Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Can You Endanger Yourself To Teach Torah? Rav Elchanan, The Ahavas Eisan, & Rav Elyashiv

54 views
Rabbi Daniel Glatstein Official avatar
Rabbi Daniel Glatstein Official

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

okay good morning friends so we were not to get together last uh two weeks so we have three blot we want to uh say on hopefully we'll try to do so um expeditiously first we begin with z z this will be for Z discusses the Fantastic account of the practice of rishu Lei who who even though y would warn people from being near the Flies of Bal raan Bal ran were a a type of M there 24 types of muken and Bal ran were the is the most severe of all and RAB Z would not sit in their wind space rabar would not go in their tent Rami rasi would not eat from the Egg of the alley rabish Ley would attach himself to these people and he would be he cited the a beloved gazelle that engenders Grace that if Tyra gives Grace to those who learn it certainly it will protect those who learn it from this very debilitating and disgraceful illness fine the question though is the question they ask is that it's a life-threatening disease how is R allowed to put his life in Jeopardy so you'll say well the problem though is that does not apply if it's what is called if it's we do not apply the principle of uh we do not apply the principle of so let's begin with uh let's begin with this question uh let's see do you see the mar no yes yes you do see it you see it now Mar yeah okay so that's the question who asked this question many let start with in the how could I go anoint David sha will hear and he'll kill me what do you mean you have a Mitzvah to do it won't the Mitzvah protect you from there we see from here we see that if the hez is likely we cannot rely on the principle that will not be harmed says the only way to address this question is to be between the that is only by other but learning is different we make that if now let's get something straight was this actually a lifethreatening illness did the gamar say that people die because of it no the gamar just said that it causes the the nose to run and the mouth to run and there flies around you it sort of distorts the regular features of a person so somehow you allow to rely on this that if certainly it should protect This Is The Answer between there's a p on the side of the it's called ever see the the inaky is a collection of theas and on the side you have a and he also asked question he says how could protect those who cling to but the he is very common says that where the damage is likely even could get harmed says the he says that protects even where a Mitzvah can't and therefore um even where it could protect that's exact same answer but then says you ready for this is one of the biggest I ever saw that the din of maybe applies to and maybe it applies to as well when it comes to teaching to others we do not apply the rule of to teach T publicly you're allow to rely on Miracles there's no you're allow to that's what the said to puppy do you cling to of it it's masma that he is doing proper he was teaching others you hear this in other words there's Mitzvah is greater than a Mitzvah is even greater than that that you could rely on a miracle says with this it comes out well not to ask we find him bakama we find that someone who gives up his life for to we don't say over to in his name that's where the that's if he's giving up to make money and not only that we know T is greater than saving someone El else's life so if it could if it supersedes saving someone else's life certainly or also it would supersede saving your own life and says that that which says is greater than so it comes out according to this that the reason why was able to give up his life it's because he was doing it to teach to teach it would come out then what would be if somebody is a rebi and they have to travel up north to give Shear are you allowed to endanger your life to give a Shear so and theuk says from here we see that if you're a rebi and missiles are flying in the North in the Galil mayos Pim I don't know exactly what a Paz Paz is maybe look it up but I assume it's a missile if the Pim are flying are you allowed to travel to give a shear saysin also said we know that even though you're allowed to give up more than your fifth of your money because that's for regular not for I don't think that has any bearing on this but based on this gar in kuis the uh wants to say that you would be allowed to endanger your life to give a she okay now I want to I I think I would like to present an original answer to this question I don't know why um it's not given I didn't see it anywhere but first first let's um extrapolate based on this approach there's a the end ofum who says that not only are you allowed to give up your life for you're required to give up your life because we find for those learning yua was punished for not engaging in tah at the time of War so R interprets this that not Mish you have to give up your life to teach tarim but if it's not a out WR Sak it's a quasi Sak so then since the Torah is magly then you would have to risk your life you you should do a differentiate between traveling to go to teach versus teaching in of itself well look if you would even have to if you would even be allowed to travel certainly you'd be allowed to teach right I'm saying when you're traveling this could be you're not in the in the learning or do include the traveling as part of the learning right but you know um I guess is saying not only Could you teach you could even travel right that would be even bigger sh brings from uh he brings a story there was a family in Minsk in Russia that during communism they were go there not to teach and the yusim were overseeing that this should be maintained and the considered a shash and they passed him to teach even though it's s mes anyone who was C was sent immediately to Siberia um and they did this for many years and they were taken and he brings supported them andus H led the yiva for many years okay very interesting bottom line is says that it's not for teaching is different than MIT by by we say by we say sh by but is saying no it's not a it's a brings someone's going on a far Road and it's a corrupt Road they're robbers on the road there are terrorists on the road um to or their kidnappers and then the communities have to redeem them about such a person who travels we say he should have waited a little bit until the danger passes and the says he applies what sh said to sha what sh said that sha will find out and he'll kill me and we don't say because sh okay bottom line is so far we've seen um a number of approaches re re says like this he asked how could learn with these people you can't even eat eggs there so he says and answer ofon Cutler says a similar answer with k with for him it was not a s and for him that was not considered being but for someone else to it would be a problem in other words I think what rash is saying is andon says a similar thing that R was on a level of that for him he wasn't concerned he didn't have to worry him on his level it was okay I want to present an approach I don't know why uh this is not said there's a Rashi on the gamar here that I think learns the whole sugya differently so thus to review the is how could put himself in danger says is different the says is different said are different let's go with the approach of for a moment that it's either or the approach of teaching I think there's a factor here that's being overlooked look at Rashi says you know Pap he also he wanted the to show him his spot in the says okay you keep everything do you even hang around Bal R so Rashi says why did Rish Le hang around Bal rasan very simple he endangered himself to honor the Tyra what are we going to do with that Rashid doesn't say he endangered himself to teach Tyra he endangered himself to honor the T how is he honoring the T he was showing that tah has such power so it it extends such Grace to those who learn it that nothing could harm a person who who is learning it and the proof is I will learn with those who have the most despicable illness and I will retain my charm I want to share with you gar M gim the gamar says gar is discussing that what's greater thear wants to know what's greater or so we know the Mal came to and he Saidi I came now I came now because the gar wants to know how do we know that you're all to to hear the says from we make a that if you're for the M certainly says really is more than but the Mal criticized yushua more for not learning than for not bringing carbon says that's not arah that's not has a no but even is more important than the says is greater than did you know that that even though the greatest Mitzvah is learning T it's more important to honor even than learning gar is greater than T I would suggest that this sugya you can't prove that you're allowed to endanger yourself for a mitzvah you can't prove your L endanger yourself for Learning and you can't prove your L endanger yourself for teaching look at Rashi what happened to good old rashi rashi says that the intention of rishu Lei was to honor the Tyra how is he honoring the T he wanted to show the world the power of toyra not to be m in the midst of learning or teaching he was being M you could put yourself in Sai form honor the to you could put yourself in Sak for so it come out if there was a and there were there were uh bullets flying you could go you could endanger your life to honor him couldn't endanger your life to learn or to teach according to this approach I didn't see anyone who says it but I think Rashi is saying it those are the words of Rashi I I you know I don't think R Le was doing this for har you know who's going to teach the b r son well that's that's what it was there was no one else in CLA world to teach he couldn't find a a teenager who needed some extra tutoring he had to teach this guy you'll say well nobody else could teach this guy somebody else could Rashi seems to indicate It's A din in cover we already know is greater than T that's I don't know that's how I see it anyway this is very interesting Su there's more to it we're going to move on to okay what

Up next

24 recommendations shown

The Coronation of King Charles III and the Coming of Mashiach {Torah Illuminated Series}
4:27

The Coronation of King Charles III and the Coming of Mashiach {Torah Illuminated Series}

Daf Hashavua - Nazir 18b
38:03

Daf Hashavua - Nazir 18b

God is protecting Israel, WOW!
0:29

God is protecting Israel, WOW!

Berel Solomon
3 years ago
The Coronation of King Charles the Third With the Oil of Har Hazeisim - The Historic Message
9:35

The Coronation of King Charles the Third With the Oil of Har Hazeisim - The Historic Message

Daf Hashavua - Nazir 18a
33:29

Daf Hashavua - Nazir 18a

Matisyahu - King Without A Crown
3:42

Matisyahu - King Without A Crown

Matisyahu
18 years ago
SOLAR ECLIPSE 2024 - WHAT DOES IT MEAN???
56:41

SOLAR ECLIPSE 2024 - WHAT DOES IT MEAN???

Pausing Eating Out Of Respect For Others At The Table -Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Siman 170 Seif 1-2
19:40

Pausing Eating Out Of Respect For Others At The Table -Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Siman 170 Seif 1-2

Yerushalayim  - MIAMI BOYS CHOIR
4:11

Yerushalayim - MIAMI BOYS CHOIR

Solar Eclipse: Should You Look?
29:24

Solar Eclipse: Should You Look?

When It's Time To Leave the Country - The Chofetz Chaim's Powerful Insight
2:07

When It's Time To Leave the Country - The Chofetz Chaim's Powerful Insight

The truth about addiction
1:26

The truth about addiction

DAMASCUS IN THE END OF DAYS
8:43

DAMASCUS IN THE END OF DAYS

ALL PARSHA - The Malbim on Parshas Vayeitzei
9:27

ALL PARSHA - The Malbim on Parshas Vayeitzei

Benny - Ivri Anochi - I'm a Jew and I'm Proud - The Music Video -  בני פרידמן - עברי אנכי
4:30

Benny - Ivri Anochi - I'm a Jew and I'm Proud - The Music Video - בני פרידמן - עברי אנכי

Benny Friedman
10 years ago
Khamenei Eliminated on Shabbos Zachor!
3:34

Khamenei Eliminated on Shabbos Zachor!

Saying Divrei Torah at the Meal - Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Siman 170 Seif 1
18:19

Saying Divrei Torah at the Meal - Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Siman 170 Seif 1

Gabriel Tumbak - Pardonne Moi - גבריאל טומבק - סלח לי
4:50

Gabriel Tumbak - Pardonne Moi - גבריאל טומבק - סלח לי

Gabriel Tumbak
10 years ago
Partner in Eternity - When the Jewish People Need it Most
2:55

Partner in Eternity - When the Jewish People Need it Most

Vayeizei & Chanukah: Words of Torah - DNA of The Universe
57:33

Vayeizei & Chanukah: Words of Torah - DNA of The Universe

One Day
3:28

One Day

Matisyahu
10 years ago
Pesach: Revolutionary Insights into the Haggadah, the Exodus, and the Final Redemption
1:01

Pesach: Revolutionary Insights into the Haggadah, the Exodus, and the Final Redemption

How Did Chazal Know Lavan Kissed Yaakov to Look For Diamonds? The Insight of the Chofetz Chaim
2:56

How Did Chazal Know Lavan Kissed Yaakov to Look For Diamonds? The Insight of the Chofetz Chaim

a miracle in israel – did you hear?
0:40

a miracle in israel – did you hear?

Explore Category

More Torah Albums & Music