Daf Yomi Shevuos Daf 4 by R’ Eli Stefansky

[Music] Good morning boys. Come bring them in. Bring the guests [Music] in. I would I forgot the guy's name. This is Yossi Klein's manager Gel. What's his name? Whatever. Every those who know. So his brothers are making a sem. It's a big thing. This is Ari Simon's son making his very very first summ. Check it out. [Applause] Look at that cake. Now talking about cakes, we have a lot of cakes. But first, we're going to read this email. Just wanted to share with you Yoda's excitement for making his first seum. I had over he had over 10 friends for a barbecue ending off a delicious MD white cake. See attached photo had inserting an interesting epiphany during the seal when he was telling all his friends about the daily antics. Can I call that that go on in the shar? And they're all interested to join and they couldn't wait to go home and nudge their fathers to join and let them too. When I originally got my 9-year-old to join, I called him I called it lowhanging fruit and thought that that was the end of it. But now with the butterfly butterfly effect, who knows how many more generations of daffers will join the ranks from my first recruit. As an aside, I'm already in double digits on direct recruits that I've brought to the biat for them. These are his children, he's saying. So this is a message to all you people out there who are hesitant to recruit people like I was in the beginning saying what's one more in the grand scheme of things you have to realize that your one recruit will most certainly have a ripple effect to many more people regard Simon Adar global CEO has another cake mo's wife made a special cake here look at dishon from Montreal. This is his son David. Check out this Lego boy side. This is insane. This is in You're not going to believe this. In Melbourne, Australia. Where's the email? I forgot. Here it is. Oh, this is a picture of white from Melbourne, Australia. Five out of the 10 mim were first timers ever making a seum. Five out of 12. This is only a fraction of ND wires in Melbourne. My son Dobby tugand something like that. Tuggi that's what they call him. Tuggi tuggies made the mdy gimar out of Lego. Josh tuggy Melbourne Australia boy. One day MDY is going to come to Australia believe we got to make a trip. Here's Israel 9 and Ko 12. The famous Israel and Ko 9 and 12 making a seum and Israel saying the hydrron with a special makus cake on the side. Um Pure is another nine-year-old almost 12 staging away. I walked into my son's room make sure he's already sleeping. He was still busy catching up today's daff. That's what the parents should catch their sons doing. Like that guy that walked in his son was fell asleep in front of the computer. or this guy Yosim Mas proud father my son Schulam Staten Island my father's yard site is also dal I made that's my mother's yard I made my third sem ever now in his yard side was very special and emotional for me to give his so you understand that your next time you're going to be able to make on the day is another 28 years I'm from longtime friend I don't know what that word is roommate I'm a very strong I was very strong these few few years already hers did a beautiful job with events in in Sum in the past but sadly in the last year we had only one summ in Aronov's house but nothing for Sanhedrin or Makus it bothers me and others greatly that there's no community feeling here from the nobody calling or emailing me to ask if they're doing the daf where's hurse what happened to him we got to get him back into the fold we got to get him back but also more importantly you Marv Handler you stand up and do it why are we waiting for others I don't serious action needs to be taken here other people I'm including Jackson times river howell brick and manchester okay look look he did the first step he wrote an email now it's the time for the other guys to step it up and mix by the way I know shops two from he rocks the house I'm putting liquid in the line of fire but it's urgent measures that are needed you devoted to helmet and longtime fan since yuma moisha marv handler just want to say thank you for your incredible sh for the past three years I didn't have the best to learn and since I started with it all changed a day doesn't go by without doing the daf no this is just a thing of his kid this you'll see the the no this kid teaches us what true havat is even before like the excitement to go u so so I some listen this year in the car while driving my little son that's not two he's not even two sits quiet and listen he's love the good morning our Zevy Breer, Stanford Hill. Here we go. [Music] If that if that was that would be that's a new thing. Good morning. Okay. What else do we have here real quickly because we're running out of time. Oh boy. Somebody put this on a status and says maz to you and everyone that finished I'll always be thankful to you for putting this year on the status. In other words, this person came this year through the status and he has tremendous forever. I feel like a new person learning every day. It absolutely changed my life. This is a new license plate because join with a I is not available anymore. So this guy has join with a Y. Cool. And even he even has a look what he has. He has the new calendar. So, we're at Boyai talking about calendars. Look at Chimmy Leafman's van. It's all about the Davo. Join Davoi.com with a bunch of calendars. You can see his daughter putting the calendars up. I have some if anybody really will use this. I have This is what I have here in N. This is what all Anybody want a calendar here? Of course you do. Here two over there. Anybody? Oh, my brother wants one. Ashi, what else? Who else? Anybody? You want one here? Here. So, pass it down over there. There's two over here. Two. One for him. Schwarz. Who else? Zo. Oh, Mo. Robbie Einhorn. Next. Zo. I down. Next. We have two left. Anybody that wants one of these, by the way, you could just go on mdydaf.com and uh you order. It's free, but you have to pay for shipping. I don't know how much that is. A couple bucks and you get it. Huh? In Australia. What is this? Oh, Lakewood is making a seal. Somebody stepped it up. Thursday night. Details coming soon. Uh, all right. These are the six guys that it's the very very first see them in Hebrew. Very first in their life. And one of them is Nonfix's son with the orange stripe on his shirt. That's nonfix's son. and Rabbi Girtner that that rebi it's unbelievable he knows a lot that guy mit they're learning over there this is MDY Toronto goam and 12 birds of a blau hosted by Porto and creme cafe it is going to be a killer look they all have Nerf guns that have MDY logos on it whatever okay beautiful see Montreal sponsored by Yankees Pizza arranged by Yankee Gross in Schulen Goldstein Queen. And don't forget the expo. We got a free booth over there. So go check it out. Montreal Jewish Expo. Thank you to Isaac Blackman for sponsoring an MDY booth themselves sponsored by monthly sponsors. Jeff's gourmet Los Angeles for that all our children daily sponsors Martin beloved 15year-old son and Alan Gross was our grandmother and aunt Ya ypha Dr. Rubin, Dr. Daniel Rubin, the side of our father, Dr. Isaac Ev. Interesting. I don't know what this is. Anybody know? Explain to what is that? He's gone. He's out of the year. I'll see you later. What does it mean? It's a salute. Salute. Do Rubin's father passed away. Dove Ruben's father, old man. He was doing the bath. We talked about him a bunch of times. His father was like, "Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. He's doing it in. You're so happy." Finish. Wow. Doing the kids monthly, the whole staff continue to make many in honor of Klein and Marazi for all the work they do. Uh we are holding on daf gimmel om b so we are holding two lines from the bottom just a shiloh first of all you can give these out if anybody wants I found these in my house and I think um sapaznik made them sitting around here anybody want like just I'm downsizing um if anybody anybody can imagine Can I have one of those? Oh, maybe here. He wants one here. Here. Next. If anybody ever learned clu and has trauma from it, raise your hand. You have trauma from it. You have trauma. Only three people that can admit to it. Okay, here they go. Here they go. Okay, fine. So all you people that go to psychologists and spend hundreds of hours on the couch talking about clu past trauma and how it affects your current life and you can't move forward. This is the share. It's super super easy. Not a single person came out of the sh yesterday saying people came over and said wow it's so easy. Let's little kids. I'm talking about young kids and we're only going to talk about it for five minutes maybe on B and that's it. What we had yesterday is as follows. There's something called the sha that's if you there's a thera says a negative commandment. It's ushered to do this and this thing but it doesn't involve any action such as if you swear that you you're going to eat a loaf of bread and you don't eat it. You don't eat it. Do you get malcus or you don't get malus? You didn't eat it. You didn't do anything. You kept your hands like that. So, how could I give you a punishment on something that doesn't involve any bodily action? There's nothing. You didn't move your hand. You didn't do anything. You swore you're going to eat and you didn't eat. So, we said that our Mishna holds since there's four in our Mishna all four for the future in the past. And one of them, one of the four is problematic. One of them four is I swear that I will eat this and you don't end up eating it. And it says in the Mishna according to the way we were explaining it cuz initially we were learning the Mishna that we're talking about a carbon a carbon I show you the picture if you're wealthy you bring this carbon you're not wealthy you bring that then we switch we did a switcheroo the mission is not talking about carbon the mission is talking about malus so now we're going to have to fit in the entire Mishna talking about malcus the problem is there's no malus on on the that doesn't involve action So we have to say that goes according to that says that even though there's no action you do get malus there's a problem with that because always pas and somebody wrote me an email I forgot to show it he did a research according to him this is the most used phrase in the holds that is like an anonymous so since our doesn't have a name to it then is like that according That means is forced to say according to the we're learning that red that's our problem is he holds in other places that you don't get malus so how does how does he fix our mishna so the answered yesterday because he has another mishna there's two anonymous mishnas and he went with the other anonymous mishna he does go only like anonymous but the problem is there's a contradiction in anonymous mish and he picked the other anonymous mishna that says that when there's a no action no malus so it's not a contradiction to our mishna but the say that is not a good riot so now that's where we're holding right now where else is there in sh another mishna that says that if there's no action there's no malus and therefore will fit right in okay here's the answer let's just do about pets very very simple the answer is in our there's another mission So then the question is why did he pick and what's the the answer? The answer is because comes after. So that means rebi retracted once in his life one day he decided is so he developed a new Mishna talking about is no malus if there's no action no malus and understood that knows the rule that if there's a second Mishna that comes afterwards in the same that means rebi says straight out it's like a it's a unwritten rule but it's known is like the second Mishna so therefore goes that if there's no action no mal Don't ask me a question from that's that. So let's do it inside two lines from the bottom. Oh found another says two times he repeats his words. I swear I won't eat this bread. I'm not going to eat it. Twice. How many malus do you get for saying the same thing twice? And then he went and he ate it. And you only have to get one malus. Why? Because the second is to is to keep the first but that's already sort of it's the first you don't get malus for that. You're going to get malus on the first one. You swore that you you're you're not going to eat it. This is action. boy said this is not this is not our sugi yet right he took action what happened he said I'm not going to eat this loaf of bread and he ate it eating is action you have to chew you have to pick it up put in your mouth that's action for that there's no shus but look what it says this is the only one this is it right here a case where there's action because you swore you're not going to eat it and you couldn't control yourself and you ate by the way it I'm telling you the works for me it's crazy how it works I don't know how it works but it works if you want to be on a diet I'm giving toa to everybody wants to be on a diet and your weakness is cake pizza it doesn't matter whatever your weakness is so you don't make you do something similar to you say this is what I do say if I eat this thing nash right because I might I have weakness for nash for cake I once said in sheir years ago I learned my lesson said, "I love American cake." The bakery that cake so good. I'm not exact. It was during co or something. All of a sudden, a box. I'm this big. This big from one of the bakeries. Marble cake. Seven layer cake. You know the those New York cakes. I'm not That's not a hint. Do not send it to me. I can't eat it. It's awesome. If I see that, I'll devour the whole box. Some sugar just left the shear. I'm going to be the first one to send him a box. Do not. My wife needs a pair of diamonds. That's a different story. Anyway, no, I'm not not exaggerating. And then that was in the time that we didn't have coffee because, you know, because of co soy Klein sent me coffee was those days. Okay, free stuff. So, oh, talking about free stuff. Hold on. I'm in the middle of saying what am I saying? I forgot. Hold on. Yi Schwarz sent me this. I opened it up last night. Um, I forgot the guy's name. Whereas he drove all the way like kun knows almost an hour to deliver it to me and I wasn't there. It says it says to learn the dafansky now you're trying to help people with the diets right. Oh oh oh I'm trying to help people with the diet and it works and it works mish works. If you have a weakness to to New York cake, you say like this, if I eat a piece of cake, I'm going to give X amount of money to not if you're lit, you give it to and if you're you give it to a modern Orthodox and you give it to a place you don't really you don't really want to give. You know, I have a bunch of places that I I support I don't want to support them. So when you're about to eat this piece of cake, what this is going to cost me everybody the fee whatever hurts you. Some people a dollar hurts them, some people $1,000 each and I'm telling you it works. Immish works. So this guy, how did I get to that? I have no idea. So thank you for that donation. You're not give it to a place that has zero car. That's the best. I'm serious. So what happened there? I don't even know how I thought about it. But anyways, let's say, oh, because you swore. That's what it is. You swore you're not going to eat this bread. And you went ahead and you ate it. Why didn't you swear? Cuz you're on a diet. So you said, I swear I'm not going to eat this this uh cake. They call it bread. And you went ahead and you ate it. So for that, you have to bring if it's by mistake, you bring a carbon. If it's on purpose, you get malus. Says this is the only case. But the other case, the opposite case, the case that I will eat it. I swear you tell your mother, I swear I'm gonna eat the spinach, you didn't eat it. You don't get malus. Why don't you get malus? You see from there's no action because you didn't eat it. So you don't that's what goes by says. So if we take a look at these two things, we have two that are both anonymous. Why did he pick? Let him pick our mission. And you come out that you do get malus. So as every good Jew does, if you ask me a question, I ask you back a question. Hey, but this is a good question. Think about it's so obvious. How in the world did Rebi, the author of the Mishna, contradict himself? In the same as what he forgot from that B of he forgot. He didn't even have Gar. They went much closer, right? So obviously we have to have an answer and the answer is going to explain once you have an answer that you have an answer with us in one it seems like you you do get you do get you don't get that's what he held he held in the beginning like so he wrote a without names in it so everybody would know that is you get and then later on in his life he realized he made a mistake So he retracted it. So he wrote another and here says you have to understand in those days everybody learned everything about pet. So you have people invat people in they're all learning all the schools all the all the adults they're all learning after about in ina all these other places that they're learning about. One day Rebby decides, "Oh, I got to switch it." How you going to take it out of this? How are you going to take it out of the curriculum? It's in there. It's It's done. One city will hear about it. There's no WhatsApps. There's no There's no email blast. What are you going to do? There's no phone. I took it out. Okay. He took it out. And this school keeps on teaching it. So, the only way is you add another Mishna. You add it. Eventually, it comes into the system. They realizes and then people know that is like the second one says that only works in one like but let's say anonymous and in anonymous you don't go back to because there's in the same there's a beginning there's an end but not okay says so let's go back we're doing a little here little chuva a Let's learn a little better. The Gumar yesterday brought four in the Mishna. First Mishna we have four cases and tum and the Gumar asked a question. We have a problem. The bottom right corner doesn't go according to says there's only two ways two. There's no four. There's no past. There's no shu in the past only in the future. So the whole Mishna if the the bottom right corner can't be then all four things can't be. And the same problem will be with ribbika. Raika doesn't hold that there's four tumas. There's only two tumas. There's only that you forgot that you're there's no tum in carbon. You don't bring if you forgot that this is a bdash. So yesterday we answered that the whole we're switching. We're not talking about a carbon. The whole time we're talking we thought we're talking about no no we're talking about malus in the bottom. There is malus. So we said this was the problem that this cannot be and we said it could be ribbal because we're not talking about carbon we're talking about malcus but what we need to do is if this case is malus then all four cases are malcus everything is malus we're going away from a carbon the whole mission is talking about malus you get all these malus in all these cases so let's think about it how can you get malus for you have teras. You didn't do you spoke, but I'm not going to give you malus. What's the think about it? Pause. Think. How do you get malcus in a case of teras? Cut it off. Who said cut it off? Very good. Oh, was holding. How do you get malus for being shabas? Did you learn the m already? Only people that don't know are allowed to answer. Yeah, we did learn in Sanra the problem with Shabas is that the the punishment for Shabas kill Shabas is misa death not malus. So how do you get malus and chabas? There's no one of there's no 39 that you get malus for. The answer is going to have to be that they made a mistake or on purpose. They warned him instead of warning him, you're going to get stoning, you're going to get skiila, they warned him, hey, you're going to get lashes, you're going to get malus. Does that work? According to one, okay, so let's see inside. You said the whole all four cases are talking about Malcus. So, but what's the case when it comes to how says check this out? If you cut the the saras right off that is malus how do I know like says so here's the sh so he says that that's one of the three words and al means this is if you touch This harass did I tell you the the story lately about the the wart in Mishair's office? Mhm. Okay. So, Mer does surgery in a certain uh like a smaller he does surgeries in hospitals and uh not stop when I was there he used to have two operating rooms. The only doctor that had two operating rooms go from operating to operating room do two surgery at the same time and then he al like a smaller clinic close to the thing they do smaller surgeries. So, I had this uh for the mice, I'm going to say I had this, let's call it a wart on the bottom bottom of my soul. Every time I stepped on it, it hurt. I couldn't get rid of it. Use this cream, that cream, garnish. He says, "Why don't you just go to my place?" And uh they'll take it off in a second. They have laser there. So, I go there. Oh, yeah. Dr. Freeman sonic. Okay. They you sit in bed. They bring the machine. I said, "How long does it take?" It's less than a millisecond. Put the machine on. Okay. It's gone. So I I sit up. No, no, no. Sir, sir, sir, we have policy here. You have to sit in the bed for 15 minutes. I'm like, it was on the bottom of my leg. It was a laser to my skin. You're right. But that's policy. Okay. So policy is policy. So I sit there, but I was annoyed. So then after 15 minutes, she says, "Uh, okay, Mr. Staskki, you can get up." So I get up and I fall to the ground. I'm a Dava. I'm like, they start running, rushing. I said, "You just you lasered me, you know." And I'm like, "You're not I should have been here for 20 minutes." Yes, sir. I got into trouble with my father-in-law that they thought I was dying from the laser. Okay. Anyway, now where is the malus in Shabas? This is America. Only in America. In Israel, you never have this. It's like policy. This is no light blog. Light blog. cuz because we do brain cancer and we do this and we do that. So also the wart is the same 15 minutes anyway. Fine. CO shot minutes like all the Israel just like just walk out there. It's like no no but it's the same when you see that 90year-old lady literally 95y old lady walking through they the TSA no okay leg plug. So you got this and that but P almighty I'm not going to say the whole kaf everything right through he's 25 years old anyway we don't have policies that don't make sense that I don't know and these things they they know how to see my where is the [Music] raisita oh oh here we Oh, check this out. Raoai, here's a guy plowing on Chabas. And they say they say him they they're telling him you'll get stoning. You'll die. That's how it's supposed to be done. What happens if they do this? You get Malchus. Does it work or not? Says it doesn't work. You're supposed to give for a love. Okay. There's a guy said that my grandfather he was a a person and he knew the exact day, the exact time and the exact place he's going to die. So guy said, "I don't understand what He said, "No, no, no. The judge told him exactly where it's going." I had enough from it. I did. You didn't. Says, "Oh, you asked me a question that if you give a guy a warning on for Malcus instead of miso here, what's the case?" Simple case. Let's say you have a neighbor that's really annoying. He's one of those neighbors. Every time he brings the garbage out, it drips, drip, drips down all the steps. He makes noise. He doesn't say hello to you like he's supposed to. So now you catch him in the act. He's like literally he's plowing on Chabas. But you don't want to kill him. You don't want to, you know, you don't want to kill him cuz he has, you know, you know his kids. They're nice kids and everything. So you want to give him Malcus. He deserves a nice beating that. Yeah. So you give him fromus. Does it work or not? No, you only want 180. Yeah. Yeah. You bring your friend. You real quick. You know how to do it. So the says holds that works. You could do that. The says he gets you downgraded to malus. You're allowed to do that. So it works. Our mission works. says, "But what what are the options over here?" Let's say it's not you're telling me that is the one that holds that you could you could give him malus in this case, right? Cuz in the Mishna we talk about Shabas. That's one of the four cases Shabas. But how how's if the whole Mishna is talking about Malcus, right? All four C. How do we have Malcus and Shabas? It must be goes only according to that I could give a guy Malcus and Shabas. But let's say you can't come up with that that answer. It's not there's no such. So who the go like right? We said that the bottom left corner cannot go like cuz he holds in the bottom left corner that there's only forgetting that you're not forgetting there's a mdash. So how how could you say that the mission goes like you already came up with a a little bit of a not the best terrors in the world. So we're just going to say that is also the same answer that you answered for you're going to answer in we're not talking about we're talking about Malus says the but wait a minute I have a bomb take a look at the Mishna here's the says in our If you look at this, every word here doesn't fit into Malcus. Every word, let's start from the bottom. The easiest one. It says, we're talking about a carbon. It says he forgot in between. Forgetting is only when you're doing something by mistake. You forget. If you forget, it's a mistake. If you get Malcus, it's not a mistake. It's on purpose. So there's no forgetting. How does forgetting forgetfulness and malus go together? It's like somebody killed somebody, you give them the death penalty and he forgot in between. There's no forgetting in the death in the death penalty. If if you killed somebody, that means you had full awareness from beginning to end. That's the only way you get a death penalty. The kids all these things don't make sense. There's no four. It's only two. There's no y. There's not I knew I didn't know the whole thing. Nothing makes it doesn't fit into the mission at all to say it's talking about malus and not a carbon. Question number one, why does it say there's an awareness? We're talking about you have to talk about the warning, not the knowing. Okay. So one out of the four questions we could brush away with the it means the knowledge of the warning why this here not with yeah I don't know it's good kasha we have to it's not a good what you're asking but I don't know why what hold on the what is what yeah that you're asking that the word doesn't fit in there it means means what it means to say is the knowledge of the we are talking about they use the funny word but another question so here if you're talking about you talk in ribbika this is a kashika so maybe this could answer what you're asking but according to ribika there's only two cuz what happened if you get mal That means you knew what you're doing. So there's only two possibilities. You knew you're going to the B mikdash, so you get malus. And you knew that you're eating kachim, so you get malus. How do you have four? Four only exists if you forgot. So this two forgetting that you are to with b mikdash and kachim. And two forgetting that you're in a b mdash and you're forgetting that you're eating kachum. Two that you're you forgot that you're two that you forgot what you're doing. But if you know what you're doing, there's only two. There's only mdash and I know that I'm going into and I'm know so it's only two. How do you how do you tell me and another question there was a knowledge in the beginning a forgetfulness in the middle and then a knowledge at the end. If you're getting malus that means you had knowledge from beginning to end nothing to do with forgetting the best question for me at least the easiest one it says we're talking about a carbon that's a carbon not malus fine so to answer the question again real quickly we have four cases in the Mishna the bottom two one doesn't go like one doesn't go like what do we do says rebi rebi wanted to Make a list. It's a cool list. In all of Shas, I have four cases. Two that are four. Two that are four. It's a list of two that are four. It happens to be that number three goes according to number four goes according to but it's just a part of I'm compiling a list. Two things in my list are it's a cool list. Yeah, it's a it's a riddle. Where in the is two two that are four? Oh, so now I have the I know the whole list. One of them can't go according to one of them can't go according to okay not the end of the world it's still a nice list it's part of a good riddle when it comes to I'm going to say that he has four only has two cuz he doesn't hold of forgetting that it's a mdash and when it comes to the list of I have to say that because according to there's only a in the in the future not a in the Don't tell me that it's not true that he himself he's just compiling a list. He doesn't hold that. No, no, no. He actually holds in one case like in one case he he's not compiling a list. He literally holds in the case of like and in the case of like that's how he holds. So he wrote it like that. this this simple case of right over here remember this and that's the classic case of the that I knew I forgot I knew so that's why I bring a carbon how do I know that I need to know before and the end how do I know it's in this kind of order and I bring a carbon vanilla pal. Take a look at the pukimo say vanilla twice. So one of them is definitely extra. So what do I do with this? So it stops right over there. So we have to explain it a little bit. It says like this. The first vanilla comes to teach me that it's only forgetting that you are tummy. If you forget where you are that you're in the b mikdash or forgetting that what you're eating is kachum that's not included in the ple vanelam. It's it's extra. So it's coming to tell me this now the second minam what do I do all the kids are getting up and going to school thanks for being here it's okay it's okay a little is better than none so they're going to complain how can the doesn't have these charge okay I'm going to get into trouble afterwards now says raika the second vanelam the extra one comes to say that you have to have this order vanelam before the helm. Vanilla means that I had a sorry the before the helm that it has to go. I know. I was aware. I forgot. I I remembered. Now Rashi just asks how do I know that I remembered afterwards that there was an awareness and a forgetfulness that I learned from vanilla. But how do I know the third step that there was an awareness afterwards? This is actually very simple. How are you going to bring a carbon if you don't know? You can only bring a carbon if you know. If you never knew, if you died not knowing how how you going to bring a carbon. So obviously you knew. Now here comes argues on. He says I'm going to take these two vanilla and I'm going to learn to torug up. If it says vanilla that he forgot says you could only forget something that you knew. So it's obvious that he had an awareness first. So you have an awareness of forgetfulness. So I know that there's an awareness of forgetfulness and awareness like this picture. So then why does the say vanilla twice? Oh that adds the other two. It's two that are four. That's why says in this case in tum two that are four. Not like I hold that the from the second vanelam from this vanam the red vanilla I'm going to learn says not what it says over here I'm going to learn that your even if you forget that you're in the B mikdash that's also a forgetfulness not only that I forgot that I'm and I ate and I went to B mdash but also I forgot that this is B mikdash right there those in this room that go to Harab so they tell them listen if you go to Harbay you get cars but you're not allowed to step from this tree to that tree they give them different parameters and the guy forgot he forgot the parameters he thought he meant this he meant that and he walked into the and he gets carus how do you know how do you know that you're for that says rebi from the next reanima says no no forgetting that it's bas no no you don't bring a karm for that forget that you're and you walked in that like today maybe regular people don't know that they're very tummy they don't know to m so he walks into the harab So that's that's a that's what Rebeika agrees but that you forgot that it's a listen no no no and rebi argues can go what can go on Spencer. Sponsor. Oh, Spencer. No. [Music] I hear I hear turning of the daffations LC in honor of our son's combo that we saw a picture of. If you saw we saw a picture of for learning Sanra with the rebell global still experts in international financial service anonymous in honor of the whose name we cannot say who shows us what it means to be given a sadic I thought the people are very careful not to walk in certain places over there no okay not because okay let's go we have a kasugi coming up here ashkan what's his name natan natan came and gave me this this thing he he drove a long I don't know thank you very much is the one that sent it in the letter says this okay so we just said that holds like when it comes to there's four two that are four so that's why he wrote in the how do you know that when it comes to he that there's four that also in the past are also included the the problem is that the says look it's in the future the doesn't talk about the past so how do I know that rebi holds the past oh so it's logic so it's very very simple it goes like this when the Tyra says a general thing so it includes everything then the Tyra sometimes limits it and then the Tyra says a general a general so there's a generalization generalization and in the middle there's a limitation or the the art calls it a generalization specification generalization so a a good example is so let's talk about because talks about it here's [Music] Amen. I think I was at three of these. Not even one. I've been to one. Yours in in New York. No, the one here. Oh, mayors. Yeah. My grandsons. Yeah. Okay, cool. Okay, so he gave him money. So take a look at it's so simple. When the says, so the T says you could give the anything. Give him Yeah. special money that Yoshi made, real estate, socks, a slave here. There's a right over here, a note of debt. But then the Torah says, It has to be. It has to be money. Everything goes off the table. The only thing that's left is money. That's what it says in the Tyra. But then the Tyra adds rebu. Okay. So it says which means everything. So everything goes back on. But we have to take one thing off. Now this exact thing is also clu exact same thing. One is called ribi. One is called clop. If you come from the school of reebu so your entire life you go through shas and therau rebu it's the same words if you if you come from the school of thought that it's a cloud cloud cl same exact thing just what's the difference the difference is that a prat we say it whoever says kbonus knows this so what does that It means that because the specified So now I'm going to add everything but they have to be exactly in the same parameters of of this money. So I'm going to knock off a lot of stuff that's not like money. Like real estate is not like money. You can't move it. Aar is not like money because it's worthless. How much is a is a check worth? Zero. You can't even blow your nose with it. It's it's it's you know it's hard and it no you can't do anything with it. You owe money. So me that's the difference on a re you get more stuff. You only limit one thing. One thing only. What thing would you limit? the thing that makes most sense to limit which is the thing that's the furthest from what the Torah describes says use money for you're going to limit one thing only don't are you having trouble now this is easy stuff okay you with me okay so check this out again I'm going to add everything I'm going to take everything off the table but now that I'm going to do another boy I'm going to add everything besides one thing. What's that one thing? Aar. Because ashar is the least similar to money. But if I do a clat same exact process, I'm going to add everything. I'm going to take everything off. And now when I add back, it has to be similar to money. So I can't add everything back. I'm going to I'm going to take three things off instead of one thing. Slaves and real estate. So if you go with the thought of cloud rather cloud, you lose more things. If you go with less things. That's the whole difference says now what does that have to do with our because rebolds this guy so the also in our talks about check this out only in the future any type of if you do it includes all of the world. So how many sh do we have left according to rebi now the four what's excluded oh what's excluded one thing I'm going to exclude one thing the furthest thing from one thing but if I hold it has to be similar to the future so only that are in the future I'm going to so I won't be able to do the futures of the past of the past that's the that's the whole thing let's eat inside behold. Was it hard? Seriously, is there a reason to have trauma from this? You do everything and then comes and explains my time of the way here everything's included. Sorry. Now I take everything off the table. What comes back on the table? Oh, sorry. So now you have like you see on the on the chart. Everything comes back on the table. But you have to take exclude one thing because it says I'm going to take off one [Music] thing. He only takes off one thing. We're doing the same thing again. It includes everything. You could use anything to redeem your son. Take everything off the table. But now I'm going to take off three things because it has to be similar to the exclusion. So I cannot redeem my son with real estate because it's not something that you can move. Anyways, slaves are always similar to kaka. So I can't use a slave. I can't give the a slave. The boy said, "Could you give a cen a $100 bill?" Cuz now in our days, there's no there's no there's no gold in the things. It is like a like the Okay. Hill. Uncle Sam is saying Rabbi said listen to Hill. What does Hill say? Very good. How do you know? How about Bitcoin? Could you use Bitcoin? That you say no. It does. It works for MDY. A guy in MDY just sent Yicle. If Bitcoin hits $100,000, I'm giving $50,000 to MDY. If it hits 150, I'm giving $100,000. That means he made $400 million or something. No, the kids say, "Okay, so we have to dive in. It should hit 100." Okay. What? When did it hit 100? No, no, no. He wrote it yesterday, a few days ago. Okay. So anyways, we explain how Rebi fits in here, right? Cuz Rebei holds and therefore in the case of he has four because do we show this in I don't think I showed this yesterday. He did a thing he's in front of a piece of gala and he's lit and he's like I swear I'm going to eat it and he can't eat it. He can't bring himself to eat it or sees a steak and he has such a tit and says I'm not going to eat it. And then okay. So now we have all four all four according to Rebi. Oh dar tell what darian his whole life brought to we know that darian this is a somebody gave this to me I forgot who. So, whoever gave it to me, it's an all. Okay, this is how do you show it that it should see fine. This is very very hurtful. It hurts sharp. Oh, check this this thing out. This is what the says you should use an all. How do you know that you can use a splinter or a needle or a thorn? In other words, the thorn and the needle are made out of wood or a giml like some sort of um bit that turn I I have to say this cuz this reminds me of it. So I have to say there's a guy a big who told everybody that when he dish he doesn't feel any pain whatsoever. So a guy decided that let's went and uh gave him a little thing with a needle took a needle and gave him the finger. Now it hurt him a lot but he has reputation to keep. So he just he just closed his eyes and continued nothing as if nothing happened. So he took the needle and he went to his other hand garnished. So he's garnished. He takes a takes a nail and sticks it right in his arm. He the guy jumped and started screaming. He said what are you jumping? I thought you don't feel any pain. See? Yeah. But what about the first two times? All right. You got it. He got it. No. Ask what the shot is. Huh? Choke was all right. How do I know? The Torah says you use this. What happened? What happened? We have a we have a slave, a Jewish slave, who doesn't want to leave. After 6 years, he doesn't want to go home. Whenever he's supposed to go home, he doesn't go home. So, we take this and we we put it through his ear. You're my slave. You're not this person gets. How do you know that you could use another tool? anything that you could hold in your hand any tool rebi is going to use a cloud cloud to say no ma by the way just a riddle what does this martaya have to do with the minor in the ba mikdash what what's the connection between this so the connection is that both of them have to be made out of metal and you both learn them from It has to be this has to be made out of metal and therefore check out this chart. You have to take out two stylus. You have to take out the two wooden things. You could only do with something that's made out of metal. Rebu. So the question is how come over here Rebby says I thought once you go with one certain line of thought you have to go with that for the rest of your life. Rais have a wonderful day. Merit the of spreading Torah throughout the world. Sponsor Ashir today. mdysponsor.com or sponsor at mdy.com.