17th of Tamuz - Rabbi Eli Kadi

foreign [Music] but until then the rambam tells us that we have to fast on certain times for certain reasons in order for us to do to shuva and not to do the same sins as our fathers did as our grandfathers did and the times is a bit amigdash in other times also that five things happened on this day the first thing that happened was comes down from harsinai and what happens he sees benazel are sinning with the eagle as I have with the golden calf and what does he do he throws the luhot from his hands and they break the first little hot break so that's nishtabru alohot the question to be asked is that there's a greater sin that was done over here the greater tragedy that we have it's the tragedy of clanisal doing the egala zahaf of doing the calf of gold we saw in last week's parashay and Rashida tells us that any problem that comes to Clan Israel takes a little bit of the egalazahab's punishment and throws it in so why does the mishnah only tells us so to answer that you could go to a different Rashi in ele devarim in the varimi goes and he tells us there's a bunch of cities that are mentioned and he brings hazalda tells us that none of these cities exist but all they are are a hint to what we did wrong and in order to not embarrass us moshira bin was so kind that he gave us a hint that we should be able to do Toshiba over here also by the eagle they're doing exactly the same thing they're telling us but you know what the cause of what is the effect but the cause is what is so the first thing that we're told is not straight out it's more of uh it's not hinam it's one of the reasons that the betamic dash was destroyed was because that sinat henam people didn't love each other they didn't care so what hazal is teaching us right now is when you go and reprimand somebody when you tell them you did something wrong don't tell it straight out to their face explain it to them in a roundabout manner like that things go better and like that there's no animosity and like that we have the vitamic dash again the next thing that happened was the second when was it but we didn't have the qurbana tamida anymore every day we used to bring in the morning a korban and in the evening we would bring a korban also and that Corban kept us alive kept us going they realized that this teflote that we're doing these prayers that we're doing praying to Hashem coming close to Hashem is stopping the destruction of betameer so what did they do they went and they put according to one midrash they put up a pork inside in inside they used to they used to go in the morning they would bring them a basket full of gold and the soldiers would put inside two sheep now what did they put inside they put a pork inside that weighs about the same amount and that pork went and grabbed onto the walls and scratched the walls of the homat of the of the betamic dash and it went in it scratched it because it didn't want to go there and this is a very tough thing that happened the same meat was gone what else happened here and the city was breached they were able to go into Jerusalem not to harabite but into your shalim itself now when they went into harabite when they went into Jerusalem what happens it was either on the ninth day of tamus like the pasuk tells us or was the 17th day of tamus so according to our according to the marably what is it it was all the first betamic Dash was on the ninth day of tamus like the pasok the second bataming Dash was on the 17th day of tamus and the reason why we do the second one is Maran tells us is because that's that's brought down from all the a lot of rishonim that that really that was the last thing that happened to us so you remember the last the last Calamity that happened more than the first one the yirushami disagrees with that he says that both of them happened on the 17th day of tamus it's just that Clan isael didn't know how to count it was so mixed up they even didn't know what day it was we all know what it was by July 4th when it was on a Monday and then you went to work on Tuesday you didn't know if it was Monday or Tuesday you were all mixed up when it came Thursday and you take out the Sephora people were screaming it's Wednesday today now people get confused a little bit with times and this is what your xiaomi tells us that the ninth of tamus was really in the first bet I mean their second time it was the 17th day of tamus then there was enough apostomos etatura we don't really know who he was the only reason why we know who he was is because he's brought down over here in the mishnah some people go and tell us apostomus was Antioch was um anti-pattered every single they had different opinions and different thought ways of who it was but at the end of the day he was a Roman legion he was a very bad man and he went and he brought this Torah which Torah did he burn because it's a safer with a the known Torah it was the book of ezraffer so anytime a safer Torah gets burned hashemy schmitten what should never happen again it was a Calamity for clan Israeli was crying for clally Israel so this guy apostolus went and started up with us with our most important thing which is the Torah this torahamas probably was Ezra so first Torah that he went and he wrote it was in the times in the second batamidash According to some and that was the Torah that apostomus went and burned then it says and he placed at Cinema who placed at Cinema according to the rambam and a lot of Adam who was that that was apostumus also he went and he put an idol in the bitter migdash Rashi on the other hand tells us that who was it it was minashe that went and put the idol in like it's brought down in the navi so they ask on Rashi excuse me it should be chronological order you first have the the that were broken then you have the tamid that wasn't there then you have that here then you have apostamus so a camp why are you going back in history you should have brought down Menasha beforehand but Rashi is telling us like we said beforehand about the again as I have why isn't it mentioned because we do not want to embarrass minashe if we look at Ibrahim we see that he did Tosh in the Navy it doesn't tell us so in order not to embarrass him and to reprimand him in front of everybody that's why we put it together according to Russia president that everybody should have a Google and next year we will be in betamic dash and from Shiva salvitamus and tilty Shabba have is going to be more ed [Music]