Parshas Pinchas: The Question of the Galya Mesechta - How Could Zimri Turn Around & Kill Pinchas?

this Tower class is brought to you by torahanytime.com okay the closing moments of the tightness I want you to put on your thinking caps I want to share with you along the shikasha usually at the end of the fast people like to be inspired that's the big buzzword Everybody Wants To Be Inspired what that's going to do for you makes you feel warm and fuzzy but anyway I want to share with you a very sharp question I'm going to first start off by telling you a story so there's this guy his name I'm not gonna tell you his name yet but he was the he had a very important position he was a Nasi he was the Nazi of shave at shiman and he got in his head that he wants to live with the daughter of the prince of mayav her name was Cosby her father's name was balak Sur was balak's name she was a daughter balak anyway so he's mazana with her sees this right and now at the time Pinterest was not a kind he wasn't kind according to Rashi he was uh he was not grandfathered and you see Aaron was a cayenne and our own Sons were kind and anyone who would be born to them later he born so he was out so technically speaking he could be matame right because he's not a coin and he he did an amazing feat he was able to stick the sword into the zachrus of zemri into the male organ of zimri and to the nakvis of Cosby and like a shish kebab he stuck the stuck into the two of them and the gemara tells us that six Miracles happened to allow this to occur and to avoid any um Tuma now interesting thing is usually if a kohen kills someone there's a question if an Israeli soldier he's a operating in Janine and he shoots someone this is a very interesting topic I once spoke about it repsolovacic said not because you know when uh I'll leave it at that without getting into any political innuendos of what our preference is what we love to do but uh Rivera says uh it does not disqualify the Cayenne from Duchene but it's interesting that here pinchas by killing became a coin usually by killing you're disqualified here by killing he was Miss kahin by killing it's interesting okay anyway the gamara tells us something amazing says what would have been if um would have come to bezden and said am I Atlantic kill zimrian Cosby you're allowed to do it but if you're once you're asking you're not gonna do it you know there's certain things you're allowed to do but not if you ask so you're allowed to do them if you ask you know how to do them but if you do it on your own you could do it I can't tell you what those things are but this is one of them this is one of them I'll give you another example there's a question that when the Metreon were drowning so big wanted to say shirashem said you can't say Shira question is so why were them that's because kaiso didn't ask so they were a lot of Singh Shira big shoe they asked no you can't do it there's such a idea that you're allowed to do it if you feel the you feel the cause so deeply that you're you're compelled to do it but if you're not sure see obviously you don't feel it so deeply and you're asking so the answer is no fine now so the gamara says that if uh Pentecost would have asked us would have told them no ich in my online what would the halach have been zimri was in the middle of the act with Cosby okay he's in middle of the ACT what would have been if as pinchas is coming to kill him zimmri would have pulled away and then Pincus would have killed him after Jimmy in other words zimmri did what he had to do he stopped he desisted and then Pincus would have killed zimri is would have been a murderer because you're only allowed to kill him in the ACT but once he would have separated then he's killing an innocent man because you know how to just kill someone who lived with the guy someone who's in middle of living with a guy you're a lot of if they stop next question what do you call as far as the zimmery is concerned what what do you call pinchas zimmery's doing his thing he's not allowed to do it but he's doing it is what he's all right Dave could zimri turn around and kill pinchas says the camera zimri would have not have been killed that's very interesting is allowed to kill zimri the zimmery's allowed to kill pinchas good stuff right so if zimri would have desisted and penichas would have killed um zimri Pincus would have been a murderer if zimri would turn around and kill pinchas nothing would happen to zimmri because pinchas is now can zimri in middle of living with Cosby he's doing his thing could end during the mice so he turn around and kill pinchas while he's sinning absolutely that you wouldn't have expectedness I doubt anyone asked him okay but uh I feel like sees Pincus is about to kill zimri so he says he's a murderer so even though everybody else is okay these are the rules okay you got the rules it's actually pretty interesting okay so let's just get this clear and it can stop yes in in a if Ruben's running after shiman to kill Shimon Levy could come and knock off revenge yeah you're a lot of killer writing huh have their two denim one is because you're the near death and then there's a din that array Dave you're allowed to kill a Roy day to save somebody so so here but here is the exception to the rule because zimry is allowed to kill pinchas but plenty of money can kill Penthouse okay fine so now you ready minutes before the end of the fast I'm going to tell you one of the most lumdish all-time questions this is a question of the gallium also asked this question why I chose the end of the tightness to bring this up sometimes the most interesting things are the most complicated okay it's very it's very simple actually okay so if zimri would turn around and kill Penthouse zimri would not be a murderer right if somebody would come and kill pinchas they would be a murderer what's the halacha if you see a Roy Dave you see it right do you allowed to kill a ray Dave yeah yeah what if you don't so roofing's running after someone to kill him so you'll have to kill rovane what if to save Schumann from getting killed you could just shoot ruvane in the leg so you allowed to kill him so that the gemara says if it's you're obligated to do that meaning it is not like heartblesh oh good I always I'm really happy ruvain is uh right there if he stepped on my tongue yesterday so it's a good excuse to knock him off no you can only knock him off if you can't save him elsewhere but if you could just shoot him in the leg or shoot him with a BB gun play laughing right don't answer that question if you could just shoot him with a paintball or something then uh then you can't kill the right Dave so the question of the Goliath is like this why is zimmery allowed right zimmery's a lot of kill Pinterest cause Pentecost is so zimbry could turn around and kill pengas but wait a second just like you can kill a Roy Dave if it's zimmery could have shot pilgras in the leg you know how he could have stopped sinning because would have been that if he stopped sinning can't kill him right we said to start that Pinnacles could only kill zimmery if he's in the middle of stunning the moment zimri stops sinning if zimmri pulls away and Pinnacles kills Emery then Pincus is a murderer sorry but if zimri stops sinning then pilgrims can't kill him so how is zimri allowed to kill Pinchos it's analogous to a case where if you kill someone instead of shooting them in the foot You're a murderer so zimri should be a murderer for killing benjas because zimri has a way to make it that Penthouse does not arrive Dave how by stopping to sin what allows zimri the gemara says if zimri turns around and kills Pincus he won't be killed because pincos is the right day for wait a second what allows zimri just to kill pinchas there's something else simri could have done zimri could have stopped sinning cut it out simri now you're sinning and you're gonna use the sin as an excuse that's the Kash of the gallium you can look it up you're there Simon hey rev um rozovsky in the small brings that according to the rambam even if you could save yourself by killing the guy with you're not going to be killed for for uh killing him the random is you're supposed to shoot him in the leg but if you don't you're not a murderer so then it comes out very good but according to the Richard mohold that the same way someone else is now to kill the Roy Dave if they could not kiss knock off his leg the near Duff has to knock off his uh the near Duff has to knock off his leg so why is zimriola to kill um pinchas you want to hear the guy himself this answer he answers from here we have a proof that only a different person has to be careful to try to shoot him in the leg and not kill him but the near death himself there's not enough peace of mind to say hmm biblical's trying to kill me let me see if I could first you know uh shoot him with a stun gun before I kill no no if your life's in danger you're allowed to kill the guy straight up even though technically you could kill the person back you could uh knock him off laughs so this is a question that uh is a very big question and schmuel himself says what if somebody says you're in shul and you like the shackle nothing wrong suckling is good I don't know if it promotes circulation I'm not sure but uh somebody said I don't like your suckling I'm gonna kill you if you don't stop chuckling so are you allowed to kill the person or do you say no the same way I have to shoot him in the leg I so just stop chuckling so there's a control says if this guy comes and threatens my life and I'm doing something I'm a lot of shackle so I'm allowed to kill the guy he can't who are you to tell me not to do something that I'm entitled to do don't tell me I'm now to kill you now because instead of killing you I could not I could shoot you in the leg but don't tell me I should stop chuckling so the same way he says logic dictates that I don't have to save my life by not doing a discretionary activity and also I don't have to say My Life by not sinning none of your business whether I'm saying if I want to sin and you're you're threatening my life okay that's your prerogative my I right now I want to sin so you're going to tell me not to sin that's fine but I could kill you you say well shoot him in the leg you're right I could shoot you in the leg but you can't require me not to sin if I choose to sin anyway usually Tennessee are dedicated to overcoming sin but this is uh this would be the alumnus that the Rushmore gives Regarding why zimri would have been allowed to turn around and kill pinchas even though he has a simple solution to stop sinning okay are they say but uh yeah you could turn off I want to tell you something something about shivasa batamas you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com