Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
The truth is when Adam was originally
created so eating eating animals was
prohibited. There was not that was not
part of man's diet. What was man's diet
consisting of vegetarian he was a
vegetarian. Someone asked me a question
last week. You know isn't the idea of
sacrificing animals primitive? We want
to address it and hopefully explain
what's really the base of corbanote
sacrifices so we can appreciate because
we are praying in ashmon every day for
god to restore the temple and restore
this the service. So if it's so
primitive why are we why are we praying
and hoping to return to such behavior
and and offer up sacrifices once again.
So to appreciate where sacrifices come
from let's go back to the very very
beginning. We know that when God made
Adam,
so Adam is the first person to bring up
a sacrifice.
Now I want to ask you guys what what did
he was he thinking? What made him decide
you know he he of course there was a sin
of the of the sin involved the tree of
knowledge and and part of his repentance
you know it involved bringing up a
sacrifice. What was he thinking? He's
the first man created. there is no one.
He's not copying anyone's prior
behavior. He's the only one that exists.
He decides, well, part of, you know,
trying to rectify my standing with
Hashem and come close to Hashem will
include, let me think, what should I do?
Should I pray? Should I beat my my my
palm on my on my chest? You know what?
I'll grab an animal and I'll slaughter
it. That'll make God happy. The truth is
when Adam was originally created, so
eating eating animals was prohibited.
There was not that was not part of man's
diet. What was man's diet consisting of
vegetarian? You're going to ask very
nice. So man should be vegetarian,
right? According to this man should be
vegetarian. Why? If Adam was vegetarian,
he's the first man. So we you see on our
digestive system was is built to be
vegetarian better, right? So let's all
be vegetarians. Where does it come up
that we should eat human eat animals?
Where does that come up? So we see a
shift after the flood in the generation
of Noah and after. So God changed the
dietary rules of of of man and included
in what was permissible to eat animal
meat to eat animals, steak, chicken, all
the good stuff. Now why was there a
change made? You know, was God didn't
get it right the first time? So the
truth is there's no way to understand
the the reason why eating and animals
were were were first prohibited and then
became permissible without understanding
the spiritual nature of the world. And
that of course everything that God made
although the end result is this physical
world be for this physical world.
There's spiritual worlds and spiritual
dimensions that parallel this world. And
the only way to get a clear picture of
what this world is really all about is
to see its parallel in the spiritual
sense to the higher worlds that exist.
Once we see what's existing up there,
we'll be able to understand more clearly
the nature of this world.
>> My old admiration, what was the
provision not to eat animals?
>> It wasn't it wasn't it wasn't it wasn't
part of what we what he was allowed to
eat. wasn't told I mean the baby
>> okay it wasn't an a it wasn't listed as
one of the aot but it wasn't part of
what he was was what he ate or what he
was given to eat the Torah clearly
expresses that God gave man food that
food was was grown from the ground
that's why the curse was such a terrible
curse they weren't eating animals so it
when when the earth no longer brought
forth its produce easily and it was the
sweat of the brow that men had to work
very hard to get produce that's what
they lived off of so that was the tre
terrible curse, terrible punishment that
mankind had to work hard and to to
barely get what he needed to survive. I
mean, if we could just go and barbecue
some steak, so what would be the big
punishment of not being able of the
earth not producing what it's full?
Anyway, so let's let's appreciate where
where the shift what's really behind the
shift. The cabala explains based on you
know the teaching of the Arizal and the
zohor is where the main sources of of
where we learn kabala zor and the arizel
explains it all in depth in his
writings. So we he explains why meat
wasn't originally part of what a person
was supposed to eat because eating to
tell you the truth eating the whole
process of eating is really also part of
the our job in this world. Um, we're
taught the mafarian bring of course also
based on on on on mystical ideas that on
shabas when you eat that's also part of
the the holiness of shabas and the
spiritual elevation and rectification
that takes place through learning Torah
and praying on shabas. That's part of it
and of and also which we wouldn't think
we would think eating is just something
that we physically enjoy. But the eating
on Shabas when it's done for the sake of
the sanctity of Shabas the pleasure of
Shabas is also results in a spiritual
rectification and elevation. That's why
the de the gumar actually talks about uh
with holidays is it or hashem there's a
contradiction in verses and the the
contradiction would imply in one place
it implies that that the holidays were
given for us to enjoy in another place
it implies that the holidays were given
for us to use to serve hashem more. So
what is the nature of a holy day? Is a
holy day meant to be spent fasting and
praying and learning and we become like
angels? Well, that's what we do on Yam
Kipper. But Yam Kipper is called the day
of affliction. The holy days that we
have i.e. the holidays and Shabbat
included are days where on the one hand
we do pray and we do learn and there is
a sanctity there and we are ascending
and trying to transcend this mundane
world because it's the essence of the
day is holy. But part of that holiness
is to indulge indulge in eating and
enjoying the food we eat and having
delicacies. And it's even more than
that. It's not only that, oh, God said,
I'll give you some time to relax. No,
that enjoyment becomes part of our
divine service and accomplishes
spiritual rectifications and elevations
according to Kabala. And this is the
deeper meaning as to why there's this
whole discussion of and like why we have
to decide and do we split and and
ultimately Shabas everyone agrees
there's a split part of Shabas has to be
for God and part of it has to be for you
because in both avenues in both
directions we are accomplishing our
purpose in this world. Now with that
said we can appreciate an interesting
play on words that a says I may I may
have said this before but it's worth
mentioning again on shabas we talk about
the mitz of on shabas it starts with the
letter
the same three root letters spell the
word nega on means pleasure and
enjoyment and nega means affliction and
explains that the same type of behavior
that we do on holidays and on chabas to
enjoy the physical world, to enjoy the
food we eat, to eat delicacies, to
spread a lavish table and eat like a
king and and and and enjoy wine and meat
and it the actually expresses to buy
fatty meat which was in the time very
delicacy, you know, and wines good the
things that that are pleasurable to the
pallet and that we enjoy dessert. Now,
of course, one shouldn't overindulge.
The the the the idea of sanctifying the
Sabbath with with enjoyment doesn't mean
to become a glutton and just like, you
know, pig out. That's for sure not
that's counterproductive. As a matter of
fact, the mad the angel that taught the
Bose warned him against overindulging on
Shabbat because it would detract
ultimately. But the general idea of
indulging is part of the divine service.
Now, the word nega coming back to my
point, the word nega means affliction.
So explains that to behave the same way
that we're told is a mitzvah to behave
on Shabas. It's on it's pleasure and
it's a gift from Hashem to enjoy and
it's an opportunity to take the physical
and enjoy it without the negativity
involved. Usually on a weekday if we
would behave the same way and eat the
same delicacies, it's called the nega.
It's an affliction to the soul because
six days of the week is the work week.
We're meant to work on ourselves and
work on the world. It's not a time to
relax. It's not a time to indulge in in
the in the physical delicacies and
pleasures. And then when you do, it
detracts from the sanctity and the
purity of your soul. On Shabbat and on
holidays, when you indulge in the
physical, the food and the delicacies,
it doesn't detract again without getting
carried away with it. So with this, we
can also appreciate the whole concept of
eating meat, which goes back to the
generation of Adam and then Noah. The
same way that on Shabas eating is part
of serving Hashem. So too in the times
of Adam, eating was part of one's divine
service. God made a whole world and
everything he made in it has a purpose.
We we'll start to explain. We generally
break down all of existence into four
levels. There's inanimate like rocks and
dirt. This is inanimate objects. There's
no life and growth, but they exist. God
has to create earth. Without God's
creative power, [clears throat] the
earth wouldn't exist. So the same way
that God creates a tree which grows,
which is animate, it grows. He also
creates the earth which doesn't grow. So
we look at earth and rocks as if they're
lifeless, but the truth is there's life
inside of rocks and earth as well.
There's divine sparks and there's
vitality that comes from the creative
power of Hashem within the inanimate
objects of this world. Otherwise, they
wouldn't exist.
God added a level of existence in
creating the animate objects like the
the trees which grow and of course now
we see a different form of life. We see
something that and a sign of a tree
being alive is that it in fact grows and
the the trees are able to give out fruit
which are edible. That's a secondary
level of existence. So you have
inanimate animate which is really the
the the plant life is the second level.
The third level, God adds an additional
level of existence onto the idea of the
trees which grow and plants that are
able to grow in creating animals. And he
brought now a different level of life
into the animals. They have a a a soul,
an animal soul, which you can also call
a vital soul. Their soul gives them this
vitality to move around and to live and
to exist. They breathe. They have
instincts. It's it's it's accepted that
animals function on a level of
instincts. They don't have a yet that
this next level which we're going to
talk about. But the level of animal is a
third level of existence. All animals
exist on that level in general of
course. Now this fourth level of
existence is man. God made a speaking
being. And he gave that person that he
made Adam and all of Adam's descendants
intellect. Now intellect is has a few
ways that it we benefit from intellect.
First of all, one of the benefits of
intellect is that we can perceive our
own existence and we can contemplate an
an animal as sophisticated as they may
seem. You can put a monkey in a suit,
but it's still a monkey. Now, the point
is that a monkey is not going to he
might scratch his forehead because you
could train a monkey to scratch his
forehead, but he's not going to be
asking those fundamental philosophical
questions. You know, am I satisfied with
my life? What's my purpose? Am I
accomplishing? Animals are not going to
think like that. They might
instinctively do good things. They might
risk their life to save their children.
They might even save human beings from
danger sometimes, but it's not their
existence is not comparable to that of a
human being, which is it's funny because
when you think about it, when a person
has a pet and he loves his pet. So, he's
he's he's giving the pet his, you know,
all of his capacity to love and care to
his pet. And he thinks the pet's
reciprocating, you know, but the pet's
not really reciprocating. The pet is
acting back in as much as an animal can
instinctively. Of course, it's going to
be happy when he gets fed and he's going
to show what the person perceives as
this affection like a, you know, he
needs a wife. He doesn't need or she
needs a husband, not a a pet to to have
all this affection back and forth. It's
the wrong place to invest. But anyway,
that's that's obviously a side point.
We'll get to the back to the main
discussion. So human beings are the
pinnacle of creation
and they represent again the ability to
discern and understand and with that
ability to discern and understand we've
been we have the opportunity and the
essence of this gift is really to
perceive God and to turn in the
direction of serving God.
Now within the category of human beings
there's another distinction. God made
Adam as the father of all mankind and
and as a result of the sin there was a
descent in the level of Adam himself.
uh and there were generations until
Abraham Abraham shows up on the scene
and Abraham represents the restoring of
the of the beginning level of Adamishon
before the sin and Abraham reached a
level of belief and understanding in
Hashem and a devotion towards serving
Hashem that he was rechosen to be the
father of the nation of Israel until
Abraham came along. So all mankind would
have been one nation. That's why we talk
about the tower of Bavl when they were
all one language, one people. Had the
world got their act together then? Then
God would not have had to separate the
world into [clears throat] 70 nations.
It would have been one nation under God
and would have had its
general system like we would have think.
Some people believe in that system till
today that the world is really a melting
potter. We all are one people. They are
half correct. That was the original plan
and in potential the Ram Khal explains
and the Azizal also explains that had we
got our act together as a whole mankind
we would not have been separated. But
once God divided the world into 70
nations, 70 languages and he selected
Abraham and his descendants to be the
nation of Israel. So they took on the
responsibility of Adamishon to carry on
and what man was originally this this
connector between the divine and
creation became the role of the Jewish
people. That is why the Jewish people
are a chosen people. We are supposed to
be a light onto the other nations. That
is why we were given the land of Israel
which is the center of the of the world.
It's where heaven and earth unite. The
dream that YaKob had with the latter, it
says that the latter went from earth and
connected heaven. So the connecting
between heaven and earth is exactly
where Adam where Yakov went to sleep and
had his dream. And we're told that that
exact place is of course the place where
the Ba Mikdash was, which is the same
place where Adam Marish was created
from. Same place he went back to to
offer up his sacrifice. when he brought
the first sacrifice up. So to Noah when
he brought his sacrifices after the
flood, same place, the place where the
Msbah was ultimately built in the Ba
Mikdash. That is where Yakov went to
sleep. That is where Yitzk was taken to
be sacrificed until God said not to. And
of course they sacrificed in this place
the animal and that is where we have our
B mikdash built and that is where the
western wall is until today where we
write those nice notes we mentioned and
we go to pray because that's where the
divine presence rests and now we can
appreciate the connection between all of
this. Uh there's an interesting story
which will hopefully shed more light on
this. Sometimes stories are the best way
to express some ideas. Um we know that
that there's a concept called
reincarnation. It means that a person
that was living in one lifetime if he
for whatever different reasons it could
be because he committed some type of sin
or it could be that he did not fulfill
his purpose and he is he wants to come
he's supposed to come back into the
world in order to elevate his soul more
so that he can have an animal.
>> Ah so that's what we're we're going to
address right now. Anyone who's already
familiar with these concepts is already
accepts it. I mean before you're told
you might think it doesn't make any
sense but according to Kabala a person
can come back as an animal now what what
what possible reason could there be for
that and what possible benefit could
there be in that is hard to for our
intellects to grasp but again when we
understand how the all the worlds work
together as one whole unit that God is
in control of. So we understand that the
secrets of reincarnation and how that it
can occur in an animal is all part of
the rectification of a person's soul in
things that it has to go through. One
particular story for example that's
recorded from the you know is is
interesting a particular
soul for different whatever reasons we
won't get into the details required to
come back in a fish and that will would
have will was going to eventually help
that soul find its its its
rectification. Now with leaving out the
details as to what it did to have to
come back in a fish, but the the story
talks about the fish being you know at
the you know sold at the market and the
fish the the soul in the fish realizing
that you know I if if I get bought by by
some person that's not religious that's
not going to make the braha on me it
could affect his rectification. So he
the the soul was praying let me be
bought by a righteous person and lo and
behold Hashem ordained that that came
and bought the fish prepared it for
shabas and when they ate it on shabas it
was the right way for the for for that
soul to get its tikun when we make
blessings on food we we we that's part
of the the secret depth of what happens
when we eat food and we make blessings
on food you know not always is that the
case but possible potential case is that
there's A there's a soul there that
needs to be elevated through the the
braha, through eating the food kosher,
through the learning of Torah together
while you eat. All of this helps to
elevate the food again. And this is all
this just extension of what happened in
the B mikdash. The rabbis tell us that
the that the table of a person today
takes the place of the misme of the
altar because the same way that today
when we eat food, we can elevate the
food. So the essential elevation really
took place in the BA mikdash and we're
just on a smaller level trying to
continue that that idea. So with
everything we said I think it it comes
out very clear how important and
necessary it is this all these concepts
of eating and also the sacrifices as
well.
>> What about different animals like
>> okay so this is a connected related
question
>> out of the whole of the animal.
Okay. So we have to just like there's
different different types of animals and
we know that there are different
nations. The nation of Israel was
instilled with a particular aspect of
holiness by virtue of being a descendant
of Abraham. So to animals their
spiritual root will determine whether
they're fit to be sacrificed on the
altar or not. Not every animal can be
put on the altar. We have a special
mitzvah to take the the donkey and to
either you know um either to to kill it
or to be p it to redeem it with a kosher
animal to put on the altar. So you're
asking a good question. What why can't
we eat kazir? So the same question will
be asked why can't you offer up a kazir
on the altar or why can't you offer up a
donkey on the altar? So obviously it's
not just arbitrary. Okay God doesn't
like the the donkey. what God likes a
bird more than a donkey or he likes a
cow more than a donkey. It's all they're
all all his creations. So the real depth
to why certain animals are fit to be
brought up as sacrifices and of course
also fit to be eaten and certain animals
are not is because of the spiritual
essence and nature of those animals. To
understand this really we have to go
back and explain the whole concept of
these different categories of
spirituality. There's a realm of of s of
holiness. There's a realm that's outside
of the realm of holiness but remains
neutral. And there's a third realm which
is called a realm of negativity, a realm
of of of evil and impurity.
So I'll explain now. All of the animals,
there is not an animal that's born holy.
There's no animal that's intrinsically
holy. Only the the Jew has a holy
nishama. It's called a part of Hashem.
Only the Jewish person, the nation of
Israel has this element of sanctity
instilled within them. And that is why
it says in parha's kadoshim God gives us
a command. You should be holy because I
am holy. The obvious question is asked
and we all must ask it. What's the
connection between us and God? Because
God is holy. Well, God's holy because
he's the creator. We're just human
beings. Why should we be holy? Because
God is holy. Who says because God is
holy that we have the capacity to be
holy. So the the commentators answer
that it's because God instilled within
us a part of of the divine
aspect of a divine soul within the
nation of Israel. Therefore because we
have within us this potential kadusha
this potential sanctity we have a
command to activate it to be holy. So
only the the nation of Israel has this
intrinsic sanctity within them. All of
the rest of creation doesn't have the
sanctity. But all of the rest of
creation can be divided into two parts.
There's the neutral part. And when we
say an animal is kosher, the word kosher
really just means prepared.
Something means to prepare it. The word
kosher kin
is just means ready or prepared which
which is essentially in this deeper
sense is saying that all of the animals
that we define as kosher are from this
neutral realm
>> which means they're ready and able to be
elevated but they're not they're not
holy yet until you take the animal and
slaughter it properly and draw the blood
and if you make any mistakes in that
process then the animal becomes
forbidden. U
asser user the word user we translated
as forbidden but you know what the real
root words user alfin
I'm sorry alf
it means tied up bound it's tied it's
bound and what in spiritual terms it
means is all of the animals that are
forbidden are really bound and tied up
in this third realm that we mentioned
it's a realm of impurity and of
negativity and since they're bound up in
that realm so they're counterproductive
if a if a Jewish person eats from these
impure you know you know negative
spiritual items like pig like a like
anything that's uncos all these you know
these delicacies the nations of the
world it's a delicacy shrimp lobster all
these animals the spiritual nature of
those animals are detrimental to the to
the spiritual well-being of a of of of a
Jewish person and of course also at the
same time they become unfit to offer on
them as because they their spiritual
nature nature is not able to be elevated
to sanctity and the whole purpose of the
misbak the altar was to elevate to the
realm of sanctity. So you it's like it's
like it doesn't work. So that's that's
that again your your question about
kosher and not kosher is really answered
all together with all of this that
animals that are from this neutral realm
that are able to be elevated are both
kosher to eat when you prepare them
properly and when it's done correctly it
elevates into the realm of kaduca it
becomes whole you can elevate it to
holiness the second realm we said which
is the impure realm is like the pig and
the donkey and all of the other
uncoosure animals on the one hand they
also they can't be used as sacrifices
because They cannot be elevated. And
furthermore, if a person would eat them,
it's going to be dam it's going to
damage his soul. So, he's not allowed to
eat them.
>> In resurrection, can a can can
God send this man down become a
>> You're asking an interesting question.
In reincarnation, can can a person be
sent into an uncultured animal? The
answer is yes for different reasons. As
a matter of fact, all of this is
discussed in the writings of the Arizal,
as we mentioned.
uh what sins will warrant being brought
down in this type of animal or this type
of animal. And there are documented
stories from the mystics that confirm
all of this. It's not uh don't think
it's to take it lightly. These were the
holiest people that that you know the
zohar was written by Rabai and the
Arizal was taught by Elijah the prophet
himself. So the the information we get
about reincarnation should not be taken
lightly. That would be a grave mistake.
And uh when we talk about being
reincarnated in animals, as as unusual
as that might sound to uh to the naive
person or the the person that's never
heard it before, well, get familiar with
it. Study it and you'll realize it is
part of Judaism. It is part of our
Torah.
>> Can this person be redeemed?
>> Yes. The whole purpose of reincarnation,
>> the whole purpose of reincarnation is
for that person to be redeemed. It's for
that person to rectify his his sins or
his mistakes, shortcomings, whatever,
however you want to define it and
receive the elevation and that he's that
he needs. It's in order to him for him
to eventually get his true place in the
world to come either whether it's in
Ganedan until Msiah comes or when
Mashiach comes in the ultimate world to
come. The purpose of everything we go
through in this life, any suffering we
go through, whether it's uh sickness,
whether it's being reincarnated in in
these disgusting type of animals even
and and and there's a lot of suffering
involved when that takes place. All of
it is in order to and of course ganim,
the greatest suffering that we can
imagine. 11 months, 12 months in ganam
is terrible. All of that is in order for
the soul to ultimately receive the good
that that that it's that it's going to
get later. I think we've covered
everything for now and thank you all for
coming. Uh have a good uh day.