CHAZARAH - Zevachim Daf 107 | "Nothing but the Daf" with R' Eli Stefansky

Good morning. We're holding Don't get used to it. We're holding on. Unbelievable. So, we're discussing about a person who does and who he brings the carbon on some sort of makeshift misb. It's not a real misb. It's a fake misb. So, so we see that if somebody card and he put it on top of his own outside of the mdash that we know. But how do we see that if somebody outside of the mdash if the happened outside? How do you know that if he puts it on top of outside? This is the so that don't don't read it to them. doesn't mean to them over here it means let me see if I can go backwards over here within which means on top of them in other words as we saw yesterday the two paras of andal are together so the says mix them up they they all have they all serve the same thing why because we instead of reading with the olive we're going to read with the Does it say with says you can't change the the a meaning of a word. You can't change from. So he says it's the v the of Let's go back. Let's see if we have it over here. No, not this one. This one. That is region. In other words, the two parishes are combined and as we saw yesterday it says over here it says over there it says it's even if you outside also which we're going to get too soon. It says that there's 36 ways and in fact there's 37 there's two bringing on top of them is if you shed it inside and brought it outside and one is if you shed it outside and brought outside you're right according to what you're saying it should be 37 not 36 now think about it we discussed if you do outside of the mdash if you do outside of mdash putting the carbon on top of It's on top of him. What if he do? What if he do the other what are the four things you have? So what if you did? What if you did? So to answer the first thing is going to say later on. Yes. So here's the throw a little bit of blood outside. It's like how do we know because I'm learning we have two ways to learn it according to I learned from the two words it comes to include even if you do not but from two other words it comes to include now This this is a lot of the gimmar now going to go back and forth forth and back. In other words, according we could either be from or now if you learn from what are you going to do with if you learn from what are you going to do with and that's what we're trying to figure out here. So simple simple stuff what used what does he learn from there to say that the actually mentions so you don't need to bring both outside it's either or one or the other that I learned from the word obviously holds that you don't need both it's one either the or the new is one out of the And what does he do with the if the animal is missing something like a limb or let's say if you bring such an animal on outside excuse me is singular that not singular but that it has to be whole a whole thing it And why what does he do with there's two types of missing animals animals that are missing a limb. One is that you inside and you brought it outside and the other one is outside you brought outside. So you need two for each one for each. So he said not not a question here we see that if it's missing and you bring it outside your potter doesn't learn the pos why because he actually holds it if it's missing a limb and you bring it on you are oh learned from the word. So the question is what does learn what does he do with the word adime somewhered you just like if you carbon outside does he know this obviously doesn't argue that if you another what is going to This is if you do malik you take a bird outside of the mdish and you go like this with your thumb you putter because malik is only inside the mdash if you do of a bird inside which it's not appropriate you are if you do on a bird means this is the way this because we're discussing This is only through. So we have if you do on a bird inside which is not the way to the bird. You don't shuck bird. You only do malik. And if you do so I would think that if you do outside that's the way to the bird inside you do no only through that doesn't go into but I need the for oh so if you Take a look at this and we're going to discuss it also in the first Mishna of lines up with the there four avoid in a carabal and there's four aid in a in a in a when you go like this into the flower with your hand that's you're you're really mimicking the avoid of and then you take the flower and you put into a second vessel that's kabala and then you take that vessel, you walk it towards the and then you pour it onto the that's so says when you do or outside that's what I said before and outside how do I know this says what do you mean first you have to tell me why you think it's then I'll tell you why it's don't ask me how do you know Potter says I'll tell you why just like so too if you do or if you do no no say is a beautiful maybe we're not so aware of this we we discussed it in the past but not so often if a person and he has in mind to feed it in a nursing home full of people that cannot eat meat the carbon is possible. So that's ara that you only have by you don't have this by therefore you cannot learn from is more you can't learn something that's from so maybe learn the idea of outside from we already established a minute ago that if you do so to say so there's something special about that but forms this he's so says oh so now says the this is what Kobe did smack in the middle of this year oh take and learn that just like if you do it outside so two now what's the problem with you can't learn from anything. Why? Because has a special that if somebody doesn't have teeth, it's possible. Okay. So learn from no but has something special that if perform so learn from but no but so learn from so learn from both of them together and then I have says he can't. Why? Because then for the same price let's learn from and do the same exact thing. Learn from no is special because it's pes. So learn from that if you put it on on top of the outside. No, I can't learn from Allah because it's so learn from both of them together. So how come this apostle to tell us that you do not do one of these? Let's learn from two of them together. You don't learn to be somebody. Let's see inside and learn from and what's how is it going to work? by we have the problem of it's that's this is also based on that slide we just took it we stole it in middle and let me just make sure I didn't skip any words nice learn from both of them no that's why there's a the telling us you cannot learn from a you need a special to teach us anything that has to do with outside that's from special okay so we we were discussing outside of the what if he did performed two bad things outside of he did so this is what I wanted to show you says that comes from one source What if a person performs both of these things only one if you did it by mistake? Why? Because it comes from one pos one source says no is one source. So if you do one and what if you do according to what if you do and two because it comes from according to what if you do and you also now what if you did and so according to everybody only two because according to small is one so that's one and then the is two and according Allah is one and the other one is that's according to since it's two sources. See notice what is doing here. He plays on both sides. Pretty soon he's going to say two. So right now according to one of the all these is one. What if what if you only did you did and you put it on top of your because it's two differently as you can see on the left side. It's one opposite of what he said before this case. Okay, now I think he has Oh, what if he did all three according to everybody? Only two. Why? because one according to Allah is one according to so you can't have three maximum two because two out of the three are one. So they take out these words. We'll read it anyways just in case you don't take it out basically because the bride is going to bring it again. If you you bring you do outside of the maybe you have to do the outside all three mach let's see the three. Oh, what if you take it out into the blue part and you sh over there where you in the in the northern part of the here in this case it would be in the green box not in the purple box. So what if you sh in the purple box? Isn't that outside of the allotted place that you're allowed to do it? I don't know if that's the word allotted, but the place you're allowed to do it is in the green and you did in the purple. No, says no. It has to be like like outside of the camp. is can never any animal outside of the but on the southern part of them is you could a lot of animals anything that's in the category of like all these things that you could check in the in the in the southern part of the If you on top of the roof of the So over here, this is where you're supposed to sing. That's where you're going. All right. Beautiful. So now you just told me that you're not in a place that you and you're in a place that you never so guess what on top of the roof of the nobody there nobody ever there. So if you something on top of the roof says yeah you can't anything then the the puzzle right after is the don't say it at all what do I need isn't coming to exclude that if you did on top of the roof that you're potter not that you're what is going to say no the opposite According to you just say that he's doing it in the opening of the at all. It's coming to include the roof that you are on top of the roof like it's coming to include that if the entire animal is out inside the mdash and the neck is sticking outside that's of course why is the so worried about the part who cares with animal was at the end of the day you did while you standing outside of course the entire animal is outside but its neck is inside and you sh it like that when the neck is inside guess what you are because it's as if you outside of the mdash because most of the animal is outside even though the neck is inside if a person brings a carva in our days 2025 brings it on top of right outside the md you know exactly here is right over here and you do it over here right next to it are you or not it's very positive says because it has to do with how much there is if there's then you're because now you took it out you went from a kadesh to non kadesh but if there's today. So you where did you take it out from? It's all not. So says that it's a last forever. You took it out of perhaps CL when they were building the second BDS they they put up um what is it called that the fabric that they put up in construction sites >> tarps? No, this is a better word. Okay, here here's a picture. these tarps that they they uh now every building every building has scaffolds today in New York, right? With the but yet you put the >> tarps the fabric so that stones don't fall down. This behind the tarps are is is where the is going to be. So what they do is says the put up the tarps and they build the wall on the side of the tarp that we see. In other words, where the yellow dump truck is, that's where they're building the wall. So all the builders are never going to see the inside of the the inside of the is going to be completely covered. But when they build the the the outside of the uh B mikdash, so the tarps, the tarps are I guess where they are, but you're you're going to see the inside of the azara. You're standing in the aar and you're building the wall. That's where these people, let's say, are standing right over here. You'll be inside the building, but you won't be inside the building the wall. You'll be on the outside of the building the wall of the So, let's see inside. They put up these tarps both in the both in the they're standing on the outside of the tarp and in the building inside the bring even though there's no they would eat over there even though there's no wall and they would eat and even So there's no wall around. Why? And they remain in their place holds that you have to put up these tarps to create the otherwise there's no and he says no there's from from from the previous generations from who told Everybody agrees that so each one just said over what he heard from his that they put the tarbs. They didn't put a but at the end of the day they both agreed perhaps that this ask me so according to what was the point of putting up the tarps if it doesn't create. So what does it create? So it's just so that it's not appropriate to show the inside of the to the world to show all the the and we have to put around from this that we had a few times of have a wonderful day. I'll see you from >> merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor a share today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdyop.com.