Mishna Berura DH Siman 124 Seif 8 The Danger of Amen Yesoma When Answering Chazaras Hashatz

okay good morning everyone we're continuing we're learning Sim we're middle of in said you should not answer as if the AL did not have a and you should not answer it quickly before the conclusion of the bra you should not answer namely where you swallow the N at the end of the main also you should not interrupt in middle of the word you should not cut it in half then the said don't answer what is an so says is in a situation where you're in the and makes the and you don't hear it even though you know what he's making since you didn't not hear it do not answer it's again the opinion of is is when you are in the and you need to be with the and you know what is but you didn't hear it you can't answer a there are those who are that even if you're not if you don't know what made does that that's also called in other words in the world of the's you're the you know what is being said since you didn't hear it don't answer aain however if you're not in the and you don't know what is being said you could answer the is the problem is when you're in the then it doesn't matter if you know what is you can answer if you're not in the you don't need to know what is that even if you're not don't answer if you don't know what is being said CU that's called an that's what the pointed out in we did last time that the opinion of the is that it's only an issue if you want to be with the let say you want to be or but if you're not you ready even though it's aah for every person but you're not inherently or according to the you're L answer even though you don't know what it is you just heard it from others the opinion of is any if you don't know what BR is then you cannot answer aain but if you do know what bra is and you're not in it then you're allowed to answer mean right that was the question what about the SCH in Alexandria how you it was such a big show they didn't actually hear the how are they allowed to answer the answer is that everybody agrees you're allowed to answer as long as you know what is because you're not in that right there there only two definitions of the's definition when you're in the then if you don't hear it you can't answer aain even though you know what it is and then the Ra's definition that not to answer to any if you don't know what that is says you are allowed to the ra says you're not allowed to again that's something about we don't know where it is you do know which it is and you're not in it everybody agrees you could answer how would you know what is if you didn't hear you recognize according to the order of the or or if let's say you missed out from hearing the end of the in other words you know they're in you just didn't hear the words but you know those are the words that are being said if you do know what you're answering on you're answer to even okay so now what we're learning is the expanded that not to answer if you don't know what it is Accord to the you could answer to if you don't know what is right for let's say according to the you hear a you have no idea what they're up to and you have no idea what the guy's saying you just answer aain if you're AI if if you're ashkanazi then you go to a place where the guy's mumbling the bra like he's at an auction house so then uh if you know what BR it is you could answer him and you don't know what BR it is then according to you can answer but again if you know what is being said and you're not being with it you could answer a according to everybody now the brings a more stringent opinion this is going to be the of in the name of there are they that since were that you should repeat that should say again the even if everyone D then we consider it we call it that you're even if you know what up to unless they heard the end words of himself so now we've come to a third opinion of the opinion that everybody agrees to is that if you're and you didn't hear the words you cannot answer the based on that if you're not you can't answer if you don't know what is being said but if you know what BR is being said you could answer I me then there's a stringent opinion that if you're not that when it comes we're going to consider it as if you're in it and therefore if you didn't hear the you cannot answer a even though you know what is being said so what do we hold about this opinion to hear the himself in other words we are that you have to be careful that if you want to be able to answer to hear every word and even aside from this consideration it's a to have and to hear the words of so therefore it's a if you have the ability to tell them in your not to collect you're doing a why because aside from the fact that there's azv to hear every word of are that you need to hear every word in order to answer a and if you didn't hear a word you're not supposed to answer a if you didn't hear a word will let you do it you need to try to listen to every word you're not being with the so then even the r would agree that since you know what is being said it's good enough right because is that if you're not you have to at least know what BR is being said so this is shot you know what is being said you're not the however want should be concerned for the opinion of the and the that we're going to treat as if it's a that you need to be therefore even though you know a is being said it's still not good enough you need to hear the it would be good enough last se you have to hear the whole thing what's the of the M right the Mish said that um that we read that the opinion of the m is that when it's that you need to be even though you know what is being said so M said how would you know what is being said the answer is because you heard the the whole BR except for the end still it's still not good enough uh you have to hear you have to hear the what's the reason why you have to hear the cuz you're being so if you're going to answer it's going I guess it's going to be uh it's going to give the impression that you're y but you're not would it only be words it would only be words that if you didn't say them you wouldn't be if you are being you have to every word you're not being you just have to be able to say look the says like what I said that means you need to hear the and if you miss a few words you can't answer that's how the that's how the grips the that since we hold in that when you want to be you need to hear agreed ising you have to hear every word you want to know sometimes the is very difficult to hear at the end he slows down okay so look I mean you don't even have to hear the end right M says I don't think so I guess according to the according to the m that when you want to be and we're being to treat like you need to be you need to hear the whole thing in other words you know this is another reason why you can't learn during even at the beginning of the right in other words by the way this this comes out uh interesting okay this is a very good point what's the reason you're not learn by there are two reasons number one because you might not answer and number two somebody might learn from you that if you could learn I could talk okay so you'll say well somebody's going to learn from me okay that sounds far-fetched L I'm not going to answer I'm going to stop learning by the end of the so we see here this that's not good enough why because we treat as if it's a that you need to be and the says which means you need to if you if you miss even the beginning words then you're not allowed to answer me you're not allowed to answer me you could do it but you're not to put put yourself in that situation you hear the guy starts Ash and Kadesh is very unclear the way you're speaking so you better off waiting for the next menu for what for what for kadish you're saying no you you hear the way the guy pronounces his words and he's slurring all of his words is not speaking clearly and he has start schra yet so you better off like you know I'll wait for the next minion they have a better chance of being y the next not maybe not what are you talking about guy will do the same same pronouncing the words no you're saying forar yeah yeah what do you mean it's like a it's a what are you referring to what no no no I it's an indicator of how clear the person Oh you mean the guy starts he can't read Hebrew yeah he saying very very quickly and maybe his pronunciation is a bit off meish like he saying kadish I'm saying look it depends what kind of daily schedule you have if you know if you're not gainfully employed and you have all day then uh of course you need to hear you know you don't I'm just saying it comes out that you know whenever the talks about not learning by he he never brought in this reason that you need you're required to hear the words otherwise you're not allowed to answer aain it's not good enough to like just okay let me tune in for the last you have to hear we treat I mean that's what says otherwise you're not allowed to answer a about learning he did say even if you're going stop learning listen to the end of the I'm not mistaken he said that a different place right why because somebody might learn from you but this is another reason right this reason is because otherwise he can't answer a I mean that's what it comes out from this be so one second another thing would come out is if let's say a guy was learning in the beginning of Kes he's not answeres that's a CO to everybody according to everyone when you're being you need to hear it's it's very nice you know a is being said but if you didn't listen to some words you're not you're not allowed to answer aain recording stop have a good day everyone