Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Okay, good evening everyone.
We're continuing our Shirim on Ferius
and actually
this year Shirim 5786
are sponsored by the Israeli family
their grandmother Malio
for her whole family
is dedicated by Dr.
of
and tonight share is sponsored by a dear
friend of mine in Israel anonymously as
is for KL and for the gula. Okay.
So now we're in safer
safer.
Make sure you have magaka on safer
bracious.
It's available in local sperm stores.
Make sure you're equipped for Kaneka,
the light and the splendor. And the
Benla Ashri, it went to print and it's
having a very special cover design which
first they sent me an email that it's
being produced. It's a very rare
material. It's going to take 3 weeks to
produce and one week to deliver. And
then they were able to find 400 of them
in Arat Israel. So there will be 400
copies sooner rather than later and the
rest of it
I don't know if they have to uh
manufacture the animal first from what I
don't know I don't know the process they
didn't reveal to me the process of the
cover material but it's it's in the
queue. Okay. So this week uh we're
continuing last week's subject.
I have to say surprisingly I got a lot
of amazing feedback on last week's topic
about whether Kavino benched go when he
came out of the aa
and today we're going to segue into
theic ramifications of it just to
refresh your memory [snorts] we discuss
the dream that
the father of the ka
appeared
Before
the great rebel, the author of
the father of the wasabenu
and he appears to rebel
and rebelar asks him in a dream
when he came off of the he asked him
what about the four tanoim that entered
the parades. Uh some of them were in
mortal danger. Some of them did not
survive. Did they bench go? Did Rabi
Akiva bench goal when he emerged from
the paradise? Also the when he comes out
of the kadesh does a bench and if you
remember in the dream what did reply? He
didn't give an answer in the dream.
However, in a state of awakenness
came to Zaraka and he asked him these
Shilas and the father of the gave the
following answer number one the never
were maky. So somebody wanted to know is
go a it's okay
we're not in only if the comes to a
person against their will without their
knowledge without their desire and a
miracle happens somebody became sick
somebody had to traverse the sea
somebody had to traverse a desert
however if God commands a person to be
in a situation Hashem commanded Abraham
to shak
Then were never
and asks [clears throat]
why are you asking me about the why
didn't you ask me if Abrau should bench
go bench go when he came out of orazd or
moshen when he went up to
vazar when he when he when they were
saved by the fire or Daniel when he was
saved by the from the lion's den.
[clears throat] So said no, you only
bench go if something happens to you
against your will, not if you're
commanded by
moreover
said the true story is that when Abraino
picked up the knife at the aa he
actually's
soul departed and in that case Yitzk
actually died. So why would he bench go?
He wasn't saved. He was actually
resurrected. So the question is did he
makeim?
And the answer to that is of course he
did. That's the second of
regarding those who are parades. They
didn't actually enter you know the
botanical gardens. It was a mystical
arena. And why would they bench go just
because their minds were were
contemplating the secrets of the
universe.
And again did the bengamon came out of
the no. The also commanded not uh to go
into the
therefore the conclusion of
is that there is no goal said in any of
the above mentioned circumstances not
when the not the four that entered the
parades and not when the enter
disagreed with
said number one if Hashem had to
designate an aisle in lie of and abrau
[clears throat] and which obviously
required specialus
also the bless brings that the malar
said to hashem you're a raon so
obviously he needed great ramanus so of
course he had to thank and blesses
and you wanted to know why I didn't ask
you about abra mayor kazdim I'm not the
one who asked the question that somebody
came to somebody. It was the bal who
asked the question. You came to me in a
dream and in a dream the the master of
dreams asked you the question. And
regarding the four that entered the
parades if they entered a dangerous
situation, they certainly had a bench
goal. Why would this be any worse than
somebody who wakes up in the morning who
they didn't actually die in the evening
and yet when they wake up they say
Mim even though they didn't actually
die. So too in all these situations
let's say the four that went to the
parades they didn't actually enter an
orchard but they were saved and
therefore they should bench go. This is
like a a classic historical conversation
between Rabitak Zaraka Aulai
as we mentioned he's buried in Harazim
at the foot of Harazim next to Zakaria
happens to be this Shabas is the yard
site of the great great grandfather of
the Rabbazulai
not to be confused with Rabb Ramulai not
to be confused with Rabb Ramazul and not
to be confused without Rabb Ramazuli.
There were four Rabbi Ramazulis.
The first one
was Motes Farad was one of the Gurushes
Farad. He's the father of of the Azulai
family and he came from Spain in 1492
to
Fez and very little is known about him.
Then you have the great greatgrandfather
of the who uh came from Fez to Kevron.
He's buried in he's the great
he wrote a
I believe it's called Arba Shekel. He
also wrote a safer
and in it he has many mystical secrets.
One of them being that there's no city
in the world more predisposed to
understand Kabala than the city of which
summarily dismisses as out of hand. Um
that's the great great-grandfather. Then
you have
a descendant of Rabbi Ramazuli
[snorts]
named Rabb Ramazuli who is the great Ra
and Makob in Marrakesh.
And [clears throat] then his grandson
was also Rabbi Ramazuli. In any event,
the most well-known Rabb Ramazuli his
yard is this Shabas. Okay. So this is a
conversation between Rabut Zaraka and
Rabar.
You would think this doesn't really this
is more of a theoretical question. This
is more uh an interesting
uh question to ponder and doesn't really
haveic ramification. But as we're going
to see that this debate of whether said
when he came off the actually has many
ramifications. We're going to start with
Simon. Here you have a guy. He had
enough. He couldn't take it anymore.
[snorts] Why? Life is not just going is
really just not going his way. You know,
nobody respects him. He he gets gala
every every Monday and Thursday they
give him gala and other terrible
injustices and he decides that for
supper instead of drinking water or
instead of drinking yen he's going to
poison himself and what happened
in the last second he drank the poison
and they took him to the hospital and uh
miraculously ly
the or as he gets to the emergency room
and everyone else is sitting there for
48 days, he goes right in. They take him
right in and they they save his life and
now he comes to sh the next morning. He
looks a little, you know, little pale.
They say, "What happened?" He said,
"It's terrible. You wouldn't believe
what happened. What happened?
Nothing I do works out. What did you
do?" He said he tried he tried to kill
himself and they saved his life. Does he
bench go? Does he bench go? That's the
question brought in
Simmon
Gimmel. And Falagi says that in his
opinion,
why would this be why would this be
different than any person who was ill
and has a recovery? So this person had
temporary illness, temporary insanity.
He tried to kill himself and he was
unsuccessful so he should bench go and
says look I know that I know there's a
very big difference between these cases
because
in one case the person was sick against
their will the other case the person
purposely tried to kill himself so maybe
we can't prove that you'd be obligated
to bench goal says the main taka
of goal
is
for the healing, for the salvation that
heaven had mercy on you. So it doesn't
matter what how you got into the jam,
whether Hashem put you in the jam or you
put yourself in the jam, you're not
making a braha on the jam, you're making
a braha on the the salvation. So in both
cases, you're saved. In fact, says you
could argue there's a bigger of if you
save yourself from attempted su if
you're saved from attempted suicide than
if you had an illness. You know why?
Because the is
Hashem bestows kindness to the guilty.
So who's more guilty? A guy who's sick
because of his sins or a guy who tried
to kill himself? guy who tried to kill
himself is the very epitome of guilty.
So says he definitely
this is very appropriate for him. He's
saying Hashem who bestows kindness of
him for those who are guilty. This guy
is anaran. He's a sinner. He almost lost
his share in the world to come. Hashem
had mercy on him in this world and in
the next world.
Especially in light of the fact that
says it's not only someone who crosses a
sea or crosses a desert. Anyone who's
bailed out of any difficult situation
should have to bench go. Besides that he
says there's a lot more this guy has to
do. He should have to do chuva for
trying to take his life.
And he should actually not only bench
go, he should say halal hagal that God
had mercy on him in his complete
insanity.
And he should give a lot of sudaka and
support those who learn Tory tora and he
should accept upon himself from now on
not only is he not going to try to kill
himself. From now on he's going to wear
a seat belt in the back seat. He's never
going to even put himself in safik sak
the way to do chuva for not taking care
of yourself is going the extra mile to
be extra careful. So from now on he's
going to be taking multivitamins. He's
going to look four ways before he
crosses the street
and he's going to he's going to
exercise. He's going to eat omega-3 fish
oil and he's going to have flax seed.
because that makes you live much longer
>> flax seed but I can't get into that
right now. Okay.
[clears throat] So then palagi says
that there's a very similar shila
addressed by nissim
about the story in the gar migillah that
raba got up and he shed rabzer
and then when rabba woke up from his
stuper he realized you know maybe he
went a little bit overboard in the
simaspur so he brought back to life did
zer bench go and says sure he did. And
then he goes on to um deal with the
following dilemma. When Rabba killed
Rabzer, Rabzer's children inherited him.
When Rabba brought Rabzer back to life,
does he get his money back?
You don't there's no you know once your
children inherit you, there are no back
seats. How how you get it back from
them? You you reverse the process of
inheritance. There's no way to reverse
the process of inheritance. Did anyone
ever after they bury them come out of
the kev and make a claim on the can't do
that no more. So that was a shila raised
by
Nissim.
>> Is he still a father?
>> There there are a lot of different
Shilas. Is he still a husband?
>> Right. That
>> right. Could his wife remarry?
>> Right.
>> Right. Imagine, you know, he disapp he
went to a purm party. He ca [laughter]
he went to a purm party, he got killed,
he came back to life.
You know, does he need a new kaducian?
Okay, I'm using a lot of discretion now.
Now
says,
you ready for this? I'm going to bring a
raya that you're obligated to bench go
if you try to kill yourself and you're
unsuccessful
from the shila that the father of the
discussed with okay I'm going to bring a
right now what would you say the father
the father of the said that when came
back from the he did not bench goal
and said he did bench ga
What would you think these respective
opinions hold about someone who tried to
kill themsel? Do they bench go if
they're unsuccessful?
Amazingly
says, I'll prove that the father of the
who says did not bench go would hold
that if you try to kill yourself, not
you, if someone heaven forbid is not
successful, they would have to bench
they would have to bench goal. Why?
Because why did the father say that did
not bench go?
>> Because you only bench go if it's a
situation against your will. But if God
commands you to do it, you don't bench
go.
The guy who tries to kill himself, God
commanded them to try to kill
themselves. God commanded them not to
kill themselves.
The whole logic of the father is that if
you're commanded to do a mitzvah and
you're endangering yourself and you're
saved, you don't bench. But what if
you're commanded not to do something and
you do it anyway and you're saved, THEN
OF COURSE you would bench go. Says
the father of obviously holds that
someone who tries to take their life
would have to bench go. And that's his
conclusion that someone who tries to
kill themsself would have to bench go
and and the rioa he brings is from the
father of the
interestingly
ysef wrote a chuva on this topic.
Okay. inad.
Now the difference between and are
extremely lengthy chubis
are shorter chubis.
I believe these are chuv that raya
discussed on the radio. Ra was uh a
regular on the radio. People would ask
questions and he would give more a
bridged answers. A bridge means only a
few pages as opposed to you know dozens
and dozens of of
Ravaji was asked somebody who tries to
kill themselves or let's say someone is
not careful with their health every
night they have um deep fries you know
and uh double hamburgers covered with
pastrami and then all of a sudden
uh they're they're they're not in good
cardiac shape and miracle of miracles
the doctor saved their life. Do you
bench go or do you say the guy brought
it on himself? You know nobody told him
he should have red meat and fried food
three meals a day every single day. So
what what would the be if a person
is negligent with their health
and they bring certain health conditions
upon themselves and then they're
miraculously saved. Do they bench go?
So Raadya says something very
interesting. Raadya says someone who
tries to take their life
is now to bench go.
Not only they're now to bench go if they
bench go their blessing is a disgrace
because basically what they're doing is
they're publicizing their sin. Hey
everyone let's take a let's take a
threeminut break now in middle of the
creatur. I just wanted to let everybody
know that, you know, last night I tried
the guy says he tried to poison himself
and he was such a he's such a
schlamazle. He does everything wrong. He
couldn't even care. He couldn't even
kill himself.
What a disgrace. He's make he's going to
bench. No, you're not to bench go. That
sitzar agrees you're now bench ga.
Moreover, the says that someone who
endangers their life to make money and
they're saved miraculously cannot bench
goal. However,
if somebody is negligent with their
health and then they're miraculously
saved,
they would bench go. Even though one of
the great Rabaja hoda you ever hear
says you do not uh bench go says that he
disagrees if someone is negligent in
their health they would in fact bench
go. So it's an interesting
says someone who tries to take their
life
you bench if you're saved
says you're not allowed to bench go.
Okay there um the reason we're speaking
about this topic is not for any
practical reason. It's just really to
show that this so to speak midnight late
night conversation where the father of
the comes to in his dream and they're
discussing the theoretical whether Ben
after the it has
interesting there's a safer I had never
seen it before called
from the bareb
and the bialba discusses many different
questions about benching goal and he
brings a cha from Hildersheimer
who agrees with that someone who tries
to take their life and they're
miraculously saved they would in fact
bench go
and then he brings something very
interesting you know this is the most
common question by the way that rabbis
get telling you if you if we made a
rabbi convention now 99 out of 100 would
agree that this is the most common
shila. People love asking questions.
Why? Cuz everyone has a need. Everyone
there's a human need to ask a shila,
right? So what are you going to ask the
rabbi? Questions that actually affect
your life. Why would you want to put
your life into you're going to ask
somebody a question like what's the
right thing to do and how I live my
life? No, that's that's too dangerous.
Who actually has the courage to ask a
real Shila? So therefore, most Shiloh
are. Should I bench go? What happened?
What happened? You know, I was supposed
to, you know, I heard there was a plane
and it Yeah. And what happened? What
happened was I didn't go on it. Were you
going to go on it? No, I never was going
to. Why didn't you go on it? Cuz I don't
have a travel agent. Why don't you have
a travel agent? I don't even know any
travel agents. So why should you bench
go? Cuz I wasn't on the plane. You know,
you ever hear the silus? You know,
people they they hear that of this
terrible disaster and usually they
figure out a way why they were supposed
to have been there.
[snorts] Now
>> happened to my father.
>> I know. I believe me. We'll go around
the room. Most people say it happened to
them.
>> He had tickets to fly back and somebody
told him go home early in Belgium.
>> Say it publicly. Yeah.
>> And [laughter]
the plane that he was supposed to be on
got or blown up or something. See this
sadic over here? His father-in-law was
on. You weren't the one who was gonna
blow it up. No. [laughter]
>> I think you
>> Yeah. So the question is like this,
right? If you avoid a situation
altogether, in other words, if if loy if
somebody's in an accident and nothing h
and they walk out unscathed, they bench.
But what if someone's in a car and they
swerve and they miraculously swerve and
nothing happens? Do [clears throat] you
bench go?
You don't bench go. Why? Because they
were never in the situation to begin
with. You know, they they averted the
situation altogether. So you only bench
go when you're in the danger and you're
saved from the danger. But the fact that
you you know a guy asked me once, no I'm
joking, you know, should he bench go?
Why? Because uh he wasn't at the
tsunami. Was he supposed to be there?
No. You know, but imagine if he was, he
wouldn't have made it. So that you don't
benge Goymo for that.
>> What about people that survived 9/11
because
>> they were in the building?
>> Yeah.
>> Yeah. So if somebody was in the building
and let's say 99 out of 100 people let's
say in other words if you're if
somebody's in a dangerous situation and
in reasonable likelihood one should not
survive that dangerous situation then
you don't bench come but let's say
somebody was uh supposed to have been in
the building and a miracle happened
>> he was sleepless that morning and he
came late so so he should he should
thank Hashem he should uh say he should
say
he should be very grateful but he can't
bench. Okay, he was never in the
dangerous situation. Now surely it's
preferable not to be in the dangerous
situation to begin with. But those are
those are the guidelines of goal or are
they or are they there's a big question
how do you define what the obligation of
goal is? Is obligation of for being
ins and being saved from it? Or is
come for the miracle of hashem? If it
comes from the miracle, maybe I didn't
have to be in thesara. If it comes from
being extricated from the tsara, then
you had to have been in it. So the
bialarb says he brings from the maral
and the
is not for the miracle. is for for
being extricated from the situation.
And he says that somebody who try to
take their own life,
>> he says,
>> but if somebody wanted to take their
whole life, so this is the way he says
it. The person wasn't in the Tsara and
extricated. The person put himself in
the Tsara. the of if in other words if
the obligation of is you're stuck in
a bad situation God pulled you out so if
you put yourself in the situation to
begin with you would not be to bench go
but if the obligation of goal is for the
miracle of Hashem then we don't really
care how you got there you'll be you'll
bench go for the miracle and the the
upshot is for the most part we say that
go is for being extricated from a
dangerous situation Not just for the
miracle per se. Okay. So that's also an
important in benching. You're not you're
not saying go just for the miracle. It's
for being in a situation that was so to
speak against your will and then being
extricated from it. Here's one more very
interesting
ramification from uh the discussion of
and
that is
do you say when you travel by airplane?
Okay, we started discussing this last
week. Do you say goyal when you travel
by airplane? So there's a question. And
you say go let's say you know you fly
from uh New York to Washington you bench
go you fly from New York to Florida you
bench go what are the parameters of
benching is there only when it's very
dangerous is it more or less dangerous
when you fly more locally than if you
fly across the country if you fly
internationally is it only if you fly
over the waters so first the brings the
that says that whenever you fly in the
airplane you bench. So the says okay on
the one hand maybe that indicates that
flying in an airplane is always
situation where you bench but it's not a
at all because
andardis they always bench the says even
when you take a flight from here to
Florida will bench according to so
therefore you can't prove from him uh
that airplane travel will always require
goal. But then he says, you know, they
say I I they told me in the name of the
satba that when you fly uh you fly
internationally, you would bench go.
But he says the bellba
that when you travel by airplane, you
say without hashem's name. That's
the a famous pak of the bellba. when you
travel by airplane you bench go without
the name of hashem if I'm not mistaken
kamki said the same and his logic is
that uh airplane travel today is very
safe is very safe and therefore
kamineski says even in the nine days you
know airplane travel would uh could be
okay
but the [clears throat]
says let me explain to you some of the
rationale of the saka the bells of rabba
by the way the minute in general is if
you're flying internationally you you
will bench ga if you fly you know more
domestically in general unless you're
raisha says I believe any flight over 72
minutes uh you're going to bench go but
in general the min is the only bench go
if you fly overseas
says
let me explain to you the rationale of
the bellba why you wouldn't bend
with the name of Hashem
when you fly in an airplane and you know
who it's based on the same source that
cited that he wanted to prove that if
somebody tries to kill themsself they
don't bench go I'm sorry they would
bench go because you only bench go if
you're commanded to do something if
you're not commanded to do it if you're
commanded not to do it you would bench
go
the says something very interesting
Interesting
says,
"Didn't the father of the say
that
you only bench
when the danger is against your will?" I
you'll say it was also against his will.
He didn't want to go to the wasn't
against his will. Hashem told him to do
it. He didn't have to do it. He decided
to do it and he saved. You don't bench
Gal. He agreed to do it willingly
by he agreed to do it willingly.
Therefore, he [snorts] did not bench.
But when someone travels across the
desert,
he has no other way to get there.
Somebody crosses the sea, he has no
other way to get there.
says,
"Who asked the guy to take an airplane?
An airplane is more dangerous than going
on a boat
or going on a camel. Who asked the guy
to fly thousands of feet in the air? Oh,
the guy wants to do it. Why is he
putting himself in such danger? He
decided to do it." You don't bench when
you decide. He put himself in this
situation to begin with. You don't
when you put yourself in the situation
again the is so to speak citing the
father of the and applying it to
airplane travel. Now, I think nowadays
you could strongly make the case that
it's probably safer to travel on an
airplane than to take a sailboat across
the ocean or, you know, some kind of uh
ca, you know, ship with holes in it
across the ocean or or to take some kind
of uh camel uh through the desert trying
to pass through marauders or dangerous
areas. But just you see how he's citing
the father of the ka and trying to apply
it to
[clears throat] to modern day air
travel. So this is another another uh
source for this is this is another way
that the conversation between the father
of the and has a practical
ramifications. So on the one handi cites
the father of the ka that if somebody
tried to take their own life they would
bench goal for a a failed attempt. On
the other hand it could serve possibly
as a support that you would not bench go
on airplane travel the we do we do bench
goal on at least an international
flight. And uh this conversation between
Rabbazar and the father of the even
though the brought it down
you know it's interesting the says he he
brought it down so that these two
sadikim his rebi and his father's lips
should continue to uh reverberate even
after their their departure from this
world. So with all of the modern shilus
that are based upon their conversation,
there's no doubt that their uh lips are
continuing to uh reverberate for uh for
many generations. Okay, that's that's
tonight's share.
>> Is there still a
>> Why didn't Why isn't
>> What's mitsahabit?
That's an aa the fact that in the after
is if it's simultaneously the now
there's a separate question it's already
make on something that you did on a ver
>> you're not making on a you're being
you're making a braha on the fact that
you were saved the the salvation wasn't
you're right the guy did an aa
>> so you're [clears throat] going to make
a brah on it because the guy attempted
to do a
>> no you're not making a brah on attempt
to do that that the a he attempted to do
did not result in his uh yeah did not
result in his demise.
>> So you consider
also
>> no suka and lul the guy only was able to
procure a suka and fulfill the mitzvah
because he stole something.
The same thing this prophet could only
be done at this more point is if he
attempts to make suicide.
>> All right.
>> Yeah. Look the look the by the suka the
item in which right now he's doing the
mitzvah is stolen
right now presently in order to do the
mitzvah. This guy here yesterday tried
to kill himself. right now though he's
alive the the a is not uh clear and
present in front of him assisting in the
performance of of the braha that he's
doing you know
>> you can argue this he's not he's not the
he's alive now he's making a that
yesterday isn't it was a failure
>> he can say you make he didn't do the
>> you know he didn't do it
>> all right there still
>> thank you
>> okay have a good day good night everyone
Let's go.
>> When we respond,
>> is that a riot?