Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
so it's good to be back in Atlanta and
especially at Chabad in town where
just to give you a an understanding of
specialty or the specialness the
uniqueness of this particular
place
as I was walking up to the lectern
I asked Robert Schusterman I said oh you
know what it would really help for my
talk would you have a copy of the Big
Book of Alcoholics Anonymous and he said
yeah I got one in my office so
this is going to factor into the talk
but I don't know if you know there's not
too many shows where you could get that
and
that's a very special thing
and of course we know about the
incredible work done here at Jeff's
place
for the recovery community
and how it is seamlessly blended with
the spiritual programming that's done
for the the butter Community here so yes
this is a special place and in case
notice that I'm telling you as an an out
of town guest this is a very special
place okay
so really to start off I want to tell
you something
about the
a Jew in recovery
I I had a conversation a few years ago
with a young man
who grew up
in a somewhat observant Jewish Home
uh they they observed the holidays and
and Shabbos
and he would say the prayers in Hebrew
he'd been to a religious school
and he drifted away from that
and
long story short
he what they called uh in recovery he
hit bottom he hit rock bottom his life
was falling apart faster than he could
lower his standards
and
he eventually came to a program
called Alcoholics Anonymous
12-step program the original 12-step
program and they told him he has to have
a higher power
he wasn't really sure what to do about
that because as far as he was concerned
he didn't have a very good relationship
with uh
with the God that he was raised with in
fact
when they told him to do the fourth step
inventory and write his his resentments
he said my number one resentment was God
himself
so uh
at any rate
there's a
there's a saying in recovery
which is uh
take the steps and you will be contacted
and that's what happened he he followed
instructions he took the steps and
eventually he did
received that call
he felt that God as he understood him
had reached out to him and that became a
very real feeling for him
this feeling of
having a a real relationship with with
Hashem
but he had a little dilemma
he told me
that it's coming up the the high
holidays
yeah
and he cannot bring himself to go to
shul
because
he said what he learned about God
in the program meaning in the program of
Alcoholics Anonymous
he said he learned how to pray
in fact prayer is one of the 12 steps
and it says very clearly
in step 11.
sought through prayer and meditation to
improve our conscious contact with God
as we understood him
praying only for knowledge of his will
for us and the power to carry that out
so he pointed out he said look
the god that they raised me with
didn't work out very well for me
the god that contacted me after I found
the rooms of recovery
they tell me here how to pray sought to
prayer meditation improve our conscious
contact with God as we understood
praying only for knowledge of his will
for us and the power to carry that out
he says I can't go to shul
and Davin
that Hashem should give me a good year
he says that's toxic for me I'm going to
go in there with my laundry list he says
that's that's my my alcoholic thinking
that wants to get in touch with God
because I feel like God works for me and
he has to answer to me and he has to
give me my checklist of needs he says
that that's that's how I was drunk for
all those years my
sober relationship with God is when I
pray praying only for knowledge of his
will for us and the power to carry that
out the minute I flip it and I start
telling God what I need instead of
asking God what I'm needed for I'm going
to get drunk
I'm bringing this out not because I
think everybody here can necessarily
relate to it but because everybody
probably should relate to it
because it's a really good question
and it's a question that I don't think
necessarily everybody thinks of which is
is that what it's all about
you're supposed to come to shul on the
holiest day of the year
and tell God
what you need
you're supposed to tell God here are my
problems come fix them
that's what the holiest day of the year
is for
you know Sidis explains the teachings of
the balsham the inner Dimension the
mystical
spiritual teachings of the Torah explain
that the real significance
of Rosh Hashanah
is what we call
a crowning a coronation
that were crowning Hashem as king
or like we say in the in the prayers we
say we actually say
we say to Hashem rule over the entire
world so the point of
Rosh Hashanah is we're telling Hashem
you're the king we're accepting your
Authority
in other words we work for you
so then how do you reconcile that
with
the popular notion
the way that most people experience it
and most people think of it
is asking Hashem to work for us when you
see people
at high holiday Services who are praying
and they're crying and they're they're
getting all emotional what what are they
doing they're they're asking for their
needs they're talking to Hashem and
saying that you know help me with with
health help me with my children help me
with my finances they're struggling with
this area of life or that area of life
or or a relationship that needs mending
or or some type of uh a challenge in
life that's persistent that's nagging
and they're pouring out their hearts and
they're crying they're saying Hashem
help me but
how do we make sense of that
are we there to coronate God and tell
God we're here to work for you
or are we here to tell God this is what
we need and we want you to work for us
and my friend in recovery was saying for
him it's really got to be that I'm here
to tell Hashem that I work for him and
the minute I start telling Hashem how
he's got to work for me that's going to
start a very unhealthy cycle
I I write in in God of our understanding
which was
the book I wrote on uh I think that the
subtitles Jewish spirituality and
recovery from addiction and it's about
Jewish spiritually recovery from
addiction but I think I wrote in the
introduction there
that there's a there's an old Yiddish
saying
that the Jews are like everybody else
only more so
and I and I and I said addicts are like
everybody else only more so that
addiction is sort of like the Human
Condition writ large it's an
exaggeration of the struggles
that all human beings have so at any
rate I'm pointing out the struggle of
this fellow in recovery
because I think
even though it's not a conflict that
most of us relate to
because it's a conflict that takes place
in recovery then it is it is a conflict
that really we should all relate to but
we might not automatically relate to it
on our own and that's why I'm trying to
emphasize it and bring it out and I hope
you can relate to the question even if
you never had the question before if you
had the question before then you're good
to go if you never had the question
before I hope in the past five minutes I
adequately summed it up and you can
relate at least to what the Dilemma
would be
or at least you're sympathetic to
someone else having that dilemma okay
ah
so I want to tell you what I told this
guy to help him to be able to go to
scholar and Rosh Hashanah as a sober
alcoholic
I told him that
on the first day of Rosh Hashanah
the the haftorah reading
is the first chapter of Samuel the book
of Samuel
and it tells a story about a Jewish
woman
named Khana
or in English they say Hannah
and but I'll say Hana
and Hannah is the mother of shmuel or
Samuel
Khana was Barren for many years
and uh
her husband
his name was Alcona
he used to go every year to the mishkan
in shilai
that's the Tabernacle or the sanctuary
that they had before Solomon built the
temple in Jerusalem there was a
temporary structure called the mishkan
it was in a town called shilai
in English I think they call it Shiloh
Shiloh like a Civil War battle
shouldn't mention it down here right
I don't know I don't even know which
side what I don't even know which side
you guys are on I don't know I don't
want to talk about it actually I'm going
to stay out of that no politics I'm sure
so at any rate
Hannah goes to Shiloh I'm going to call
it shilai that's the Hamish away to say
it
so Hannah went to Sheila it sounds so
much better than Hannah went to Shiloh
right
Hannah went to Shiloh Connor went to
Sheila
and uh
she was davening she was praying
and what was she praying for she was
Bare I told you she was barren
so what do you think she was praying for
to win the lottery
well what was she praying for
to have a child of course yeah it's not
a trick question he was praying to have
a child
okay
and it's interesting
when she's praying to have a child it
describes
she makes a a deal with Hashem if you're
going to give me a son
if you're going to give me a son
call him
I'm going to give him to Hashem all the
days of his life
you're going to give me a son I'm going
to give him to Hashem all the days of
his life
okay so who's the son for
Hashem yeah
Khan is saying give me a son so I can
give them back to you very good
this is such
a pleasure to be in the Bible Belt
where we can learn some scripture and
everybody's
getting it the first time okay
that's right so Kana is davening for a
child but she says right there what the
deal is she wants the child to give the
child to Hashem so Hashem should give
her the child she'd give so she could
give the child back to Russia okay
now what happens
and this is what we read the first day
of Rosh Hashanah
there was a coin goddel the high priest
named Ailey
right in English I think they call them
Eli but we're going to call him Ailey
and he comes in he sees her he sees her
diving
it was
when she was uh praying and Ailey
observed her mouth he saw he was looking
at her mouth why you know how Jews pray
at least the the main prayer the asset
are the 18 blessings
silently right
where does that come from
comes from here
she started it Hannah is the one who
started that the concept of Silent
prayer
she was the first one who did it that's
why we do it we do it in emulation of
her
it's interesting when you see
Jewish men praying
they're praying in a way to emulate the
way that a woman
prayed when she wanted to become a
mother
so
since she's the one who started it
when Haley saw it he didn't recognize he
didn't know what that was today if you
see a Jew praying moving their mouth and
not making a sound you know what that is
because we've been doing it that way for
a few thousand years
but before that nobody knew what it was
so he was he was watching her mouth
thinking what's going on here
aliba
and Hannah was speaking to her heart
meaning she was speaking in her heart
noise
her lips were moving
but her voice was not heard
and Ailey thought she was drunk
Ali
how long are you going to be drunk for
remove your wine from you
the timer
answered him and said no no my master is
I'm a broken-hearted woman
I didn't drink any wine
the ash plate Hashem I'm pouring out my
soul before Hashem
do not deem your maidservant to be a
base woman
because it's with much grievance and
anger that I've spoken until now
Haley answered and said
go in peace
foreign and God the god of Israel shall
Grant your request
that you requested of him
what's going on in this story
if you know anything about
the laws
the actual laws of the mishkan or the
mikdosh
the sanctuary in shilai or the
Sanctuary they had in the wilderness for
40 years or the temple that was built by
Solomon
there are laws that regulate
what happens in those buildings
you can look it up maimonides has
chapters and chapters all about it in
his code of law
and he talks about
the prohibition against being drunk
there in fact it originates from a story
I'm sure
many of you are familiar with the story
of Aaron's two sons
that entered into the holy of holies and
they died in one explanation is that
they had been drinking which is why
immediately after that story
Aaron receives the the Commandment from
God that the the priests are not to
imbibe wine when they're serving
and based on that we have an eternal
mitzvah
that no one is allowed to be drunk in
the temple
if you learn that law and you understand
that law
this story doesn't make sense anymore
because if Ailey thought that Hannah was
drunk
he would not have entered into a
conversation with her
he would have had her tossed out of
there immediately
immediately
that security in the in the mishkan
wasn't uh it wasn't just a place every
anyone can wander in
and there were regulations
a drunk person would have been thrown
out of there immediately
so we have to reapproach the story
when he says how long are you going to
be drunk for
he doesn't mean that she is actually
intoxicated that she actually is
chemically
inebriated
because if that were the case if she
were literally chemically inebriated you
would have thrown her out of there
so then what's he saying to her
he's saying to her
you're in the holiest place in the world
you're in the place where Heaven meets
Earth
and standing here in God's presence
rather than being in awe
of the spiritual presence of this place
what are you doing you're talking about
yourself
you're self-consumed
you're drunk
not chemically drunk
we all know what a dry drunk is right
a dry drunk is somebody they don't have
to take a drink in order to be drunk
because they're not emotionally sober
they're self-consumed
they're completely blind to
how to be of service how to be useful to
others because in that alcoholic way of
thinking before they even touch a drop
they're obsessed with how to meet their
own needs and when once you're obsessed
with how to meet your own needs you'll
use anyone and anything in order to meet
your needs you'll even use God if you
have an opportunity to do so so Haley
was telling Hannah you're coming into
the holiest place on Earth and you're
obsessing on your needs and you're using
God to meet your needs like he's some
Butler
you're drunk meaning emotionally drunk
you're not emotionally sober
so that's what Haley told Khana
what did Hannah tell Haley
she says no no you got me all wrong
I'm a woman of a grieved Spirit a
broken-hearted
I'm not coming here making demands
I came here to offer Hashem a deal
I asked Hashem if Hashem would give me
and you all know because we read it
before Haley came in what it kind of ask
Hashem to give her
to give her
not a child
to give her an opportunity to give
Hashem a child
so whose child is it
and who's this prayer for
it's for hashan
so she explains to Haley you think I'm
here with my laundry list you think I'm
here making demands you got it all wrong
no to the contrary
I came here asking Hashem
to allow me to serve him in this way
I want the opportunity to give Hashem a
child
so when Haley heard that he said oh
very good
continue
and in fact what you're asking for
Hashem is going to give you
she flipped the whole thing
he thought she was self-absorbed she
realized no this whole thing was about
service this whole thing was about her
desire to give to Asha he then he
understood not only she was not
emotionally drunk spiritually drunk
but to the contrary she was completely
sober
she was thinking selflessly
when he told her that's good continue
and you're going to get what you asked
for
so I
I told this young man the young man who
was conflicted about davening and Shaw
I said this is what Jews all over the
world are going to read
in shul on the first day of Rosh
Hashanah
it's a story about a woman
who asked Hashem for one thing
for the opportunity to be of service
for the opportunity to do God's will
Haley suspected that she was there to
ask to make her life better and ask for
selfish things but she clarified that
that she was there to serve Hashem
and we read this every year we've been
reading it for thousands of years
and then I said you know what
if you look in
the big book
you're right in the in the 12 steps
it does say
Step 11 sought through prayer and
meditation to improve our conscious
contact with God as we understood him
praying only for knowledge of his will
for us and the power to carry that out
it's true it says that
I said but
you got to read a little further a few
pages further
a few pages later
when uh
it's actually describing step three
which three is even before 11.
step three is the uh the surrender
made a decision to turn our will and our
lives over to the care of God as we
understood him that's the surrender
it's interesting when it describes how
to take step three
it includes a prayer
I've been asked by many people by the
way Jews and Recovery whether whether a
Jew is allowed to say the prayers from
the big book there are prayers that some
people say in meetings that come from
other religions and that is problematic
but the prayers from the big book itself
it's not a religious text
and uh
I encourage people that if they connect
to these words to to use these words
but anyway
with step three
on page 63 we were now at step three
many of us said to our maker as we
understood him
and here the uh the co-authors of the
big book I have to apologize because
when they wrote their prayer I guess
they sounded they thought it sounded
more holy to use some archaic language
and they kind of use some of that uh
King James type of pronouns
so it sounds a little bit grading on our
ears but you'll get past it okay
here's the the third step prayer
God I offer myself to thee
okay that's to thee to you to you okay
to you
to build with me and to do with me as
thou Wilt I'm going to make it normal
English God I offer myself to you
to build with me and to do with me as
you will as you please as you want
relieve me of the bondage of self that I
may better do your will
okay so you get the the drift here the
first couple sentences this is a prayer
of surrender this is a prayer of giving
myself to God
I'm not setting the terms I'm
surrendering to his terms
that was not a civil war reference
can I joke about the is it too soon
okay yeah as long as it's a joke it's
just a joke
okay it's just a joke okay
it's clear from the first two sentences
here
I'm surrendering to God I'm giving
myself to him he's the one calling the
shots but listen to the rest of the
prayer
and this is what I pointed out to this
young man who was very conflicted about
being in shul with a bunch of people who
were praying from a book that talks
about having a good sweet year
he was afraid to ask God for a good
sweet year he thought it would get him
drunk but let me continue the prayer
here
take away my difficulties oh
now you're giving God orders all of a
sudden it flipped you were surrendering
to him to do whatever he wants now all
of a sudden you're telling him what to
do
take away my difficulties
that victory over them may bear witness
to those I would help of your power your
love and your way of life may I do your
will always
you catch it
take away my difficulties yeah you're
asking God to give you an easier life a
better life
whatever it is that you're struggling
with health money Family help me God
take away those problems
if you can't like kind of you can't have
a child give me a child
but not for me
not because it's better for me
but because it's better for you
give it to me so I can better serve you
that's what Hannah said
she said this child's not mine to keep
this child is might that it passes
through me it goes straight back to God
and all I'm asking for is the
opportunity to be of service in that way
so I showed him the third step prayer I
said listen it all depends on why you
want a good sweet year if you want a
good sweet year because you want a good
sweet year yeah you're right it's
probably toxic for you and it'll
probably be a downward spiral toward
taking a drink again
because once you start getting selfish
you don't know where it's going to end
but if you want a good sweet year
because you are God's servant
and when he gives you a good sweet ear
you can serve him better
and you can be a better example and a
better role model and get other people
to serve God then who's good sweet year
is it is it yours or is it his
you know our forefather Abraham
he had a similar uh situation
going back to uh
we read from the book of Samuel now
we're going back to the Book of Genesis
the very beginning
interesting story here
Hashem tells
leave your leave the land where you're
living
where are you going to go I'll let you
know when you get there
and he comes to
he says this is where I want you to
settle down
and the minute he gets there what
happens
famine
what's he supposed to do stay there and
starve you can't stay in Star he has to
leave so he goes to to Egypt
and uh
here's the problem
was 75 years old when this story
happened and he'd been a monotheist
since he was a kid in fact he was kind
of famous for it smashed the idols and
King nimrod
wanted to execute him for it
and ever since then he was going around
telling everybody about God there's
really one God you got to worship the
one God
so he had a reputation as the big
monotheist
everybody knew it
and then he obeys God this God that he's
always talking about he obeys God
and he goes to the land of Canaan and he
gets there and he gets hit with a famine
now I want to ask you a question
do you think that that shook avraham's
faith
no no it did not you think avraham felt
that if he listens to God everything has
to immediately work out well in a way
that he can see no he didn't think that
didn't shake his faith
so he had to go down to Egypt
and uh
he had to do whatever he had to do
but it's very interesting
after he's on his way back
he comes back and he's Rich there's a
whole story there
sort of got abducted
the Pharaoh had to release her and he
had to
pay damages
so he comes back from Egypt and he's
wealthy
and tells us something very interesting
here
yeah real avram I'm looking at the
Genesis 13 1.
describing it was called avram at that
point not avraham but avram
it was coming up from Egypt with his
wife also with his brother-in-law named
lot or light
the avrum covered he was very heavy
laden that means he was rich he had a
lot of wealth at that point this is
after the payoff
from from pharaoh
the mcnam
he had cattle he had silver he had gold
that was a wealth in those days
of
and he went to his travels he went
according to his journeys I mean
negative from the south what does it
mean he went according to his journeys
obviously however he went those were
those were his journeys
it's a little bit funny and you know
that there's an incredible economy of
language in God's word there are no
redundant phrases so Rashi the foremost
commentator he jumps right on that
because he he went according to his
journeys I mean obviously whatever way
he went that was his journey
so Rashi explains and says
he went according to his journeys means
that on the way back from Egypt he
retraced his steps and he went to the
exact same spots that he had visited on
his way down to Egypt he went according
to his journeys means the journey back
up followed the exact same route as the
journey down there and Rashi tells us
why he did that
in order
to visit the same hotels that he stayed
in on the way down there he stayed he
stopped at the same hotels on the way
back
why
to pay his debt
because remember the whole reason he had
to leave Canaan and go to mitraim is
because he was poor and he was starving
so when he went to the hotels he
couldn't pay them
and now he's Rich he got the payoff from
from Pharaoh so he goes to the same he
couldn't just send them a a PayPal
or a cash app he had to actually
physically go to those places
and he paid them back
so there's a fascinating explanation of
this from the Sam Cipher who was the the
rabbi of of pressburg now called
Bratislava
and he was a great thinker and leader
of European jewelry in the 1800s
so the Sam Cipher explains
that this story has a deeper meaning
when it says that avram went back and
retraced his steps and Revisited the
same Hotel so he could repay his debts
he says
it's probably not talking about monetary
debts
because uh let's be frank who was who
was going to extend him credit
no one was going to extend him credit
he's coming remember means leave your
land he's coming from another land
he's a he's a brand new immigrant he
just got to town
doesn't have a state ID you know who are
you can I pull your credit like who are
you
so no one extended him credit
the Sam Cipher says it was a different
type of debt that he paid
the debt was
avraham couldn't hold himself back from
speaking about God
even when his life was a really poor
model of what a servant of God should
look like in the eyes of people who are
skeptical in other words at that point
in his life
he was not a good advertisement for
belief in God I mean it depends if
you're already a Believer if you're
already a believer that it doesn't
bother you what you know why do the
righteous suffer you don't have that
problem but if you're not yet a Believer
and you see a guy who's righteous and
talking about God all the time and doing
God's Will and then you say well how did
it turn out for you well
we're starving and we have no money and
we have to leave the country and we just
arrived here and now we're leaving
well that's not a very good
testimony
to how it works out when you listen to
God
there's a Jewish concept and term called
Hashem
means a desecration of the name and it
means if God forbid somebody who's
religious or visibly religious somebody
who you associate with religion does
something unseemly so it's not just a
personal disgrace it it discredits God
because people look at this person they
associate that person with God
well was a walking billboard for God
and he's stopping at these hotels
and they're asking him oh how's life and
he's telling them you know he doesn't
lie he tells him the story well I
listened to God I left my home I came to
a new land and now I'm starving and we
have to relocate again
so people were pretty unimpressed they
were like whoa
well thank you for warning me not to
listen to this God
because I don't want my life to also go
the way your life is going
some safe explains that avraham could
not abide by that that was not going to
be okay
his whole purpose in life
was to teach people about the one God
he couldn't live with this idea
that all the people who had met him on
his way down to Egypt might think
that if you listen to God you're not
going to have a good life now it didn't
bother him remember when he was having
troubles in life it didn't shake his
faith
he didn't feel that just because he
listens to God he's owed a good life
doesn't bother him but he knew it
bothered others
he knew that the Skeptics weren't going
to be very impressed or even worse it
could be fodder for them they could
weaponize it
so he made a decision now that my life
is going well in the way that everyone
can agree to it going well now that I'm
rich I mean what do people value money
so now that they see that I have wealth
you know what I'm going to do
I'm going to make sure to go back to
every single one of those people who saw
me
when my life was objectively speaking
from an outside perspective when my life
was not going well I'm going to revisit
them all and show them how it turned out
like Paul Harvey used to say the rest of
the story and that was incredibly
important to him
this also
this also explains a lot of other things
that we read about avraham
I mean
right in the beginning of Paris talking
about the previous I read from chapter
13. so this from chapter 12.
when Hashem tells him leave your land
Hashem says I'm going to make you into a
great nation
I'm going to make your name great I'm
going to make you famous Lifestyles of
the Rich and Famous why did avram care
about being famous
or I'll flip to a little bit later
um
uh chapter 15.
after the war when he went to go uh
rescue his brother-in-law a light
don't be afraid
I'm going to protect you
your reward is very great your reward is
very great
Abram cares about reward
it's the same questions the same answer
why is Hashem telling this this selfless
spiritual think since he was a kid he
was ready to go totally sacrifice
himself he never he never worried about
himself he only worried about Hashem
and Hashem is telling him don't worry
this is gonna be good you're gonna
become famous don't worry you're going
to get a lot of reward like how is that
congruent so you have to understand From
avram's perspective he doesn't need to
be famous he doesn't need to be wealthy
he doesn't need to have a good
reputation he doesn't need any of that
but he values those things because he
knows how people look at him and that he
represents God here on Earth and
therefore when he has a good life
meaning objectively what other people
consider a good life
that's great PR for God
this this is what it says here
this is the third step prayer
God I offer myself to thee right
complete surrender
to build with me and to do with me as
thou Wilt right I'm not in charge you're
in charge at your service reporting for
Duty relieve me of the bondage of self
getting total selflessness that I may
better do thy will I'm here to work for
you you don't work for me I work for you
take away but then it does that pivot
take away my difficulties hold on a
second all of a sudden you're making
demands that victory over them may bear
witness to those I would help of thy
power thy love and thy way of life may I
do thy will always
so that's the prayer the prayer is give
me a good sweet year give me Health give
me sustenance livelihood money
give me good relationships a marriage
that's healthy and good relationships
with my children and with my with my
family and with my neighbors and my
co-workers give me a good life and in
objective terms a good life why not
because I'm demanding it because this is
what I need
but because I've already given myself to
you Hashem I'm yours I belong to you
and now everything you give to me is
just an opportunity for me to give that
back to you
so uh this young man I spoke to
him he did pray in troll that year
and he was able to ask God
for a good sweet year
and have it be no contradiction
with the underlying theme of Rosh
Hashanah of where we had we asked Hashem
to rule over the world
and I think also
that year
they started
after services
a uh an AAA meeting in the library
at that show
so this is this is the bottom line here
if you're an independent operator if
your life is your life
and God is just basically there because
you can't avoid him because he's bigger
than you stronger than you he's got all
the stuff that you want
then yeah it's probably not appropriate
to go bother him and ask him for stuff
especially on the holiest day of the
year
probably not very emotionally sober
probably self-indulgent
but if you've given yourself all of
yourself to him
then what what can't you ask for it's
all for him
it's not for you it's for him
there was uh
gathering in 770 in Crown Heights in
Brooklyn
labovitch World Headquarters and it
happened to have been that that week
a uh
a rabbi
alabavatory Rabbi had been
interviewed on the radio
and somebody I think it was a caller or
maybe it was the host I don't I don't
think there are any recordings of this
but that ABBA spoke about it at the
Gathering so that's how it became a
famous thing somebody asked this rabbi
how come the Torah punishes people for
things that are really Nobody's Business
like I understand every society has to
punish murderers I get that
but like something that's your personal
business like Shabbos
I think they
they brought out in the question they
were like
do you know that
in according to Torah it says the
Sabbath violator will be stoned I mean
you're going to kill a guy for Sabbath
so the the rabbi was being interviewed
said well it never happened
he says the talmud tells us
that in the times when the court could
give the death penalty
one opinion is that if it happened once
in seven years that was considered like
a bloodthirsty Court another opinion is
if it happened once in 70 years it was a
bloodthirsty court so he said basically
yeah it's on the books technically it's
true but in reality and never it was so
rare because they would find loopholes
how to exonerate people and how to never
actually carry out the the death penalty
so that's what the rabbi answered
so the debit conveyed this
and that ABBA said you know he could
have answered a more compelling answer
he said the answer was okay but what did
he do he essentially said yeah it's true
but it just it's not as often as you
thought it was that episode there's a
there's there would have been a better
answer a more compelling answer and he
could have drawn from recent events in
the world this is back in the in the 60s
so that week there had been a manned
space flight
so that ABBA said he could have used
that as a as a as an allegory
you could have explained like this
NASA trains astronauts and they spend a
lot of money and a lot of time
training these astronauts to have this
specialty
and they spend a lot of money
to build the
the spacecraft and the launch and the
whole team the launch Team and everyone
all the scientists involved
there's a lot of expense and a lot of
time that goes into it
and so they launched these these
astronauts up into space
and imagine
if while he's uh on a
on a mission
he's up there in the
in the the the the Space Capsule
whatever it is
and uh the astronaut says oh I've got a
couple minutes free I got a break before
I got to do my next thing
and he wants to light up a cigarette on
the Space Capsule
so needless to say
you're not allowed to do that and to do
so
would jeopardize the entire Mission and
not just all the money and the time and
the effort but even
would be a risk to human life
so I'm Sorry Charlie you're not allowed
to light up a cigarette even though
technically you're on your two minute
break
so that ever said he could have said
like this you're asking how can Torah be
so invasive how can Torah dictate the
way that you do private things that
don't affect your neighbor
well
that's only a troubling question if you
think you're a civilian
but if you realize that we're all
astronauts and we're all on a mission
every single one of us here is on a
mission and when you're on a mission
there's no such thing as downtime
there's no such thing as private time me
time it only affects me
there's no such thing
every single moment you're on that
spacecraft you are indebted to everyone
else who's involved in the mission and
to carrying out the goal of that mission
so don't tell me that's your personal
business there's no such thing as
personal business it's all for the
mission
and that's really what what it's all
about
is realizing
that we're constantly on duty
there's no we're not civilians
there's no break from this we are at
service 24 7.
now that sounds so daunting it sounds so
precious
hold on a second
just wait a second do you understand the
implications of this
this is a beautiful thing
when you not only you work for Hashem
you belong to Hashem
then whatever you need
to better fulfill your mission it's his
problem to get it to you
and when you ask for it you're not being
selfish you're not being annoying oh you
know maybe could I get a little bit of
this
go ask for it proudly because it's for
the mission
whatever you need for the mission ask
for it
you need a bigger house
for the mission ask for it you need to
raise this year ask for it
whatever it is if it's for you don't ask
for it
but if it's for the mission
then there's nothing to be ashamed of
just like Hannah wasn't ashamed
she said no you got me all wrong
I'm not here to be self-indulgent
quite the contrary
I'm here to surrender myself entirely to
a shop
okay I'll tell you one last story
I think I told it here before but it was
years ago since I've been here
so I'll just tell you this one's one of
my old favorite ones
and it's about the guy
driving down the highway at night
he's all depressed
and he says
God if you're out there I want you to
know
I hate my life
I hate everything about it I'm begging
you God I can't go on anymore with this
terrible life God
give me a new life
and all of a sudden wouldn't you know it
he hears the voice of God right there in
his car answering him
God says
my son you've asked for a new life
I got a new life for you right here
the guy says okay thank you God give me
my new life God says hold on a second
it's not free
it's going to cost you the guy says how
much
God says how much do you have on you
the guy says I got twenty dollars on me
God says Okay so the price of your new
life
is 20 20 exactly twenty dollars
the guy says but you're gonna clean me
out that's what I have
that I'm going to give you all my money
he says look at the gas gauge here on
this car I'm driving like it's almost
empty I'm gonna run out of gas and I
won't have money I won't be able to get
gas
God says oh that's a great point
yeah I forgot you have a car the price
of your new life just went up it's
twenty dollars in your car
the guy says hold on a second God if I
give you my car
how am I going to get to work in the
morning
God says oh you have a job
price of your new life just went up
it's twenty dollars your car and your
job
guy says God if I give you my job
how am I going to pay the mortgage
God says oh a mortgage that means you're
a homeowner
great
the price of your new life has now gone
up again it is twenty dollars your car
your job and your house
the guy says God if I give you my house
where my wife and children going to live
God says oh wife and children yeah yeah
I forgot about that
the price of your new life
is twenty dollars
your car your job your house your wife
and children
the guy realizes at this point that
every time he opens his mouth it gets
worse
so he's not going to speak anymore
now he's not going to speak
so God says
taking it all
but before I give you your new life God
says I'm taking it all your stuff
taking your twenty dollars in your
car job your house your wife your kids
have taken it all but before I give you
your new life
I want something else from you
can you do something else for me
at this point the guy knows better than
to speak just says um
God says okay here's what I want you to
do for me God says
see this twenty dollars it's not your
twenty dollars God says it's my twenty
dollars
you used to have twenty dollars you
don't anymore it's mine God says
I want you to spend this twenty dollars
but it's not your twenty dollars it's my
twenty dollars God says so you have to
spend it only on what I would want to
buy
can you do that
mm-hmm
God says you see this car you used to
have a car just like this
you don't anymore it's my car God says I
want you to drive it
but because it's my car you only drive
it where I want it to go you can do that
mm-hmm
you see this job it's not your job God
says it's my job but I want you to show
up there every day
and I want you to do business the way I
would do business and I want you to
treat your co-workers the way that I
would treat your co-workers can you do
that
God says see the house it's not your
house God says it's my house you gave it
to me it's mine but I want you to live
in it
but because it's my house when you live
in it you can only use it the way that
God's house
should be used
see this wife and children they're not
your wife and children God says they're
my wife and children
and I want you to treat them
the way that God's wife and children
ought to be treated
can you do that for me
[Music]
God says okay
so I think we have a deal over here
's your twenty dollars
here's your car here's your job
here's your house here's your wife and
kids and here's your new life
what's the difference between
your old life and your new life
it's the same stuff
just a question of ownership
to whom does it belong
and if we belong to him
Our Lives belong to him everything we
have belongs to him
then it's all for his glory
so it comes Rosh Hashanah we're going to
do two things that are seemingly
antithetical but they're not at all
I hope you see that after I've been
speaking so long how they're not
antithetical two things that seem
antithetical
we're going to give it all away to God
complete surrender
and we're going to ask him for a good
sweet year with health and sustenance
and good relationships
and all the things that make a good life
because it's not our life anymore it's
his life
okay everyone should have a really
beautiful sweet healthy happy New Year
make it a good one okay
[Applause]