't make 10 pizzas and give a child one of them. So he says the moer that said this with his was and he really was very critical the quotes and now my plea is the ra that says you're allowed to cook as long as you eat from each dish the says is that says you're allowed to cook a lot and eat some of it and the raja now the on the on the on the says the rajb is the raj is He's a critical of our story, but it's not a kasha. I think it's posh. The raj was talking that you made 10 pizzas and gave the child one of them. So nine are bish. But if you make a food and every bit of it you give to the child to eat and that's the right time of the child to eat, that's not cares. That's a being a very devoted parent or grandparent. So it's not a har is in fact in say is worse than maze it says you know why because when someone's amazed he'll do chu okay he'll get his act together he's become smarter and smarter quote unquote he'll become more and more tricky in and is until after so when you're dealing with an stay far away is a But the case that our case is making an extra dish in the morning for that day is okay. Don't say why cooking for a child with if it if it's reasonable it would not be an but making extra 10 each one needs his own is awesome making one big kage even though you don't need need all of it that's fine that would be that would be so that's basically make sure you make that now what's interesting is the end of says is awesome And says, but what you see again and you see the we saw today was was very not you know in a few different places after all don't be so also writes in not to to So is still now let me leave you with our something to think about over but our version of the fear cautious four different basically as I told you and I'll say it again is a different beautiful but one point we need for now the question we began with can I carry a box of tissues to shul I'm only going to use at most 10 of them I have 165 extra Can I carry a a pack of diapers to my in-laws home on the first day? I'm only using seven at most out of 24. So was asked this question. And he says it's a it's one pack of diapers, one box of tissues. It's perfectly motiv as a different question. Someone has on again on Yam a key ring. He has his house keys and the garage keys which he knew he needs because he goes to the garage to open to get a bench. And he also has his car keys. So on one ring he has and nonvive. So they asked can he wear that ring of keys on Y because says that's a great idea and is that you're allowed to carry a box of tissues or a bag of diapers in was told about this and he wrote a cha very very respectfully. He says the the key ring is awesome because you can't use the car keys on Yam. He says you told me that the Shabas writes this mut in my name. He writes such such me this I don't think he was right. You know I would say why are you miscoding me? But he says I maybe should rethink it. Now shabas himself later said that his was so how do you understand is right key rings is also the keys are not so how can be the terror is it's totally if the is because the whole is so why does it have to be it's one do you care about the but if you learn like understood and there's no keys now you're not going to touch it but the hel has to be a if each one is roy each type is roy each tissue is but the car keys are not roy now tell me I'll tell you another story the I heard this many years ago I found it printed was an ad of the disciple and he came to the uncle and noticed it was y that his there was a hook now we have hook or loop, I don't know you call it on our jackets. There's like a little piece of material that you could really theoretically hang your jacket from that. It's like this hook that I am showing over here. Nowadam say if that's torn on chabas so it's dysfunctional it doesn't work and you're carrying and you're going to fix it. It's so if you have a torn loop on the belt or on the jacket it's carrying on. So Kaz noticed that Burman's hook was to he says you can't wear that on Y. He says but Y it's allowed to carry. He goes you allow to carry what you need but the but the hook is you're not using. He said but it's listen do me a favor. Take my jacket wear my jacket but don't wear your jacket. Now there's a different l this in what held but I want to ask you a question. Even if we go to wear that jacket, why isn't wearing the loop is not a what's the if you have a to carry or do a so the goes to B also wearing a jacket does need a only works that the of A goes for B but A is but it's more than that is Not Roy. Okay. Another question. Someone found asked me once. He found in his jacket pocket this shabas suit a place card from a what's this chuva? Cuz he wore it out in in the street. I said when was the said 8 months ago said thank you. 8 months he's carrying a place card. Now that is terrible on chabas. But even on is a problem is also awesome. And that's why the P advis carrying on check your pockets if there's no dirty tissue you won't reuse or a place card that is totally functionless but again the question could be asked what what's the problem let us say it's the same number one according to it's not right and even if you go with those that are but it's not a of because no you don't need a ha to wear your clothing. What's much more of an issue is people going with a stroller which is we pass and in the bottom of the stroller in the compartment there there's a leftover banana peel from 3 months ago and other nonusable items. So this is more of an issue because this should be removed before y because here you do need a to carry the baby holds carrying a baby on is also only you do need a and it's also not and a person should be careful not to carry out what he doesn't need even though carrying is but it has to be for them we laundry for a child that soils the clothing often you allowed to wash laundry. So the one of the most common child that rub ass is I have my laundry in the laundry basket and most of it is children's laundry. I have some socks, whatever that I would wouldn't mind wearing on Yam. Can I just take the laundry basket, put it into the washing machine, press one button, put in the dryer, press one button should be to wash my clothing as well. The answer is basically it's wrong because your child cannot wear your shirt. So if the heck is it has to be right for the child but says it's another problem because really washing laundry but didn't want you are not clean. So and that applies here as well something to think about the question of showering on is not for now it's a big but we don't shower with hot water on because the bish is considered not a you could wash with hot water that is considered enough of so So in the chas of love why can you already cook water for so the simple ter is I mean that's what don't be but I saw that what he says there but it's really what the meant that means Means you have had to do a so b also the understanding is washing your face is not a pleasure it's a basic human need you got to be a you have to be a mench when you cook water to wash that's not plus that's that's that's a water that's there's no for that so therefore the ra falls to the side you're left with the bish to you That's the one. Okay. [Music] for today's [Music] was 718518651 email.com [Music] scholarship foreign. Just learn as we saw is basically like every that's really it's only not only for that day. There's besides the one day to the next or one or there's also the is if it's one and of course it's one and you don't say why you're doing it. A person's allowed to cook what he needs, what he might need a little extra. That's the why should be a person should not be. But even when he's cooking extra that he knows he's not going to use for today, if it's one and he doesn't say why he's doing it, you'll have to add extra a big cook, a big volume of water, a big pot of meat, carry diapers, a big pack. As long as it's one and one, it's even though the bulk is going to use for the next day. Meat has a special as we said, it improves the taste. But cooking chicken with soup, you don't have to eat the chicken. That's the purpose of that cooking. Adding water to a pot on the fire and say it's wrong. That's doing an extra separate. adding meat to the on the fire that there are those that are because they hold it's considered mash and even that there are person that ask that as well. Even when you do make don't say why even though there are some that are the one piece of meat for the entire one piece of meat is a longer candle is also the question of carbon paper might be too or it might be fill only in one pour and only when the when the heating element is on to add water later is a problem. Adding cup after cup when the heating element is on is a problem. Only adding in one gush or one pour. Filling a kettle off the fire and putting it on full onto the fire is fine. That's adding a whole bag of frozen vegetables, a whole bag of raw potatoes and cooking is as long as you peel only what you need. Latis fried items. All that is separate. Making a big k is fine. A big potato cook is problematic unless the small one will won't come out, won't taste as good. Baking on even though part of ital is okay. Cooking for a child on is that's extra dish and using part is also cooking after the sama even though you're eating some of it. Tissues and diapers is okay. A keyring that has nonusable keys, car keys is a problem. The torn loop or pockets that pocket items that in the pockets that are not is a problem. But empty a stroller from what's not needed and is to add for the adult and the hot water is more than p of no.