Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Siman 128 Seif 1-2 Does Nesius Kapayim Push Off Tumah?

okay good morning everyone could you hear me yeah okay good morning everyone we're continuing in so we saw yesterday that for you need a minion the could be part of the minion is even if they're other and the even brings that AAR is over in could be the say your only if you do it by yourself so it says a a a is going on that is even with other even if you want to say that you're not over when he is May the of only and not is only when he makes the himself nevertheless would still be awesome for him to because of only commanded to so in other words there is a debate when a this that we say that a is over and say when is it only if he himself or is it even if he with other but even if you were to say that is not over when he with other it would still be because it's it is a now why is only the why isn't the itself it's a you're saying hashem's name and it's by the way says even saying alone would be but the doesn't say that the Mish says only the itself is so the says it's you're only saying right it's simple it's not a because you're not saying when you say formulated by if you just say so even though you're not authorized to do it in this context it would not be a no so that's what no CU there you're not trying to be in the context of there you're just there it's clear you're saying you're just saying and that's what we had yesterday that if you hold for sure it's not an issue it's for sure you're not over the you're not over the because you're not in terms of so according to the you're just you want to know according to the if you say why isn't that Friday night according to theud I personally would not be surprised if theud did not say those Friday night but uh that's a different story okay hey B if not for if it's not aala meaning the theama here says that that the re did not know what iser is there in a zar that is cuz it could be with it's permitted so the m just points out there there certainly would be an of what the is he doesn't know what is of there would be for to be right so there's among the whether AAR is um and I say if he but for sure there would be an for saying the and the ra conclusion is it could be that with other is not says regarding this the re said that he's not maybe maybe in other words the way the ra is learning the is that which the re says that there's no when could he only said that when the is with other side not like the that if um let's say he have a guy he wants to get a good so he decides he's going to with the other he is now what if he goes up there and he doesn't we saw yesterday he doesn't do it then he's not over let's say the guy just goes up and he hums so he's also not over it's not the best thing to what doesn't say the itself he doesn't say the bra and he yeah he doesn't say the no just the opposite he if he the BR is only regarding will determine whether he's over any who does not have one of the impediments if he doesn't go up even though even though he is like violating three ass so a he has no reason not to go up if he doesn't go up even though he's one he's violating it's like he's violating three if he was present in the when they announced or if they told him to go up or to wash his hands let's see the mission later on this we're going to learn it will explain many things that prevent the from going up to some of them are biblical impediments some of them are according to everyone it's like you're violating three what are the three that it's like you're violating the you're violating it's like you're violating however in fundamentally in principle you're only over one which is which was said in as a command to be the say that would not push off in other words let's say like this the coin's in the back row and on the third back row you have a guy laying there that's dead so it the Cen can't make it to the front of the shore so now he has a dilemma he's not a he's not a pass by this dead body he's going to become tummy on the other hand he's going to be if he doesn't so the question is do you say say so the say that is not because [Applause] becoming even if let's say a guy dies suddenly after the said by the way unrelated to the to the voice of the kazen meaning it's not the Kaz didn't necessarily kill him that's not the but a guy died a guy in the sh died after the now the question is it's ofing otherwise he can't really conjure up a case mean what what would a case be where the the has a he knows about a that there's ding with a dead body there there's no ass on him to do that the ass only kicks sin once they call out but in such a case where after the calls out somebody dies so now it's he has to go out right away let's say the doesn't know so should you let him maybe sometimes it's better you know ignorance is bliss no you have to tell him okay if the is in a house nearby the and you could steal up the doors and the windows the house that the even if it is known to him even if let's say the knows he doesn't have to leave until the completion of because is biblical and such is only meaning when the when the windows are sealed the is only M so even though doesn't push off pushes off M now let's be m in the Mish somebody write this down the Mish says only if he already started and he discovers he's allowed to continueing but is he allowed to go even though that means he'd be violating I think we could be from the Miss he can't why not why we say pushes off he says um if it became known to before it's better that he go out so then you be the other way that's only if it became known to the Cain before he washed his hands but so then it's better for him to go out once he washes his hands it sounds like he even though he didn't get called up yet so it's somewhat of what we call a contradictory implications cuz first the Mish says that if the co is Middle he doesn't have to leave and then the Miss says if it became known to the before he washed his hands then he should leave that implies if it became known to him after he washed his hands he stays he doesn't stay Happ no there it's talking about he has to leave even after they call even after they called now we're talking about they sealed up the windows so if they sealed up the windows the is only M then it seems like he would stay as long as he he didn't wash the hands but once he washed his hands um it sounds like he would leave as long as he didn't wash his hands but once he washes his hands he would have to go by the way the says that even if it became known to the in middle of the says even by he would have to go but the mishab says once he started right the is so at what point is the grandfathered into the because the M says if he knows before then he leaves that implies once he washes his hands he stays even though he didn't get C up yet the sh says that if he if it became known to him before he washed his hands it's only to to go out but that implies he's low to stay by that's another Mas the mash says if he if he didn't wash his hands yet it's good to leave but it does sound like he's allowed to go um have a great day thank you for the patients hopefully tomorrow the uh will'll get going timely sorry for the technical difficulties call Tough recording stopped