0:00 / 0:00
Rabbi Yom Tov Glaser - Jewish Thought: Don't Be Afraid to Be a Yid
174 views
Follow us: https://www.hidabroot.com https://www.youtube.com/@Hidabrootcom https://www.instagram.com/hidabroot_global https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VbCYZjl1CYoa4ulQIK2q What is the biggest fear people face when deciding whether to become an observant Jew? Rabbi Glaser explains how to deal with the challenges that arise when taking on Jewish values. For more inspiring content: @Hidabrootcom
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
what we'd set up was the
the question that had to do with change
and what gets in the way of change
and we spoke about various things
about how we can
integrate something that's new to us
that leads to change which could be
anything it really could be anything it
could be a style of playing guitar where
you
learned a better style but you're going
to have to implement that it could be
a
principle in life that you want to
incorporate
but because we're here in jerusalem
we're just and kind of the subject is
judaism and torah
so we were going even more specific
straight to the jugular of what do you
do when judaism
is
the thing you're actually um
putting under the microscope
and you're gathering evidence on the
veracity
of
torah
you're trying to figure out the veracity
of torah
the claim of judaism the claim of sinai
the claim of the rambam the claim of
rebellion the claim of hill the kingdom
of shama the claim of all of the jewish
sages for thousands of years
is that sinai actually happened that the
torah is
real that um our history is as it has
been
uh written and
tr and carried down the
tradition like through the thousands of
years through the millennia
and that basically this is the real deal
so we're gathering evidence on that
because we're trying to be scientific
about it and we want to know if
something's if you want to know if
something's real it's got to hit some
threshold of evidence
now you could you
could not have absolute evidence because
you weren't there
so you're going to be relying on what
kind of knowledge
not absolute knowledge but
you better answer this i'm gonna walk
out for everyone who was here yesterday
two types of knowledge no notes no notes
absolute knowledge and
what
oh
you just saved the entire class
deductive knowledge
now none of us were there so we got to
already knock out absolute knowledge
because
we weren't there
so we're left with deductive knowledge
and so we gather evidence and gather
evidence gavin evans and
and and when we say evidence it's not
always going to be empirical evidence
like asia tour is really good at
offering
but it could be intuitive knowledge
sometimes you just intuit something and
it's real to you and that's it
it could be intuitive as well
for example pixie you might be
impressed by and maybe intuitively know
something's real
if you can tell the stories of it to the
three-year-olds
you can read the stories with the
five-year-olds
and see their eyes light up to the
stories
and then see the 18 year olds reading it
but obviously going into depth in the
laws of it all
and then you can find people in their
60s 70s 80s 90s just their eyes already
spinning from the
incredible light there
they are extracting
that they're extracting from the same
story that the three-year-old
was reading
do you see how that's an intuitive
knowledge like hey
there's something here for everybody no
matter what age you are there's a
universal
thing going on here
for someone else another intuitive
example would be
uh and this happened to my wife this you
want to hear how my wife became
observant nothing with god nothing to
assign anything with any of that stuff
it was simply she went to a class while
she was at hebrew university where it
took modern issues and let all the all
the university students fight out the
issues with all their varying majors and
degrees
and they would fight out the issues and
then the rabbi would present the torah's
take on that particular topic
which like right now i'm studying tome
and i'm studying break and entry and the
use of lethal force
that's a talmudic passage
and
so you know different states are going
to actually google the different states
and their different laws regarding
lethal forces it's an issue
that people especially in law and
criminal law would like to know about
and write law
based on the state you're in you want to
write law about that
figure out what the right laws are
so
they the pro the rabbi would bring the
issues up let them argue it out
and then in the end of the class and
don't forget there was hot rugalach
which is why my wife came in the first
place she just wanted the hot rug luck
you know what rug allah
it's a little chocolate pastry it's kind
of a wrapped fila dough thing you know
yeah
back to our business why are we
discussing chocolate regular oh because
my wife was eating the chocolate rug at
this class
this is way out okay back to business
after a few weeks of this class the next
thing my wife knows she is keeping
shabbat kosher and everything
no concept of god no concept of tariff
from god none of that stuff
she just realized that this rabbi had
such an angle on every single modern
issue whether it was euthanasia whether
it was abortion no matter what he what
they were dealing with that he always
like way trumped the students
and really cut through it all like
really cut through it all but it wasn't
the rabbi cutting through at all it was
our sages cutting through it all so my
wife just figured
hey if this if the sages kept shabbat
if rebbi akiva kept shabbat i'm keeping
shabbat if the ram bomb kept kosher i'm
keeping kosher every name the rabbi
threw out from the tradition of rabbinic
literature
they were all keeping shabbat they were
all keeping kosher they were all wearing
to fill in if they were men and they
were all
living the life if they were
you know
they were all living the life of a
jewish jewish observant life so my wife
said i'm in
no concept of god none of that business
no prayer no none of that
it was only a long time after
that she was standing actually at an
asia tour event which you're all welcome
to we do a very big event that's coming
up today's the twenty
fifth day of the home or sixth day today
today is the
25th today's the 25th day of the omer so
another 25 days we're exactly midway
today's 26
i hear much locus
26 is tonight no tonight not today
last night was
you have to clarify this
no don't check right now
i got it right here
it's on my calendar
today is
she might be right
it is let's see
it's the 26th day of the overt
you won
one
good job so it's the 26th day of the
army in case anyone was spaced out
please say after me
it's the 26th day of the over try that
together it's the 26th daily
when you say that you get a mitzvah
because our mits was to count
so you just counted you did a mitzvah
just like boom mitts was never we're so
easy
anyway 24 days from now
we'll be holding hosting a special event
it's all night learning in this lobby
right here and we pack the place people
come from all over town and tell your
friends like it's really
a couple hundred people usually come
and
there will be classes all night long
and she came to that class the she came
to the all-night learning but it wasn't
until sunrise when she stood
overlooking the western wall
with
80 000 people down there in total
silence can you imagine getting 80 000
jews to be quiet at the same time
80 000 years in total silence
and she stood there and she kind of got
this
moment of there is a god
and then she became
a god person
but she was fully observant do you get
that was there a proof at all of sinai
was there proof of god in any of that
story
zero
and now she's here 25 years later
you know with like fully dedicated never
veered
never veered from that
epiphany that she had it at the hotel on
chavo at night and
never veered even from wanting to
be like the rabbis the rabbis are doing
i'll do it
i mean how am i supposed to say i know
more than them
they cut right through it all and always
get right to the core of things
they understand some they understand
things about some of the most modern
issues
that we're just barely able to get our
heads around and they seem to have cut
right through it so if they kept kosher
i'm keeping kosher
or
am i somehow smarter than them
someone was smarter
have you ever thought about that
can i just share with you guys this is
going to be a little harsh not for
essentials but it's a parenthetical
have you guys ever thought about
have you ever thought about the move
not i'm not talking about someone who
never kept shabbat never knew about
shabbat but you ever thought about the
move away from something like shabbat or
kosher
meaning
i know no one ever did it intellectually
it's purely emotional but just think of
it from as if you were being
intellectual you're basically saying you
know more than the rambam
rebbe mayor the vilna gone rebbi akiva
you know the
like the list goes on and on and on and
on of the greatest greatest minds that
ever lived that plumbed the depths of
all of creation
and they all
kept the shabbat
they all kept kosher
and so what i'm saying ultimately is i
am
i i must know something they didn't
i'm purely obviously no one would ever
not keep shabbat except emotionally
meaning they had some other issue but if
you went purely intellectual it's like
you know something they didn't you get
that like there's oh the rambam what'd
he know
you know i know better than rambo
no one lives in a purely intellectual
mode though if you look at it
scientifically it's basically
we're saying we know more
than them
okay back to our business
there's knowledge that is evidence
gathered and there's knowledge that's
intuitive and that was a long
discussion on intuitive knowledge
back to us
whenever you're trying to figure
something out you have the issue of
fear there might be fear like if you're
afraid of flying no amount of evidence
will ever get you on that plane if
you're really afraid of flooding
and you can gather evidence you're still
not getting on if you're afraid of
having your heart broken
because you've been hurt before
so there's no amount of evidence that
the person you're dating is the right
one
you'll just keep pushing it off and
pushing it off because there will be no
amount of evidence
because you don't get hurt again
if you've ever lost money big in an
investment
there's no amount of evidence that
there's a good investment
that will get you to invest again
unless of course you're going to be very
courageous
and there are people get married and
been hurt
but they're being very courageous
and there are people who invest after
losing money it may take them some time
they'll skip a lot of good investments
and kick themselves for having skipped
them
but eventually they'll
they'll invest they'll get the courage
they're going to invest their money
but the fear factor takes away our
intellectualism meaning
meaning we'd all like to pride ourselves
that we're intellectual people
but whenever it comes to
gathering evidence for something that
has a fear factor we suddenly become
unintellectual
and the question is why
why does the fear factor make us
intellectual
or that's not the question the question
is what is the fear
what's the fear no it depends on the
thing is it flying is it getting hurt is
it losing my money what's the fear and
so yesterday matan we listed all the
different possible fears with judaism
but what we discovered was the number
one fear
in
regards to in regards to judaism the
number one fear is who remembers it
what will they
say
that's the number one fear is what will
they say
which is pretty wild
because nothing would change or anything
like that here you're like it's a full
lifestyle shift
but that's not the issue
i mean you could have all kinds of
lifestyle shifts that would be fine with
you
you know if you suddenly won a billion
dollars you'd have a lifestyle switch
you'd be happy about it
you'd enjoy every part of the lifestyle
switch
we don't have issues with lifestyle
switch
our issue is what will they say
if i have a lifestyle switch
well if you win the lottery i'm just
shaking i'm not nervous i'm trying to
get the ink into the pen
um
if you have
people like what happened
seems really nervous about this point
so if you have
if you have a lifestyle switch
that had to do with you winning a
billion dollars
they will say a lot this can be good
stuff or bad stuff
good stuff
if you have a lifestyle switch that is
toward
observant judaism
and you were raised hasidic
and then you bailed
and then because of all the evidence you
decided to come back
what will they say
they'll say baruch hashem he's back
hashem she's back
but if you're raised secular and your
parents put all their eggs in the
secular basket
and that's where they've invested their
life and their education
and their
own kind of delivery of right and wrong
to you
and then you suddenly like win the
judaism lottery
what would they say
and what would the siblings say
what would the friends say
what are they going to say
well what they should say is what what
does it take what does it take to be
someone who integrates judaism
from from having not been raised that
way and we spoke a little bit about
those different attributes we spoke
about being strong
stroke rap being committed
spoke about spoke about being
independent in your thinking
independent we spoke about what are some
other ones
which i was sorry about
and the number one what was it
integrity
because a lot of people heard those same
classes and it didn't stick they did not
integrate the information whereas you
heard the information and you
became the information a very rare
character trait to me
not too many people become information
these days
just get to illustrate that i used to be
a little bit jealous of high school
dropouts
in yeshiva life because
because i just noticed in the students
that the high school dropouts integrated
much better than the university students
the university students had had many
years
of non-integrated overload information
that they had to somehow get onto a exam
which would be an essay or test of some
sort
they had to take information and quickly
kind of mesh the
the numbers and then quickly pop it out
onto some exam and and if there was ever
if there was any time to integrate it
it would already be in a new semester
and new information and more exams
and not to mention the party environment
which means you're cramming a lot even
if you're not a crammer you're
definitely going to be cramming up quite
a bit
and
so you're cramming the information which
means there's no way you're ever going
to chew you're not even going to chew on
it to digest
whereas the high school dropout or the
guy who never went to university but
finished high school
is used to sitting on
ideas
like chewing on it
swallow it
digest it
see how it works
see what it means to you
maybe implement it for a few weeks
see where it goes
i've noticed over the years just
watching students who didn't go through
those four years of
rammed in information compared to those
who got to have it nice and smooth
and then came to hear about judaism and
noticed there was a correlation with
them that they were able to their
integration levels or
integrity was higher
and it's wild to think about because the
ones who went to university had many
more classes on ethics and sociology
they had much more history on like the
evils of his of you know humanity on you
know in history and the wars and the
you know they of any one should have
been more integrity
the university graduates should have the
integrity they had
heard much more about what could go
wrong with human civilization than the
high school kids
but they displayed a lack of being able
to integrate the information
compared to the high school kids
it's interesting just a thought about
life and integrity
now
are families going to say these things
about you best friends are going to say
these things about you
parents are going to say these things
about you siblings they're going to say
these things cousins aunts uncles are
they going to say these things
no way they're not going to say any of
that about you
they're going to say we always thought
you were a little
odd
you were you were always looking for
something weren't you
yes
you were weak
you were you had
he's having a weak time
meanwhile you're meanwhile doing
something like of jewish observance it's
kind of like uh when we grew up the boys
had to do pull-ups and the girls had to
hold themselves up on the bar anyone go
through any of this stuff
the girls had to hold themselves up and
it was just a matter to pass the
physical thing you had to like hold
yourself up for a certain amount of time
do any women have to do this
you had to do this
would you have torah schools or
something
you grew up in tourist schools
yeah so you probably didn't know you
guys grew up you didn't have to do that
growing up
you didn't have to do that
you grew up in a tourist school yeah
everyone here grew up in tourist schools
we have one woman here who didn't grow
up in a tourist called do you grow up in
a tourist call
and they didn't make you hold a pull-up
for a long time
i just asked a group of women this like
two nights ago and like half the room
said they had to do this
anyway but can you imagine being told
you were weak
while holding yourself up
for like weeks months years at a time
holding fast
to jewish values
in the middle of a river going the
opposite direction all the time like
every single every single piece of media
every billboard every every new style is
going directly against something you'd
wear to a chat you know it's like you're
always going against this river
and you're just holding that pull-up up
and somehow
friends and family are considering you a
little weak right now
right
so
when in fact these are this is what
you're doing so from now on for the rest
of this class we're going to discuss
why you should never ever worry about
what anyone thinks of you
and i'm happy to hear more ideas than
the ones i'm going to share
um first of all i'd like to just make a
little
visual just to get a picture of what
we're talking about here
um
make a
kind of a
chart here
not sure how to do this but
see one two three four five six seven
one two three four five six so that
might work is there a center here
one two three
one two three i have to make one more
row maybe
i need a center here
is this the center
was this just a mathematical thing that
it had to be even
it probably had to be even can someone
tell me where the center is is this the
center here
okay i put an x there
that x is you okay
you're in the center
and around you are your immediate
friends and family like your immediate
family here and a best friend let's say
okay so they get an ex too
because you're from a certain
neighborhood with a certain scene and a
certain way of doing things it's like a
culture that a little micro culture of
where you're from i mean think about it
your parents didn't name you some weird
name like
moon unit or dweeble or something like
that
they gave you a name and when they gave
you that name it fit into some kind of a
culture in your neighborhood your
community something
but it wasn't like totally out of the
blue that's why you'll notice like for
example my persian friends
when they first started coming to
america so i got to immediately have
persian friends because of our synagogue
and they
they had english names that were really
funny
i don't know where they got their names
but no one was naming their kids these
names
like one family alone there was not a
single kid i knew with these are their
boys three boys
not a single kid i knew in a giant
public school had any of these names
came in
there was george
manny
and claude
what and they choose that on the
airplane over from iran or something
and there's nothing wrong with the names
they're great names and i know george i
had a george here yesterday the nothing
wrong with claude cloud's kind of cool
name manny it's my dad's name you know
but just you know how generation have
names used in generations use names you
don't use
all three of those names were just way
out of a hat for west la
you know but they
that's not the way it usually goes what
usually goes is they give you a name
that fits and there's choices of schools
they're going to send you to a school
that fits also
and they're going to go to a if you're
jewish they're going to go to a
synagogue that fits
there's a lot of choices in the
synagogues and they're going to choose
the one that best suits the lifestyle
that they're raising you in
but not only is your family all exes so
are your friends and your cousins and
your uncles and your aunts at least if
they live somewhat nearby
and the and then the community
and so it goes
i'm really getting tired of doing this
now of course when you go further out
you know like you know you drive 100
miles or something
you're going to get a different style
and i can tell you where i was raised i
was raised in probably one of the
snobbiest places in the world
maybe just below beverly hills
just below beverly hills it goes beverly
hills
bel air
brentwood
i grew up in brentwood and we probably
had the largest house and largest
property in all of brentwood and our
house was worth some two times any home
in beverly hills that was part of the
regular
south of sunset boulevard beverly hills
not the big estates but the regular
plots and
if you even drove from my house
five minutes you were already in a
different culture than what our culture
was
and we may not play with you and if
you're from the valley
forget it
we're not even going to talk to you if
you're from the valley
but basically
even being south of sunset
i i was you know sunset
sunset boulevard brent only has a few
blocks north but if you were south of
sunset
it was like
that's okay
you know pat him on the top of the head
yeah
even five minutes from our house was a
totally different world compared to the
x-land we lived in
in all of our relatives in those
neighborhoods and stuff
that's what we lived that's where we
lived that was our world
now
you had the same exact thing it may not
have been this kind of fancy place but
wherever you're from is x
right or wrong
where are you from daniel
whereabouts
had an x probably similar to a lot
bigger an area than we had in brentwood
were you from nice lady
toronto in what part what part of
bathurst
and there was a style there wasn't there
that's that was different than uh
yeah
so
it's different than thornhill right yeah
thornhill's got thornhill is z or
something you know uh
where are you from ben
which town
lawrence has a style
and lawrence is not cedars
it's different
it's different not very
not very different but
yeah
it's different
my time where you from
jerusalem
so jerusalem's definitely got a style
that you're not going to find in
ramat ghat or or did you say that right
got
kirat got it's not going to have the
same thing certainly not tel aviv
as much as the shook's gotten really
cool
right you come to party at the shook
sometimes
yeah you come to the party
i live in the shook
my neighbors are not happy about the
party
i'm happy about the party
i like the party
it's just a little interesting when they
walk by shaking their heads and all of a
sudden they see me holding a half a
liter beer
just going like
this is amazing how did this come to my
neighborhood
yes
they're walking by gun
the past
there goes the neighborhood
anyway the um
yeah but i mean it is incredible
five minute walk from my house there
must be
over 20 types of boutique beers
from israel alone not to mention the
ones from all over the world that are
being served there
and a five minute walk from my house and
i grew up i grew up loving beer from the
youngest stages
it's the whole shook every single place
in the show
okay
if you win if you win no no it's not you
go to any of those even the restaurants
like the fish and chips place remember
the fish and chips place in there so if
you look in there you'll see they have i
think they have two different varieties
from alexander which is in
uh brewing bay chemish
so you know the person who doesn't know
what they're doing says give me a gold
star and a macabe but anyone knows what
they're doing is just like
i'll take the pale ale i had one from
ramallah
you drank that
the tybee beer yeah it was the bottle or
the untapped um
yeah
don't drink on bottles
yeah from now on only on tap only on tap
so let's just say
let's just say
that you
you have some experience
is have some experience where you leave
the world of x you left the world of x
yeah it happened to me i went to europe
i traveled through europe 17 countries
for several months
the first few days i was you know
enjoying a smoke and a beer with uh
europeans and
they were always talking badly about
americans
and i would always kind of pipe in and
say
i'm american
can we change the subject or just like
please stop doing it and they were like
you're american
can you explain why you never fight a
war anywhere near your country
and i was just like no
yeah
and they would just like as soon as
they'd find out i was american they
would just go in on me
you know and and
this was going on for day after day
and
by the end of the week of my very first
week
i was no longer an ex
from brentwood
i was a backpacking
why
i became a why
who suddenly it took a week but suddenly
had an open mind about where i'm from
and
what we consider normal as americans is
not necessarily normal it's just what's
normal for us
but it's not normal in the rest of the
world
you know like europe's fed up with
google's infiltration into our lives
americans would never even think of such
a thing
we have such a like we're so like
classified by
placated by
no one would ever try to harm us because
we've never dealt with such things
and europeans are just like
get out of my business
and they're making lawsuits against
google
which the us the us is printing it in
their news but no one in the us would
ever think about
such a thing
which is really wild because the whole
point of the us was
what was it life liberty and the pursuit
of happiness but liberty part of liberty
is the privacy to
to
fulfill your own
destiny without everyone having to know
about that
and europeans don't like that
anyway i became a why
when you hear new information or go to
an environment that is not your own
you become a why you can't help it you
may fight for a few days but eventually
if it's logical if it makes sense
if it's realities that you just never
considered before that you're saying i
think this is real
you become a why
and
in order for you to be a why
for most people they need to be around
wise for a while
but sometimes you got to come home
and so you come home no longer an x
and now you're a y does that look like a
y yeah
i'll make it better
you come back as a y
and how's it going over there how's it
going being a y amongst all those x's
look at that does that look like fun
is everyone would be like hey here comes
the y
we're making a parade for mr y coming
off the airplane back to wherever you're
from
they're all gonna be really excited
about your you being away
no one's gonna be excited about that
no i mean you might have someone who's
like very evolved and like they're an
evolved person and they're like really
you know they're curious they'd like to
know what what happened
and stuff like that most people are
gonna be freaked out you wanna hear
something
the further they are away from you like
these people do these people really care
that you came back as a why
not really
maybe someone will like gossip a little
on a phone call about you hurt you hear
who freaked out
when you come in tighter
these people yeah they'd raise more of
an eyebrow it's a little uncomfortable
around you but okay
not a big deal but once you start
closing in the closer you get
the harder it is for them that you're a
why and the more likely you're going to
hear about it
they're they're not going to be able to
help it stuff's going to come out about
you being a why
and they're going to be very
uncomfortable very unhappy and they may
even attack
not necessarily physically but at least
verbally
now you guys tell me what's their
problem you see it up there what's
what's what is this group here let's go
the for closest x's what's their problem
what
you're affecting the x's around okay
what do you mean by that
there's a y in
i mean you're you're like the flying the
ointment you're
yeah you're different you're bothering
them
someone else just be creative whatever
comes to mind
what's bothering them about you
okay we're good enough stuff we taught
you stuff we were
all about you know you obviously found
something else out and now you've kind
of thrown our values into the waste
basket
maybe they because in this case let's
say it's judaism that's go on the table
here so they're like
uh this is a little too close to home
here because i'm also jewish maybe i'm
supposed to be doing this too
yeah look in the mirror
like
maybe i'm supposed to be doing this
stuff
somewhere deep and hard they feel that
you are right
yeah maybe you're right and no one wants
to be wrong
and deep down probably a lot do feel
you're right because if it's your
parents they remember their bubbies and
zadie's
and their bubbies and zadies were
shaking their heads watching them
assimilate
they're bubbies and zadies and it's not
easy to have your parents shake your
head i don't care how much you think
you're good at like not caring about
your parents shaking their head
you care when your parents shake their
head
it's just the facts
so they saw their parents shake their
heads as they assimilated and now
they're kids shaking their head
you know you know they got it from the
outside now they're getting it from the
inside someone's shaking their head
and and
it's real uncomfortable
real uncomfortable
but none of you got it yet
i mean you all got aspects of it but not
it okay i'm looking for i wouldn't have
drawn it all up there if i
it's something else yeah they're
concerned that you don't respect their
values
okay and they might be feeling
disrespected and probably are
feeling judged judged
that you're judging
whether or not
one sec one second picks whether or not
you are judging they're feeling judged
right you could come back like so not
judgmental and they're just by the very
fact that you're living a lifestyle
that has integrated jewish life
yeah they're just like feeling judge
well the guilty conscience but they're
also feeling judged by you
pixie
yeah like you've you've changed you've
grown and they stayed the same that's
another one very good you guys got a lot
of excellent ones i mean you also
changed the whole um mathematical
equation
like
they see themselves in relation to you
you switched around everything all the
angles
so you're so i forgot your first name
sure is much more on it much more on it
let me go let me go a little further
remember how i said that from wherever
you're from
five minutes drive later could be
another whole thing
meaning if you're from if you've like
made it in manhattan upper west side of
manhattan and then we somehow like
kidnap you by a helicopter and airlift
you
and then drop you in new guinea
with no way out
you're you're a fish out of water now
it's a whole new society all around you
and you're like
uh
you start watching the way they walk and
you're like now you're kind of doing it
after a while you know okay you know i
guess i'll learn this world here
and if you drop a new guinea person in
norway there can also be a fish
underwater
because wherever you're from listen
carefully wherever you're from
is a fictional agreement
wherever you're from is a fictional
agreement
and it's an unspoken agreement
so if you're
from west l.a it's a fictional agreement
if you're from
west l.a or did i say westerly or
brentwood if you're from brentwood
you're from there's a fictional group if
you're from west l.a is a fiction
agreement
if you are from
arizona there's a fictional agreement if
you're in tempe arizona that's one
agreement and phoenix has another
agreement if you're persian there's all
these agreements that i'll never figure
out i grew up in all my best friends
persian home i i don't know understand
those agreements
but there are agreements
wherever you're from is a fictional
unspoken agreement
now listen carefully
for you
to be
who you
are
in that fictional agreement
for you to be who you are meaning your
own identity you know maybe i'll preface
this with something human beings are
very fragile i mean think about it clark
can i use it as an example
clark you were born where
from where in london
uh
what n what
meaning where did you grow up what
neighborhood
perhaps
so
so hamster garden suburb
yeah you would agree with me 100 that if
you were somehow born like a little too
light-skinned in iraq
you'd have a totally different head
space
yeah for sure right and if you were born
on the north shore of hawaii as a
hawaiian
you know just tattoo like
caucasians
and you were just raised surfing and
smoking wheat yeah
so
would you agree you'd have a totally
different headspace
human beings
in their identity of who they are are
extremely fragile
and because we're so fragile it
creates insecurity and therefore human
beings grasp onto
stuff for identity
that's why for example i think everyone
in this room knows they have certain
negative attributes
we all have issues right
but if you notice you keep those around
why do you keep your negative attributes
around if they're negative get rid of
them shake them off
why would you keep your negative
attributes because you're like at least
i know who i am i'm not proud of the
fact that i have the terrible temper or
this that or the other
but it's part of our fragility
is that
we'll even go with our negative stuff
in order not to be no one
anything
not to be no one
and so all these fictional agreements
are going around with whatever place
you're from
whatever culture your parents raised you
in
they're all fictional agreements
you have to play the game
unless of course you don't play the game
and if you don't play the game
it's a little scary because for a moment
you don't know who you are
but chances are the reason why you're
not playing the game is because you're
finding out there's alternatives for who
you could be
that maybe hold more water than some
fictional agreement
like for example the information you
hear usually in this room
is an amazing alternative
and it's not a new fictional agreement
asia tour is not offering a fictional
agreement
my black vest in black pants
black keeper
and black coat and black hat and on
shabbos the furry hat
that's all fictional agreement that for
sure is just an agreement that certain
people made and that's a fictional
agreement but the actual mitzvahs that i
do and the torahs that i study
and the general dedication in my
lifestyle
is hardly a fictional agreement this is
a major departure from a fictional
agreement i grew up with in this fancy
area of los angeles
this is my departure from it not because
i wanted to depart from it
it was just that when i got here i
realized oh my gosh i'm just totally
well i already realized that in europe
but i knew already that wherever you're
from is so random
i mean your whole identity based on
where you're from is the most random
thing ever
a totally
unconsidered
undiagnosed
un
um uh
uh
what's the word for it
investigated reality where you're from
it's an uninvestigated
fictional agreement
and when you learn something that's real
and you integrate
that thing it takes strength you got to
be committed you can have to be
independent you're going to have to be
courageous
but when you
internalize
and integrate that
or those values
that you are learning
you're no longer playing the game
and when you're no longer playing the
game so you're a y amongst all these x's
and you're actually doing fine
but what is the problem i know you guys
all told me what the problem is for all
these x's but
maybe you got it better here and now
what is the problem
is that
they listen carefully these little final
moments here
this class ends and another begins
in a short break
please look at this x right here
and look at when you used to be an x
just imagine
who are they surrounded by
x's
it's very easy to be an x when you're
surrounded by them but when suddenly on
your inner core you got a y hanging
around there you don't know who you are
anymore
people have been needing you
to play certain games
to be who they are
again it's a subtle point but it's very
deep
and when you stop playing the silly game
of where you're from because it's a
silly game
proof is 100 miles away they're playing
different games
so it must be silly i mean it is
arbitrary random i can't come up with
enough adjectives
of how silly it is
when you stop playing that game they've
lost a key ex
partner
they don't know who they are
and no one likes that feeling
so they don't embrace the new why
thing
they must they can't help it they react
they have to react
and they'll do anything
to get you back to being an ex not
because they think it's better for you
but because now they can live with
themselves because we don't know who we
are human beings are very fragile when
it comes to identity
people latch onto all kinds of random
things
sports teams
i grew up going to all the eve sporting
events and people would punch each
other's lights out because the guy was
wearing another shirt
in the crowd from the opposing team
they would talk about not knowing who we
are and that we've taken on a sporting
you seen people actually i went to a
sporting event first one in 20 years my
dad gave me laker tickets when i was in
l.a two a month ago i went to lager
again there were people wearing lakers
outfits
like they're on the team or something
in fact i think i was only one without
laker paraphernalia in the whole place
this was full identification
gotcha we're fragile
and
therefore
our job
is to be real is to have integrity
strength and all the stuff and us rabbis
around here and all the rabbis in
jerusalem and even where you're from
we'll hold you up we'll do our best to
support you but in the end you got to be
the one with the strength
but you stop playing the game not only
for you do you stop playing the game but
for
them
because
you see
what the average person who leaves this
classroom and goes back to kansas or
goes back to wherever part of jerusalem
they're from or whatever part of
new york they're from the average person
winds up developing an appendage
when they get back to where they're from
why why why do they do that for them
they don't want to hurt anybody they
don't upset their mom they don't accept
their uncles they don't accept their dad
their grandmother they don't accept
their siblings for them
they become exes again
when think about it ladies and gentlemen
right now this is my final point
you
were the last
chance
in an absolutely devastating dying
generation
to turn them around
before they completely wash out
into never never land
from the greatest tradition
and the greatest common destiny that's
still right we're right on the edge of
it look where we're having this
classroom right outside the holy of
holies we're back
there's only a few things left to do
but people are dropping like flies
and you can either be have this trip be
irrelevant when you get back for them
because oh it's really freaking
everybody out or
you can be
someone
who lives it
and is part of this destiny for them
because you're their last hope
either way it's for them
do the right thing for them
and be be an oxygen tank
when there's no more oxygen left
be a flashlight when there's a power
outage
in people being able to see anymore
what's real and what's not
make sure your trip to jerusalem just
sinks in full
like you're just
you're a sponge and you're just
absorbing every last word every last
experience
absorb it all so that when you get back
there you can be a why
for the world of exes
out there thank you
you